B.C. tries to stop Lions Gate suicides

Lions Gate is getting phones; the Golden Gate is getting a net

by Ken MacQueen on Thursday, April 23, 2009 2:40pm - 13 Comments

B.C. tries to stop Lions Gate suicidesVancouver’s Lions Gate and San Francisco’s Golden Gate bridges—Depression-era, art deco masterpieces of form and function—have much in common. The 2.7-km-long Golden Gate opened in 1937 and the 1.8-km Lions Gate, a year later. Both civic icons are crucial commuter links for vehicles, cyclists and pedestrians. Both have cable-suspended decks high above busy waterways—and therein lies their tragic allure. Both bridges are magnets for the suicidal.

A fall from either bridge is almost always fatal. The Lions Gate has 61 m of clearance above Burrard Inlet, the Golden Gate has 63 m—time enough for a jumper to hit the water at 138 km/h. Preventing such suicides has been a much-studied challenge for both communities. This month, after years of muddling and debate, the B.C. government activated six “crisis hotline phones” on the Lions Gate. The yellow phone boxes connect to a general assistance number to report accidents and to a crisis line. Transport Minister Kevin Falcon calls the phones “an important tool for suicide prevention.”

It was Falcon who moved the project along after he asked police to rethink their policy of closing off bridges, often for hours at a time, as they negotiate with potential jumpers. The $97,000-pilot project is “a rescue option for people who have thoughts about ending their own lives and are desperately seeking a way out of unbearable emotional pain,” said Ian Ross of the B.C. Crisis Centre.

Authorities in San Francisco plan to install a stainless steel net under the Golden Gate, which still averages a suicide about every two weeks, despite the fact it has crisis phones.

There were 45 suicides from the Lions Gate between 1991 and 2007, and the B.C. Coroners Service wants barriers installed on it and four other bridges. Barriers are an engineering challenge on a suspension bridge, but they seem to work. An array of steel rods retrofitted on Toronto’s Bloor Street Viaduct in 2003 successfully ended its run as one of the deadliest bridges in North America.

Bookmark and Share
  • Someone

    Won’t they just go to another bridge that doesn’t have a net? I think the only solution here is to TEAR DOWN all of our bridges.

    • Boondockmom

      Please read the information at

      http://www.bridgerail.org/pressroom.html

      This cites studies that show people do not go elsewhere, that restriction of a suicide method is effective.
      Lions Gate had 45 deaths in 16 years whereas the Golden Gate has over 30 EVERY YEAR !

      The Golden Gate Bridge District has approved using a net for prevention and will vote on the final environmental impact report in May.

  • robins111

    Ban bridges, or register them into a multi billion dollar registry.

    After all we see how successfull it is with firearms, by registering long guns we stopped suicide, or thats what the coalition for gun control would have us believe.

    Individuals will suicide, whatever the efforts that we take to stop them, we cannot identify every possible potential suicide and treat them.

    The true tragedy is the family and friends they leave behind.

  • willow

    i have bipolar disorder and i am plagued with suicidal thoughts..the bridge is an "easy" option as once you jump there is no turning back. i am very upset when i read about other people saying that it is a cry for attention as it is such a public way of ending your life…please remember that people who are so distraught and ready to end their lives are not thinking about such things but just thinking about the 'easiest' way to end their suffering and not about publicity….it's very difficult for me to put this into words,but i have called the crisis line once and the people there were incredibly sensitive and compassionate to my feelings and my situation…..i am very happy to see that people,not money,came first in installing the phones on the lions gate bridge and that the new bridge,the golden ears bridge will have a suicide barrier put in place. i do believe it will be a deterrant,and that any amount of time talking to a compassionate person will help someone gain no matter how small some perspective in their situation and give them some time to consider their options….i do know that it helped me and i was able feel that i was not alone and i had some support,even from a stranger,to help me out of the depths of my despair and continue on…..i read in a report about failed suicide attempts that 90% of people who did survive a suicide attempt did not repeat it again . that gives me a lot of hope. know that you are not alone and there are people,even strangers,who want to help you….

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/BCres BCres

    How do they know how many jump from the Lion's Gate? Are there cameras recording? I don't doubt 45 have. Maybe more have? Maybe many more? A half dozen to a half dozen feet have been found on the shore around the lower mainland. Given the unlikelihood of them having floated to the surface, washed up on shore, and then found, I wonder how many people have jumped off the bridges in the BC lower mainland.

  • Dr. Lim

    I think jumping off a bridge is quite possibly the best way to die, other than being complety drugged and not feeling anything. It was not until I researched forms of suicide that I have come to the bridge as a favourite decision. Some people just can't hang on.

    I think the real matter here should be APPROPRIATE medical and psychiatric therapy. I've gone to numerous Dr 's and 3 different hospitals and have not recieved the intensive therapy I so desperatly need, from a childhood of horror and numerous adult tragedies .

  • Dr.Lim

    There are some AWFUL dr's at our hospitals that should rethink their career choice.

    I am positive if an average citizen went into the EMERG at a hospital with a broken leg, they would be assesed, x rayed, administered pain medication, put in a cast, maybe even get to stay in the hospital so the Dr's can keep checking on him… Then this average Joe would wait 6 weeks and get his cast off and start 6 months of massage and physio thereapy.

    Now If I, a suicidal/chronically depressed person goes into EMERGE seeking relief from both emotional and physical pain, not only do I not get appropriatly assesed, but I am told to leave. No sedatives, no observation, No counselling and no referals.

  • Dr Lim

    Everyone has seen the commercials to go to a hospital if you are thinking of suicide. Well they will tell you to get better coping skills and then the idiot Dr moves on the that old, wheezing guy with lung cancer that has been smoking for 50 years. Poor dear.

  • Dr Lim

    For me this has been going on 20 years. I have always been compliant on medications given. But from what I gather The health minister does not care to fund my treatment. My condition is the reslut of a whole childhood of abuse and negelct, sexual abuse and rape. I had no choice in those things. But I do not get appropriate, REAL treatment.I have severe PTSD

  • mr Lim

    I dissociate, It is not just a matter of thinking these things happened a long time ago. My brain has come to know only the negative things in life. My whole family has been torn apart as everyone in my family is so toxic.

    How do I march on as a single Mom? Why can't the Dr's do my kid a favour and sit me down and for one listen to the horrors that have been burned into my mind. I have Dr's telling me "the past is the past".

    I have nightmares. I even drive my car and don't know where I am when I wake up. That is what my child abuse has done to me. What kind of life is this? What kind of person puts themselve through 7 years of medical school to let this suffering continue?

  • Mr.Lim – Superstar!

    I needed a GOOD Dr to sit and listen to my problems and help answer some of my current issues. I just wanted a bit of guidance. I wanted to be validated and heard. I wanted to be given some sedatives to ehlp me through the rough days. I wanted the nurses to treat me with more kindness.

    And at this point, all I can say is Thank God for the Lions Gate Bridge

  • anonymous

    dear lim. i hear your pain! i hope you're doing okay. how are you surviving? how can you carry on as a single mom? do you have support? do you have a job? please reply

    i have borderline personality disorder am with a new child, facing lots of financial debt and shunned by family and friends. i am scared and thinking of jumping myself.

  • anonymous2

    please call a suicide hotline and see your doctor immediately if you are having these thoughts. get help. you are worth it. people do care, despite what your brain may tell you.

From Macleans