The man who brought down a tyrant

Cindor Reeves helped bring Liberia’s brutal dictator, Charles Taylor, to justice. Now Canada may kick him out.

by Michael Petrou on Wednesday, July 22, 2009 5:00pm - 11 Comments

The British haven’t lifted a finger for Reeves, despite the spying he did for MI6. Nor have the Americans, having seemingly forgotten that Reeves risked his life to identify al-Qaeda operatives whom the U.S. holds responsible for the murder of more than 200 people, including 12 Americans. Reeves says he isn’t bitter. He co-operated with anyone he thought could bring Taylor to justice. He never asked for or was promised anything in return, and doesn’t think he’s owed anything now.

Reeves’s fate will be decided at an admissibility hearing held by the Immigration and Refugee Board, likely later this year. A good lawyer might be able to argue his case, but he can hardly afford one. Reeves faces being deported to Liberia. He won’t be safe there, says Crane. Some will seek revenge. Others will want to protect themselves against what Reeves might say at future trials to address war crimes committed in Liberia. “If word ever got out that he was there,” says Crane, “I would not give him long.”

If Reeves is deported, his life will have unfolded pretty much as Charles Taylor predicted when he warned Reeves not to testify against him because the international community would use and then discard him. Taylor might have been a brutish dictator and war criminal, but he got that right.

Bookmark and Share
  • Alex

    A very intriguing article, Michael. Thanks for sheding some light on this case.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/AdenMurphy AdenMurphy

    I can't say I've been particularly happy with Immigration Canada's recent decisions. As if the absolutely shameful treatment of Abousfian Abdelrazik wasn't enough, we appear ready to deport someone who risked his life to bring justice on a dictator. I understand that we generally don't want to have members of violent regimes immigrating to Canada, but this case is very clearly exceptional. And I'd add that we currently have many members of terrible regimes quietly living in Canada (take Désiré Munyaneza, a Rwandese génocidaire), but the difference is that these people lied about their pasts.
    Cindor Reeves trusted the fairness of the Canadian immigration system in coming to Canada and disclosing his past. I'd hate to see his faith disproved by him being deported and murdered on his return to Liberia.

    If Jason Kenney or anyone from Immigration Canada happens to read this, I'd appreciate a response.

  • Maureen

    From my reading of this, Britain (through MI6) have a responsibility for him, as well as the International court. As for Canada excluding him because of his pass – a case can be made for any number of terrorists, dictators, thugs etc. etc. etc. coming to Canada – they have reformed, they were forced to do it, they didn't know the whole picture, they were young, they were poor, et. etc. etc.. Yet we are quite willing to go after 87-year-old Nazi foot soldiers. They are either excluded from entry because their past, or they are not. And I say they are excluded. Period.

  • Robyn Doyle

    If there are any refugees who deserve the right to remain in Canada, it is this man. Even if he had committed crimes in his past, the fact that he has put so much on the line to bring Taylor to justice, and has barely asked for more than a safe place to raise his own children, greatly out-weighs the crime of smuggling blood diamonds. He has risked not only his own life, but those of his family, and that takes courage.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/janicemaerose janicemaerose

    I agree with you Maureen on your first point that Britain OWES this guy and his family and that Canada technically does not necessarily, especially since he came from Europe.

    But his story is so compelling that Canada shoud step up to the bat for CR and family – but, big BUT, Stephen Harper is in office – fat chance!

    • Maureen

      There are lots of compelling stories out there – but I don't believe it is in Canada's interest to allow this individual to stay.

  • Terry Alms

    So this guy helps rebel groups by engaging in smuggling,therefore,helping them wage a disastrous war that has shattered the lives of millions.Hundreds of thousands have had their limbs hacked because of this man.So save the sympathy for the victims here.He has a falling out with someone,turns him in and somehow,that is supposed to just make everything okay?He needs to answer for his activties.

    How dare you potray this monster as an angel?You even go far to describe him as having principle.Are you retarded?We are supposed to feel sorry for him because his lifestyle of aiding and abetting the murder of civilians got disrupted?This man needs to go,NOW!Nobody 'ever recalls seeing him with a gun'.Are you sure about that,what about the civilians that were murdered because of this man`s activities.He has blood on his hands.I can`t believe they actually let him in,feeding his sorry ass with our tax dollars.

    Why don`t we get the Taliban settle here because we disrupted them in Afghanistan?How about that?You could write about how Zawahiri is'such a good man' because he was not there in New York when the twin towers got hit.

    • Jack

      I agree completely, For whatever reasons, this is a bad guy who has such an atricios past that cannot be overlooked. It would appear that "luck" has been on his side and has saved him twice (at least) … but, just because he turned on his former associate, he cannot be excused for the atrocities he created, caused or forced upon his neighbours. Perhaps his punishment should be lessened, but he must answer for his own (brutal) actions …

  • Soshay Kaiser

    Well, i lived in Ghana, at the time and happen to know the brother, he is a liar, whos trying to hook on to over stay., I knw since i dated his sister and was a guess at the huge house he built in Ghana. Getting the asylum witha bunch of lies is all he did. Charles taylor is no longer in liberia, why not return???

  • Victor

    I would expel him to U.K.
    NOT deport him to Liberia or Sierra Leone.
    if only to encourage other insiders to talk.

    London (England) is the place he should be expelled to.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/madeyoulook madeyoulook

    This is a tough one. The man is of great value indeed to bring a tyrant to heel, but his past earns him a justifiable keep-out stamp on the welcome-to-Canada form.

    From the sound of it, his safety (and his family's) might be better served if the world did NOT know his whereabouts.

    Maybe the rich western countries who have helped mess up that part of Africa owe a greater duty of care to this family than does Canada?

From Macleans