UPDATED: Who inspects the meat inspectors?

by kadyomalley on Saturday, September 6, 2008 3:28pm - 9 Comments

An as-yet-unnamed prime ministerial appointee, of course, with a mandate to “examine the efficiency and effectiveness of the response of the federal organizations … [and] their food safety partners.”

What’s not clear, however, is whether that will include Maple Leaf Foods or any other private company involved in the recall, despite recent media reports that suggest the outbreak could have been caused by contaminated meat slicers.

NOTE:  Less than an hour after this release came out, PMO put out an updated version, which sets March 15, 2009 as the deadline for the final report.

For release:   Immediate

PRIME MINISTER ANNOUNCES TERMS OF REFERENCE FOR AN INDEPENDENT INVESTIGATION OF THE LISTERIOSIS OUTBREAK

OTTAWA – The Prime Minister today released the terms of reference for the independent investigation into the recent listeriosis outbreak related to certain processed meat products from Maple Leaf Foods.

The Canadian food safety system is generally regarded as one of the best in the world. Protecting the health of Canadian families and the safety of the Canadian food supply is of paramount importance to the Government of Canada. As such, it is important to determine exactly what transpired in regards to the listeriosis outbreak.

The investigation into the listeria outbreak will:

(i) examine the events, circumstances and factors that contributed to the listeriosis outbreak;

(ii) review the efficiency and effectiveness of the response of the federal organizations, in conjunction with their food safety system partners, in terms of prevention, recall of contaminated products and collaboration and communication with its food safety system partners and consumers;

(iii) make recommendations, based on lessons learned from this event and from other countries in terms of best practices, as to what could be done to enhance both prevention of a similar outbreak occurrence in the future, and removal of contaminated product from the food supply;

(iv) perform his/her duties without expressing any conclusion or recommendation regarding the civil or criminal liability of any person or organization;

(v) adopt procedures for the expedient and proper conduct of the investigation, including reviewing relevant records and documents and consulting as appropriate; and

(vi) submit to the Minister of Agriculture and Agri-Food, in both official languages, a report on the matters listed in (i) to (iv) above.

UPDATE: Huh. I wonder if today’s announcement had anything to do with this:

Agriculture Minister Gerry Ritz held a news conference yesterday to discuss the outbreak. The conference was rescheduled twice — on the second occasion, reporters received a notification of the new time after the time at which the conference was to begin. An audio recording of the news conference provided to The Globe and Mail indicates it lasted about seven minutes.

You almost have to feel sorry for the poor guy — I mean, the powers that be have made him hold one of these press conferences every single day since the story broke, and the one time that he could have garnered a half-decent headline, he gets elbowed out of the way and PMO gets the credit.

Bookmark and Share
  • http://homeboyz Greg

    The question is Kady, will the MSM let Harper hide behind the “We will have to wait for the report” crap we all know is coming (that is, if Harper even talks to you folks during the next 5 weeks)?

  • Dr Riff

    UPDATE: Huh. I wonder if today’s announcement had anything to do with this:

    etc

    nah i emailed him and mentioned some things this morning.

    gazoo

  • http://liberal-arts-and-minds.blogspot.com/ knb

    You almost have to feel sorry for the poor guy

    No I don’t. He’s been on and off arrogant in handling this file.

    A presser a day? Tough, that’s being in government and has Clement even said boo about all of this?

    Sorry to take the hard line here but I have no sympathy.

    Kady, can you clarify if the documents that the Lib’s put out the other day substantiate what they were saying in committee? I’m confused now.

    Don Martin intimated that there are 2 sets of documents and if anyone knows documents, it’s him. I mean that in a nice way.

  • Baloneyman

    Didn’t Harper already apologize for the outbreak? Wouldn’t that assume that he had some guilt in the matter?
    Or was that just an empty, disingenuous bit of smarm on the part of Stevie-boy?

  • Colin Morrison

    My bread isnt fresh enough anymore. I anxiously await an investigation into why.

    I blame government. It couldnt possibly be the fault of the baker. Its all Harper’s fault. He cut funding to artists who love fresh bread and can no longer afford it. The collapse in the really fresh bread industry has led to my having to eat bread that isnt really fresh.

    It’s really part of the hidden agenda. Its right there in black and white…

    section 3.
    food freshness

    A truly right wing and George Bush loving government will do all in its power to lower the quality of food.

    damn that hidden conservative agenda, they have even taken the freshly fried doughnuts from Tim Horton’s.

  • http://www.macleans.ca Kady O’Malley

    KNB – I think it’s possible you’re confusing the Secret Dysfunction-o-matic Committee Handbook with the “leaked” CFIA documents. Which, incidentally, weren’t leaked by the Liberals, as far as I know, but by an unknown source to the Globe and the Post, one of which posted them online, earning many kudos from ITQ.

    As far as I can tell, those documents corroborate the questions that the opposition was asking at committee, although I don’t believe they had copies at that point — not unofficially-officially, at least — but were working off what had appeared in the press thus far.

  • Phillip Huggan

    I wonder why S.Harper has made it a personal crusade to kill the farmer’s KVD. KVD is a method of telling different batches of grain apart by their physical appearance. Now all grain looks the same and quality control is accomplished by paperwork. It is inevitable documentation will get mixed up and one small batch a grain will spoil an entire elevator. Not on the same scale as listeriosis, but I’d expect the Conservatives to get the farmer issue right.
    Ooo, and why isn’t meat tested as soon as multiple equipment positive listeriosis tests occur. Presumably this would require *more* government food inspection, not less as S.Harper untimely forwarded this summer. I’ve been forced to eat healthier in the last month. Disgusting.

  • T. Thwim

    Phillip: I believe KVD also makes Canadian grain distinguishable from American grain.

    Remember, the conservatives of these days are not for individual farmers, as they believe in trickle-down, supply-side economics, which basically says “You give the biggest players what they want, and the scraps they give the rest of us get bigger”

    Well, the biggest players in the grain industry aren’t Canadian.

  • Jack Mitchell

    Rather off-topic remark: this whole listeriosis outbreak makes me wonder what other strange, though not deadly, bacteria are emanating from these packaged meat plants. I’m not paranoid (or vegetarian) but it certainly is food for thought, as it were. The words “meat plant” have a rather ugly ring to them.

    Colin Morrison, what makes me think that if terrorists, and not contaminated meat, had killed a dozen grandmothers, you might want the government to investigate, not to mention prevent any repeats? You might even lay off the sarcasm.

From Macleans