From the Words We Don't Often Find Ourselves Typing In That Order department: Hurray for Jason Kenney!

by kadyomalley on Saturday, January 24, 2009 8:39am - 75 Comments

… as well as his ministerial staff, bureaucratic advisors, departmental officials both at home and abroad — really, pretty much everyone who played a part in making sure that this made-for-Canadian-TV story had a happy ending.

From today’s Globe and Mail:

Afghan woman given refuge in Canada

Masoda Younasy’s first mistake was her unwillingness to conform to the strict rules of conduct governing women in Afghanistan.

Her second was being fearlessly – some might say recklessly – willing to talk about her disdain for customs that render many Afghan women the chattel of their fathers or husbands.

For her perceived insolence, Ms. Younasy was forced to flee the country where her grandfather ruled as king for four decades. She arrived in Toronto Friday from Islamabad after obtaining an exceptional three-year permit to live and work in Canada.

Federal Immigration Minister Jason Kenney signed the papers during a recent trip to Pakistan and India. It is the first time since the Conservatives took office in 2006 that this kind of protection has been extended to someone outside the country. [...]

“My relations are calling me [to say] that they will kill me because they saw the newspaper and they saw my picture,” Ms. Younasy said in December. She had called the Globe from the home of a friend in Kabul, where she was in hiding.

“I got a message from my uncle,” she said. “He told me that this time we are not going to leave you alive.”

Then her family in Kandahar got a call from the Taliban, who were also looking for her. And one of her best friends, who had occasionally worked with her at the construction company, was gunned down.

Afghan experts said there was no way to help her. Too many supporters of the regime of President Hamid Karzai are trying to get out of the country as the Taliban regaincontrol over vast swaths of land.

Mr. Kenney’s staff office was asked for advice. Three hours later, a spokesman for the minister called to say Mr. Kenney was moved by the story and was trying to figure out what he could do to secure Ms. Younasy’s safety.

Bureaucrats suggested issuing the permit that is sometimes given to foreigners who are already in Canada on a temporary basis and must remain for humanitarian reasons.

But Ms. Younasy had to get to Pakistan to get the documents, and she was not answering her phone or her e-mail. It took four days for her to resume contact with Canadian officials and to learn the good news.

During that time, her uncle had called the home in Kabul where she was staying to ask whether she was there. “My mom told me change your location and don’t tell anyone where you are. So I changed my location and now I am in a hotel,” she explained when she resurfaced.

It took a few days and some wrangling to get her a visa for Pakistan. Finally, on Monday, she flew to Islamabad to obtain the documents that allowed her to get on the plane to Canada Friday. [...]

As divided as Canadians may be over Afghanistan, our foreign policy and what our role in the world should be, I have a feeling that, if asked for an example of the kind of thing that the government should be doing in our name, most would point to the above and say, “More like this, please.”

UPDATE: For more background on the remarkable Ms. Younasy, check out the original Globe interview in which she mused about someday running for the presidency.

Bookmark and Share
  • Compos Mentis

    Kudos to Mr. Kenney!

  • Caper

    About time.. There must be many more situations like this. Unfortunatley we will never be able to change the culture of foreign nations. That will come only by evolution.. In the meantime we can step in and assist where we can.

  • Anon

    Right. Good for Ms Younasy.

    Well, there’re thousands of women in Afghanistan, Iran, Darfur and elsewhere who are enduring much worse everyday.

    What is Kenney going to do about them?

    The cynic in me says that this is little more than a taxpayer funded publicity exercise for the Kenney-for-Conservative-Leader campaign.

    • janice

      Liberals just have to politicize everything, whether they are in power or waiting to get back into power. Such is the plight of freedom seeking, education seeking Afghan women, to be coldly cast as a political move. Or the hopelessly predictable partisan rhetoric of the various Liberal spokesmen this week concerning the upcoming budget. Get out of the Ottawa bubble for a week or two you morally challenged bobbleheads.

      • Ti-Guy

        Oh, please. You can’t help but be cynical about all the glorious rhetoric surrounding nation building, civil rights and social justice after the last eight years of disastrous military misadventure.

        • http://www.macleans.ca Kady O’Malley

          Surely it’s possible to be cynical about the glorious nation-building rhetoric while still being genuinely glad that this woman was able to flee to Canada. Not that I’m saying you can’t be cynical about both, of course, but you shouldn’t feel as though you have to choose.

          • Ti-Guy

            Personally, I’m more bitter than cynical. Too many accusations of Saddam- and Taliban-hugging.

          • Dee

            Wonderful! A grand-daughter of a king, who has no political connections, was able to escape.
            Looks like only those with the right pedigree are able to escape.

            I’m with Anon on this one. Cynicism and all.

      • http://www.macleans.ca Kady O’Malley

        I’d have to say that your rebuke would be considerably more effective if the very first word of it wasn’t an example of exactly the sort of politicization you go on to sanctimoniously condemn.

        • janice

          You are right Kady. I should have refrained from saying Liberals were politicizing this or that issue. Thanks for reminding me. – Brenda Martin -ish

          • Vates

            Liberals are not mentioned in the story.

            No one here spoke for, or identified with, the Liberal party.

            Apparently anyone who even might possibly slightly disagree with you is . . . a Liberal.

            You aren’t Ryan Sparrow’s sister, by any chance?

  • http://myblahg.com Robert McClelland

    Too many supporters of the regime of President Hamid Karzai are trying to get out of the country as the Taliban regain control over vast swaths of land.

    So as our little exercise in democracy building nears its tragic conclusion we’re now supposed to be proud that the Cons have helped get one woman out of Afghanistan. Forgive me if I don’t rush to join you on the parade route of lowered expectations.

    • http://www.macleans.ca Kady O’Malley

      I’m not disagreeing with what you or Anon are saying, really, but as far as coming to the aid of women – heck, anyone – facing almost certain death, one may only be one, but it is still one more than zero. Which in no way means one shouldn’t push for more, of course.

      • http://myblahg.com Robert McClelland

        After reading the G&M article in your update I’m not only unimpressed with Kenney but this woman as well. This will undoubtedly shock you but when Ms. Younasy was confronted by her assassin she should have pulled out $1,000 and told the guy to slit the throat of the a-hole who ordered the hit on her and then deliver his head to her uncles. When confronted with a death threat in a lawless society it is acceptable to take the law into your own hands in order to protect yourself.

        • http://www.macleans.ca Kady O’Malley

          Well, we all make different choices. Hard to know what one would do in that situation until you’re faced with it.

        • Vates

          Remind me to keep that strategy up my sleeve.

        • Critical Reasoning

          Thanks for the chuckle, McClelland. Nobody does self-satire better. You really are a first-rate clown.

          • http://myblahg.com Robert McClelland

            Nyuk, nyuk, nyuk.

      • Brad

        I wonder what Jason’s boss will have to say about this? Is Jason allowed to make this type of decision? Or, was the three hour delay caused by Jason asking for permission?

    • mike

      So. you mean Chretien’s folly, right?

  • Wascally Wabbit

    Minister Kenney has to work a heck of lot harder to catch up with the work that this NGO organization has done in the past – and continues to do…

    http//www.sharbatgula.org

    Sharbat Gula is the Afghani woman whose photo was on the cover of National Geographic about 25 years ago – her amazing green eyes staring out at the reader. The NG reporter who prepared the original piece went back to Afghanistan a few years back to see how her life has changed since the Tilban was driven out of power…found her…and ran a followup in NG.
    The Sharbat Gula Center is focused upon helping women in regimes that constrict their full emancipation. One of the co-founders – whose photo is the tenth in the photo montage of Afghanistan on the web site – is an American / Saudi woman – whose name – for reasons of her own protection – was removed from the site – becasue she herself returned to Saudi Arabia – and is caught in the constraints of that repressive regime.
    The Center always welcome volunteering and financial contributions…

  • William

    Hurray for Kady for recognizing what is a useful role for gov`t employees. Good Government is like training a dog—-you can`t be all about discipline—a little pat on the back occasionally seems to have good long term results. I`m sure Jason thanks you for the treat.

  • Dave

    It’s going to be tough rearranging my attitude toward Jason Kenney, the politician. But, you’re right, this story speaks well of him, the Minister of the Crown . Reminds me of the novelist from Bangladesh who has, for a couple of decades, been under similar threats for advocating for the same things in her homeland.
    A small point that strikes me in this story is the reference to supporters of Karzai leaving Afghanistan as the Taliban advances. Bodes ill for Karzai and his foreign support,…like us.

  • Jenn

    I agree with you, Kady. Yes, many more need to be helped. But that doesn’t negate the fact that Jason Kenney DID step up and help someone when he could. He did it well and he did it in our name. So good on him! Bravo!

  • Chuck VS Macleans

    Wow, what a crazy story..

    Thanks for pointing this out Kady.

  • http://www.macleans.ca Kady O’Malley

    Just a note – I’ve updated the post to include a link to the original Globe interview with Ms. Younasy – she really is an amazing young woman.

    • Anon

      Not exactly part of the downtrodden in Afghanistan, is she? A fairly good PR operative too.

      All of 22 years old. She wants to get a Canadian (why not British? or Australian?) or American degree. Then she wants to go back and run Afghanistan, presumably when she is 25. Hopefully, she has some money saved/siphoned from those construction projects to pay for her education.

      Amazing is the word I’d use.

      But then again, if Stephen “TheStrategist ™” Harper could run Canada with a post-graduate degree and not much else, why can’t Ms Younasy run Afghanistan with just an undergraduate degree?

  • Dave

    I just read the update.
    So, I’ll be the one to say something stupidly simplistic about it.
    You want to help the women of Afghanistan, then give them the guns, rather than the men.

  • sf

    We will prevail in Afghanistan so that people like Ms Younasy do not have to flee to Canada to live in freeedom.

    Hopefully she can go back to manage her company some day, because that is where she is needed the most.

    • http://myblahg.com Robert McClelland

      We will prevail in Afghanistan so that people like Ms Younasy do not have to flee to Canada to live in freeedom.

      Good gawd. All we need is for her to be whisked off a rooftop by helicopter for the imagery to be complete.

      • janice

        Your cynical world of legomen must be so lonely and cold. Gawd i think there is an atheist reunion you’ve forgotten to go to this weekend.

        • Vates

          Gawd you’re right. Jeezus, gotta go!

  • John D

    Ministers (of all political stripes, not just Conservatives) are great at helping individuals they find out about personally. If only they were as good at implementing policies that help people in the first place. I know these circumstances are beyond Mr. Kenney’s control, but I’ve seen so many circumstances where politicians are more than eager to help one person but not address the exact same problem if it is affecting a portion of society.

    But yes, kudos to Mr. Kenney and I really, really hope sf is right but I haven’t seen much evidence to suggest he/she is.

  • Wayne

    Well done … what is particularly significant besides the fact that helping a person is important but that it seems the Taliban don’t seem to like it and as far as I am concerned anything they see as a threat is a new friend o mine!

  • Mike T.

    This must be some horrible lie!! All the women in Afghanistan are now in school. Or at least that’s what the hawks keep blathering. DEMOCRACY!! FREEDOM!! HEARTS!! MINDS!!

    • Critical Reasoning

      Your witless sarcasm was very effective at demolishing the claims of those straw-men “hawks”. You should consider switching to the Torstar comment boards – I think it’s a better fit for you.

      • Mike T.

        My wit isn’t destroying their argument. Crowing about being able to sneak a single women with fairly western ideals out of the country several years after its been occupied is what’s destroying their argument.

  • Wascally Wabbit

    Actually – hate to flog the dead horse to some of the cloth eared bloggers here – but the good work that is being done in Afghanistan is being done principally by NGOs – the good part that Canada CAN claim is that our military is providing cover for these brave folks while they do their work of rebuilding / building new schools -especially for Afghani girls and women.
    I have just finished working on a project back here in Canada with a Canadian Reservist who had recently returned after seven months in Kandahar province doing just that – and it is good to hear of the positive results coming from Canadian involvement.
    The type of involvement that we should continue with beyond 2011 – when the military part ends!

  • http://www.bornin63.wordpress.com Karen Krisfalusi

    I’d rather we take in 1000 residents of Gaza at this time than Ms. Yousanbyml.. how do you spell it again?

    • Chuck VS Macleans

      Wow, you are a class act..

      (Sarcasim off)

      • Another Sean

        I think that she’s missing the “cl”, there…

        • nascarfan

          That’s for sure!

    • Mike T.

      I keep thinking, imagine if before 9/11 Canada had announced it would take several thousand afghan refugees and immigrants because of the harsh conditions of the gov’t there. Can anyone imagine the angry fit Preston Manning would have thrown about letting them in?

    • nascarfan

      YOUSANY
      You couldn’t scroll back up?

      Ms. Yousany is an amazing young woman.

      • http://www.bornin63.wordpress.com Karen Krisfalusi

        nasscarfan,
        you suck!
        Yousany,
        you lucky!

        the photo of her in the airport wearing sandals with a winter coat did capture my heart (ala Jason Kenney) — I’m not totally crasss / assinine / kissmyassine. my point — that maclean’s here said squat about gaza while it was under fire, but can put out this type of rah-rah over what is obviously an obscene favourtism shown toward one the Afghan elites, who should have said ” take me…and this one also”…if she was truly one of the people…
        let me be the first to educate her about Canada.

  • Chuck VS Macleans

    Thanks for the update Kady.

    I can’t believe she is only 22 and owns her own construction company in afghanistan, WTF. I just cannot imagine the stuff she has gone through.

    Geez, I am 28, and my biggist worry is if I will make it to comic con this year, this story really puts in perspective how good we have things in Canada…

    I am so glad I live in Canada, what a crazy story…..

  • john g

    Wow. What a sad bunch of commentary. There is just no pleasing some people.

  • wml

    It’s nice to see a politician do the right thing because it’s right, and not for political gain. Right on Mr. Kenny we need more of that…keep it going.

  • Sisyphus

    A good news story ! Throw it to the ground. Then kick it !

    But I still don’t like Jason Kenney.

    • MJH

      What’s liking someone got to do with it?

      • Critical Reasoning

        “Liking someone” has got everything to do with it when you’re hyperpartisan.

        • Sisyphus

          I’ve always been partial to the Anabaptists.

  • kody

    I take it folks have no clue here about the brutality of the Taliban rule on women. I also take it, that folks have no clue on the amount of liberation women there experienced since their overthrow (no its not up to our standards now by a long shot, but women aren’t being shot in the head in soccer fields for the crime of having a boyfriend).

    There couldn’t be a more “just” war than first taking out Taliban rule and then seeking to keep them at bay from regaining their horrific rule.

    I credit the Chretien government for supporting it then, and the CPC government for continuing the support.

    That the left needs to find an “escape from Afghanistan” story as the only source of redemption in this conflict is beyond sad.

    The anti-war left will seemingly oppose any conflict (if it involves the use of US power which to them, is inherently evil).

    Note to my leftist friends: silence in the face of evil, is itself evil.

    And yes, there are far, far, far greater evils on this planet than the expression of US power. The Taliban rule is one of them.

    • Ti-Guy

      Pull yourself together, Kody.

      • glak from planet zork

        I’ve read most of the above. I gather that if Jason Kenney can’t save everyone, he dare not save one. Must be some kind of leftist thing.

    • http://myblahg.com Robert McClelland

      I also take it, that folks have no clue on the amount of liberation women there experienced

      Sure we do, kody. They’re being liberated right out of the country.

      • kody

        Sad how folks attention turn to the plight of women in Afghanistan,

        only at a time when it gives them an immediate partisan attack position,

        and not at a time when women were far worse off there under the brutal Taliban regime.

        The reality is that the far left doesn’t really care about rights of the oppressed at all. They care about utilizing the lack of the rights of the oppressed only so far (and not a scentilla more) as it gives them an attack position against their ideological foes.

        This is why the left is put in the perverse position of screaming from the rooftops the “horror horror!!” of waterboarding three terrorists who were vowing to kill more Westerners for the crime of being infidels,

        while for decades ignoring the systematic detention, torture and murder of political dissidents under their favorite thorn in Amerca’s side – Castro. Same continent as us. Far, far worse. Far far more extensive, to a group wholly innocent and worthy of our collective attention.

        So, so sad.

        • Vates

          Among other things, kody, you are a great humanitarian. Not just in the little things, either. In the big things too.

          • kody

            What I’m not is a “fairweather rights activist”,

            purporting to champion the afflicted,

            but only when it corresponds to an attack on my political opponent,

            while leaving those truly afflicted to suffer in silence because those doing the brutality are sufficiently politically aligned (or at least appropriatly anti-American/anti-neocon) so as to earn my tacit green light for brutality.

            “Oh, you hate Bush too? Well then, you’ll get no protests out of us, feel free to torture, murder and terrorize your populace [for such awful crimes as wanting to speak out for political freedom].”

            And off to champion the “rights” of a few avowed terrorists, who not so ironically, murder to create the world in which brutality and lack of rights is the law.

            When the temporary fog of political passion is lifted from this time of ours,

            history will indeed be harsh to those crying for the terrorists’ freedoms, while sitting in scandalous silence for the truly oppressed.

          • kody

            As a fitting example is the name “Abu Garib” prison.

            It’s as if the west discovered the brutality of that place, not in the torture chambers where completely innnocent Iraqis under Saddam were dragged away in the middle of the night from their loved ones to have their lives ended in a horrible tortuous death,

            by the thousands and thousands.

            But the true “horror” was a handful of wrongdoers (not sanctioned by the state but punished by the state for doing so, no less) putting panties on the heads of prisoners and posing in pictures.

            THAT was the horror associated with that notorious prison, and spread round the world in headline after headline.

            THAT prompted the marchers on the left to rise up in outrage, by the tens of thousands.

            Not the murder and torture by the thousands at the hands of Saddam. There were no marches for those poor souls.

            The isolated “pantyhead” incident, that was the forum the ideological opponents of Bush utilized.

    • Shenping

      As much as I generally laugh at Kody’s opinions, the only point I can disapprove of is the last one (assuming by “left” he means the loonie & not moderate variety). The Taliban is a localized (although intense) evil in a country with a low population.

      At any rate, those of us who were political junkies back in the 80′s remember that the Taliban were funded with American money funneled through Pakistan as an expression of US power. The Soviet Union hadn’t had an international debacle on the scale of the Vietnam war, so the Reagan administration had to create one.

      How about a list of the results of the expression of US power? Let’s see — the Mainland China/Taiwan conflict & the resulting China/US proxy wars in Korea & Vietnam & splitting of the Korean peninsula, the creation of the Taliban (see above), the arming of Saddam Hussein, the destabilization & funding of civil wars against democratic governments in Central & South America, the propping of neoconservative dictators like Suharto & Pinochet . . . If I was feeling snarky I could probably fit Coors Light & Baywatch into this argument, too, but it’s hard to keep track of every crime against humanity.

      The Taliban (outside of Afghanistan): the destruction of two office buildings, resulting in an escalation of the expression of US power.

      I’m trying to think of arms given by the US to a foreign group that weren’t later used to shoot at US troops.

  • Sophie

    I, too, can’t believe I’m writing this, but our government did the right thing.
    The decent thing.
    How unfortunate they can’t reach into that place more often.

  • Liz

    Bit of a love fest going on. I have some questions: When did Canada or Kenney learn of her plight? Why only this one woman of substance hied to safety? What about the other good women who were gunned down in the streets? Canadians have been warned before by the Kenney government about the dangers of war-resisters and war refugees coming to Canada, even people who have been wrongfully tortured, imprisoned and who narrowly escaped becomin unaccounted for. What makes this person’s story different?

    What makes Mr. Kenney’s government, Canadians or Ms. Younasy certain that the people who threaten her there will not threaten her here?

    Will the Kenney government need to provide security for Ms. Younasy beyond what is offered to an ordinary run-of-the-mill war refugee?

    Will Canada be seeking out additional worthy people to rescue in it’s new-found role, or is this a one-shot deal?

    Will Ms. Younasy consider taking her university courses in western Canada? Alberta, Saskatchewan and BC have some good schools.

    It seems to be a given that Ms. Younasy is self-supporting…

    Many questions in this good news story.

    • Shenping

      She could study economics at the U of Calgary. They follow the same neoconservative school of thought that helped establish the Taliban back in the day.

      Not to knock the U of C. Its social science & fine arts programs are pretty strong, & it’s one of the better-funded uni’s outside of southern Ontario.

  • http://www.canadianrosebud.blogspot.com burlivespipe

    Exactly right. But would Kenney even bother to cock his head at her story if some UofCal intern hadn’t told him that there was political gold in showing a dose of empathy and signing a paper.
    Otherwise, how do you explain the gov’t's handling of the likes of Martin, Kadhr and Arar?

    • glak from planet zork

      “Kadhr”? Your equating Ms. Younasy to a prisoner of war?

      • Vates

        Oh-ho, he’s a POW now, is he? I think you meant something else.

        • Liz

          True that Kenney lit out for Pakistan for some reason… is this the only reason Canadians paid for the junket: to sign some papers that couldn’t be signed elsewhere or to seal a deal that couldn’t have been dealt with by diplomatic or military means? Why the Kenney junket? Not a one-issue trip, surely!

          • JN12

            Liz, according to the news release about the Pakistan visit, he also did this:
            “Islamabad, January 10, 2009 — Citizenship, Immigration and Multiculturalism Minister Jason Kenney held official bilateral meetings with the Pakistani Prime Minister, Foreign Minister, Advisor to the Prime Minister (Interior Affairs), Information Minister, Minister for Labour and Manpower, Minister of Minorities, and other government officials during a two-day visit to Pakistan. Minister Kenney also met with Canadian visa officers at the High Commission in Islamabad and important Pakistani political figures, as well as religious leaders from different communities.” http://www.cic.gc.ca/ENGLISH/department/media/releases/2009/2009-01-10.asp

        • glak from planet zork

          Semantics.

          • Vates

            I’m sellin’ . . . you buyin’?

          • Shenping

            Sometimes law is all about semantics.

            Khadr was a child soldier, and under international law he can’t be held as POW. The 3rd & 4th Geneva conventions pretty much prohibit his current legal status. Illegal combatants have to be given the same legal rights as POW’s until a “competent tribunal” determines their status to be either that of a POW or as a civilian criminal. If they are determined not to be POW’s, the constitutional rights of the holding country apply. Gitmo violates this, and a case could be made that it’s a crime against humanity, regardless of how evil the section of humanity it detains may be.

            Regardless of whether Khadr was a murdering bastard or a victimized, brainwashed child, he was still a child soldier as defined by international law, and therefore entitled to the protection of the United States Constitution and legal code. Even when it’s ugly as hell & politically inconvenient, justice is still justice.

From Macleans