Beyond The Commons

Beyond The Commons

Aaron Wherry covers all the goings-on in and around Parliament Hill. Follow Aaron on Twitter: @aaronwherry

'He never did desire an election'

by Aaron Wherry on Thursday, June 18, 2009 1:55pm - 18 Comments

Glen Pearson mounts an explanation of the Liberal leader.

Mr. Ignatieff took something of a drubbing in the media this week and it shows. He never did desire an election, yet there were many advisors around him constantly explaining the key strategic advantage for bringing the Harper government down. He has aged years in a week. He is not like many here, never having fed on meals of political machinations. The media accused him of “electioneering,” but there isn’t an opposition MP in the House who honestly believed anything could be negotiated out of Stephen Harper.  The PM’s way is hardball, 24-7, and he would crush you if you flinched. And so Michael Ignatieff attempted to stay in the game, believing he had the cards in his hand to finally make Harper himself back down. It seems to me he did, and that he got concessions that no one thought he would. Many question the substance of those concessions, but the truth is that at the beginning of the week nobody gave him much chance.  Now he is older, wiser and, I fear, wearied for his efforts. But he has always said to me that Canadian citizens didn’t want an election. Judging from the emails coming in, they did right by him and he can take some comfort in that.

Bookmark and Share
  • Hugh Taylor

    On Friday Ignatieff was neatly boxed in by a crisis somewhat of his own making. On Monday he offered his conditions to support the government. Three relatively easy for the government to deal with and the third, the EI 360 days, a loss leader that Ignatieff knew wouldn't fly. On Tuesday Harper 'blinked', acknowledging that he saw a real threat to his government and possibly his personal future. Gone was Friday's bluster in favour of Harper the 'great conciliator'. Exit Ignatieff from the box, bruised, but with the consolation of having again moved the PM off his game plan and further out of character, while marginalizing the NDP & Bloc and burying any remaining vestiges of the Coalition of Three. It may not have been pretty, but it means we can go fishing ……..

    • Michael

      Last week Harper tried hard to frame this around EI rather than the update. Lo and behold Ignatieff just agreed to frame that Fall opposition day around EI.

      Harper's got to be pretty pleased to play the genial host who hands out such lovely door prizes when folks drop by to visit.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Silly_Walks Silly_Walks

    I'm very happy to have Pearson as my MP.

  • Wascally Wabbit

    Oh yes – let's go fishing!
    Typical Canadian response!
    No wonder we are turning into a third rate nation – with Harper – now aided by Mr. Ignatieff's misstep – actively orchestrating it.
    Let's follow the typical Neocon move of selling off the family jewels – our skills in Nuclear – it was a disaster for the UK when Thatcher did it – it was an unmitigated disaster for Ontario when Harris did it – and now Harper and Flaherty – guided by Guy Giorno – are merrily doing it for the rest of Canada.

    The only Conservative right now worthy of any kudos is Danny Willams. Just negotiated a deal where Newfoundland and Labrador own part of the action – and where royalties go up to 50%.

    Hey Danny – I know you don't talk to these guys much – but maybe you could send a Gna Gna to them right now…

    As for Mr. Ignatieff – and his advisors – I agree with Glen Pearson – who I admire greatly – they misread this one.
    Whether we were ready or not – we should have gone!
    Don't miss the oppotunity in September!

  • Wascally Wabbit

    My bad – hit send before I edited – my point was Thatcher sold off fundamental assets like water to private investors who ran them into the ground made the profits then walked away when they had to ante up heavy capital.
    Harris tried to sell everything and the kitchen sink – Hydro – including Bruce – a major part of the Nuclear division…
    The mess that became Ontario Realty Corp. and the prosecutions around the sweetheart deals that went down during the Tories reign are still flowing through the courts

    • William

      The Ontario premier in the 1990`s that history will show was the most unpopular and ineffective was named Rae.

      And you seem to contradict yourself in the first comment—-you say you admire Pearson who obviously agrees with Iggy~s retreat but then you say you wanted a summer election because you seem to have a problem with the Harper Gov`t but then the reason there isn`t an election was because the Liberals finally realized they would be hammered if they forced one for no good reason.

      • John W.

        The Ontario Premier with Ipperwash and Walkerton on his hands is not Rae.

        • William

          The lasting legacy of the Ipperwash Inquiry is a provincal police force that refuses to get involved in Native affairs. Walkerton was caused by a couple of town employees who didn`t do their jobs.

          • John W.

            Not quite that simple. I want you know who out of the park.
            And those civll servants are lazy and useless, think Linda Kean, let's trim them back, save some money, and they don't vote for us anyway. Whose ever gonna notice?

          • William

            McGuinty wanted to score political points at the Inquiry and succeeded in poisoning Gov`t and Police relations—-now he has Caledonia—good luck.

            I don`t care how civil servants vote—just do your job or someone else will. You should learn the real facts about Walkerton—the labs did their job, they communicated that the water was contaminated—the civil servants ignored the warning.

  • John W.

    Is it possible that through the force of his personality and intellect, Michael Ignatieff could single handedly elevate Ottawa political and parliamentary debate, its civility and intelligence, to a higher level?

    This weeks events show that it's possible. His use of Question Period shows it's possible. His speeches and his handling of the media show it's possible.
    Of course, it won't be noticed until it has already happened and everyone wonders why it's sudenly better..

    • William

      Iggy is proving to be an excellent opposition leader.

      • John W.

        Another Robert Stanfield?

        • William

          I do see the resemblance.

  • Wascally Wabbit

    It would be better if the CPC was drastically reduced in numbers and sitting on the other side of the aisle too!
    Cause and effect?

  • RayK

    There's old political adage: "if you're explaining, you're losing".

    If you need to "explain your leader", you're f*cked.

    • http://bcinto.blogpot.com BCer in Toronto

      That's true. The Conservatives have up trying to explain Stephen Harper years ago…

      • RayK

        Indeed they did. It's remarkable how much more successful the Conservatives have been by simply ignoring Harper's firewall/socialist/defatism comments rather than trying to explain away or justify them.

        I don't think this SHOULD have been successful, but it was. At some point those comments just became old news.

From Macleans