Inkless Wells

Inkless Wells

Paul Wells on all the latest out of Ottawa—along with the occasional post about jazz. Follow Paul on Twitter: @InklessPW

Afghanistan: no more commuting?

by Paul Wells on Tuesday, June 23, 2009 11:34pm - 5 Comments

AfghanistanFor a reporter, I get on fairly well with the Privy Council Office’s Afghan Task Force, but as a generalist (dilettante?) I don’t follow their work from day to day. So I was surprised to get an email this afternoon from their press shop bearing a complete sound file of a news conference that was held this morning in the south of Kandahar. Clearly this is something Canada’s Afghanistan shop views as important.

The voices on the recording, which you can listen to if you have a lot of spare time or interest, are: Kandahar governor Tooryalai Wesa, speaking in Pashto and then English; Ben Rowswell, Chargé d’affaires at the Canadian embassy in Kabul; Ken Lewis, the civilian Representative of Canada in Kandahar (or RoCK); and Brig.-Gen. John Vance. So you have the Afghan, Canadian civil, and Canadian military leadership in the province, all gathered in the little mud-hut town of Deh-e-Begh.

The short version: Dar-e-Begh, a pretty nondescript town, has been a pilot project for a more concentrated Canadian development effort — one that focuses less on megaprojects (though those continue) and less on military confrontation (though that does too) and more on local, small-scale projects to provide immediate tangible differences to local Afghans’ lives.

“This is a logical turning point in Canadian operations,” Gen. Vance says. “The mission can transition to where we can focus more effort on reconstruction, development, and governance.” It’s Rowswell (who’s scheduled to become Canada’s third RoCK, after Lewis, in 2010) who explains the main reason why that’s possible now: the Americans are arriving, in very large number, to do more of the security work in Kandahar and across the South. So hints dropped by U.S. Defence Secretary Robert Gates way back in the first week of the Obama administration are being borne out: a clearer division of labour, with the U.S. soldiers doing more of the soldiering and the Canadians doing more of the, uh, nurturing.

This is also the beginning of an answer to a bunch of questions Colleague Petrou posed in April. This so-called “Operation Kantolo” does look like an attempt, inspired (or more likely prodded) by U.S. Gen. David Petraeus, to get and keep our soldiers closer to the Afghans and their preoccupations. That’s what a successful counterinsurgency does. Which is not to say that this operation is guaranteed success. Only that as the Americans rethink their strategy and arrive in force to implement it, it’s having a big, obvious impact on Canadian strategy too.

Bookmark and Share
  • madeyoulook

    Thank you for sharing, Paul. I lasted nine minutes before opting for your "short version." Can you advise just how much "spare time" we require for the whole thing? Is there Q&A after the prepared statement part that I didn't get past?

    It's nice to see that the leadership within US and (at least one) NATO ally(ies) might actually be trying to WIN against a counter-insurgency, rather than what appeared (to me, anyway) to be treading water for a few years hoping to not lose too badly. Here's hoping…

  • Inkless

    Once the file loads, you can move the cursor around to fast-forward or reverse. There's a Q&A section, with questions from Canadian and Afghan reporters; the guy from Tolo TV wants to know how much stimulus cash has actually been spent, and then complains that he doesn't get a follow-up question. Hire him for the Parliamentary Press Gallery, I say!

    • Stephen

      Or the official opposition

      Great book for background on all of this is;

      Hammes, Thomas X. The Sling and the Stone: On War in the 21st. Century. Zenith Press,
      2004. ISBN: 0760320594.

      Hammes, a Marine Colonel, does an outstanding job of defining and explaining the evolution of 4GW. Hammes stresses the value of people, “networking,” over technology, and the concept that superior will power can overcome superior economic and military power.

      Worth reading if you havent already. Likely referenced in much of Petraeus new handbook.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/DroppingBY DroppingBY

    So what usually happens after foreign troops conduct a PR exercise around reconstruction projects?

    From my reading, what usually happens is that the Taliban follow up a) by destroying the project, and b) by killing any and all locals implicated/involved in the project.

    So why won't this be the result of this particular PR exercise?

  • DroppingBY

    So what usually happens after foreign troops conduct a PR exercise around reconstruction projects?

    From my reading, what usually happens is that the Taliban follow up a) by destroying the project, and b) by killing any and all locals implicated/involved in the project.

    So why won't this be the result of this particular PR exercise? Is PR more important than the project itself, and more important than the lives of involved locals?

From Macleans