Eckhart Tolle vs. God

The spiritual leader that evangelicals rail against has a new book—on the divinity of pets

by Ken MacQueen on Thursday, October 22, 2009 10:00am - 58 Comments

Tolle did not immediately sort out the puzzle of his awakening 30 years ago. He drifted for years: poor, happy, but aimless, sharing with fellow seekers his evolving thoughts, rather like an itinerant monk. In 1995 he washed up in Vancouver—one of the least formally religious and most spiritually restless places in North America, as poll after poll has revealed. He was home. “There is an openness here on the West Coast, anything is possible,” he says. “It could be that the lightness here has something to do with the relatively little past. Obviously there were people here before the Europeans came but they didn’t accumulate past the way Europeans do. They didn’t keep records of the past. They probably lived naturally in the present moment.” Professor Mark Shibley, a specialist in the sociology of religion at Southern Oregon University, puts the attraction in more base terms. “Spiritual entrepreneurs” like Tolle, he says in The Elusive Utopia, “relocated to this region because they perceive an open religious marketplace.”

In fact, eckharttolle.com reaches everywhere. The site sells an impressive product line of Tolle’s books, with the message recycled into music, cards, calendars, CDs and DVDs, as well as meditations from Eng and her instructional Qi Flow Yoga video. Tolle lives well, though not ostentatiously, on what must be substantial royalities. There is this high-end condo in one of Canada’s most expensive neighbourhoods, and a property on Salt Spring Island. He drives an Infinity, because he loves the name. Now comes Eckhart Tolle TV, an Internet site with streaming video of monthly group meditations, video responses to life’s tough questions (“To Think Or Not To Think?”, “What is Self?”) and perhaps most important, unlimited access to an “online community to chat with members worldwide.” The cost: $14.95 a month; six months, $74.75. “We think we have a winner here,” says Anthony McLaughlin, its executive producer and founder.

ET-TV had a soft launch in the summer and will be more heavily promoted this fall. “You can travel the world and teach 2,000 to 3,000 people at a time, but that’s got limitations,” says McLaughlin. “The idea of the online model is to make it really affordable and be able to go worldwide on demand.” The message board is already abuzz, with a discussion string on “sexual energy in the process of awakening” drawing particularly enthusiastic attention.

The site is at once technically advanced and decidedly unslick. A case in point is Tolle’s meditation, broadcast Sunday, Sept. 20, “a live transmission of stillness,” as he describes it. The camera fixes on a black backdrop, a table with a vase of flowers and an empty chair. Tolle enters the frame. He sits silent, staring into the camera—a concept that would be death on Oprah, or 100 Huntley Street or the emotive theme-park excess of Jim and Tammy Faye Bakker’s old Praise The Lord Club. Finally, he speaks. “I trust that everybody is comfortable with stillness,” he begins, with an uncharacteristic hint of steel. “If you’re not, then get comfortable.”

The camera draws close and for the next 46 minutes he expands on achieving the virtues of stillness and emptiness through “a cessation in the stream of thinking.” He stops speaking at the 41-minute mark. “And that’s it,” he says with a slight smile and a bob of his head. There follows five minutes of unblinking silence, broken just three times as Tolle delicately strikes two Tibetan meditation bells. Then he walks off camera.

No communion. No choir. No saints. No sinners. No benediction. And yet, in the bells, chiming into infinity that Sunday afternoon, in the silent meditation, in the online congregation, there is something akin to liturgy. One is reminded of Bishop Ingham’s musing on the well-travelled arc from spirituality to religion. Tolle may be farther down the path than he cares to admit. “How does one get closer to God?” an admirer would later post on the site. “Listen to Eckhart Tolle.”

Bookmark and Share
  • Ed

    Pete wrote “Eckhart could easily create his own religion & followers build up a formal structure & have even more power & money, yet he chooses not to.”

    And that is a truth. Unlike his critics in the MacLean’s article here, he does not say one thing and do another.

    Chapter Three of ‘A New Earth’ clearly states “All Structures are Unstable”, IOW all “lower mind created” structures. Structures such a Christianity are lower mind created, this is confirmed by such comments as, “James Beverley, a professor of Christian thought and ethics at the evangelical Tyndale Seminary in Toronto, ……has read Tolle’s books …….. finds Tolle denies “the core” of Christianity by claiming there is no ultimate distinction between humans and God and Jesus. “From a Christian perspective, Tolle misquotes “…………………….excuse professor!!!!!!! but you and no one else can speak for all Christians! and your comments are COMPLETELY incorrect wrt who/ which branches accept or do not accept that …….BOTH God and therefore Human is Divine.

    It was you that “misquoted” here, you really sould get the right wrt the “core” of what Jesus was pointing to professor. Christianity is a large subject with No ultimate Expert of the Higher Consciousness. None but the individual Human heart that is.

    This was stated by a group of young musicians ‘Naturally Seven’ …”What this is can’t be told, can’t be bought and can’t be sold”.

    Eckhart is a living example to that TRUTH which this group of young hearts sing out with great enthusiasm.

    • Jim Beverley

      Ed,

      I did not read the follow-up Internet discussion to the article on Tolle until today. I do not claim to speak for everyone who claims to be Christian. What I think can be done, however, is find out what the Bible clearly says about God etc and relate that to Tolle. He wants to make no distinction between God and humans. He denies the reality of the self. These are not the views of the Bible. Tolle got his basic ideas from Hindu advaitism and Buddhism. Tolle has many, many good points but he misses the core of the Gospel…about Jesus as Son of God, Saviour, Lord.

      Let me add one apology. I regret that I made reference to the fact that I have read Tolle's books "in gory detail." That was an off-hand comment that I realize is unfair. I find much of The Power of Now confusing but I should not have used the word gory.

      Jim Beverley

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Nich Nich

    The Condensed History of Organized Religion, by Gary.

    Substitute any religion for 'He' and Eastern cultures with any previous religious organization, stir well, and you have a new cult. If successful, it will later be called a region.

  • http://cashwithatrueconscience.com/rbblog Ryan Biddulph

    Learn from others. Seek your own truths. Speak with conviction. Believe in yourself. Simple to say, but most difficult to practice, namely because humans like to judge. He's right, he's wrong, this one is nuts, this one is a god.

    All judgements, all emotional, very little clear thinking. Stillness cures all illnesses. The best way to get close to God is by spending 30 minutes in a quiet room. I think that Tolle has amazing things to say, just like many other people who I come across. But there's nothing like stillness.

  • Kent Lowe

    How many anti-christs are there? Besides poor Mr. Tolle, the evangelicals also claim Obama, Pope Benedict, and others over the years are or were the Anti-Christ.
    Mr. Tolles’s teaching success points to the incredible failings of the major religious traditions, and Christian denominations in
    particular, to provide relevant spiritual tools to their flock in our complex time.

  • RosettaStone

    There’s an old saying that I’d like to share. And it applies to everyone, both high and low, whether you’re Eckhart Tolle or no one in particular, at the end of the day:

    "You’re as sick as your secrets".

    Ulrich, if you’re reading this, just know:

    I am so ashamed I once called you "friend".

    • HowNowBrownCow

      Why did he change his 'label' from Ulrich to Eckhart when it seems to go against the grain of his teachings:

      'When you don’t cover up the world with words and labels, a sense of
      the miraculous returns to your life that was lost a long time ago when
      humanity, instead of using thought, became possessed by thought.And the
      greatest miracle is the experiencing of your essential self as prior to any
      words, thoughts, mental labels, and images. For this to happen, you need to
      disentangle your sense of I, of Beingness, from all the things it has become
      mixed up with, that is to say, identified with. That disentanglement is what
      this book is about.'
      'The quicker you are in attaching verbal or mental labels to things,
      people, or situations, the more shallow and lifeless your reality becomes, and
      the more deadened you become to reality …' taken from 'A New Earth'

  • http://marioarana.blogspot.com/ Mario Arana

    Everyone who is interested in living a fullfilled life should read Josh McDowell´s book: MORE THAN A CARPENTER.

    God bless you all!

    1. God Loves You!
    The Bible says, "God so loved the world that He gave His one and only Son, that whoever believes in Him shall not perish, but have eternal life"

    The problem is that

    2. All of us have done, said or thought things that are wrong. This is called sin, and our sins have separated us from God.
    The Bible says "All have sinned and fall short of the glory of God." God is perfect and holy, and our sins separate us from God forever. The Bible says "The wages of sin is death."

    The good news is that, about 2,000 years ago,

    3. God sent His only Son Jesus Christ to die for our sins.
    Jesus is the Son of God. He lived a sinless life and then died on the cross to pay the penalty for our sins. "God demonstrates His own love for us in that while we were yet sinners Christ died for us."

    Jesus rose from the dead and now He lives in heaven with God His Father. He offers us the gift of eternal life — of living forever with Him in heaven if we accept Him as our Lord and Savior. Jesus said "I am the way, the truth, and the life. No one comes to the Father except by Me."

    God reaches out in love to you and wants you to be His child. "As many as received Him, to them He gave the right to become children of God, even to those who believe on His name." You can choose to ask Jesus Christ to forgive your sins and come in to your life as your Lord and Savior.

    4. If you want to accept Christ as Savior and turn from your sins, you can ask Him to be your Savior and Lord by praying a prayer like this:

    "Lord Jesus, I believe you are the Son of God. Thank you for dying on the cross for my sins. Please forgive my sins and give me the gift of eternal life. I ask you in to my life and heart to be my Lord and Savior. I want to serve you always."

    If you prayed this prayer go to http://joshmcdowell.blogspot.com/ for resources to help you live this new life you have!

  • o1biggen

    Ted thanks for giving us an insight into your state of consciousness. Obviously you have not experience the transformation that Eckhart is pointing to in his writings.

  • medea

    Need to say, where do you know him from?

  • Guest

    "To Eckhart Tolle, spiritual enlightenment is synonymous with pleasurable feelings."

    No it isn't, in fact it's the opposite: pleasurable or not his message is to face everything that is happening right now; to over think things causes unnecessary mental anguish. I think the "tollites" have completely missed Tolles message themselves and i'm not going to suggest you read everything he's written nor am I going to argue whether he is right or not but you obviously haven't really read or heard anything of his. If you have then you are in your head when you do because everything you've critiqued he goes over in his works. Whether it is really doable or not is something else all together.

  • Guest

    This is interesting especially in the wake of "tolletv" and the fact that he charges about 200 a pop for a seat at one of his talks. I've justified this by thinking that Tolles business is responsible for most of these things and since he's already said all he needs to say in the power of now he's just clarifying for those that want to buy into it. Really though if things where really that negative I think we'd be hearing more concrete things from people out there as it seems many have a beef with him and I can imagine the wolves would be salivating if they had eyewitnesses that can verify that Tolle is nothing but a greedy gold digger.

    I don't know I've never personally paid a dime for Tolles works, I get them from the library and find them very helpful even if it's just plagiarized eastern and western ideas repackaged for the layman. Would love to hear real facts to back up your statements on Tolles "dark side" but that's just my ego wanting to hear gossip…

  • Need to say

    I don't want to say anything more beyond this posting except to say that everything I have stated is the truth and nothing but. Again, he is excellent at what he does. He speaks well the language of these universal, spiritual truths. He is skilled in this and I believe there is a partial sincerity in what he does. However, who he is behind the mask is pretty disturbing.

    Sad to say, but like many before him, this man does not walk the talk.

    Not by a long shot.

    His EGO is ENORMOUS. (you can cull evidence of this just by the entire enterprise that has been built up around him.) Now compare him to someone like the Dalai Lama. Every book and appearance the Dalai Lama makes is for the cause of saving Tibet and anything pertaining to it. All proceeds are donated. Listen to HIS talks. Read his books. The Dalai Lama's message is not about being in the NOW, or being present or being out of ego. It's about being compassionate, being a good person, giving to others. Doing the DEED work.

    The Dalai Lama definitely has no issue with his Ego . Nor does he tell others that he has overcome his Ego (Tolle is lying, by the way) and that you might want to do the same. In fact, I bet you anything the Dalai Lama has a good sense of humor about his own ego. And he might add something like the old Buddhist axiom: "chop wood, carry water" or, doing for others (humility–something you never hear Tolle say) is truly the way to forget or diminish your ego.

    Actually, he would probably say– it's the Abuses of Ego that gets one into trouble, and Eckhart (incidentally, he ditched his real name for a bigger Ego-identifier with Meister Eckhart–how's that for ego-identification with one who is considered a Spiritual Master?) does not make that distinction. Unfortunately, Tolle has exhibited ego abuse in his underhanded dealings with others. 98% of the people out there only know his staged persona. Not the man behind the mask. And unfortunately, I am one of those people.

    Sorry, that is all I am going to say. And you don't have to believe me. Just trust your good common sense. The man is very human. I want to say, dangerously human.

    • Guest

      I'm starting to think you are a tibetan buddhist with an axe to grind with Tolle as despite The Dali Lamas visit with Tolle many of them do as they value staunch tradition and practice. Tolle dosen't head a religion nor does he pretend to so I don't see the point of saying he needs to do/preach good deeds as that has never been the point of his teachings. Without any examples to back up your assertions it's really hard to believe you, anyone could come up with these insinuations since his background is very murky. I haven't made up my mind about Tolle but these little vague games just strengthen him.

      • AJ Kemp

        "Guest"–

        Why don't you re-read the post that "Need to say" entered? This person is clearly saying that he/she is not giving any examples. That this person wishes to not go into it. Yet you are pushing for this person to do so.

        Giving an example from Buddhism (Tibetan or not, so what?) is just that. Furthermore–the point is made clear that what one does might be a little more resonant than what one says. That is all the person is pointing out. Or do you not get this one?

        I find Tolle very egotistical. I have heard him in person–and it's totally clear the man is self-absorbed from his talks. Pay attention! It is there to be perceived if you listen and look close enough.

        I also want to note that "Need to say" clearly says: "you don't have to believe me". And encourages you to use your own perceptions. That is fair.
        Stop pushing for "proof". Obviously, this person wishes to not go into it. It seems you still wouldn't be satisfied if the person were to flesh out the details. You'd probably still argue with it.

        • Guest

          If need to say gave clear details instead of vague accusations I would keenly hear him out, as I said i'm still on the fence about Tolle. I just don't see the things you do when i've seen/heard him speak, his philosophy and teachings answer all the questions to why he is the way he is I don't see it as ego. What does worry me is the prices he charges for his spiritual teachings and his murky backround, but until someone comes out and gives us some concrete proof then you just don't like him and his teachings and that's fine, but why make stuff up?

  • David

    hmmmmm, wonder why the Dalai Lama would hang out with such a guy?

  • AJ Kemp

    David–

    I would think that having Tolle (whose hometown is Vancouver) attend a conference featuring the Dalai Lama as its main presenter and speaker is hardly a "hang out with" scenario.

    Tolle's people got him on the roll call along with these other guests at that 3-day event that was held in Vancouver a month or so ago. This is not the same as "hanging out" with–actually, I rather think it's the other way 'round.

  • steve

    You want to get over to the forum on Eckhart Tolle's site. It is a world of pain and spiritual bullying. It is unmoderated and therefore a free for all. It has become the home for many false prophets and imposters mirroring the world which Tolle would like to rejuvinate. His own site has is now a focus for unconsciousness, intolerance and unbridled ego.

    • medea

      On the other hand there is a lot of love and wisdom shared :-)

  • LifeXpression

    You guys are blinded by your dogmatic beliefs. To be 'wrong' (and the teachings of Eckhart and others are the biggest threat to Christians, as their teaching actually makes SENSE) is tantamount to death…death of your rigid little egos. And so you fight. The crusades are very much still alive. I leave to dream your little dreams. I am awake.

  • http://www.gadivorcelitigators.com Athens Lawyer

    I can see all of the are smiling.

  • Andrea

    Why was my comment deleted?

  • ckURselfFOOL

    Religion is another medium for the ego to feed off of. Look at how many divisions there are in the christian religion by itself. 38,000 different versions of the religion just because of petty differences in interpretation. These differences occurred because one persons ego thought they were better than the next.

From Macleans