Maclean's Interview: Dieudonné M’Bala M’Bala

French comic Dieudonné M’Bala M’Bala on why he called Jews slave traders and why he’s running for the European Parliament

by Martin Patriquin on Wednesday, June 10, 2009 7:30am - 12 Comments

Q: You were quoted as saying that Jews were slave traders who became bankers, and that the yearly commemoration of Auschwitz is “memorial pornography.” At the same time, you say you are anti-Zionist, not anti-Semitic.

A: I don’t consider myself an anti-Semite. I am supported in my political aspirations by a large number of Jews, whose parents were victims of heinous atrocities during the war. Yes, I’m anti-Zionist. It is a political project that is on par with apartheid, and it must be resisted.

Q: But did you say that Jews were slave traders who became bankers?

A: I wasn’t addressing all Jews. I was addressing a bunch of Zionists who came into one of my shows in Lyon, and who were screaming that Israel will be victorious, death to Palestinians and that sort of thing, and they injured a 13-year-old girl who was at the show. That part wasn’t in the paper. These people were Zionists. And because I was talking about slavery during the show, I made the parallel with Zionism. I was quoted out of context, but if you look at the transatlantic slave trade, which was legal for 400 years, you see among the traders people who were bankers, people of all sorts of backgrounds, but especially Christians and Jews. To say otherwise is to lie.

Q: You’ve broken up and gotten back together many times with your long-time collaborator Elie Semoun, who is Jewish. What did he think of your thing with Jean-Marie Le Pen?

A: He is in business now, and politics are dangerous for people in business.

Q: One of the strange things is that his cousin, Patrick Bruel, successfully sued you for libel after you called him a liar and a member of the Israeli military on a Quebec television show. Have you paid him the $75,000?

A: It’s not finished, and we should let the wheels of justice roll on.

Q: A lot of attention has been paid to what you’ve said about Jews, but it’s worth mentioning that you also make fun of Muslims.

A: In my shows I go after any extremism in any form. The divided communities, and the borders that divide us all, are a game to me. I play with them, and they get outraged. But that’s a good example. The Muslim community has never been hostile toward me. It’s like they have a better sense of humour.

Q: Doing jokes like that in, say, Iran would be slightly more dangerous than in France.

A: Maybe, but we aren’t in Iran. We are ostensibly in a country where we can laugh and have fun. The problem is that France is a country that is under the thumb of the Zionist lobby, and because of this the reaction to my words wouldn’t be out of place in a religious state.

Q: People hear you say things like this and suggest you are promoting hatred.

A: I don’t want to promote hatred.

Q: Le Pen has said some awful things.

A: He’s been quoted as saying some things, yes. I’m actually running against him for the European Parliament.

Q: How does he rate as a godfather to your daughter, Plume?

A: Ah, you are talking about the promotion of my last show, Je fais l’con (I’m Playing the Idiot), where I used a promotional strategy that was based on provocation.

Q: To say the least.

A: It was a way to promote my show.

Q: But he is still godfather to your child?

A: You can’t ask a magician his tricks. What I can say is that it was a way to introduce my show, and in the first 10 minutes of that show I basically told the story of getting Le Pen to be my daughter’s godfather. I mean, the whole baptism thing was fantasy. I have a profound respect for Christ, but the Church? Do I think putting water over the head of a child does anything? That’s open to debate.

Bookmark and Share
  • Crit_Reasoning

    Brilliant interview, M. Patriquin. You asked all the right questions.

  • Kevin Solez

    Dear M. Patriquin,

    I think you missed Mr. M'Bala M'Bala's point when at the end you called his ideas "malformed and idiotic." Were you listening when Mr. M'Bala M'Bala said: "I don't know if it's to confuse. It's more to start debates, to make people question themselves"? You seemed not to understand his point that embodying extremist positions as an entertainer is an extremely effective way to start debates, to make people feel foolish for the things they think. He invited you to examine your biases, but you did not, you simply gave him your standard rote response to someone who is anti-Zionist. Pardon me, but while Israelis are reasonable people and Judaism is a reasonable religion, Zionist fundamentalists are some of the most dangerous people in the world, easily on par with the worst Muslim extremists. Unfortunately, Mr. Patriquin, you have proven yourself unable to reexamine your view of Jewish suffering as some kind of incomparable outrage, unmendable by any concession, an outrage that justifies all subsequent affrontery. This is the danger of the Zionism that you so respect, that if a people has gone through an ordeal that is incomparable to any other the world has seen, what should be the end of their vengeance?

    All best,
    Kevin Solez

  • Maria

    Est-ce quelqu'un a vu son dernier spectacle "Sandrine"? Les médias se focalisent trop sur son engagement politique et ne parle pas du tout de son spectacle. Je meure d'envie d'avoir un commentaire sur son nouveau show!!!! Merci.

  • Sean

    "but if you look at the transatlantic slave trade, which was legal for 400 years, you see among the traders people who were bankers, people of all sorts of backgrounds, but especially Christians and Jews. To say otherwise is to lie."

    To say otherwise is the truth. Jews were locked out of the slave trade unless they converted. There were a few converso slave trader families in the Caribbean. It's funny how he doesn't admit to the Islamic share of the blame, after all European Christians never captured black Africans, they bought them from Arabs. All slave traders in Africa were Arab or black.

    Don't get me wrong, buying a slave is as bad as catching one. But his attempt to transfer Islam's culpability onto the Jews shows his true colours. An absolute scumbag and his popularity in Quebec makes me realise that everything Mordechai Richler ever wrote about the Quebecois is true…

    • Kevin Solez

      He got the slave-trade thing wrong, and a bunch of other things too. But, he's a provocateur. He made it clear in the interview that he pretends to hold bizarre views for the reaction he elicits. The fact that his bizarre views get under people's skin is exactly his point. He's a 'squirm-entertainer,' kinda like the old Denis Leary or Stephen Colbert. I don't believe for a second that his shows actually promote hatred. He's just hit a raw nerve in society, with contemporary political connections, so people think that you're not supposed to say these things. The fact that he bugs people with his strange views is exactly his reason for holding those views.

    • Kevin

      If you looked at what he said in depth you would realize that he is going after a reaction. He can be considered cheaper than an Indian man when it comes to publicity.

      Think about it, he manages to get free publicity and that is precisely what he wants. By outraging people like you he gets what he wants. He likes free publicity, it is for that reason that he likes how people tried to ban him from the elections.

  • Orest Slepokura

    Dieudonne is hardly alone in appropriating the Holocaust in a vulgar way for cheap laughs. The frat boy comedy The Hangover also uses the Holocaust as a crude comedic motif. Four guys spend three days in Vegas getting totally wasted. One of them, a dentist, shows the other three a special ring "my grandmother kept [from the Nazis] during the Holocaust". He reveals his intention to pop The Question ("Will you marry me?") to his live-in girlfriend, a real shrew, and offer her the the so-called "Holocaust ring". Instead, he gets royally pissed and the "Holocaust ring" ends up on the finger of a hooker-stripper he marries in a 3 a.m. ceremony at a Vegas chapel. When he bemoans the loss of his grandmother's "Holocaust ring" on the morning after, his fellow reveler – the Dumbo in the group – voices surprise over the fact that something like a "Holocaust ring" even exists. Dumbo: "I didn't know they give out rings at the Holocaust."

  • moliere

    dieudonné is the best !!!!

  • Bloodklat

    I´m sorry, you did not understand what he is saying. He is talking about the people who tried to disturb his Show. There were no Moslem there, but a lot of zionist and others.

  • http://dieudonne.over-blog.com Monsieur Z

    you're right bloodklat

  • Cheryl

    Zionism is just the Jewish people coming back to a homeland they had lived in for thousands of years and had been ousted from several times. It's called Israel. Two of their temple ruins are under the Dome of the Rock. Israel is Zion and it's not going anywhere anytime soon, so everyone should move on

  • francois

    wow…
    Zionist is just a political movement created in response to a huge antisemitist wave in the end of the XIX century, which say that jews should "go back home" (to be simple).
    But it is highly criticised by lot of jews saying that the Torah (their bible) implicitly tell them to wait for a messiah to return to israel…
    One problem is that this simple fact (jews against israel) is everytime hidden, or assimilated to extremism.
    Another problem is that they (the zionist, not the Jews !) have seen in the USA coming to help UK in WW2 their messiah… Eheh. (palestine was an english colony, right ?).
    Arabs and Jews lived in peace in Palestine for centuries… Who is making an apartheid in Palestine are not Jews, but zionist. Please look what happening, and not from some Reuters or AFP source…
    To end, please do not make the mistake "they" want you to make : antizionist is not antisemitism. And also : Dieudonne is everything but stupid, and less again antisemitist.
    (sorry for my bad english)

From Macleans