The employment storm of ’09 is on its way

Economists expect 251,000 jobs will be lost this year. Will yours be one of them?

by Jason Kirby on Thursday, January 8, 2009 10:05am - 36 Comments

The employment storm of ’09 is on its way

Every Thursday, Kim Kent’s bosses at Cooper Standard tack a list of names to the wall. Cooper is an auto parts plant in Stratford, Ont., that makes rubber door trim for the Detroit Three, and the printout dictates the work schedule for the week ahead. It’s simple, really, explains Kent. “If your name is on the list, then you’re working; if it’s not, you’re not.” On Dec. 11, hers wasn’t. And with that she became yet another victim of the job crunch sweeping the country.

This isn’t the first time the 41-year-old autoworker has faced the axe. Two decades ago she took a job at another auto parts maker, where her father had worked before her, only to see the company go bust during the recession of the early 1990s. As stressful as that time was, it was nothing compared to the anxiety she’s feeling now. “This is so much scarier,” says Kent, 41. “The first time I lost my job, there were lots of other plants in town. Nowadays, there’s nothing else. I don’t know what I’m going to do.”

Kent’s worries have been made worse by the sudden drop in the real estate market. Five years ago, when her job seemed secure, she took the plunge and bought her first house. Once her unemployment insurance cheques begin to roll in, Kent figures they’ll barely cover her mortgage payments, let alone food and other basic living expenses. “My car is sitting in the driveway with a flat tire, another cost I can’t afford to deal with now.” She regularly checks the local newspaper for other types of jobs. There was a “livestock trucking mechanic” position open the other day, but when you don’t know the first thing about engine repair, let alone cattle, what are you doing to do? “If I knew the layoffs were going to be very long term, I’d go back to school,” she says. “But even then I really don’t know what I would study. Where are the good jobs?”

It’s a question being asked far beyond the assembly lines of the automotive industry. After 15 phenomenal years of employment creation, Canada’s job machine is seizing up. Canadians got a startling glimpse of what may be in store last month, when Statistics Canada revealed employers shed a jaw-dropping 71,000 jobs in November, the worst monthly plunge in a quarter of a century. Since then, a steady flow of pink slips at Canadian companies suggests that figure is almost certain to rise.

Pick any region of the country and layoffs are becoming a sad fact of life. Detroit’s Big Three have already laid off thousands of workers in central Canada, and announced they’ll be shutting down many of their plants for a full month. On Bay Street hundreds of lawyers, investment bankers and analysts have been let go. Media companies across the country have slashed their newsrooms—most recently Quebecor axed 600 jobs at its Sun newspaper chain. In Quebec, a major T-shirt maker sent 400 packing. In Calgary, 400 carpenters building housing for oil sands workers are themselves out in the cold. And in Vancouver, industries as diverse as mining and video game development have slashed jobs and are closing up shop.

Add it all up, and economists believe unemployment is set to jump dramatically over the next two years, and no province or industry is immune. TD Economics estimates 251,000 jobs will be lost over the next nine months. The major bank economists are cautiously optimistic that the country won’t see a repeat of the downturns in the 1980s and 1990s, when the ranks of the unemployed swelled to around 12 per cent of the workforce; if they’re wrong, the scale of job losses would be far worse. During the 1990s Canada suffered two straight years of job losses totalling 356,000, warns James Marple, an economist with TD Bank. “Our forecast is that job losses won’t be that dire,” he says. “But the risk of job losses being worse than we anticipate is there.”

So the ultimate questions on most people’s minds are these: could one of those vanishing jobs be mine? Who’s safe and who’s at risk? What parts of the country will be hardest hit? And can I do anything to protect myself?

Bookmark and Share
  • T. Thwim

    I’ve already lost one job specifically due to the industry’s concerns about the economic future. Fortunately, I’ve always believed in diversification, so losing one source of income isn’t too bad, it just means more effort can be put into the others.

  • K.Kent

    UPDATE: Kim Kent is one of the lucky ones. I was recalled to work at Cooper Standard after only being laid off for 3 weeks — this time. But many of my brothers and sisters whose livelihoods rely on the manufacturing sector haven’t been as lucky. While this article focuses on the doom and gloom facing us in 2009 it should be noted that over 400,000 jobs have been lost in the manufacturing sector over the last 5 years in this country already.

    Working people like myself are scared. This crisis is a lot different than the recession of the early nineties. Then, we still had the Auto Pact that protected Canadian jobs in the automotive sector. There was a hope that we would come out of the temporary downturn and employers would start hiring again — and they did. But as a result of neo-liberal policies like the North American Free Trade Agreement, whole industries have closed up over the last decade and left the country! While the recent auto ‘bailouts’ are welcome news for the short term, without a long term strategy to level the playing field in global trade, the auto sector and the estimated half million jobs it supports in Canada is doomed.

    Once my Employment Insurance starts running I will only receive 45 per cent of my gross earnings which is only around $20 more a week in benefits than I received fifteen years ago. Our EI program is deplorable, especially during these times of crisis. Not only is the benefit level at an historic low but less than half of unemployed Canadians even qualify for it at all! Training programs are woefully inadequate. The above article suggests we train for jobs that will always be in demand like doctors, nurses, and teachers but the current EI system will only support training that takes less than two years, preferably less than one, and seldom, if ever, at the university level.

    Maybe we should follow the advice of the vice president at Manpower and all become ‘specialists in corporate restructuring’. There should be good job security there!

    • http://maclean Joe

      you haven’t work a day in your life at Cooper

    • Scott

      “Working people like myself are scared. ”

      I am sick to death of hearing phrases like that. Just because I’m not a blue collar worker doesn’t mean I don’t ‘work.’ Guess what, I don’t get overtime and I take my laptop home all the time and I’m working my butt off.

      • It is what it is

        I am sorry for anyone that loses their job – but the free ride is over. Anyone that did not see the demise of the manufacturing secotr either cannot read or just refused to believe it. Drinking beer on the weekend and getting paid $60K a year to put a bolt in a door is not work. Try putting yourself through multiple univeristy degrees part time while working 60 hrs a week in a white collar job. Now that is real work. I never understood why people live way beyond their means ($400K house) and expect to get paid big bucks adding little value and then can’t quite fathom why they are not better taken care of when the obvious happens. Just be glad that there is EI.

    • Union Boss

      without a long term strategy to level the playing field in global trade, the auto sector and the estimated half million jobs it supports in Canada is doomed

      It’s because your a high cost producer that your job is in jeopordy pal. Thank your unions for that.

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/rave_in rave_in

      One of the lucky ones? You have no credability when it comes to labour issues. You sold out four hundred senior employees to put your self ahead of them when a certain Cooper plant closed. For all your Union activism, that will be your legacy . Sister.

  • http://ragingranter.blogspot.com Raging Ranter

    K Kent, how has NAFTA caused jobs to move to China? NAFTA was only between, you know, NA countries. Manufacturing moving to Third World countries is something quite different from NAFTA. I hate to disappoint you, but there is no level global playing field, never was one, and never will be one. People in poor countries will work for pennies, and that won’t change anytime soon. Whatever future employment prospects our country has, it doesn’t include competing for labour-intensive jobs with heavily populated low-income countries. I don’t pretend to have the answers, because I don’t have them. But I do know where the answers DO NOT lie, and that is in attempting to level the unlevelable. By the way, Autopact was only ended a couple years ago, long after the manufacturing exodus was under way.

    • Shenping

      I don’t think there Canada has a problem with a level playing field in the auto sector. Very few cars are actually “imported” into the NAFTA zone. Shipping is too expensive. Within the NAFTA zone, Canada has the competitive advantage, since we are roughly on par with the States on skill & expertise, but our nationalized health care makes manufacturing cars more affordable here. The playing field may be tilted, but in our favour. There’s a convergence of crises effecting the industry. The first is deplorable management in the American manufacturers. Ignoring rising gas prices, no focus on quality control, caving in to every single union demand in exchange for union’s lobbying power, and spending billions on advertising to keep consumers buying vehicles that aren’t in their best interests aren’t problems with the playing field. And when they coincide with a collapse in the banking & real estate fields, it’s a recipe for disaster, but not a playing field problem.

  • http://ragingranter.blogspot.com Raging Ranter

    My one reason for optimism right now is that economists are unanimous in predicting doom. Since economists can’t yesterday’s sunrise if you played it for them on tape, I consider their morbid forecasts a light at the end of the tunnel. Albeit a faint one.

    • sf

      Hear, hear. I agree. There’s onlt a handful of economists worth listening too. If an economist admits he doesn’t know everything then he might be worth listening to.

      • David Bakody

        Economist Hello Harper is one with a Masters degree ……. just remember it was those clowns who got us into this mess selling the future for hedge fund managers. Who got the $ billions of taxpayer bailout money …… banks and financial institutions …. around the world ….. with no contracts ,,,, no accountability … and now the news is they want more ….. It is like asking the greatest train robber in history Jessie James which train to put your money on …… Next trick is wage freezes and wage roll back and even pensions ( now being reported in the US) ….. so do you want to believe some economist ….. good …. you put your money on Wall Street ( now reported to be DOA due to any lack of confidence in public) or the TSX (getting there) ….. hello … now there are talking Securities Regulation …. matters not ….these clowns move the money offshore to play silly games (to inflate their numbers and bonuses) ….. that is what got us in to this mess ….. World Wide WTO Greed ( White collar theft)…. these clown made billions and socked it away …… and our money went south …….they went to Dubai ……. to be continued ……

  • Grass Roots

    During the election, “Don’t Worry Be Happy McGuinty” wasn’t concerned about jobs. Companies were packing up and leaving and Dalton simply hired more civil servants. The province requires less electricity, but this hasn’t stopped the development of higher cost nuclear facilities where the unions have negotiated fantastic contracts for their members. Other provinces, such as Saskatchewan, are making regular trecks to the have-not province and luring some of our best to move west. Barrack Obama’s reforms to Medicare, will require more doctors, and there is an excellent chance that Ontario doctors will be lured away by offers of better pay, better working conditions and less tax. And there’s a good chance that the more reasonable UAW will out compete the CAW and bleed more manufacturing jobs from the province. Things are going to get very bad for the McGuinty province.

    • oompus boompus

      “Things are going to get very bad for the McGuinty province.”

      Very bad, yes. But not for the Mr. McGoo and his pals. Consider what happens in the halls of Q. Park and in the halls of bureaucracy when the stuff hits the fan and jobs go south, go west, go to Asia, or wherever.

      All of these bad things you describe are a boon to those in the govt. More misery, a bigger crisis, more unemployment – this is just the ticket for holding long sessions of the legislature, and then coming up with all kinds of expensive “remedial” programs. Bigger budgets for all kinds of departments and ministries. Bigger headcounts. More promotions and pay increases for the people who work there, because the “increased responsibilities”. More contracts being let out to cronies for office space, computers, transportation, consulting, etc. More pork to spread around those critical ridings which will determine the outcome of the next prov. election. And of course in cabinet ministers’ ridings.

      No doctors, no MRIs, electrical blackouts, more unemployment … Of course it sucks to be you when all this happens, but you know what they say, if you want to make an omelette …

  • http://680news P hirsch

    It’s all in the price of Gas,, if it stays around 75 and leave it there we will spend more on things we want ,, l had to down grade my truck,, WHY ? The big jump in gas . i want to buy another but with the gas prices the way they go no way.. I’II just save my money and stop spending on everything,, All because of the bloody Gas companys

  • Len

    No job is safe. Everyone I know is scared to death right now – regarless of what they do for a living, from white collar professionals to blue collar truck drivers. With most Canadian home owners being about 3 mortgage payments away from losing their homes, I see nothing but dark clouds on the horizon. We are not waiting for a great depression – WE ARE IN ONE! The suicides at the top…they’ll be working their way down the social scale soon. How anyone can predict a turn around is beyond me because we don’t even know how bad it’s going to get! I wish everyone the best. I hope we learn how to act more like communities in our neighbourhoods instead of little sylos, operating independently of each other – not even knowing each other…you may need that neighbour or they may need you for survival soon. Over the years I’ve diversified my career in to many areas and am qaualified to do just about anything with computers, sell real estate, offer technical training, make drinks at a bar…but still…I don’t feel this will be enough. I hope times will return to prosperity in time for my teenage son when he hits the job market after university…ya, I think it’s going to take that long. :(

    • Grant

      I think you’ve been watching too much news. Even if we get to a 10% unemployment rate, it’s still a 90% employment rate. People still need to buy toilet paper to wipe their behinds. They need to buy food to feed their families. Somebody has to make all these things.

      Will it be tough? Sure. But is it cataclysmic? Absolutely not.

    • Bill

      I recognize that a lot of people are concerned for their jobs, but I am not. I feel quite safe working in the medical industry. People will always be sick, houses will always burn, people need to eat, sleep, drink, swim break the law, and such. There will be hard times but not for many people.

  • Len

    No job is safe. Everyone I know is scared to death right now – regarless of what they do for a living, from white collar professionals to blue collar truck drivers. With most Canadian home owners being about 3 mortgage payments away from losing their homes, I see nothing but dark clouds on the horizon. We are not waiting for a great depression – WE ARE IN ONE! The suicides at the top…they’ll be working their way down the social scale soon. How anyone can predict a turn around is beyond me because we don’t even know how bad it’s going to get! I wish everyone the best. I hope we learn how to act more like communities in our neighbourhoods instead of little sylos, operating independently of each other – not even knowing each other…you may need that neighbour or they may need you for survival soon. Over the years I’ve diversified my career in to many areas and am qaulified to do just about anything with computers, sell real estate, offer technical training, make drinks at a bar…but still…I don’t feel this will be enough. I hope times will return to prosperity in time for my teenage son when he hits the job market after university…ya, I think it’s going to take that long. :(

    • oompus boompus

      “ya, I think it’s going to take that long”

      It shouldn’t take that long, but it probably will. You should have a short, sharp recession as bad investments, bad debt, bad companies and bad banks are liquidated. That is how every bursting bubble up until the 1920s was handled – free enterprise and free people stopped doing what was unprofitable and resumed profitable activities. What changed after 1929 was that you had a bull market in governmental arrogance, expressed as a will to “fix” everything, and a long bear market in common sense among the public.

      I know I’m swimming against the tide, but I will fight against it anyways. There is no excuse for continued public ignorance when so much accurate economic information is now available free for anyone to read.

      lewrockwell.com/orig9/recession-reader.html

      (note, most of the books listed for sale at the mises site except for the ones by Murphy and DiLorenzo are available free online at the same site, google a bit and you’ll find them)

  • larry

    In my career as an electrician I have been laid off on or near December 24 four times in fifteen years. This time it was from North America’s largest solar power generating project. We raced to get a small portion of the project on-line to the grid on December 17. Jobs of this size require enormous amounts of capital and it may be that due to the ‘credit crunch’ the manufacturer halted construction, it might also be the somewhat different climate than California and the managers have never seen snow or cold. Whatever the reason I have learned to save some loonies for these times. It is never easy when you may have to live from week to week and when I hear complaints about the wages of construction workers I get a bit upset. I have had years of below poverty income and some good ones too, the simple trick is to spend less than I earn all the time. I can sympathize with all those who are being told not to report to work…it makes you feel unwanted. This latest downturn into depression is not only economic but emotional as well. To those without work in the near future I can offer a suggestion to take some time to help out as a volunteer in your city soup kitchens or shelters. Helping others will always make our spirits rise above our own despair.

    cheer Larry

    • sf

      Good luck.

  • Chris

    If you have looked at the Unemployment figures that were put out today by Stats. Canada, are not the actual unemployment numbers.
    Once you have fallen off the Employment Insurance Roles of any province in this country, you no longer register as unemployed. All the statistics that you see are based on the actual people on the dole and not people who’s benifits have already expired.
    If you want the actual unemployment numbers you have to change how you collect your information. As for a City of Thunder Bay, almost everyone who has been laid off by the forest industries, are no longer on the Employment insurance roles, hence they are not counted as unemployed. If you added them our unemployement rates would be close to 15-18 % of the population.

    If you want a big project that will help all of Ontario, the proper expansion of the Welland Cannel for movement of larger ships with employ thousands of people and take at least ten years.

  • Grass Roots

    Don’t get me going on unions and their insatiable craving for more and more and more and more. Unions worked hard to get McGuinty re-elected. Why? Because they knew Dalton was easy. And the political arm of the Unions, Taliban Jack, who is supported by the Canadian Islamic Congress, used an underhanded method to try and steal an election from the people. Canada is rapidly becomming a hoplesly divided country.

    • TobyornotToby

      With your Taliban Jack and Islamic Congress smears you are the one that is working to “hopelessly divide” Canada. Why don’t you reign in your own rhetoric and figure out a way to get along with other Canadians as your contribution to uniting the country?

  • arlea

    Tell me I’m not the only one not surprised by our current economic state. I’ve been waiting for this ‘correction’ for the last 3+ years! Was it not obvious to all that most were living beyond their means? Come on, how was it possible that the average family ‘appeared’ to have had a beautiful house with two new(er) cars in the driveway, children into all kinds of activities, equipped with the latest cell phones and gagets gallor, all the while taking in expensive family vacations each year… not to mention the expenses put towards lifes necessities!! My spouse and I bring in a generous annual income but at the end of the day, I know what we can and can’t afford. And it sure isn’t what I’ve mentioned above. What happened to everyone else?

    I enjoyed the perspective of this article; the good, bad and ugly. We may be in a recession but it’s not all doom and gloom; don’t get sucked into everything coming from the media. Now is the time to put things in perspective, regroup and return what one could never afford.

  • Kim Morton

    I grew up in the forest industry and have survived countless boom, bust cycles and will no doubt survive this one too. The last boom was fueled by way too much credit and now all the cards, including most governments are maxxed out. If you want security of employment work in a funeral home. Not many repeat customers but eventually everybody is a customer.

    • David Bakody

      Kim ……. things are far different to-day than yesterday ever was…… this is not a slow down it is a World Financial Crisis …. America is in serious trouble and fighting two wars of their own making ….. the worlds auto industries are in uncharted waters ….. we have the world’s largest every older generation about to retire worn out and broken ….. say what you will the new 65 is not 55, just like an old car, parts wear out …. health care is more expensive and demanding ……. there are many shortages in trained people to do the work as the younger generation know only computer work, Wall Street is DOA ….who in right mind will trust any fund manager ….. white collar crime is so big and spread world wide …. no rules can stop them …… and to top it all off the rich and powerful are about to smash the working class especially the higher middle class who dared move to close to their world …. Kim since the beginning of time the working class were the peasants and nothing has changed ….. think KIm whos children fight wars and fires ….. the rich – never happened ….. and our Armed Forces have become very unattractive and overpaid in their opinion ….. the list goes on …. all different from times gone by …… am I wrong? …. I hope so …. but each day the little guy/gal gets another slap in the face ….. world wide!

  • Pingback: The most popular WordPress.com posts are ranked here according to a special formula. « ATer: Criação de Sites Empresa (5511) 2527-3032. Sites Dinâmicos!

  • ALta Vista Dude

    I was ahead of the curve. I lost my job last year.

  • Wayne

    Like Kim Morton above I started my working career in Cedar Mills here in BC so early on became very educated in the boom and bust pattern. Even though I have been in the IT business for 30 years now (started main frame computing in 77) the same patterns exist albeit not as radical shifts none the less they exist. Frankly I rarely feel sorry for the unemployed who sit around complaining about lack of jobs as I have never had to wait for more than 3 months to get another job a… s I turn getting a job into a job and will go where the jobs are … in which case I recomend Victoria right now as I just got back from a walk and a smoke and saw 2 help wanted signs in one block!

  • joe

    I lose my job at the end of every job. That’s because the job is finished. If I don’t have a job to go to next, I live on my savings. I have no debt, because I worked in good times to pay it all off. I don’t live beyond my means. I have one credit card and it is paid off every month. My parents grew up in the Dirty Thirties. They didn’t have EI, welfare, CPP or Health Care. So, most people today should just get a grip. Your own parents made do with less.

    As for all the doom and gloom: gasoline is half what it cost a few months ago, interest rates are the lowest I’ve ever experienced and not everyone is out of work. people still have to eat, heat their homes, go to work if they are working, take the bus, go to school, teach, bank, and yes – still invest their money. Our population is still growing so we need to build more homes, offices, stores, string power lines, telephone cable, fibre optics. buy or sell office equipment, clothes, used vehicles, new vehicles, repair stuff, paint, renovate, relocate people, sell real estate, buy real estate, file taxes, call our accountants, lawyers, friends, neighbors.

    I’ve seen three recessions and survived them all, stock crashes, Dot-com crashes, Asian contagion, savings and loan debacles. The world didn’t end those times and it won’t this time. Sure people lost out, lost their jobs, just make sure it isn’t you this time and prepare for the next time because there always will be a next time.

  • David Bakody

    Yes indeed the worst has yet to come even thought (Canada’ s Economy is as strong as the Canadian Shield) ….. “Nothing in Politics happens by accident” having said that I would like to take everyone back to the Harper/Flaherty Autumn 2008 Financial Update ….. many wondered why they attacked government unions with a “No Strike Clause” after they signed a peaceful 4 year low wage increase contract …… Are all you journalist listening? ….. The US is now talking of wage freezes and wage roll backs …… now does it all make sense …. and if the government does it …. so follows big business ….. California is broke and so are many other towns and small cities and the banks now want more money …… hang on to your hats ….. Do you trust the dynamic duel of Harper/Flaherty ….. who will spend millions trying to sell the same old Separatist and Political Funding CRAP avoiding jobs and health care and telling us Canada is different …… different than the rest of word? We need our professional journalist more than ever …… the truth belongs to your professional talents …. if we lowly bloggers can dig this up ….. you can a least hold them responsible ….. no more silly questions pre-submitted …. and should them demand them ….. tell the public first with a blanket statement ….. this question comes only because Harper screened it first ……… and hold all Minister accountable….. bout time …. were sinking and all Canadians need to know the truth ……

  • David Bakody

    Jason ….. the boys were sitting in Tim’s this morning and I said …. look out the window guys … how many of these hard working people driving to work are thinking ” How long will my job last” many said almost at the same time …… “All of them” !

  • Generation X

    So, is the government going to reverse it’s decision on mandatory retirement ages? If not, the baby boomers will work until they’re 80 and being dragged out of the office in a coffin. It’s too bad they spent all of their dollars spoiling their rotten kids and spending indisciminately to the detriment of the following generation that is getting the boot. Dinosaurs, retire!!!!

  • Amy

    The only jobs I would love to see disappear are those telemarketing jobs. Although we now have the “do not call list”, I still get these types of calls and I am really exhausted of reporting each one. And all the shady tradesmen who took advantage of the good economy and screwed me over big time with bad workmanship. Now with this economy only the good tradesmen will prosper. Good luck to everyone who has lost their job in the auto sector and manufacturing industries – I hope things will work out for you. I was outsourced 3 years ago from the best job in the world and have only been able to find contract work, which I hate as there is no job security at all!

From Macleans