The World Desk

The World Desk

The World Desk

Michael Petrou writes about international news and Canadian foreign policy.

How Fowler's freedom was bought: letting other countries do our dirty work

by Michael Petrou on Thursday, April 30, 2009 12:29pm - 5 Comments

I’ve just spoken with a source who is familiar with the negotiations that took place for the release of Canadian diplomats Robert Fowler and Louis Guay from the Canadian and British side. He or she confirms they were sprung because of a ransom and prisoner exchange.

This information now comes from multiple different sources and cannot be discounted as speculative. J. Peter Pham, an Africa specialist at James Madison University, has it from senior officials in the government and security services of Mali and Niger that a prisoner swap was in the works, and he later spoke to an Algerian security source who said that Germany and Switzerland paid a ransom of about US$8 million. Al-Qaeda itself has confirmed in a statement that a prisoner exchange took place. Two separate Algerian newspapers, Ennahar and El Khabar, confirm aspects of the deal. Steven Edwards at Canwest News Service cites a “North African al-Qaeda observer with close links to people involved in the effort to free the Canadians,” who also confirmed the prisoner exchange and provided some details about the terror suspects Mali released.

All this raises an important question: If, as Prime Minister Stephen Harper claims, it is Canada’s policy not to pay a ransom or release prisoners in exchange for hostages, why is it okay for other countries to do so on our behalf? 

Bookmark and Share
  • James Connors

    May I just compliment Michael’s appearance on Newman today; informed clear, concise, complete commentary and analysis absent random opinion or partisan spin entirely.

    Give this man a television program.

  • Maggie’s Farmboy

    I agree. the guy is totally underrrated. And is one of the few journalists who “gets” the threat of extremism/terrorism without exaggerating it.

  • Maurice Poirier

    Excellent article. I agree that this writer is vastly under-rated. His insights and analysis are among the best in the business. Wasn’t he on CBC in the Maritimes a few years ago? I also think he wrote for the Ottawa Citizen at one point.

  • http://macleans.ca Gilbert Barre

    It seems that Canada cannot do anything by itself. It is the same thing for the defence of this country. The civilian MANDARANS are squeemish and cowards look at our navy no ship to go to the artic. The politicians that were held captive were released because they were politicians not ordinary joes.

  • scf

    If, as Prime Minister Stephen Harper claims, it is Canada’s policy not to pay a ransom or release prisoners in exchange for hostages, why is it okay for other countries to do so on our behalf?

    As far as I know, our government is in charge of Canada, not other countries.

    Anyway, the policy is in place to protect Canadians from being targeted for abduction and ransom. If there are no ransoms available there are no incentives to abduct. If other countries pay ransoms, that is an incentive to abduct people from other countries, not Canadians. So there is no contradiction. Stopping the assistance from other countries would be insane.

    In particular, in this case, the other countries were already paying a ransom for other reasons. This is a very clever application of diplomacy, for which the Canadian government deserves much credit.

From Macleans