UPDATED AGAIN: If Sun Tzu had access to a demon dialer …

by kadyomalley on Tuesday, October 14, 2008 12:45pm - 62 Comments

… this is totally the kind of thing he’d include in the second edition of Art of War. otherwise, I can’t imagine who could possibly come up with an election eve strategy as evilly brilliant – or brilliantly evil – as the one that apparently played out in the race underway in Saanich-Gulf Islands on Thanksgiving Monday – spotted by the force of nature that is National Newswatch, of course:

A number of residents in the Saanich-Gulf Islands riding received recorded telephone messages Monday, urging them to vote for NDP candidate Julian West – who left the race after controversy over a public-nudity incident 12 years ago.

Irene Wright, executive member of the NDP’s federal riding association for Saanich-Gulf Islands, said Monday night people started phoning her around 5 p.m. to say they had received an automated call encouraging them to vote for West in Tuesday’s election.

A woman’s voice in the recording said the call was endorsed by Bill Graham, president of the NDP Saanich-Gulf Islands riding association, and from the “Progressive Voters Association of Saanich-Gulf Islands.”

By using caller identification information, the call’s origin appeared to be the fax number at Graham’s address.

“It’s not coming from our fax machine,” said Graham. “Somebody is fraudulently using our name and our fax number to send out a misleading message.”

UPDATE: Is it just me, or does anyone else find it odd that nowhere in this story does it mention the fact that this is Gary Lunn’s riding?

AND EVEN UPPERDATED: The Tyee has more, including an on-the-record denial from Lunn’s campaign chair, Byng Giraud.

NOTE: Reposted from the comments, just to make it clear what I’m saying here: This has nothing to do with the use of a demon dialer – which, while obnoxious, is a perfectly legitimate campaign strategy. But this appears to be a deliberate attempt to frame the NDP for making calls supporting West’s candidacy, which the local NDP organizer – whose number apparently appeared on the calls  -categorically denies having done.

Bookmark and Share
  • Jim

    Layton promises to ease B.C.’s gas pains

    By Terri Theodore, THE CANADIAN PRESS

    2008-09-25

    NDP Leader Jack Layton responds to questions from citizens at Thompson Rivers University Wednesday. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jacques Boissinot

    Layton hammered over tax stance

    KAMLOOPS, B.C. – Jack Layton fanned the flames of British Columbia’s carbon-tax frustration Thursday as he urged voters angry about the cost of fuel to vote for an NDP government.

    Liberal Leader Stephane Dion wants to triple the carbon tax imposed earlier this year by B.C. Premier Gordon Campbell, Layton told a campaign event in Kamloops, B.C., as he tried to capitalize on simmering anger over the controversial provincial measure.

    http://cnews.canoe.ca/CNEWS/Canada/CanadaVotes/News/2008/09/25/6876586-cp.html

  • Geiseric the Lame

    “…when it could as easily be a misunderstanding.”

    but the caller ID has been spoofed. That doesn’t happen by accident.

  • Andrew

    Gas is $1.02/L ’round these parts. Does that still count as ‘expensive’? What price is considered inexpensive?

  • John D

    I’m excited to read the story about the NDP setting up an autodialer to spoof their own caller id and call themselves by a different name.

  • seaandthemountains

    JohnD, just made me spit out my soup! Is there a prize in Feschuk’s drawer for him?

  • John D

    I don’t want to know what’s in Feschuk’s drawers…

  • david

    att’n seaandthemountains:

    it wouldn’t be offensive if a party other than the CPC participated in fraud?

    I smell a Liberal!

  • T. Thwim

    Interestingly enough, Lunn won the riding by less than the percentage of the vote that went to Julian West.

    Just sayin..

  • TinTincognito

    True, Lunn beat Penn by 2600 votes and West got 3667. Someone would have been charged for the auto-dialer by call so it shouldn’t be impossible to see how many people were contacted and (perhaps) influenced to vote NDP instead of Liberal. Was the vote stolen? If yes, in terms of holding an elected position, this would be worse than public nudity and Lunn should resign his seat. I smell by-election.

  • TinTincognito

    “it wouldn’t be offensive if a party other than the CPC participated in fraud?”

    Of course it would. You’re being offensive to suggest people would think otherwise. No wonder voter turnout is crashing.

  • Style

    Saanich Islands (2006): Lunn (24,416); NDP (17,445); LIB (17,144); Green (6,533)

    Saanich Islands (2008): Lunn (27,988); LIB (25,367); Green (6,732); NDP (3,667)

    The Liberals tried to win this seat by pushing West out after the nominations closed – thus keeping the NDP off the ballot. The result: Lunn’s votes went up, a number of Dippers spoiled their ballots and the unpleasantness between the Liberals and the NDP in BC got that much worse.

    For a fun comparison of how well the “demon dialler” dirty trick worked, here’s the NDP vote from Durham (where the NDP candidate also resigned).

    2006: 9,946
    2008: 5,505

    Could be there are people who support the New Democrats and would rather spoil their ballot than vote for another party? It’s not always about the Tories.

  • seaandthemountains

    Dave, you did catch where i said: “Anybody who purposefully misinforms people in a way that renders their democratic rights useless ought to be dealt with severely. As Andrew rightfully suggests, the cops should be investigating this.”, right?

From Macleans