The Race for Kingsmere – I hate to disagree with my honourable colleague, The Commons …

by kadyomalley on Monday, November 17, 2008 1:55pm - 33 Comments

But ITQ cannot join with Aaron Wherry in endorsing Joe Comartin for Speaker of the House, for the very reasons that Aaron reiterates in his post — in a nutshell, he’s just too valuable a critic, committee member and cable news talking head to be silenced by the strict impartiality requirements of Chair.

Instead, we will be throwing our support behind the current associate deputy speaker, Conservative Andrew Scheer, who impressed us on the (admittedly, too few and far between) occasion that we actually paid attention to his performance of his speakertorial duties in the House, most noteably during our liveblogging of Committee of the Whole last May.

More importantly, he is, as yet, the only challenger to the current inhabitant who seems to be motivated not by a grim and joyless sense of duty (rather like the anti-”perk” Cromwellian Reformers of old), but by his unmistakable passion for parliamentary ritual and tradition, and for the Commons itself, in all its anachronistic and anarchic glory.

For that, and because we have a soft spot for anyone who dresses his toddler in miniature Speaker’s robes for Hill’o'ween, we’re backing Scheer.

You?

Bookmark and Share
  • http://www.macleans.ca Kady O’Malley

    Actually, I don’t know if he *is* the best candidate for the job, for the very simple reason that I’ve never seen him in the chair, so I’m not sure how he would handle the flurry of points of order and privilege that follow Question Period, or a protracted conflict at committee that spilled over into the Commons when one or both sides implores him to intervene, or a concurrence debate that just so happens to take up most of the day’s alloted time for debate, or hourly quorum calls, or any number of other procedural antics.

    Also, I should point out that there is a reason why a Speaker doesn’t normally deal with disciplinary matters during Question Period — it rewards bad behaviour, because an expelled member, on marching out the door, immediately becomes the centre of a media scrum, and consequently, the story of the day. Better to wait until afterwards, when the attention of (most of the nation) has moved on, and the offending member is more likely to apologize for his actions.

  • George Pringle

    Andrew needs a lot longer to grow up. He has quite a temper on him and is not suitable as the Speaker.

  • Sophie

    How on earth is it possible that Milliken is winning? I mean, he’s a great guy, I wish him well, and in a majority gv’t, I’d be all for him. But with this pizza parliament, we need someone who’s going to lay down the law.

  • Dot

    it rewards bad behaviour, because an expelled member, on marching out the door, immediately becomes the centre of a media scrum, and consequently, the story of the day.

    So, perhaps the media could stop doing that, as well as focusing endlessly on the bad behaviour in the HofC ie rewarding it by showing it on prime time news.

  • http://www.macleans.ca Kady O’Malley

    An MP being kicked out of the House for bad behaviour is news — although I suppose eventually it would stop being so if it happened every day.

  • http://www.bluelikeyou.com/ Joanne (T.B.)

    Perhaps instead of kicking a member out of the House for bad behaviour, the Speaker could order him or her to sit in the corner for the rest of the day. ;)

    And no talking to the press.

  • FrustratedVoter

    Don’t the Speaker’s duties include more than just the actual debates in Parliament? Isn’t he/she also responsible for the administration of Parliament Hill?

    I think whoever is chosen should have some tact and empathy and the ability to work with people — as well as the backbone to lay down the law as necessary.

    Me, I’ll take anyone but Galipeau.

  • MJ Patchouli

    Sheer is too tempermental, as George Pringle pointed out above, and also has a tendency to be very smug. We see him a lot on local news TV here, and he is indeed partisan, and when he gets matched up against Goodale, I’m sorry — there’s no comparison of the maturity and articulateness of Goodale compared to the smiley, smuggy Sheer. He needs a few years to grow and pay his dues a little more, so I am voting for Comartin.

From Macleans