Inkless Wells

Inkless Wells

Paul Wells on all the latest out of Ottawa—along with the occasional post about jazz. Follow Paul on Twitter: @InklessPW

"Equally unhelpful would be to repeat the lines in today's Globe and Mail"

by Paul Wells on Friday, November 27, 2009 10:27am - 67 Comments

That thing about boxing the Liberals in by making them decide federal tax policy? Never mind. Here, via the Inkless emailbox, are today’s Conservative talking points, which repeal yesterday’s Conservative talking points. So it’s flip-flop week for the government! I greatly fear Stephen Harper will cancel his Copenhagen trip, hike the GST, declare the Québécois an “un-nation” and introduce a carbon tax before sundown.

 

Subject: Provincial tax-choice and the Liberals / Le choix fiscal des provinces et les libéraux

Dear Caucus Members:

A front-page story in the Globe and Mail gives an unfortunate and inaccurate impression of our tax-harmonization framework policy.

The Government will introduce a tax-harmonization framework in order to respect provincial decision-making and to honour commitments made to Premiers McGuinty and Campbell.

Contrary to what the story implies, we are not proceeding in this manner to embarrass, box in or gain an advantage over the federal Liberals. Indeed, the Finance Minister and the House Leader have already reached out to the Liberal Caucus in an effort to address the legislation in a fair and reasonable way. Similarly, the PMO and the BC and Ontario premiers’ offices have been cooperating on how to move forward in a reasonable and constructive manner.

We have too much respect for provincial rights to treat this issue as a political football. Our goal is to secure Official Opposition support for the provincial-choice framework, not to score cheap points.

To this end, Caucus members are urged to say nothing — to national or local media — about the Liberal position on the framework or about the implications for the Liberal Party. Equally unhelpful would be to repeat the lines in today’s Globe and Mail article. Please give the House Leader and Finance Minister the space they need to work with MPs across the aisle.

A housekeeping note: This week Inkless Wells has been happy to bring you talking points from the NDP, Liberals and Conservatives in that order. We eagerly await something fun from the Bloc. So far it has been a 19-year wait.

 

Bookmark and Share
  • http://www.TennisVagabond.com Big Dave S

    I second the duck comment.
    Not a flip flop, lipstick on a pig. Or in this case, a strange duck/pig hybrid.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/madeyoulook madeyoulook

    If ChrisInKW is correct in the comment thread of Paul's earlier post on this ("Boy, it's a good thing…"), then all Ottawa needs to sign an agreement on harmonization with these two provinces is an Order in Council. So today's email to caucus may have a little unpleasant odour about it…

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Gaunilon Gaunilon

    I am so confused.

  • wilson

    The timing of the HST legislation has been bounced around the media since September.

    Canada and Ontario signed a harmonization memorandum of agreement in March.

    Better now than slip the legislation into the budget,
    then the opps would be howling about Harper's sneaky tricks.

  • Style

    It's true that there's a section of the "Federal Provincial Fiscal Arrangements Act" that deals with harmonization. It may also be true, as the Globe reports, that new legislation would be helpful to clarify provincial powers. Further, it may be true that some people briefing the government think it's necessary to have Liberal support on this. Others, apparently, may disagree and may be looking for a way to get the legislation through without too many fireworks. Or it could all be 4D Vulcan chess that only a level-13 intellect could understand…

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/ChrisInKW ChrisInKW

    I posted a blog entry (see via my ID profile) that explores this question a bit in depth. The thing that scares me (in a good way) is that it took me less than 15 minutes to find the relevant clause. Parl.gc.ca website may be drab but certainly functional.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/ChrisInKW ChrisInKW

    Gov't House Leader just tabled a motion to amend the Excise Tax Act. I guess that's it.

  • Ted

    He didn't need the legislation.

    No amount of passing the buck by you or Harper is going to change that fact.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/ChrisInKW ChrisInKW

    My suspicion is the proposed legislation will give provinces exemption powers over the provincial portion of the HST. While this is speculation, it fits with the "provincial rights" theme and the Bloc support.

  • M.A.

    I've got to say that letting provinces make exemptions here & there ruins one of the biggest advantages of the HST scheme, namely the reduced administrative burden on tracking what goods are taxable where.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/ChrisInKW ChrisInKW

    I have to agree with this. On reflection, my speculation is likely unfounded.

From Macleans