The last days of a dynasty

Drowning in debt, Canwest still suffers for the loss of its visionary founder

by Peter C. Newman on Thursday, April 30, 2009 9:00am - 5 Comments

Endless questions remain. Is Prem Watsa of Fairfax Financial still interested in parts of the business? Who might buy the newspaper chain, and at what price? What will become of the National Post? Will there be anything left for the Aspers themselves?

This much is clear: Leonard is facing serious, possibly terminal financial trouble. Canwest’s bond holders are owed an overdue interest payment of US$30.4 million on US$761 million of senior subordinated notes. The total corporate debt remains at $4.1 billion, and the bond holders or the lending syndicate led by the Bank of Nova Scotia could drive it into bankruptcy protection at any time. Canwest Media’s original $300-million credit line has already been reduced to $112 million, most of which has been drawn down.

At the same time, revenues of Network Ten, the once highly profitable Australian television operation, have stalled badly and the property is in danger of going into default. The company’s most consistent money loser (at one point dropping $1.5 million a week) has been the National Post, which the Aspers have turned into a Conrad Black house organ. Black originally sold Izzy 50 per cent of the paper for $100 million, and the balance, a year later, for a looney. Izzy overpaid both times.

Individuals die; family dynasties abide—or so the theory went. The reality of succession in today’s globalized economy—even before the crash—has been sharply different. Canada was once run by a self-perpetuating clique of moneyed clans, most of whom helped finance the social welfare and creative arts of the communities in which they lived. Few did so more passionately than Izzy Asper in Winnipeg, through his family foundation which has given away well over $200 million to local improvements, and who, with Ottawa’s help, is currently building the Museum for Human Rights. (The only remnants of Winnipeg content within the Asper clan are David’s recent deal to buy the Blue Bomber football club and the fact that long-time Toronto resident Leonard maintains his Winnipeg connection by keeping his Manitoba cell number.)

The odd patriarch may have maintained the primacy of his offspring on the basis of their seeds instead of their deeds, but in an age when global corporate conglomerates are as mean as they are lean, family-run firms have become arcane exceptions. Two dozen of the most powerful families that had once held sway over the Canadian economy lost their influence and their pride of place, not by nationalization or some other anti-capitalist device—but by the iron laws of genetics. The passage of the entrepreneurial gene—the spark that gave rise to the original family empires—has long been extinguished. It simply is not transferable from one generation to the next. The casualty list has included such once-mighty family-owned business empires as the Eatons, the western branch of the Siftons, the Birkses, Kofflers, Crosbies, Romans, Blackburns, Bassetts, Lundrigrans, Poslunses, Creeds, Burtons, Steinbergs, Hermants, Gersteins, Jefferys, Iveys, McLeans, Woodwards, Crosses and several lesser clans. Now, the Aspers have outrun their corporate achievements. What was once Canada’s mightiest media empire is fighting for its life, against seemingly insurmountable odds. The Asper family had a great run but the empire Izzy built is running out of time for a resurrection.

Bookmark and Share
  • Heath

    Bell, Rogers, and Shaw are making billions from selling CTV and Canwest’s content. How is that fair?

    As far as I am concerned they are both to blame- broadcasters don’t create enough original programming and air the same shows across all the channels they own. Their specialty channels do not have enough quality programming to fill an entire schedule so you end up with repeats throughout. BDU’s on the other hand charge an arm and a leg for their service and offer what they want and how they want it (in terms of packaging), consumers come out on the losing end in both cases.

    To me, the providers and Canadian stations are one and the same, aside from Canwest all other broadcasters own both television channels and cable or satellite companies. Here ya go:

    Rogers: Rogers Cable / OMNI TV, Citytv

    Shaw: Shaw Cable, Shaw Direct / Corus Entertainment (specialty channels), local stations

    Quebecor: Videotron Cable / TVA, specialty channels

    Bell: Bell TV / CTV & A, specialty channels via minority share in CTVglobemedia

    See what convergence does, 3 companies pretty much control everything in Canada- distribution and content. I see no distinction between the two so my complaints apply to both. Canwest is the exception but I am sure if they had the chance (perhaps under different ownership) they probably would get in on the game and buy a cable company or launch an IPTV service. Time to break this up and not allow cable/satellite providers (or vice versa) to own broadcasting companies.

    A good example I can provide is CKRN-TV (SRC), CFEM-TV (TVA) in Rouyn-Noranda, CHOT-TV (TVA) and CFGS-TV (TQS) in Gatineau, and CFVS-TV (TQS) in Val D’Or, all operated by Radio-Nord Communications (now RNC Media). They know their coverage area (Abitibi and Outaouais) and provide local news for all 5 stations in their 2 markets.

    If the SRC and TVA were operated by SRC and TVA, they would say something like “the news is not big enough for mentionning back in Montreal” and would stay home counting their toes. As for TQS, we know what happened and if Abitibi/Outaouais TQS would be controlled by TQS, these newscast would have been the first to be cut and lay off.

    I am happy that my cable provider is making me pay for basic service which includes all local stations for free. I would be frustrated to pay local stations via my cable provider since I can get it for free using rabbit ears. The price asked for basic service is plenty enough for them to operate and finance future services, to provide free previews almost every month, to provide content on Video On Demand for free.

    Back to CanWest… oh yeah, Global Quebec is losing money because everything is controlled from Toronto. CanWest doesn’t care about viewers, they don’t care about community, but they only care about ratings (which is why they simsub) which results in bigger advertisement revenues.

  • Charles

    Unfortunately Izzy invested in the old and failed to see the new. His son Leonard, laden with an insurmountable burden had little choice but to continue as a passenger aboard the Canwest Global meteor. A very bright looking star for Earth's inhabitants but nonetheless destined for a catastrophic end.

  • Lisa Mendos

    NIce Article ..
    Lisa M @ Woodworking plansWoodworking projects

  • nancy mckee

    very insightful article.
    Prada Handbags

  • http://shedplansandwoodworking.com Rob – shed plans

    Well, some good things never last, as they say.

From Macleans