Beyond The Commons

Beyond The Commons

Aaron Wherry covers all the goings-on in and around Parliament Hill. Follow Aaron on Twitter: @aaronwherry

Donuts, hockey, tax cuts and Afghanistan

by Aaron Wherry on Wednesday, September 23, 2009 4:36pm - 86 Comments

harperhortonsBelow is a transcript of the Prime Minister’s speech today at the Tim Hortons Innovation Centre in Oakville.

If I ever get round to writing a book about this time in Ottawa, I may very well argue that this, in content, setting and context, is the quintessential speech of Stephen Harper’s premiership.

This is obviously a big day for the Tim Hortons family, returning to your Canadian roots after 14 years away. Now, I agree, the United States is a great place to visit, but let’s face it, there is no place like our home and native land, there is no place like Canada. I also suspect that there will be a lot of Canadians actually surprised to hear that Tims is moving its headquarters back home. Your company is such a fixture here on the street corners and in the malls that I’m not sure many canadians would believe you actually ever moved away, but this company’s success over the past four decades is truly impressive.

The numbers speak for themselves, from one location in 1964 in Hamilton, Ontario to over 3,000 today. Tim Hortons has become the largest publicly traded restaurant chain in Canada. These figures stand as a tribute to the talented company leadership and staff here at headquarters and in the field who have built Tim Hortons throughout the years. Give all yourselves a big round of applause for that.

Now, if I were to look back to the early days, I think there were a couple of things about Tim Hortons that really connected with Canadians. First, of course, was the name and reputation of the cofounder, the great Toronto Maple Leaf defenseman Tim Horton. Baby boomers who grew up watching the original six remember him as one of the strongest and sturdiest blue liners ever to play the game. And, of course, for millions of long suffering Leaf fans across the country, the name Tim Horton conjures up their four Stanley Cups and the glory years of the 1960s.

So the name was very important, but there is another thing even millions more know. Millions more Canadian hockey parents like me know well that when it is 20 below and everyone is up for a 6 a.m. practice, nothing motivates the team more than a box of Timbits and nothing warms the parents in the stands better than a hot double-double. Perhaps no one said it better about Tim Hortons than the great Canadian author Pierre Berton. Let me quote. “In so many ways, the story of Tim Hortons is the essential Canadian story. It is the story of success and tragedy, of big dreams in small towns, of old fashioned values and tough-fisted business, of hard work and of hockey.”

Much of Tim Hortons’ success can be attributed to your commitment to the communities you serve. Thousands of underprivileged kids go to summer camps each year through the generosity of the Tim Hortons Children’s Foundation. Countless local and national sporting events from hockey to the Tim Hortons brier are supported by the company’s sponsorship, and Tims is appreciated by all Canadians, none any less than the brave men and women of the Canadian forces. I know this well because I’ve served coffee and iced caps to our soldiers on the Kandahar military base in Afghanistan.

In 1995, when Tim Hortons merged with an American firm, it effectively became an American company. That decision was undoubtedly made in the best interests of the company. But here we are today, 14 years later, because it is now in the best interests of the company to come back to Canada today. This decision, ladies and gentlemen, is all about the bottom line, and the bottom line is that Canada is now not just a great place to live, it is a great place to invest and to do business. When our government took office almost four years ago, we set out to make sure Canada would be not just one of the best places on earth to live and work but also to invest. When we took office in 2006, the corporate tax rate just at the federal level was over 22%. Today it is now down to 19% and it will fall to 15% by 2012 when it will be the lowest in the G7. Obviously numbers like that look pretty attractive to companies like Tims but just as attractive to the executives and managers who run the companies like this are the cuts we’ve made to personal taxes. Tax freedom day in this country now arrives 20 days earlier than when we took office thanks to the tax cuts introduced by Minister Flaherty. And soon, the federal tax burden in this country will fall to its lowest level in 50 years.

Lowering taxes has helped keep our economy relatively healthy even as we’ve been dragged into the global recession, and because of our strong long-term fiscal position, when the recovery comes, while others will be raising taxes to deal with their massive debt burdens, we will be able to continue lowering taxes. Canada’s economic future has rarely looked brighter. Our banks are secure, our markets are expanding, our stimulus is working, our taxes are falling, and our long-term fiscal position is solid. Tim Hortons’ return in the midst of the global recession is a clear signal that Canada is poised to come out of these tough times stronger than ever. The path we are on will draw home many other Canadian companies and businesses, it will attract highly skilled immigrants here from all over the world. In other words, Tim Hortons’ return is just the beginning of a new era of prosperity for Canada and there could be no fitting—no company more fitting to lead the way. So it is my great honour and indeed my pleasure to be the first to officially say welcome home Tim Hortons.

Bookmark and Share
  • Evalina

    He appeals very much to the Tim Hortons crowd – uneducated, blue-collar and most likely to vote Conservative.
    Sad but true.

  • joe in ottawa

    Harper a PM I can be proud of : )

  • J. Lebel

    Actually, it appears to me that the whole point of the article is to ironize on Harper's absence from the G20. While the whole world gathers there preparing the way for the Copenhague summit, our PM chooses not to represent us; he'd rather defend Canadian donuts than try to establish us as a country worth listening to. Whether you are on the left or the right doesn't matter at all here; it's about defining the importance of our country and expanding it beyond its current status as a militarily weak, relatively rich but clearly not proactive country.

  • Oemissions

    Tim who????

  • http://prolinehockeypicks.com Hockey Picks

    “I bought my childhood home. ”

    This made me tear up…….

    And that is some serious paneling, my friend.thank u post…..

  • http://www.intensedebate.com/people/Crit_Reasoning Crit_Reasoning

    If I ever get round to writing a book about this time in Ottawa, I may very well argue that this, in content, setting and context, is the quintessential speech of Stephen Harper’s premiership.

    Are you seriously planning a book?

    Content: pro-Tim Horton's, pro-Canadian business, pro-1960's hockey, pro-Pierre Berton, pro-economic competitiveness, pro-lower corporate taxes, pro-highly skilled immigrants, pro-prosperity

    Setting: Oakville, Ontario: Tim Hortons Innovation Centre (home of the titanium dioxide sprinkles)

    Context: One of Canada's most recognizable and successful companies returns to Canada; meanwhile, the debate rages about climate change and other international issues at the big UN conference in NY.

    Impact: Negligible, will be ignored by most Canadians and by the media.

  • http://www.intensedebate.com/people/Crit_Reasoning Crit_Reasoning

    If I ever get round to writing a book about this time in Ottawa, I may very well argue that this, in content, setting and context, is the quintessential speech of Stephen Harper’s premiership.

    Are you seriously planning a book?

    Content: pro-Tim Horton's, pro-Canadian business, pro-1960's hockey, pro-Pierre Berton, pro-economic competitiveness, pro-lower corporate taxes, pro-highly skilled immigrants, pro-prosperity

    Setting: Oakville, Ontario – Tim Hortons Innovation Centre (home of the titanium dioxide sprinkles)

    Context: One of Canada's most recognizable and successful companies returns to Canada; meanwhile, the debate rages about climate change and other international issues at the big UN conference in NY.

    Impact: Negligible, will be ignored by most Canadians and by the media.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/PoliticalPundit PoliticalPundit

    Quintessential Harper speech! Yes it is. But Wow! The speech is a load of crap or should I say soggy donuts! Surely our journalist should start being just a wee bit more analytical in these photo op matters.
    Brilliant political move to get the Tim Horton crowd vote once again but truly lame economics. Like Harper's cuts to the GST. The GST cuts got him a second minority but doomed the Department of Finance's abilities to pay down the ballooning deficit and debt.
    If our economic future depends on mac-jobs created by the likes of Tim Horton companies – more fast food outlets to make us fat and cost the health care system a bundle – then Canadians are in deep doo doo!!
    But then Harper came to office pandering to the irrational side of Canadian voters and he will get elected by pandering even more to the fears and anxieties of Canadian voters.
    A great many of our high paying manufacturing jobs have disappeared never to return. Educated Canadians will have to settle for low paying service sector mac-jobs that offer few or no benefits, not even a meager pension to retire on.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/john_g2708 john g

    Pure politics. Tim Horton's is one of the strongest, most powerful brands in Canada. Not surprising that Harper wants to take credit for bringing a good Canadian name home. I don't know why this couldn't have waited until after the G20.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Ricard_S_Argent Richard_S_Argent

    My attempt at a Wherry Post :)

    "If you're going to make a new business investment in Canada, and you're concerned about taxes, the last place you will go is the province of Ontario." – Jim Flaherty Feb 29, 2008

    "The bottom line is that Canada is now not just a great place to live, it is a great place to invest and to do business." – Stephen Harper September 23, 2009

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Ed_Sweeney Ed_Sweeney

    Richard,
    there is actually a contextual link between those two items. I think you're going to have to work on the impersonation some more.

    I have it on good authority – my local magi from a nearby mountain top, that if Wherry spoke the "context" aloud three times – POOF, Armageddon.

  • http://www.intensedebate.com/people/Ed_Sweeney Ed_Sweeney

    Richard,
    there is actually a contextual link between those two items. I think you're going to have to work on the impersonation some more.

    I have it on good authority – my local magi from a nearby mountain top, that if Wherry spoke the word "context" aloud three times – POOF, Armageddon.

  • http://www.intensedebate.com/people/Ed_Sweeney Ed_Sweeney

    Richard,
    there is actually a contextual link between those two items. I think you're going to have to work on the impersonation some more.

    I have it on good authority – my local swami from a nearby mountain top, that if Wherry spoke the word "context" aloud three times – POOF, Armageddon.

  • Neil from Calgary

    What has changed between then and now:

    In U.S.:
    -economic crisis in the U.S. with fears of a lost decade of economic activity.
    -increased trade protectionism and the rumblings of trade wars
    -speculation around higher income and business taxes

    In Canada:
    -Business taxes cut at federal level
    -Business tax cuts planned for Ontario
    -HST in BC and Ontario
    -Talks (and action) around free trade with the EU
    -Middle-income brackets expanded (tax cut)

    A lot has changed since Feb 08. Have you heard about this fella called Obama? He could become the Dem's nominee in November!!

  • dan in van

    Yep, a few weeks after helping pack the truck of Nortel and all its belongings, Harper's out backslapping the joe and jills for having brought Tim Horton back from the States… the place he then returned to for more photo op/tv appearances in his quest to be the new Billy May. Canada, we hardly knew yah.

  • John W.

    Good one. Who cares about RIM when you got those Tim Horton voters? Who cares about those arts types at their galas, and legal crazed feminists, and those pesky climate change scientists, when you got Tims?
    With few exceptions the media never calls him out on this stuff; he doesn't even believe it himself but knows he can get away with it. Pure cynicism.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/TJCook TJCook

    Yup – can't wait to bump into my old Nortel colleagues in the applicants line for jobs at Tim Hortons.

  • bert

    Sure PM and the Cons lowered the corporate tax and put it on the backs of ordinary Canadians. Wonder how much our politicians have invested in companies. The more these companies make the more rewards for the investors at the cost to the consumer. Maybe its time to tax these companies at 60% of their gross income. They would then have no reason to hike up prices. At the same time tax all incomes over $250.000 at 100%. Measures such as these would limit the rip offs in the corporate system.

  • ABarlow

    I'm assuming that you'd still like to have doctors in this country? University professors? Professional athletes? Lawyers? Judges? Computer specialists? Accountants? Confiscatory tax rates will drive these people from the country–and probably collapse our tax base, since the top 1% of incomes already pay a huge proportion of the taxes–something on the order of 25% of the total tax base. The problem will be the same with taxing companies–who would ever want to make a business in Canada if they're going to get taxed at 60%? The only companies that would be able to survive would be foreign corporations that can pay minimal taxes in Canada–you'd be choking off Canadian enterprise to the benefit of foreigners. Or you'd just have a situation where nobody would be willing to do business here at all, unless they're able to dump the 60% tax rate onto the consumer. This plan would be a recipe for unmitigated disaster.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/psiclone psiclone

    Excellent Speech and a very good example of priorites (1) we have option 1 attend UN general Assembly and waste an hour and half out of your life listening to Omar Kahadafi raise such xcrucials issues like where he can set up his tent – or – (2) Help celebrate one of the premier flagship companies that left canada 14 years ago and has now decided to come back home and hundreds of new jobs – hmmm let me see .. I don't know it's a tough call – Harper just earned more points than Iggy will in the next month and no doubt about it. What the naysayers fail to take into consideration is that canadians want economic results right now and all of the other stuff is just white noise!

  • Yawn

    Mr Igantieff, dont you have better things to do?

  • mit

    What Harper fails to remember is that The Paul Martin government was on track to move corporate taxes to the point they would be in 2012 a year or 2 earlier. Harper also forgets to tell Canadians that the first GST cut was at the expense of income tax cuts that Paul Martin had instituted but failed to get changed in legislation because Harper pulled the plug with his coalition. The GST cut favoured only those at the top income levels and those that did not already pay income tax leaving the middle class to pick up the burden again. He repeated the trick agin and although he did later reduce income tax because Harper and Flaherty could not outspend the surpluses (Deemed to be overtaxation and a bad thing by Harper) – Now we have deficits – no Paul Martin rainy day fund – No reverse auction process for Government Procurement (Fortier and Baird killed that $3 billion savings opportunity) – promises that we have yet to pay for and a balanced budget horizon that keeps moving out and a Prime Minister saying he is not going to cut spending or raise taxes.
    AND THIS IS A GOOD THING?

From Macleans