Curses! Foiled again … by National Newswatch stealing my headline!

by kadyomalley on Saturday, August 16, 2008 11:42am - 0 Comments

Shocker: It wasn’t ‘The Green Shift’

The Law Society of Saskatchewan has reasonable grounds to believe that Garret Oledzki may be guilty of conduct unbecoming a lawyer in that he: MORE…

I’m still, however, going to take credit for being right when I went all Doubty McColdWaterPouringson last week over that burst of conventional-wisdom-via-Conservative-talking-point that these two resignations – Oledzki and Bob Morrissey in Prince Edward Island – were all because of that dastardly Green Shift, and not for those maddeningly cryptic “personal and professional reasons” that, at least in Oledzki’s case, was the reason given by the party and the now former candidate at the time.

UPDATE: As for Bob Morrissey’s resignation, we still don’t know whether there is anything more to it than the new business opportunities that he initially gave as his reason for pulling out of the race. According to the CBC parliamentary bureau group blog “Political Bytes”, that may well turn out to be exactly what happened:

[...]Liberals are admitting they started hearing as early as last April that Morrissey lacked the “fiire in his belly” to run in the first place.

A former provincial MLA, Morrissey had been out of politics since 2000 before deciding to try a comeback as a federal candidate.

If rumours of him reconsidering his candidacy were surfacing in April, that would have been a couple of months before Dion’s plan was unveiled, or its details well understood within Liberal ranks.

One Liberal source admits that when Morrissey did finally decide to pull the plug on his candidacy, organizers were afraid he might use the Green Shift as an excuse, and were grateful when he didn’t.

The non-election call

Morrissey was nominated in November 2007 when the rush was on to get candidacies sorted out in the face of election threats at the time. But that election still hasn’t come to pass.

The on-again, off-again election call is making it difficult for would-be candidates who are not yet in Parliament. Some have spent months trying to decide whether to put their energies into campaigning now, pre-writ, so as to be ready when the race starts or to pursue their careeers outside the world of partisan politics. In Morrissey’s case, a recent business deal is said to have made his mind up for him.

Further, the Liberal spin on the Island is that the carbon tax, while unpopular, will not be the ballot question in PEI. Premier Robert Ghiz has endorsed the policy and he has been pretty good at checking to see which way the political wind is blowing before he takes a stand.

(I meant to post a link to that post when it first went up, but it turned out to a considerably crazier week than even I expected, and I completely forgot.)

Bookmark and Share
  • dB

    Well if forging wills disqualifies you from being a candidate for public office, then send me to Elba.

  • Jarrid

    O.K. Kady, what dastardly deed did Morrissey do to earn his resignation? Because that’s what people were talking about, not Oledski.

  • http://deleted Sandi

    Oh, Jarrid, give it a rest. Everything comes out eventually, just like it did when Conservative candidates withdrew or Harper de-candidated them.

  • http://www.macleans.ca Kady O’Malley

    Actually, Jarrid, they were talking about both – and it was the Morrissey resignation that first sparked Ryan “The” Sparrow to speculate that it was because of the Green Shift — which, now that I think about it, may have had something to do with the anti-Green Shift ad campaign that his party was about to launch in Atlantic Canada, on the eve of the Liberal Atlantic caucus meeting.

    Anyway, I’ve added a link to more background on what may or may not have motivated Morrissey to step aside, but if you read my original post, I’ve never said that it *wasn’t* because of the Green Shift. I just wasn’t willing to take Ryan Sparrow’s word for it.

    (Also, as for Oledzki, at least one Conservative claimed at the time that he, too, was afraid of campaigning on the Green Shift, and the “personal and professional” line was just an excuse.)

  • MJ Patchouli

    I live in Palliser and can say that Oledzki never got out of the gate. Not a Liberal friendly riding either; the Lib candidates are generally invisible, except for everyone’s favourite lawyer, Tony Merchant in 1996. Come to think of it, he’s been disciplined by the bar association too, hasn’t he?

    Interestingly, the riding is currently held by conservative back bencher Dave Batters, who Kady wrote about in July because of his alarming yet unnamed healthcare problem. It is still unnamed, with disparate rumours; he IS a nice guy, as you wrote, Kady, although not strong MP material. Everyone out here wishes him the best.

    He won the riding by only about 100 votes from Dick Proctor, NDP, who demanded a recount, and has since moved to BC.

    So, the only active candidate is now Don Mitchell, former mayor of Moose Jaw, which is part of the constituency too, and the brother of the popular SK author/businessman/actor Ken Mitchell. They are successful men, but essentially cowboys, and popular.

  • http://www.macleans.ca Kady O’Malley

    Thanks so much for the background, MJ – I guess now the big question is whether Dave Batters will run again, and whether the circumstances surrounding Oledzki’s resignation make this seat the NDP’s to lose.

    Which reminds me – does anyone else find it exquisitely hilarious that, on the week that a former Liberal candidate is revealed to be having serious disciplinary problems with the bar, the government is facing an entirely separate controversy over a disbarred lawyer turned senior prime ministerial advisor? It’s detente-alicious!

  • penlan

    Yes, Kady, Bruce Carson got a 3 yr. sentence. Plus he has just been appointed to an environmental commision at he, I believe U of C. So if the Cons start in on Oledzki for his disbarrment at least there will be a comeback for the Libs with Carson.

    Would love to see the fireworks on that one!

  • Anon

    Why didn’t the Carson story get more play before? I mean the guy was next door to the PM for the past 2.5 years, you’d have thought that somebody at Lib oppo research would have a file on him.

    Also, this CSEE to which he is appointed seems to be a virtual organization with no staff, no website, nothing. Just a press-release and one backgrounder page that I could find.

    Also, since it’s a Canada Research Chair, shouldn’t the person heading it have some sort of qualification in energy and/or environmental research before he/she can head it?

    What’s next? Sandra Buckler as head of the Canada Space Agency?

  • BR
  • http://www.macleans.ca Kady O’Malley

    I have to think this is probably more of a potential public relations problem for his now former law firm than for the Liberals. I mean, really, let the federal party that has never inadvertently wound up with a controversial candidate cast the first stone. They’re just lucky he decided to resign last week, instead of waiting for the news to come out, which would have led to at least a few days of “OMG WILL STEPHANE DION REPLACE HIS ALLEGEDLY CROOKED CANDIDATE IN THE LIBERAL STRONGHOLD OF PALLISER???!!!” – or, worse yet, during the campaign.

    The law firm, however, will likely have to answer questions from actual paying clients.

  • penlan

    Kady,

    Is there some way to find out how many “pouts of order” were made by the Cons each day for the 4 days?

    I’d love to know!

  • http://www.macleans.ca Kady O’Malley

    Unfortunately, not until the transcripts are published, which won’t be for a few days. The minutes will have points that resulted in challenges to the chair – there were at least seven or so of those, I believe – but not every single pout.

  • Jarrid

    Kady says “As for Bob Morrissey’s resignation, we still don’t know whether there is anything more to it than the new business opportunities that he initially gave as his reason for pulling out of the race.”

    About those supposed “new business opportunities”? Today’s Chronicle-Herald (via National Newswatch link) has this to report about those mysterious opportunities: “The only thing that might lessen the sting would be if those private sector opportunities Morrissey claims to be pursuing happen sooner rather than later.”

    We have no confirmation at all about any business opportunities. Meanwhile the Liberal organization in Egmont, a Liberal stronghold, is in disarray on the eve of a federal election. Shades of Outremont I’d say.

  • Richard

    The speculation that Morrissey’s not running had to do with his disagreement with the party seems to be unfounded. yet it makes national news.

    Meanwhile, throughout Atlantic Canada, in ridings like North Nova, Halifax to name just two, Tory candidates have publicly declared their disgust with the party’s direction and abadnonded their candidacies. Add to that list the two former candidates in Random-Burin-St. George’s and Labrador who have also publicly declared their abandonment of the party whose banner they once ran under, and suddenly you’re up to four. You could just as easily speculate that Norm Doyle’s announcement that he would not seek re-election is also driven by his disdain for Harper’s policies, coming as it did in the weeks of the Harper/Williams eruption of hostilities. Loyola Hearn, Harper’s regional minister still won’t say if he’s running either, bringing the total up to at least 6 nominated tories who have abandoned the party over policy differences.

    But instead, idle speculation about Morrissey makes the news.

    You folks are either desperate for headlines, or suckers for PMO spin.

  • Jarrid

    According to Punditsguide.ca the Liberals have had another three candidates resign in addition to the one that was in the news last week. These are new candidates, like Morrissey. Nobody said much when Joe McGuire retired in Egmont, after all, he’d been the sitting MP for some time. The question people are asking is why are all these newly minted candidates all of sudden having cold feet?

    Maybe it has something to do with a lack of confidence in the leader and the program and the fact that the Libs are always trailing the Cons in the polls.

    Anyhow, Dion’s latest declaration doesn’t exactly inspire confidence. As reported in the Canadian Press: “Leader Stephane Dion criticized Prime Minister Stephen Harper yesterday for threatening to call a general election.”

    This coming from a man who’s been threatening to call one for the last what, year and half? This has to be a Canadian first: an opposition leader in a minority government who’s been propping the government in Parliament criticizing the government for wanting to go to the polls. It’s surreal!

  • MJ Patchouli

    I’m looking forward to seeing how Orchard operates out here as a prominent Liberal. He always gets headlines, one way or another.

  • Jarrid

    “He always gets headlines, one way or another.”

    Well put.

  • Tom

    Call me a crazy apologist, but could it be that since the Liberals are now expecting a fall election, they’ve been actually concertedly trying to shake loose the less-interested fruit now rather than dealing with them either quitting later or half-assing a campaign?

    I mean, the cold truth is that every party has candidates that were nominated in a rush eons ago who were expecting the parliament to last six months. They mightn’t have been the best possible candidate in the first place, or they might just be burnt-out and pissy after permanently being ready to go for two years. Would any party really, really want these people to be leading their charge? Why would it be so hard to believe that the Liberal powers that be let it be known to their candidates this mid-summer low-media-profile period was their last chance to back out of running – be it because they’ve gotten jaded waiting for an election, or because they’ve found some thrilling new “business opportunity”, or because they dare not run for Stephane Not-a-Leader Dion and His Permanent-Tax-on-Everything (who happens, apropos of nothing, to be leading in the polls).

    Besides, all the Sparrowspin in the world can’t change the fact that these last two candidate resignations have had next to zero net impact on the Liberals’ odds of forming government. One year ago, it looked like they would win Egmont, and would lose Palliser. Today, it looks like they’ll win Egmont and lose Palliser. And I’m fairly certain that the day before the election, it’ll look like they’ll win Egmont and lose Palliser.

  • http://caiti-online.blogspot.com/ Transcanada

    I sure hope the Conservatives aren’t claiming the moral high ground in the case of Garret Oledzki when Harper still stands behind (with one hand on each shoulder) the likes of MPs like Saskathewan’s own Tom Lukiwski.

    “There’s A’s and there’s B’s. The A’s are guys like me, the B’s are…” and he is still around.

  • Shenping

    In defence of Mr. Oledskzi, while he may have faked a signature, he didn’t do it for personal gain. Mostly likely he did it to save someone a trip. Moose Jaw Palliser has a large rural area with increasingly limited postal service (another decision made on our behalf in Ottawa). It can be hard for the elderly to get in to see a lawyer, or to go to their mail box, which may be 50km or more from where they live. I’ve known other lawyers get suspensions for this, but never a permanent disbarring. The .pdf just says “until further notice”.

    IMHO, anyone who runs for the Liberals in Palliser is probably very committed to the party, and is willing to donate a lot of time to help them be involved in local debates and have a presence in the region. If there was another explanation such as actually expecting to win, they’d probably need to be disbarred on psychiatric grounds.

  • Deb Prothero

    What I think people fail to take into consideration is that candidates still have to earn a living somehow to feed families. A person just can’t hang in limbo for months on end and keep up appearances. It takes money to run a campaign so they either have to keep on with their profession and campaign in the off hours or they have to be independently wealthy enough to campaign for a couple years.

  • http://berlinshotel.com Korbin Stephens

    How captivating!!

From Macleans