**UPDATED** Reality show shocker: Susan Boyle's got all kinds of talent

47-year-old is Britain’s latest singing—and YouTube—sensation

by Anne Kingston on Tuesday, April 14, 2009 12:11pm - 52 Comments

Reality show shocker: Susan Boyle's got all kinds of talentUpdate: The singing sensation, who seems to have undergone a minor makeover, appeared on CBS’s Early Show this morning via a link from her home in Blackburn, Scotland. Watch it here.

In a Cinderella story destined to warm the most cynical heart, Susan Boyle has emerged Britain’s newest—and most unlikely—singing sensation. The 47-year old resident of the village of Blackburn stunned judges, among them hard-assed Simon Cowell, last Saturday night during auditions of Britain’s Got Talent.  In her backstage interview, the sweet-natured, homely woman seemed destined to be set up for the sort of humiliation reality shows excel in. She spoke of living with her cat, Pebbles, and admitted she’d never been kissed. She also told the hosts her late mother, who had lived with her until her death two years ago, encouraged her to compete on the program. When she walked onto the stage, the audience snickered and the three judges looked incredulous. Yet she quickly proved herself an able sparring partner to Cowell’s caustic questioning, announcing she’d like to be as famous as English singer Elaine Paige. When he asked her age, she responded cheekily: “Forty-seven, and that’s just one side of me!”

The minute Boyle began singing I Dreamed a Dream from the musical Les Miserables, however, the audience and judges were awestruck. “Without a doubt, that is the biggest surprise I’ve had in three years of the show,” judge Piers Morgan told her. Cowell too was uncharacteristically bowled over.

With three perfect scores, Boyle’s the early favorite to win the hit reality TV series. Whether she does or not, is moot. Cowell has already offered her a record deal, according to the Sun newspaper. “I’ve always wanted to play before a large audience,” Boyle said before hitting the stage. “I’m going to make that audience rock.” That she did. Already her appearance has received more than 12 million hits on YouTube (watch it here). Yet as touching as her triumph is, it still leaves a nasty residue as a reminder of how quickly and meanly people who don’t conform to plastic ideals are dismissed. And don’t we all know a Susan Boyle “makeover” show is surely in the works.

Bookmark and Share
  • Brad

    streaming tears and blowing snot bubbles.

  • Tom Christopher

    Sometimes, ordinary people emerge and become extraordinary – a hidden talent; an ability to touch others; beauty in a different package. That’s what Susan Boyle displayed for the millions who will see her sing “I dreamed a Dream”.

  • b a robinson

    How wonderful–some section of society where ability can over-ride the artificial ideals of beauty and talent. AND people can revise and change their opinions about situations instantly when the talent comes through.
    I was gob-smacked by the voice–like many I was expecting the reincarnation of Mrs Miller.

    WOW!! I wish I was still living in England so I could vote for her!!

    Cheers.

  • Daniella Acuff

    A star is born (don’t you think.) With the mysterious bel canto of a Roy Orbison and the beautiful soul of a grown woman. What a reality check away from the numbing sameness we’re so used to seeing on Idol. I too am a singer, and at half her age I would not want to follow her onstage!

  • Paula

    beautiful woman, inside and out. Tremendous voice. God bless her…

  • chris j

    Someone mailed me this clip, it’s an amazing example of “Don’t judge a book by it’s cover” we’e all so hung up on appearances.

  • Tom Fetter

    It’s shocking that we’re shocked. It’s only since the age of “music video” dawned that we’ve expected all our artists to also look stunning. And arguably, the “art” has suffered, as we’ve demanded the artists to be entertainers instead. There’s a reason that the axiom goes “the opera isn’t over ’till the fat lady sings.” The “fat lady” was on stage because she was born with gold in her throat. If she was good looking too, so much the better … but nobody expected it.

    Susan Boyle’s got a great natural instrument, moderately good vocal technique, and sold the song wonderfully. Delivered a first-rate amateur performance. But a first-rate amateur performance shouldn’t bring three “hardened” judges to their knees … that should be the standard for a nation-wide talent show.

    • Martin Kerr

      You’re absolutely right. But I still cried while watching her.

    • Lija

      Gee, Mr. Fetter:

      Why not dispense with your dismissive judgment of Ms. Boyle’s vocal qualities and simply acknowledge the fact that she dead knocked that song out the back wall of the theatre– and THAT’S what got everyone out of their seats to applaud her. I trust that long after your comments and mine are forgotten (which, let’s face it, is right about now), this woman’s voice will ring with the same effect on stages throughout the world.

    • Mike C

      > It’s only since the age of “music video” dawned that we’ve expected all our artists to also look stunning. And arguably, the “art” has suffered, as we’ve demanded the artists to be entertainers instead. But a first-rate amateur performance shouldn’t bring three “hardened” judges to their knees … that should be the standard for a nation-wide talent show.

      Well, and why not? he asked cynically. It worked for Paul Potts.
      Part of the problem is that these talent shows make a lot of ratings at the expense of the bad performers (see the Idle – sorry, Idol – shows and their episodes of the poor auditions) which means that when you put someone like Susan Boyle up against them, she sounds incredible.
      She’s good. She’s very good. She has, incidentally, had some training. But that level, right there, should be more or less the baseline on an amateur talent program – very good, with some training; that it’s not makes those rare occurrences where someone like Ms. Boyle comes along seem remarkable.

      To Lija:
      > Why not dispense with your dismissive judgment of Ms. Boyle’s vocal qualities and simply acknowledge the fact that she dead knocked that song out the back wall of the theatre– and THAT’S what got everyone out of their seats to applaud her.

      The problem is, I’ve heard much better singers. But then again, I hang around with professionals, people who’ve had training and really know what they’re doing.
      Ms. Boyle is good, don’t get me wrong, but she could be better. And everyone who steps on that stage should be approaching her level (most of the time, though…). With some training, she could be phenominal, and she could dispense with the vocal qualities that made Mr. Feller’s judgment seem dismissive – which, by the way, it wasn’t.
      What got people out of their seats was that she was really good – AND that she defied their expectations. 47-year-old housewife, not exactly good-looking, wanting to be a pop star? Trust me, if a 27-year-old starlet had come out and done that, it wouldn’t have got nearly the same reaction.
      I’m not saying she doesn’t deserve to be on the show; she is good. But she’s not a superstar, and never will be without some work on her technique. And it wouldn’t take all that much – some intensive training with a good teacher or two, and Ms. Boyle comes back remarkably better.

      • Alan

        Wow…so analytical. So much detail. Just enjoy the moment!

    • Donna Trump

      I agree with Tom Fetter. I loved the performance, it brought tears to my eyes. It takes nothing away from Susan Boyle to say that she is a great amateur. She has a wonderful, youthful tone, excellent pitch, and she really projects. She’s very good through most of the song, but pushes her voice in places and falters on the lower notes. Her lower register needs work.

      Is it niggling to say that? No. I hope this person is able to develop and have a career other than as a musical novelty.

      I also disliked the tone of some of the comments after she sang. They seemed to be saying, in effect, “we shocked a toad like you can sing”. How very condescending.

  • http://freelanceallison.wordpress.com freelanceallison

    It was truly wonderful how great she sang and I think it is a good use of teaching us all the lesson that you can’t judge a book by its cover! freelanceallison.wordpress.com

  • http://MCLEANS.CA JACKIE ANDERSON

    OH MY GOSH!! I AM IN TEARS. THATS WAS SOOOOOOOOO BEAUTIFUL. AND SHE WAS SO HAPPY. AND TO KNOW PEOPLE JUDGE OTHERS BY THEIR LOOKS EVERYDAY. GOD BLESS HER AND MAY SHE TAKE THIS WORLD BY STORM!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Sandy

    Absolutely fabulous! Have watched the video 5 times! I wish her all the best!

    • Jo-Ann

      I agree with you all the way!

  • Jo-Ann

    A beautiful star was born. I have watched Susan on uYube about 5 or 6 times and every time tears just roll down my face.
    We are all too quick to judge, may this be a lesson to us all.

    God bless Susan, her career has just started!

  • Wotcher?

    I watched the longer youtube video with shots of the audience and judges rolling their eyes and pulling faces while she was answering questions before she sang. There wasn’t one answer she gave that would have elicited those reactions had she been young and beautiful.

    Having said that, old cynic that I am, listening to her sing brought tears to my eyes, too. Every time.

  • Audrey

    I watched and listened and cried….that without a doubt was one of the loveliest voices I have heard in a long time. But to hear the judges saying that before she sang , they were all laughing at her was so hurtful, I find it hard to believe people can be so mean and cynical. To see Susan Boyle’s face as she sang was to see true beauty. May she realize her dream.

    • Iris

      True beauty indeed. And honesty. And goodness. So real in this artifical world. And her singing gave me tears and shivers.

  • accordingtoro

    This should be a wake up call for all the plastic people we have living among us.Its really sad to think people will automaticlly think your a joke if your not a size 0 with DD boobs.

  • http://societrends.com nebben

    Here’s why we love Susan.

    http://digg.com/d1opbc

  • Roger Trottier

    Show the world that it is not the outside of a package that means everything it is what comes out of it .

  • http://www.doctorwolfie.com Paul Starr

    What an amazing talent! And what is this about a makeover? We hear her soul in her voice and it is astounding! No window-dressng required. Yeah, we could shape he eyebrows, apply a little eye-shadow, get her hair done……if SHE thinks we should: SHE’s the gifted one. We must do what she says. She’s already an icon for a new beauty.

  • Louise Pelletier

    1. I am from Québec, Canada tonight listening more or less to the news all of a sudden I heard this voice and it made me want to know more so I search Internet and got to this site. Susan has a marvelous voice. Like Tom Christopher said earlier: “ Sometimes, ordinary people emerge and become extraordinary” I think Susan is really extraordinary. Susan I wish you all the best…you are wonderful.

  • Manny

    Angels on earth? I believe it now. Stuff like this makes life a lot more real and dreams do come true.
    People and exposure will eventually change her.. but that’s ok! cause this moment will last forever for her and the world to remember.
    thank you Susan.

  • Kate

    I love this woman and this phenomenon. It is not a surprise that the concept of the show had her failing, but I am so thrilled that she is who she is and has succeeded. I hope very much that she does not undertake some grotesque makeover, because we as a culture need her to tell us how to get back to reality (and dream at the same time).

  • http://www.cameowhite.com cameowhite09

    The ugly duckling has been a swan all her life; you can see it in the way she walked on the stage, as well as when walked off the stage not waiting for the judge’s decision. What a woman, what a talent, she reminded of Judy Garland as a young child on stage. I was feeling very poorly yesterday and out of desperation I started my first blog on word press. After seeing her you tube, my faith in myself was renewed. And how God hands out gifts to such wonderful people.

    Micheale Thompson
    Cameo White Designs
    Struggling Artist
    Renewed in my faith to keep moving

  • http://members.cox.net/igoodman/index.html aleciagoodman

    I watched her performance a couple of nights ago…. Incredible, the lady has pipes! I think its amazing that she broke down the barrier of looks by singing. Our culture holds to too many false ideals of beauty and its relationship to money. Way to go, Susan!!! I am glad you put Simon and the audience in their place and I hope this gives others that fade into the woodwork courage to emerge and show their stuff.

  • cam

    I remember reading at one point that Jann Arden was told she would have had greater success in the States if she just lost weight… sad comment.

    But recently to see Adele play Saturday Night Live… and the example of Susan Boyle… maybe talent can trump for women for a change?

  • http://theburningbush.wordpress.com/ Moses

    she did a great job of blowing the audience away! :)

  • Mike

    It was by pure chance while listening on the CBC radio that the current singing phenomena named Susan was brought to my attention. Personally I have no interest in watching the various talent shows that are aired, but curiosity got the better of me. To the surprise of the audience and judges, was added my own. It’s a understatement to say I was very moved and as a middle aged man, my emotions caused me to shed a tear or two in response to her angelic voice. I’m unashamed in revealing my unabashed sentiments, but am ashamed in my initial judgment when Susan first walked on stage. How could I and others have known that this unassuming matronly woman held in her through the power of her voice that brought us to our knees in our hearts and minds.

    I can only wish the best for Susan and hope the fame that will lift her head in the clouds, will also keep her feet grounded.

From Macleans