A generation of failure

For a while, it looked like young workers had finally caught a break. It didn’t last long.

by Jason Kirby on Thursday, February 12, 2009 4:20pm - 74 Comments

But despite all that, after a full quarter-century of spinning their wheels, there were indications earlier this decade that young workers were finally making up for lost ground. It wasn’t just Martin who had seen his fortunes improve. After decades of lagging previous generations, younger workers were pulling ahead, at last. Between 1997 and 2007, hourly wages for workers under the age of 35 outpaced those for all other age groups, according to a Statistics Canada report released last year. Suddenly, with unemployment at a 30-year low and companies struggling to find workers, the new generation finally seemed to have the upper hand. “At last those groups that had been left behind were becoming more valuable as a source of labour,” says Roger Sauvé, president of People Patterns Consulting. On top of that, the younger generation was told they could expect an employment windfall as Canada’s 10 million baby boomers, fully one-third of the population, began to retire.

Then, with almost no warning, young workers ran headfirst into what may be the worst recession in decades. The economic collapse has already claimed 274,000 jobs in Canada over the past four months. Economists believe that figure could easily rise by another 200,000 by year-end, and even that could prove to be optimistic. With each round of layoffs, any hope young workers had of negotiating higher salaries is slipping away. “This generation has been screwed by demography,” says Linda Duxbury, a professor at Carleton University’s Sprott School of Business. “They’ve been through a recession, a jobless recovery and stagflation, while the baby boomers got in there and clogged up all the jobs in the hierarchy,” she says. “Finally, they thought, this was going to be their time. And now we have another recession.”

Duxbury hopes that the situation for young workers will improve somewhat when the economy finally rights itself. “We had a profound labour force crisis before the recession, and when we come out of this recession, we’re still going to have a labour force crisis,” she says. Because of that, she thinks employers are being incredibly shortsighted by focusing on younger workers when it comes to layoffs. “I’m warning employers, if you treat them badly now, it’s going to come back and haunt you.” Still, depending on how long and deep this recession goes, it could certainly wipe out the meagre gains of the past few years. And if it does, then today’s young workers will have the dubious distinction of going down in history as the first Canadian generation ever to do worse than their parents.

Even if things do improve for young workers down the road, it’s cold comfort to couples such as Martin and Fisher. They’re still trying to figure out how they’ll cope with the mortgage payments and other costs of raising a family over the next few years. After catching a tantalizing glimpse of the lifestyle their parents enjoyed, now it’s back to square one. “I can’t get out of the bucket,” says Martin. “I don’t know how I’m supposed to get out when there’s no work.”

Bookmark and Share
  • MJM

    As one of those baby boomers that seem to be the target of most of the nasty comments on this article I must protest – I got my university education in the 1970′s and it was not easier (I paid for my education through multiple jobs most at the minimum wage of about $2.50/hour) and while my friends were heading off to ski weekends I was working, working working. I did my graduate degree after working and saving for 10 years so that I would not go into debt. And during that time I did not go on holidays. I moved numerous times because that is where the jobs were. I didn’t buy my house until I was 38 years old and with a downpayment that I saved and I didn’t buy a huge 3,000 square foot house but a 1950′s bungalow that I’m still in. My friends insisted that their children would have a ‘better’ life which included annual 2 week holidays in Mexico at 5 star resorts (and which the children now just can’t do without and instead of saving the ‘children’ put it on their credit cards and pay the minimum). I didn’t own a car until I was in my early 30′s (have you ever walked through the student parking lot of a university or college – nice new cars – newer and more expensive than the one I currently own!). But my house is totally renovated and I owe nothing on it, by ivnesting in my educaton without going into debt (which is still possible if you are prepared to give up things – like eating out two or three times a week) I have a great income; I don’t take a huge vacation every year – more likely every two or three years but it is all paid before I step on the plane; and while my RRSP and other investments have been hit, I have been through the recessions of the 1970′s, the 1980′s, the dot.com bust of 2000 and the 9-11 attacks – all have turned around and if you don’t have huge debt loads and have invested in companies that actually make needed products, they will also turn around.

    Having said all that, I do feel sorry for the younger generations because they simply have been told by multiple sources that they are special and unique and that they deserve everything because they exist – their parents, their schools, and their politicans have told them this – its not true, but that never stopped anyone before. Yes living in your mom’s basement is sad, but if you are 25 you can work 2 or 3 jobs to pay off your debts and save money – but whining is not going to change things, particularly if you choose to spend all your money on games for your Playstation. And parents you need to kick your 25 year old out of the house – he may have to share accommodation with some others and set some priorities, but in the end it is the basic lessons that were not learned previously.

  • Crystal Mutter

    Wow! I don’t think there’s any need for name calling.

    I think the problem here is differences. Baby Boomers and Generation Xers could not be more different.
    Baby Boomers value experience and money. Gen Xers value education and time. No one way is ‘right’.
    I would say we each have something to learn from each other. But from my vantage point (as a Gen Xer) I see that we do have a difficult road ahead. We’ve had three recessions in our lifetime. We are the most educated generation in history. And, most of us aren’t working at decent jobs. The simple fact is that 1/3 of Canadians are Boomers. And I hate to “whine”, but we are the minority, we are the under-dogs, and we are at the bottom of the barrel until the Boomers retire. BYE BYE!!!

  • GenX reality

    I must agree with MJM the baby boomer although i am a over educated GenX.
    I was the first in my family to ever get a university degree and I worked my butt off to pay off OSAP which i regret taking to this day! I think GenX people are so into themselves sometime it kills me, and I hope we do learn a good lesson out of this.
    All my GenX friends are loaded with debt that its scary. They have all bought a condo or home, racked up credit card bills, drive new cars and they do all this without the fear or thinking about the consequences. I make over 200K a year and I am still scared to buy a house and I see my friends doing it with less than 50K salaries… My friends tell me I am crazy for saving so much money, that i should invest in mutual funds, buy a home, etc.., All I know is that money is the root of a lot of stresses!!! I intend to save till the day I can buy a house I like outright because I know that if I dont have to pay the bank, its more money every month for me to go eat out 3times a week! if I lose my job and still own the house with no debts, I can always work at McD’s and still eat comfortably!!! No Debt, No Stress!!! another good thing about NO debt, you can always tell your employer F-OFF!
    Anyways, there is more to learn from baby boomers than the GenX, if you dont believe me, just look at what your parents did for you!!!

    • C

      Hi GenX reality,

      And where do you think credit cards came from?? Hmmmm……

      I also have a University Degree, plus two certificate trade programs. Any advice for me? I’ve been struggling to get a toe-hold into a position for 5 years. I don’t over-spend. Haven’t been on a vacation for 7 years. Thank you for your opinions. Just remember that we all have one. And, we all come from our unique perspective which we hold dear. So let’s be easy on the finger-waving and stereo-typing. And, come on folks, let’s support our own!!

  • MICHELLE

    I can’t believe how many grown up children especially men live at home with thier parents. I see it also is ok for most of these parents or aleast they don’t say anything outloud in public. Well I’m going to. My son graduated 12 and I’m extremely happy about that. Then after I gave him about 6 or 7 months to relax and enjoys his reward so to speak. Then one day I realized I was paying his unemployed friends that practically lived at our house well some did for different periods of time. FOR FREE OF COURSE. SO THEN i TOLD HIM IT WAS TIME TO GO LOOK FOR WORK.Well he found a job delivering pizzas that didn’t cost me too much You know gas to get to work , oh ya had to buy him a car o he could get those pizzas to you still hot and insurance delivery people have to pay more of course and collision just to be safe so if by change the worst happened he would be able to get right back into another car so he wouldn’t lose his job oh don’t forget the cell phone I drew the line when gps ‘s were brought up. H e grew up here . He should know is way around good enoughand with the fines for being teo lazy atleast that what I call it to put his L and N on or had too many friends in the car.can’t get insurance without paying the fines. Well at this point the tally runs between3 and 4 thousand and he hasen’t even worked a shift yet not bad eh! and I ‘m a single unemployed mom because I got 3 speeding tickets with in 5 years so they prohibatated from being able to even apply for a drivers licence anywhere in Canada OR the USA AND LIKE SO MANY other prohibitated drivers I know I tried to keep working bute was one of the unlucky ones and got caught so there we go another fine to pay $500. and off to jail for 14 days. That was an interesting trip they have 5 seperate cages ( metal Covered over by Plexi glass ) a metal bench type seat theres NO extra space room for 1 and 1 only.. Your handcuffed then they hand cuff your feet and with the heavy duty chain attached to your feet ones they use a pad lock to look your feet to your hands,then shut your cage door put a nother padlock on then they shut the van doorsand lock them as well. I was caught driving well prohibated not running the picton pig farm! no seat belts,heat or anything and up Island we travel from CAMPBELL RIVER TO VICTORIA. . THEN ONTO A PLANE LITTLE TINY BUT VERY LOUD PLANE STILL ALL HANDCUFFED AND SHACKLED. Over to surry we went. got off at some big airport didn’t tell is which one and into another van these guys were alot nicer they gave each of us one of those gray thin wool blankets so we could sit on them or try to keep warm.. As cold as I was I had to choose sitting on it with not enough meat on my behind I discovered two new bones that I didn’t know were even there.and off to surrey pretrial maximum security prison I went I wonder what that cost the tax payers and then it was about 8 days later and they said I was free to go gave me back the clothes I was wearing when I got arrested and pointed at the stairs so I went up them and when I got to the top there was this guy sitting in like a toll booth and he pointed to the door on the right behind him and when I went through it found myself outside locked out because it’s his job to make sure only people that have passes or what ever get in. And a bunch of signs all around saying stuff like NO VISITORS tresspassers would be prosicuted to the fullest the law will allow IF YOU ARE A PERSON JUST RELEASED YOUR REQUIRED TO LEAVE THE PROPERTY IMMEDIATLY OR YOU’LL BE CHARGED AND IMPRISIONED. i WAS LIKE WHAT THE @%#& HOW AM i GOING TO GET HOME but kept on going I wasn’t going back in. OOPS A LITTLE VENTING THERE THANKS FOR LISTENING… But back to my kid he won’t lift a finger around here doesn’t pay me for his cell phone bill in my name or pay his room and board I go buy groceries like $500. at once because it’s very rare that somebody comes around with a licence and I’ve already lost 5 or 6 vehicles to the impound for people driving them without a licence. So he invites abunch of friends over for about 3 days in a row till it’s all gone.I have been asking him to leave since Dec.08 it’s march 09 and he still hasent left!!! what can I do PLEASE HELP

  • Dennis

    The Marines are hiring. Opportunities await in Afghanistan and other places that will surprise you.

  • http://www.lookyoungatlanta.com botox Atlanta

    What's the difference with all the economies if had been hit by one huge recession, I believe that it really doesn't make any difference.

From Macleans