Turns out it wasn't just Pierre Trudeau that thought of MPs as "nobodies fifty yards off Parliament Hill" …

by kadyomalley on Wednesday, April 8, 2009 4:34pm - 16 Comments

The drafters of the Federal Accountability Act apparently felt the same way, which is how defeated Quebec Conservative backbencher Luc Harvey was able to slide into his new career as a consultant lobbyist for two Quebec-based companies — Télécabines Skylink and Composte GL — without the bother of waiting out the five-year cooling off period that applies to ministers, senior civil servants and political staffers. Staffers like, well, this guy, for instance.

Formerly an intern in the office of then-Government House Leader Peter Van Loan, he would likely have worked on the Hill for less than a year, but was nonetheless obliged to apply for an exemption to the five year ban, which was granted late last month. There’s no record of when he applied, and as yet, he hasn’t filed registrations on behalf of any clients, which isn’t all that surprising, since a cursory Googling reveals that he subsequently landed a job at TVO, where he is an associate producer for The Agenda.

Luckily for Luc Harvey, who, as an MP, would have been privy to any and all information shared during closed-door caucus meetings, and got to hang out in the government lobby with cabinet ministers, no such arduous process was required for him to hang up a shingle as a lobbyist for hire. He just had to fill out a form, disclose his brief tenure as MP for Louis-Hebert, and he was good to go, although we’d advise his clients not to count on his ability to make inroads with the Bloc Quebecois, given the unpleasantness that unfolded at a Duceppe event during the final days of the last campaign.

ITQ’s views on the five year ban are reasonably well known, at least amongst those who have read our lengthy screeds on the subject. But honestly, does this system not seem ever so slightly unfair to anyone else?

Bookmark and Share
  • CAPS

    … And let’s go to the video:

  • madeyoulook

    we’d advise his clients not to count on his ability to make inroads with the Bloc Quebecois…

    Is there a massive unrecognized demand for “Bloc” favourables in the lobbying marketplace? OK, they might be slightly higher on the totem pole than, say, the NDP, what with the possibility of official opposition status only available to the former, but still…

    • http://www.macleans.ca Kady O’Malley

      Honestly, if I was running a company in Quebec and wanted to hire a lobbyist, I’d probably look for one that hasn’t actively antagonized the leader of what is still, in effect, the official opposition in that province. But that’s just me.

      • madeyoulook

        Unless all I cared about was getting advice on dealing with Tories, or hiring someone to lobby the governing party. But rest assured, I see your point.

  • PolJunkie

    myl, keep in mind that this is a minority govt and the BQ seat count is significant.

    • http://www.macleans.ca Kady O’Malley

      Also, lobbyists — both in-house and consultant — tend to want to meet with any MPs that might be won over to their side, at least when it comes to regulatory/legislative issues. Usually, an association lobby day includes meetings with representatives from all four caucuses.

  • madeyoulook

    Next question, that is perhaps even more undeserving of a reply than the previous one you so graciously acknowledged:

    Notwithstanding any actual quotes, didn’t PET actually conduct his business on the assumption that individual MPs were nobodies even on the Hill?

    • an online reader

      Next question , beside being warm bodies , fund raisers pr reps and election scoremarkers what is a M.P.s status if not nobodies ? Certainly they cannot compete with lobbyists for results .

    • http://gitardood.wordpress.com paul

      myl – you got that right, to PET everyone else was a nobody because they obviously didn’t shine with his brilliance or they would have had his job instead of him ….I think they should rewrite dictionaries in Canada with a new definition of narcissism which would just have his picture beside the word

  • Wedge

    Kady looking at the registers list – as i did being somewhat nerdy as well – you can also find former MP Roy Cullen who has followed in Harvey’s footsteps – although doesn’t have any cool confrontation videos so may not be as successful…

  • Karen

    I love how someone is reporting about this.
    Mainstream media couldn’t even comprehend this but good job on explaining it.

    • CAPS

      I believe Maclean’s is part of the “mainstream media.”

  • Antsy

    MPs aren’t public office holders. They are elected representatives of constituents. Legislative branch vs executive branch. Once they are part of the executive branch, then the obligations apply during and thereafter.

    • John D

      I would consider Member of Parliament to be a public office.

  • oompus boompus

    But honestly, does this system not seem ever so slightly unfair to anyone else?

    You want my honest opinion? It does seem ever so slightly unfair to me.

    Why should we have such a corrupt, interventionist system in place that companies selling things as innocuous as ski lifts are obligated to put political hacks on their payroll – so that they can influence the government and tilt the table loaded down with bags of taxpayer money towards themselves. Even if they took the high road and refused to lobby for government “help” they would no doubt be killed by taxes and regulations, or would be put out of business by competitors who are willing to put lots of dough into lobbyists and who will legal, accounting and, ah, “consulting” firms with the right political connections.

    It’s not just slightly unfair, the whole thing reeks.

    Oh and “Composte GL” – what is that? It doesn’t seem to exist on the WWW except as something which hires lobbyists.

  • Caper

    It seems to me the “lobbying” is just another form of payoffs. It is just that the money goes to an individual that is once removed.In my mind it is still a corrupt institution.

From Macleans