John Geddes

John Geddes

John Geddes writes on politics and policy, with occasional reporting and comment on arts and culture.

The blade in the Governor General's hand

by John Geddes on Tuesday, May 26, 2009 12:56pm - 15 Comments

So everybody is having fun with the story about Governor General Michaelle Jean eating raw seal. I guess blogging was invented primarily for the mockery of this sort of extravagant gesture.

I stopped chuckling when, in his nicely observed account of the episode, Canadian Press’s Alex Panetta mentions that Jean used an ulu, the traditional knife of Inuit women, to carve her seal.

That prompted me to recall a conversation I had few years ago when I was up in Nunavut working on a story. A young Inuk woman who was learning to make jewelry at Arctic College in Iqaluit showed me some earrings she was working on—little silver ulus.

Embarrassed when I asked about the significance of the ulu, she took a roundabout route in explaining that the knife is a female symbol. One of her instructors heard us talking—well, mostly me asking earnest questions and her laughing at them—and told me that Inuit women artists and artisans tend to return again and again to the ulu image.

It’s a concrete, tactile thing, familiar to many hands up North, which lends itself to design and even abstraction. The curve can seem womanly to the eye, but as a cutting instrument, this emblem of the feminine is hardly soft.

So I like the idea of Jean wielding an ulu. I’m guessing that the tool in her hand, rather than her taste for seal heart, will have struck some of the women of Rankin Inlet as a nice touch from a visiting dignitary.

Bookmark and Share
  • LeenieJ

    Michaelle Jean is a very decent woman.

  • Critical Reasoning

    I’m familiar with the word “ulu”, if only because it’s a handy “u”-dump in Scrabble. Mr. Geddes, thanks for filling in the blanks about this very cool traditional knife.

  • Kat

    I have an ulu, given to me as a gift from someone who travelled to the north. I can’t get the hang of it though. I guess I’m used to my straight edge.

  • avr

    How delightful, to see all the old Palin-bashers out in full force trashing someone who ought otherwise to hit all their buttons for being the ‘correct’ kind of woman in a position of power.

    • Dave

      Coherent? Articulate? Able to conduct herself with poise and dignity? Yes, Madam Jean is the kind of woman I’d like to see in power. In fact, I will extend that to the kind of person that I’d like to see in power. Too many politicians, from all party stripes, do the office they hold a disservice with their behaviour.

    • Jenn

      avr, I’m confused. Not one post above yours in any way bashes Her Excellency. Nor do they bash the Ulu, the visit, or anything else at all.

      So where are these delightful visions of yours coming from?

      • Wotcher?

        I think avr was referring to the first link, which compared Jean to Palin. But really, what else can you expect from a publication called “The Gawker”?

        Personally, I think Mme Jean showed great cultural sensitivity and respect for the traditions of the people she was visiting. And the idea of a university in the north (second link) is a great idea!

  • Eric

    What a tremendous Governor-General she has been. What a brilliant representative for our country.

    Why on earth haven’t we ditched the English already? Why do we want our head-of-state answering to a European monarch?

    • Jenn

      If you can assure me of a continued Governor Generalship, I wouldn’t mind. And I am one who has been fiercely pro-British Monarchy in the past. But I realized a few years ago I was really pro-Governor Generalship, with the pomp and ceremony and a head of state that is not a politician. When our GG represented us (I think it was in France) while the Queen was also there, it came home to me that it is the GG that is important, not the British crown.

      • Kevin Lafayette

        How can a position that is an appointment made by a politician not be political? If we are to ditch the monarchy, why not ditch the patronage also, and just elect a person to the position.

  • Proudtobethis?

    I am disappointed to be a citizen of a country with this many barbarians. I hope somebody cuts you up and eats you one day. We are all animals. It’s good to know how Canadians feel animals should be treated. Disgusting.

    • Andrew (not Potter or Coyne)

      I suppose we should stop polar bears from eating seals as well.

    • Jenn

      I’m quite sure the “barbarians” are disappointed you are a citizen of this country, too.

  • zoe

    In Canada, there are many cultures. Some cultures eat meat harvested from animals by other people, where it is nicely packaged, but that meat still came from an animal that was (usually) living in squalor, and then killed. Anyone who thinks of him/herself as Canadian, but has not endeavored to understand/ put yourself into the shoes of someone living in the North (please research the history and living conditions) will not be able to form a just opinion of why, to Northerners, seals are food, and sealing is work, good work that they are skilled at, that helps them earn a wage. The North is not Toronoto, Vancouver or wherever else in Canada where all the harvesting is done by someone else while you work a desk job. It takes a lot to survive here. Please open your minds and hearts, and do some in depth research before hurting the feelings of another culture, who ARE Canadians like you, with the same rights to human rights and respect.

    ALSO the GG eating seal heart is really quite normal – and respectful to her hosts – it’s similar to you being offered any food when you go to someone’s home – if you were polite, you would at least try it.

  • Terry

    You can't elect someone without giving them a mandate to govern. What you are advocating is a presidency.

From Macleans