Canada to shut down all prison farms

The farms are the stuff of lore in the U.S., but they’ll be history here

by Kate Lunau on Friday, April 10, 2009 3:20pm - 31 Comments

Canada to shut down all prison farmsLike those of countless other farm workers, Danny Gallant’s day would begin before dawn. As his co-workers tended to pigs, cattle and hens, he prepared cuts of meat from livestock. The farm where Gallant worked is typical in many ways—except it’s on prison grounds, and all the farm workers are inmates. “I enjoyed going to work,” says Gallant, who was recently released. “Being at the farm was awesome. I learned a lot.”

Across Canada, six federal prisons operate functioning farms. About 300 inmates take part, doing everything from milking cows to fixing equipment to producing food that’s fed to fellow offenders. This summer could be their last harvest: the government recently announced that Canada’s prison farms will be shut down over the next two years. “We determined very few ex-inmates were obtaining work in agriculture,” says Christa McGregor of the Correctional Service of Canada, adding that the CSC spends about $4 million annually on the program.

The National Farmers’ Union is urging the government to reconsider. Betty Brown, who sits on the NFU’s board of directors, argues that agricultural skills are indeed in demand. By shutting down the farms, she says, “they’re saying agriculture’s not important.” The union suggests the move may be a cash grab, as the CSC’s farm properties in Ontario alone are reportedly worth $2 million (CSC hasn’t announced its plans for the land). Others note that the farms help inmates interact with the community, as their produce is often donated to local food banks.

But while Gallant says he learned useful skills on the prison farm, he admits it’s now four months after his release and he has yet to find a job. The major hurdle, he believes, isn’t his skill set—it’s the stigma of having a criminal record. “It’s not looking good for me,” he says. “But that’s another story.”

Bookmark and Share
  • John.K

    “We determined very few ex-inmates were obtaining work in agriculture,” says Christa McGregor of the Correctional Service of Canada.

    Seems to me very few ex-anythings are obtaining work in any field of endeavour lately.

    • ZJM

      As an individual who has had a family member in this type of prison farm, I can say it rehabilitates in more ways than one can imagine. It doesn’t matter the least bit whether they take up agriculture when they get out of the institution. What matters is that they take the steps to re-integrate with the communities and gain valuable skills for when they get out. Harper and his goons are making a terrible, terrible mistake.

    • hipichic

      this is just another series of claims-making done by the rich that the government will follow as its those rich people that support the vote. These farms could be supplying food nationally to all the prisons cutting the costs to the taxpayers by millions. Keeping these prisoners out of solitary and doing something constructive as well as learning is cutting down on prison violence. These farms could also be used to take the pressure off feeding the millions of homeless Canada seems to have..especially since the government is so fond of cutting the budget in areas that hurt the common man. There are so many positive, profitable uses for these farms that they should be expanded. Why do the rich insist on getting richer at the expense of those that make them rich to begin with. What happened Canada? Proud to be Canadian…no not for a long long time.

  • Andrew (Not Potter or Coyne)

    Ummm, isn’t $4 million/yr chump change in a program that could help to rehabilitate offenders?

    • PHK

      no kidding. The system is not working

  • John W

    It’s not whether they will actually get jobs in agriculture, but what they LEARN.
    Another stupid Harper/Manning/Harris etc decision.

    • RRR

      what does this have to do with Mike Harris? He retired years ago from politics and never had any control over federal correctional facilities.

  • Pete Tong, It’s all gone

    “The union suggests the move may be a cash grab, as the CSC’s farm properties in Ontario alone are reportedly worth $2 million (CSC hasn’t announced its plans for the land).”

    $2M? This must be a typo. The farm at Collins Bay Penetentiary in Kingston, Ontario, must be worth at least $5-6M if not more given that it is prime real estate in the middle of the city.

    • Sean C

      I think that being near a prison drives down property values regardless of otherwise being prime real-estate. Now, if the prison were to go away…

  • joefission

    Such a poor idea. These farms seem useful for rehabilitation, they give the inmates productive activity and skills (even if they aren’t high demand – what is these days?), they help to feed the prison population and they donate surplus to food banks. On the prison food/food bank points alone we have good arguments to keep these farms running. Name one other way that society gains a direct measurable return on investment for what we spend housing these guys.

    • John.K

      Quite so. I rather suspect that if we had prison coal mines or prison “dark satanic mills”, we would see the programme expanded.

    • guest

      Basically — it's all about real estate. These folks do NOT care about prison reform or prison employment — they want to sell federally owned buildings and real estate that do not generate apparent profit. This isn't about employment for ex-prisoners, or prison reform. This is about money.

      Heck, these are the same government types who sold off silverware owned by Buckingham palace (and wasn't that, um, illegal?)

  • http://cancrime.com Cancrime

    Interesting that the photo atop this story shows state prisoners in Arizona pitching watermelons for $2 an hour on a private, family-owned farm – a situation that bears no resemblance to the operation of Canadian federal prison farms.

    One of Corrections Canada’s arguments to close the prison farms: They don’t provide meaningful job skills that help the inmates get jobs after release. The photo shows inmates doing menial work that likely provides no job skills that translate to jobs after release.

    Also curious that there’s no photo caption to explain that pic is from a Christian Science Monitor slideshow about the Arizona prisoners working on private farms.

    Links to Christian Science Monitor story and to the prison farm debate in Canada: http://bit.ly/50VO

    • guest

      They DO, however, provide meaningful life skills. I'd like to see you argue that one down, cancrime. Right after you tell the thousands of Canadian farmers that their life's work is irrelvant.

  • http://globe Ted Gamble

    I have never worked on a farm but would bet the life skills learned in such an environment would be transferable to the general coping skills needed in all areas of life to be successful. Could we not develop something that would be financially self sustainable where inmates would have to earn and pay for their keep rather that be housed at the taxpayers expense. This model would possibly be a determent for some while providing much needed life skills for others.

  • Mike S

    I spent most of my summers growing up helping my grandfather on his farm. This hard, manual labour taught me many important lessons that I use in my life today. One thing was the feeling of accomplishment after a hard days work. If these cons get nothing more than this out of working on these farms I would consider it a successful program. What are the stats for numbers of re-offenders between people in this program and those who just sit in jail. I think that would be a better determining factor than just cost. After all, doesn’t someone who contributes to society provide more value than one who doesn’t?

  • wafer

    “We determined very few ex-inmates were obtaining work in agriculture,” says Christa McGregor of the Correctional Service of Canada“

    This has to be the lamest excuse ever. Christa must think the rest of us are idiots. Does anyone think having these people spend all their time doing classroom type programs actually prepares them for anything?

    • guest

      Yes, wafer, they really do think you all are idiots. I work for the Civil Service — and this government, yes, thinks you just don't care, or will be too lazy to act on your concerns.

  • hanami

    I think the government is missing the point. The whole idea behind work initiatives for inmates is to give them a sense of self worth. The skills learned on the job are a bonus. The whole reason why many of these individuals ended up in jail is because of a lack of support system and a subsequent lack of self respect and self worth. These people have little self discipline and working teaches them pride in their work and themselves.

    • guest

      Again: real estate is what matters to this government. That's all. That's it. THey aren't going to change their tactics until you make them.

  • Joannie

    I think shutting down these farms is a very bad idea. Rehabilitation should be the primary objective of prison time. The satisfaction of good days work sounds right to me.

  • cybury

    funny, they want to close prison farms which produce food for needy groups and teach work ethics to prisoners yet I hear nothing of them closing the country club prisons that the choosen privledge class of executive prisoners who do nothing but play golf, squash and horse back riding seem to enjoy. Money sure has its privleges especially under this hateful, privledge class right wing orinted Harper government.

  • Dianna Inkster

    Tomorrow Andrew McCann is asking us to meet at ECO-COFFEE at the Kingston (Shopping) Centre (Thursday, April 30, 2009 at 12:15 (noon + 15 min.) if we want to promote our beautiful urban farm. at Frontenac Institution through Guerilla Gardening or by handing out burgers at the Pittsburgh Institution Roadside Barbecue up highway 15 near Joyceville. For further information, contact Andrew McCann at mccann17@yahoo.com or dial 613-787-4127 for more information..

    You might also find more information by googling “Queen’s Greens” or “Kingston Greens” . As the wife of a type 1 diabetic of 30 years’ standing, I can tell you that food and how it is prepared is vital to good health.

    At one end of the City, we are promoting community gardens and at the other end, we are threatening our wonderful prison farm–I would call it an urban farm, but, in fact, it is a prison farm–instead of making it a part of our community.

    Kingstonians and visitors! Take action tomorrow.

  • Sharon Tobin

    An ancestor of mine found great merit in alternative modes of education. Until I recently perused an American web site dedicated to bringing gardening back into primary educaation, I had no idea Sir William C. MacDonald shared my love of understanding how things grow! Perhaps "The Story of the MacDonald Movement in Canada" "Children of the Land" written by "Herbert Francis Sherwood. printed in the "Outlook" April 1910, might give you a glimpse of his insight. His partner in this and many other agriculturlal education endeavors was James Wilson Robertson. I am aware of these things due to my research on modes of education and extrremely honoured to be a remote relative of this man. I had much difficulty learning to read as a child and have gained a passion to understand other modes of learning. Even dyslexic children can learn to read eventually. I was lucky enough to figure some of those methods out on my own. My great ancestor was also mostly self taught although his siblings all received formal European education. I will never know if we shared early reading difficulties or if we share a different mode of learning. But I do know without any studies or varification, most inmates are not in prison because of there wonderful literacy skills. There are scientific theories noting many different learning styles and those do not even reflect learning difficulties. If we took the time to help people realize there learning styles and differences as adults before sticking them in another situation that has learning as an end product expectation, perhaps we should do our product research. Please forgive any dyslexic lack of editing, I don't see a spell check option!

  • PHK

    You know what ZJM… Obviously by your selection of nouns (they), meaning humans who have been in jail, it's obvious you don't have a clue. It doesn't matter what a persons past has been, their professional credentials, or whatever. Once someone really does their time with a view of "getting their life in order", no matter how earnest or hard they try, folks like you never give them a chance. I know. I have being trying ever since my release. I know you mean well, and you are right. It isn't the people, it's a tough world

  • PHK

    have you..?

  • guest

    So what are you doing about this, good folks of Kingston? Who have you contacted recently, after this long long summer? You want change: you've got to make sure it happens! Otherwise, your concerns will be long forgotten after legislation is enacted.

  • guest

    Well as one of the x farm workers in kingston,I've leard alot from the program enough that i've managed to follow my teaching, pursueing a career in a abbattior and looking further as a owner and operator of my own. I'd like to say thanks,and it would be a shame to see others miss a chance of mabe doing the same .

  • Luke

    I don't think we should give cons any sort of "enjoyable" experience in prison. Save the farming to people who did not commit crimes. Stop wasting valuable land around prisons for the prisoners sake. 4 million would be better spent in our health care system then on a prison farm. We have countless viable/law abiding citizens who would love this opportunity without having to commit a crime. This is the right decision and a start in right direction.

  • Larry Sherman

    Not everyone who is in prison is a dangerous offender. Once again our Gov't is not using the democratic process to allow us the choice.
    Prisoners are allowed to form gangs,kill, do drug deals and bribe whoever they can. Rehab is a joke. They need proper counselling and mentoring. Human rights fights for these people too much and they get rights and privileges before therer is any significant change in their attitudes. The gov't will never listen to us Canadians when there is business at hand and profit; unless we as a nation make a stand.

  • Steve

    I don't know how I only learned about prison farms a few hours ago, but when I did, I thought it was a fantastic idea. I really hope we don't get rid of these programs.

From Macleans