Beyond The Commons

Beyond The Commons

Aaron Wherry covers all the goings-on in and around Parliament Hill. Follow Aaron on Twitter: @aaronwherry

'It makes us sad. More people will die.'

by Aaron Wherry on Sunday, May 31, 2009 3:17pm - 8 Comments

Though obviously not as interesting as whatever Pierre Poilievre last said, Geoffrey York reports from Africa on Canada’s dramatic, but quiet, withdrawal from the continent.

In the fall of 2004, when Paul Martin was prime minister and Irish rock stars were chattering ceaselessly about the need to help Africa, Canada raised the flag on a shiny new embassy here in the capital of Malawi. It was the culmination of a warm and close relationship that has sent $440-million in Canadian assistance to the small republic wedged between Zambia, Tanzania and Mozambique in southeast Africa over the past 45 years.

Optimism was in the air. Malawi was making progress – it was holding democratic elections, its farm output was improving dramatically – but it was still one of the world’s 10 poorest countries, heavily dependent on foreign donors. And Canada was one of the most faithful of those donors.

Today, the mood has soured. In late September, barely five years after the opening, a small band of diplomats will watch morosely as the Maple Leaf is hauled down and the embassy closed for good. There has been no announcement, nothing but a discreet notice buried deep in a government website, unnoticed for weeks. One diplomat in a nearby country called it a “stealth closure.” With staff at the embassy (technically a high-commission office, as both countries are in the Commonwealth) prohibited from talking to the media, Canada seems to be sneaking away in the night.

Bookmark and Share
  • mceachern

    I appreciate the attention that the MacLean's is giving to this sad situation. I have friends who say that even within CIDA itself countries of concentration are not even talked about. Everyone is staying quiet — as they try to wrap their brains around the justification of the countries picked. How is this transparent? Who can be held accountable for this and the outrage that is now unfolding?

    • avr

      I think you may be overestimating the volume of public outrage that can be ginned up with regards to cutting foreign aid and diplomatic staff expenses during a recession. For the opposition to run with this would be a dream come true for Tory attack-ad writers.

  • Leo F.

    It's refreshing to see Maclean's bloggers highlighting issues of substance, rather than simply pasting in unsourced emails they receive from the Conservative Party.

  • http://functionsofnature.com Michael T

    now for some reality on Africa – Martin, and all the missionaries in Canada's government please stop with the BS!

    "Why aid to Africa must stop: Interview with Dambisa Moyo"

    http://www.nationalpost.com/news/canada/story.htm…

    excerpt:
    "Q. What's so bad about rich nations sharing their wealth with poor nations to help them cope with their struggles?

    A. No country on Earth has ever achieved long-term growth and reduced poverty in a meaningful way by relying on aid. It's just never happened. So we're pushing a strategy that has no evidence of working anywhere on Earth. And we have years of evidence that the aid strategy doesn't work."

    • Sisyphus

      The lady was on Charlie Rose a while ago. She’s getting some support from the usual suspects. I started ignoring her when she was offended that some aid groups were giving mosquito netting away free and thereby causing hardship to locals fully seized by the entrepreneurial spirit.

      http://ghanabusinessnews.com/2009/05/13/the-road-to-ruin-a-response-to-dambisa-moyo/

    • Oh Boy

      "No country on Earth has ever achieved long-term growth and reduced poverty in a meaningful way by relying on aid."

      I love it when people rely upon absolutist statements to back their extremism. Especially when they include words like never, always, etc. These are clearly false statements, but because the confirm a bias, they go unchallenged.

      I guess all those Marshall Plan recipients in post-war Europe didn't benefit from aid?
      And Korea and Malaysia, etc. … Well, no benefit from aid there, clearly.

      Spend a few minutes thinking about the absurdity of the above quote and see how long it takes you to think of half a dozen examples to its contrary.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/SophiaGeffros SophiaGeffros

    This is the real issue- what we should be paying attention to. Forget polls, ads, and the scandal du jour- let's focus on what we are and are not doing to make a difference in the world, how we are fufilling our obligations as a civilized society and as human beings.
    When we ignore the problems in the world, or focus on frivolities at the expense of them, we allow this to happen.
    As a society, we can do better.

  • dan in van

    A pox on those behind these draconian silent shifts that will only punish the most neediest of people. A double pox on most of the MsM who have chosen to ignore this – and a host of other CONservative infractions – because they have their eyes on public bailout cash.

From Macleans