Oh, it's on: Two more MPs join the Race for Kingsmere

by kadyomalley on Friday, November 7, 2008 5:13pm - 15 Comments

Does this suggest a split within the Conservative caucus? Have he and Merv Tweed established a Rae-Ignatieff-style pact of nonaggression? Most importantly, whither Andrew Scheer? 

From:   Devolin, Barry – M.P.  
Sent:   November 7, 2008 10:03 AM 
Subject:        Speaker of the House of Commons

Dear Colleague,

Congratulations on your election to Canada’s 40th Parliament. It is a great honour to be elected as one of the people’s representatives in Ottawa.

When we meet in the House of Commons on Tuesday November 18, our first task will be to elect a Speaker.

I am running for Speaker because I would like the opportunity to take the same cooperative approach that I took as committee chair into the House of Commons. I will strive to earn and maintain the respect of every Member of Parliament, and will do whatever is necessary to make House proceedings civil and constructive.

As a committee chair, I made every effort to be fair and reasonable. I enjoyed the challenge of running a good meeting, and was proud that the Aboriginal Affairs and Northern Development committee was professional and productive while I was in the chair.

(For those who do not know me well, I encourage you to verify this by speaking with your colleagues who have worked with me in the past.)

Every individual has their strengths and aptitudes. I am confident that my calm approach, contemplative nature and restrained partisanship make me well-suited for the chair in the House of Commons.

I also have a lifelong interest in democracy and its institutions. I received my M.A. from the State University of New York at Stony Brook, and my B.A. from Carleton University, both in political science. While in graduate school, I taught an introductory course on American Government and an advanced course on Congress and the Legislative Process.

Amongst other things, prior to my election, I served as Director of Research for the Reform Party of Canada in 1993-94, Chief of Staff for two provincial ministers, and Special Advisor to the Premier of Ontario between 1995 and 2000.

Over the past 15 years, I have participated in the legislative process in both Ottawa and Toronto in a variety of roles. As such, I am confident I would bring a steady and mature approach to managing House proceedings.

The Speaker is also an important ambassador for Canada. Having lived for a year in Europe, a year and a half in Asia, and three years in the United States, I appreciate the importance of cultural sensitivity and protocol, and recognize the value of parliamentary diplomacy in promoting Canada’s interests abroad.

Given the shortness of time, we may not have the opportunity to speak in person before we return on November 18th. In any event, I look forward to addressing you in the House of Commons that day. Thank you for your consideration.

Sincerely,


Barry Devolin, M.P. 
Haliburton-Kawartha Lakes-Brock

And from the NDP’s corner of the House comes this semi-surprising notice of intention from Joe Comartin Full disclosure: ITQ will be rooting against him all the way to the final ballot for the very simple reason that the House needs more opposition MPs like Joe Comartin, not less. (Sorry, Joe. We mean it in the best way possible.): 

From: Comartin, Joe – M.P. 

Subject: Speaker of the House of Commons

7 November 2008 
Dear Colleague, 
I am writing to inform you of my intention to let my name stand for election as the Speaker of the House in this 40
th Parliament.

Since my election as Member of Parliament for Windsor-Tecumseh in 2000, I have had the opportunity to serve on several Standing Committees of the House, including as Vice Chair of the Standing Committee on Public Safety and National Security.  During the 38th and 39th Parliaments, I had the privilege of being the Deputy House Leader for my Party.  In this capacity, I strived to work in a non-partisan manner to facilitate the smooth functioning of House activities.  In addition, the role of Deputy House Leader allowed me the opportunity to build on more than 27 years of legal experience and develop significant expertise in Parliamentary procedure.   I have studied extensively and visited our sister Parliaments in the UK, Australia and New Zealand to understand their workings.

As an MP I have consistently strived to be well-informed, fair, and just in executing my duties. I am confident that those who have had the opportunity to work with me will attest to my sincere desire to restore and elevate the reputation of Parliament. 

It has been the observation of many that decorum in Parliament has deteriorated and as such directly impacts on the quality of debate and indeed the credibility of all parliamentarians.  The Speaker, in providing neutral guidance and order to the daily functioning of the House plays a pivotal role in maintaining MPs` privilege and establishing rules of decorum for present and future parliamentarians.

As MPs we do not operate in isolation, and given the serious issues facing Canada’s 40th Parliament, I believe we can and should set a constructive tone for the country and reduce, if not eliminate, partisan rancour. If you are serious about the importance of Parliament functioning in a collegial and productive manner, and share my concern that we must restore a culture of civility to the House, I invite you to support my candidacy for Speaker on November 18th.  

I look forward to working constructively with all Members of Parliament in the upcoming session.  If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me at my Parliamentary office.

Sincerely, your colleague, 

Joe Comartin 
Member of Parliament for Windsor-Tecumseh

Bookmark and Share
  • Wassim

    I like Comartin’s pitch.

    I find Peter Milliken to be unfit for the job. Any serious person sitting in the Speaker’s chair would never/should never tolerate behaviour like we saw recently in the House of Commons.

    Good luck to any candidate who promises decorum and respect in the 40th Parliament.

  • Sisyphus

    I agree Comartin is more useful as a man among the mice.

    But he would make an excellent speaker.

    Wonder if it’s saying something about Happy Jack ?

    I think you should elbow your friend Pat Martin into running.

  • Dot

    ITQ will be rooting against him all the way to the final ballot for the very simple reason that the House needs more opposition MPs like Joe Comartin, not less. (Sorry, Joe. We mean it in the best way possible.):

    Joe Comartin has put in his time admirably as an MP since 2000, and has performed well despite the rather acrimonious environment he has been witness to all around him. I have seen little evidence that the current Speaker has done much to curtail the downward spiral, and needs to be replaced.

    As Speaker, he would be compensated at a level equivalent to a Minister:

    Speaker of the House of Commons Salary $74,400.00
    Speaker of the House of Commons Car Allowance $1,061.00
    Speaker of the House of Commons Rent Allowance $3,000.00

    Rooting against someone for the reasons outlined is just plain silly. If merit is the basis for promotion to Speaker, Comartin is well suited based upon his past performance in the HofC and in committees.

    I wish him well. Perhaps awarding someone on merit would inspire others to perform up to the same standards he exemplified.

    Why keep a tall poppy in a crowded flowerpot full of weeds?

  • Lord Bob

    There are three hundred and eight members of the House of Commons. Could it [i]possibly[/i] have taken that long to write “Dear Dr. Martin, congratulations on winning Esquimalt-Juan de Fuca!” with appropriate variations three hundred and eight times? What’s with this generic form letter crap?

    That’s the kind of dedication I demand from a Speaker!

  • dan in van

    I’m curious as to why Harper is allowing his ferns to go for this position, since it would take one person off the voting rolls (not that his gov’t will hinge on one less bobblehead). I’m certain you’ll agree that his reputation as a master strategist should have all democratic watchers going ‘hmmmm’…

  • dan in van

    Oh, but i’d also agree that Comartin would make a tremendous speaker. I’m thinking that Milliken has little chance of retaining his comfortable chair.

  • Two Cents

    Whatever happens Milliken needs to be replaced..I think Andrew Scheer would make an excellent Speaker. He is fluently bilingual, represents a Western riding and demonstrated fairness in his role as Deputy Speaker, something that is not always easy for one of the youngest MPs. Hey, we could be looking at a 30-year career a Speaker here.

  • http://deleted Sandi

    No women have applied? Why not?

  • http://phantomobserver.com PhantomObserver

    Sandi: probably because the new women coming in don’t have enough experience to be Speaker, and the women with the right level of experience want to focus more on representing their riding (or don’t have their ambitions pointed in that particular direction).

  • Pingback: Blue Like You » Blog Archive » Is it time to dethrone Milliken?

  • Barb

    Yes….I could see Joe Comartin in this role. Gutsy and has integrity so in that way it would be a loss of a fine mp

  • RyanD

    I have to admit I know almost nothing about Barry Devolin but his letter there intrigues me. He talks up his ability to be fair and to “restrain partisanship” but he lists being a Special Advisor to Mike Harris from 1995-2000 (one of the most hideously partisan periods of political history anywhere in Canada) as well. Since I know next to nothing about this gentleman I am quite curious as to what his role was in the Harris government and how that relates to his current character and aspirations. Was he the exception to the rule amongst the Harrisites (who tended to have a with us or against us approach)? If anyone can shed a bit of light on this one for me I’d appreciate it.

  • Scott M.

    Kady… just out of curiosity, how long does Milliken have to vacate the house should he not win re-election?

  • http://www.macleans.ca Kady O’Malley

    You know, I’m not sure — we’ve never actually had a situation where an incumbent Speaker has failed to win reelection. I’ll see if I can find out, though.

  • Pingback: Macleans.ca - “The question is,” said Humpty Dumpty, “Which is to be master — that’s all.” (An ITQ Poll!)

From Macleans