BUMPED – ONLY 11 HOURS LEFT: So it's come to this … a seat projection thread.

Welcome to the First-and-Hopefully-Last-For-At-Least-A-Few-Months Official ITQ Seat Projection Thread! …
Amaze your friends!
Aggravate your

by kadyomalley on Monday, October 13, 2008 9:50am - 0 Comments

Welcome to the First-and-Hopefully-Last-For-At-Least-A-Few-Months Official ITQ Seat Projection Thread!

Amaze your friends!

Aggravate your enemies!

The rules are simple:

  • Predictions can be posted anytime before Monday night at 6p.m.
  • If you normally use Anon as a handle, add a number or some other sort of modifier so your prescience can be celebrated, if warranted.
  • If your final projection includes Independents, you must specify the name of riding/candidate
  • Please try to avoid hijacking the projection thread for endless partisan back-and-forth – there are plenty of other places on macleans.ca for that
  • Oh, and this is strictly for seat projections, not guesses on the share of the popular vote, or the spread – sorry, Kody.

The winner(s) will be determined by some sort of complex formula that I’ll let someone else figure out, since I’m not a math person, and the prize will be bragging rights, or something from Colleague Feschuk’s seemingly bottomless drawer of random stuff, if he feels like sharing.

With that … let the guessing game begin!

NOTE TO READERS: This was originally posted way back on Thursday night, but due to operator error, it never made it to ITQ, and wound up spending the last two days in macleans.ca limbo. Sorry about that.

UPDATE: In case y’all are curious about the press gallery’s collective wisdom, here’s a breakdown of the entries in the legendary Hot Room seat projection pool, courtesy of CanWest’s David Akin – who is a very, very brave man for posting his entry, and as such, inspired ITQ to do the same in his comment thread.  (I do, however, reserve the right to tweak those numbers ever so slightly, if necessary, when I finally post my best guess here.)

PREDICTION TIP IN UPDATE FORMAT:

A tip, for those of you still mulling over your choices: I just checked the spreadsheet for last year’s Hot Room pool, and the two most accurate prediction sites were Democratic Space and the Election Prediction Project. Democratic Space was just four seats over the final count for the Conservatives – 128 predicted versus 124 actual) but underestimated the Liberal result by nine seats – 84 predicted, 103 won.

The Election Prediction Project, on the other hand, was nearly bang on for the Liberals with a prediction of 104 seats, although that did include David Emerson’s seat. Honestly, though, who could have seen that coming? Anyway, its prediction was also six seats shy of the final Conservative number, so it might be helpful to keep all that in mind this time around.

UPDATE: And we’re closed for business … as of 9 p.m. Good luck to all! I’ll post an update on the formula for determining a winner tomorrow, and I promise it will be fairer, richer, gree- wait, cancel that. It will be fair, anyway. Happy election eve, all!

Bookmark and Share
  • richtheo

    Conservatives 118
    Liberals 102
    Bloc Q 50
    NDP 36
    Independants 2 (Casey and Arthur)

    and the Habs win the Cup in 6 against Detroit

  • Burt Mapson

    Conservatives: 148
    Liberals: 76
    Bloc: 39
    NDP: 43
    Other: 2 (Casey/Andre)

  • LarryTheGreat

    CPC – 123
    LPC – 99
    NDP – 31
    BQ – 51
    GPC – 0
    IND – 2
    (Arthur, Casey)

  • Darren Trent

    Conservatives: 138
    Liberals: 75
    Bloc: 50
    NDP: 43
    Other: 2

  • http://prairiewrangler.wordpress.com/ Olaf

    CPC: 132
    LPC: 91
    NDP: 32
    BQ: 51
    Ind: 2 (Casey, Arthur)

  • Pingback: Behold the tyrannanosity of the majority (34.2/26.7/21.4/8.2/9.5)) : Capital Read : Inside the Queensway : Macleans.ca Blog Central

  • http://michaeltripper.com Mr. Tripper

    my brainless throw out numbers pulling stuff out of thin air with no basis in fact not a really a prediction but a contest entry is….

    Conservatives: 105
    Liberals: 99
    NDP: 34
    Bloc Québecois: 66
    Green: 2
    Independent: 2

  • seaandthemountains

    CPC: 120

    L: 104

    BQ: 51

    NDP: 31

    Indy Kids: 2 (Casey; Arthur)

    GP: 0

  • Pingback: Prairie Wrangler Herald endorsement for the 2008 Federal election « The Prairie Wrangler

  • ian

    CPC: 134
    L: 84
    NDP: 39
    BQ: 49
    IND: 2
    GP: 0

  • Daniel B.

    My prediction:

    CPC: 142

    LPC: 76

    NDP: 42

    BQ: 48

  • Martin Partridge

    C 118
    L 100
    N 35
    B 53
    I 2 (Casey, Arthur)

    In my predicted scenario, Casey plus a disappointed Layton will still have enough to prop up Harper.

  • mtc

    CPC – 135
    LPC – 86
    BQ – 50
    NDP – 35
    Ind – 2

  • Jamie

    CPC – 140
    LPC – 83
    NDP – 35
    BQ – 48
    GP – 0
    Ind – 2

  • http://seeingredinthesouthwest.blogspot.com Deb Prothero

    If we vote smart:

    Conservative 67
    Liberal 128
    NDP 50
    Green 1
    Bloc 60
    IND 2

  • Jean Proulx

    Conservatives – 109
    Liberals – 101
    BQ – 60
    NDP – 35
    Greens – 1
    Independents – 2 (Casey, Arthur)

  • T. Thwim

    National:
    Lib: 93
    Con: 108
    NDP: 52
    BQ: 51
    Green: 2
    Independants:
    Casey, Andre, Schmidt

    Newfoundland:
    Lib: 5
    NDP: 2

    PEI:
    Lib 4

    Nova Scotia:
    Lib: 6
    Con: 1
    NDP: 3
    Ind: 1 (Casey)
    (Sorry Elizabeth)

    New Brunswick:
    Lib: 5
    Con: 2
    NDP: 3

    Quebec:
    Lib: 13
    Con: 11
    B.Q.: 51
    Ind: 1 (Andre)

    Ontario:
    Lib: 50
    Con: 37
    NDP: 19

    Manitoba:
    Lib: 3
    Con: 7
    NDP: 4

    Saskatchewan:
    Lib: 3
    Con: 10
    NDP: 1

    Alberta:
    Con: 26
    NDP: 1
    Ind: 1 (Schmidt – Calgary West – please, please, please, not Anders)

    B.C.:
    Lib: 3
    Con: 14
    Green: 1
    NDP: 18

    Yukon:
    Lib: 1

    N.W.T:
    NDP: 1

    Nunavut:
    Green: 1

  • Bruce Stewart

    Conservatives – 138
    Liberals – 85
    BQ – 48
    NDP – 35
    Green – 0
    Independents – 2 (Casey, Arthur)

    Conservatives will take over half of Ontario’s seats, but little in Québec.
    NDP will get all of Northern Ontario’s seats, plus 3 in Toronto.
    Liberals will not take more than 5 seats south of 60° west of Ontario.

  • MG

    CPC – 141
    Liberals – 78
    NDP – 35
    Bloc – 52
    Green – 0
    Independent – 2 (Arthur, Casey)

  • Sammy

    CPC – 147
    Liberal – 81
    NDP – 28
    Bloc – 50
    Independent – 2 (Arthur and Casey)

  • watching in ottawa

    130 Cons
    105 Lib
    42 Bloc
    28 NDP
    2 Indep.
    1 Green

  • Mike T.

    Fascists 121

    Crooks 96

    Commies 35

    Traitors 54

    Hippies 0

    Other 2

  • Just visiting

    What was the question again?

  • Jarrid

    Conservatives 144

    Liberals 79

    Bloc Quebecois 49

    NDP 34

    Other 2

    (Arthur in Quebec and Casey in Nova Scotia)

  • http://drdawgsblawg.blogspot.com Dr.Dawg

    Cons: 130
    Libs: 90
    NDP: 35
    Bloc: 51
    Greens: 0
    Independents: 2

From Macleans