America: Utterly Wounded

Gawker.com gets defensive after Macleans.ca takes a gentle swipe

by macleans.ca on Thursday, May 28, 2009 2:51pm - 12 Comments

Gawker.com, the reliably snarky New York media watchdog website is on the defensive after Maclean’s gentle (read: Canadian) swipe at its post made on Wednesday “Meet Michaëlle Jean, the Sarah Palin of Canada,” a response to news that our GG’s taste for wildlife might be even rawer than that of the failed vice-presidential candidate. Gawker blogger “Cajun Boy” rails away about Maclean’s writer Anne Kingston’s retort, “Michaëlle Jean the Sarah Palin of Canada. Really?,” as well as the tenor of the Maclean’s comments thread in a nation-blasting posting: “Canada: Utterly Humorless.” Like a stand-up comic berating an audience who didn’t laugh, Cajun Boy assumes we didn’t grasp his “playful attempt at absurdist humor,” writing: “we reckon that it never dawned on Anne Kingston or any of the other offended Canadians that the post in question wasn’t meant to be a serious analysis of the similarities between Palin and Jean, something we actually thought was rather thinly veiled.” The Palin/Jean comparison was “intended to be logically inappropriate in every possible way,” he over explains, “thereby serving to not only bring attention to a truly ridiculous piece of political news from our neighbors to the north, but also to lampoon this country’s blissful ignorance of all life outside of its borders at the same time. We suppose our expectations were set a wee bit too high.” All ends happily, however, with Cajun Boy boasting of his own Canuck bona fides (“Hell, some of our ancestors have been traced back to Nova Scotia!”) and offering some helpful advice to his unfunny neighbours to the north: “get your big, salmon-eating heads out of your asses, and lighten the hell up.”

Gawker

Maclean’s — Michaëlle Jean is Canada’s Sarah Palin. Really?

Bookmark and Share
  • http://www.jackmitchell.ca Jack Mitchell

    God, the Americans. The problem is that they don’t grasp the difference between a Governor (Palin) and a Governor General (Jean). Where Palin might be suspected of eating wild animals to advance herself (create an image or whatever), Jean’s eating the seal’s heart was not self-interested. But of course Americans know absolutely nothing of what goes on beyond their borders, and can’t even imagine a disinterested motive in a public figure, so what can you expect?

    • Ed Sweeney

      Its more than a little ironic that someone preaching sanctimony on being more open-minded would start with, “God, the Americans. The problem is that they..”.

      That is the height of small-mindedness, oxymoron intended.

      • http://www.jackmitchell.ca Jack Mitchell

        “Preaching sanctimony” is a good one. Do you only think in oxymorons?

        • Ed Sweeney

          That wasn’t a normative statement, it was an observation. I was not suggesting it was advisable, only that you did it.

  • Wayne

    Don’t forget that some of cajun_boys friends are canadian too.

  • robins111

    Actually the posting was incorrect, we’ve been laughing at the Americans for 200+ years.

    Thats gotta show a sense of humor.

    ps cajun boy, our GG is a hell of a lot better looking than Sarah,

  • Terry

    I am so proud to see a national news magazine with nearly a hundred years of history get into a flamewar with a minor blog site.

    So, I’ve heard traditional media is failing.

    • Leo F.

      Get your big, salmon-eating head out of your arse, and lighten the hell up.

      • Terry

        That’s a problem, because I hate salmon, but I love my ass.

        I’m sure the publishers of Maclean’s in 1905 would be proud to have that statement associated with their magazine.

        • Leo F.

          We all long for seriousness, but let’s face it; that’s gone for good. I thought a good bout of quasi-totalitarianism in the US or economic hardship everywhere would be the cold shower everyone needs to focus and be serious about serious things, but we’re in an era now where national broadcasters host torturers and entertain jokes about torture and the change agents just want to move on.

  • Meany

    Salmon eating???

  • http://bradysbeef.com idaho beef

    God forbid any country should have anyone even resembling a sarah palin: with her hypocrisy and her illegitimate grandchild.

    what a joke!

From Macleans