Holland’s anti-Islamic firebrand

He wants to ban the Quran. He’s also leading in the polls.

by Katie Engelhart on Tuesday, December 1, 2009 2:55pm - 68 Comments

Geert Wilders is famous for his punchy one-liners. Here’s one: “I don’t believe there is a moderate Islam.” And another: “The more Islam that we get, the less freedom that we get.” Wilders, for all his rhetorical failings, is always to the point—like when he categorically proclaims: “I want to ban the Quran.”

It’s not hard to imagine one of these brash catchphrases serving as a slogan for his possible run at the Dutch prime minister’s office in 2011. Today, Geert Wilders stands at the helm of the Netherlands’ fastest growing political force: the Party for Freedom (PVV), founded by Wilders after his 2004 split with the People’s Party. Wilders, Holland’s most notorious right-wing political rock star, has already managed to win a broad base of support, picking up 17 per cent of the Dutch vote in this year’s European elections.

But the PVV has come to resemble, for many, less of a political unit than a vehicle for Europe’s most brazen and unapologetic crusade against Islam—or, as Wilders is known to say, “that sick ideology of Allah and Muhammad.” That is at the heart of the PVV’s stance on nearly every issue. “Islam,” he insists, “is an ideology, not a religion. And it’s a very dangerous, violent and fascist ideology.” Indeed, Wilders has mobilized the right wing around a shared fear: “the Islamic invasion of Holland.”

Wilders wants to ban Islam’s primary religious text, the Quran, on the basis that it is no different from Mein Kampf, Adolf Hitler’s 1925 articulation of Nazi ideology. He also backs moves to prohibit the headscarf and burka—a policy that is endorsed by the country’s integration and immigration minister. Recently, Wilders has played on economic woes, urging the government to calculate “the cost of multiculturalism.” It’s an approach that has ostensibly met success; polls indicate that were a national vote to be held today, Wilders’s party would walk away with more votes than any other.

Wilders’s rise, some say, can be traced back to the day five years ago when a Dutch-Moroccan Muslim shot and then nearly decapitated Dutch filmmaker Theo van Gogh, allegedly for insulting Islam. The killing spurred a series of mosque burnings, and pitted Dutch nationalists against a growing body of immigrants. As the German newsmagazine Der Spiegel has written, “Nov. 2, 2004 was the Netherlands’ Sept. 11, and after that day many politicians declared that the country was now at war.” Wilders’s war has included his 17-minute film Fitna, which means “diagreement and division among people” in Arabic. It juxtaposes images of Sept. 11 and the 2005 London transit bombings with verses from the Quran, such as: “Prepare for them whatever force and cavalry ye are able of gathering, to strike terror, to strike terror into the hearts of the enemies, of Allah and your enemies.” (Last February, he was denied entry to London to show the film, although that stance was later reversed.)

Wilders’s rise, says Simon Usherwood, a professor at the University of Surrey, is explained in part by “economic downturn, [which] produces swings toward more reactionary politics.” But another factor is his undeniable charisma. Wilders’s nickname, “Mozart,” is a tribute to his striking hair: longish, cut bluntly, and bleached platinum blond—an attempt, say the rumours, to hide his allegedly Jewish ancestry. But the crux of his support stems from a pressing anxiety about immigration. There are now around one million Muslims—many from Morocco and Turkey—in the Netherlands. But while they only make up around six per cent of the population, there are Muslim strongholds, like Rotterdam, where, Usherwood says, you find white citizens worried that a “national minority will become a local majority.” Tensions are ripe, he claims, because the government has stuck to a policy of “benign neglect”: “simply stick[ing] your fingers in your ears and go[ing] ‘bla bla bla, I can’t hear you.’ ” This has allowed Wilders, with his own crude solution, to sweep in.

Ian Buruma, author of Murder in Amsterdam: The Death of Theo Van Gogh and the Limits of Tolerance, points his finger at a more global phenomenon: “It is a sign of a broader shift that is happening in Europe, or even the United States with Sarah Palin, in that there is a strong populist mood.” Wilders has managed to take advantage of an “anti-elite” sentiment, says Buruma, in part by manipulating criticism voiced against him. “Part of exploiting the fears of being victimized by elites is his own position: ‘look at me, the elites are out to get me.’ It helps cement that image of the beleaguered voice of the little man being stifled by the elite.”

For Wilders, the Netherlands—which Usherwood stresses is still “liberal and permissive”—is filled with hidden Islamic threats. But how much longer this Dutch Mozart, who is under heavy police protection, will be able to run his mouth is a topic for debate. A national court has charged Wilders with hate speech, and the trial will begin in January. But Buruma thinks a courtroom show will only fuel Wilders’s following, especially if tensions around immigration are not definitively addressed. “When people get fearful,” he warns,” they are capable of following demagogues anywhere.”

Bookmark and Share
  • http://intensedebate.com/people/canucklehead canucklehead

    There was a time when the beauty of philosophy and science and art was centered in the Muslim Caliphate. Some of the people who have commented here should reflect on that – that there was a time when the least discrimination for Jewish people was found in Islamic lands, and when the self-confidence of that empire allowed a publicly gay and publicly religiously sceptical poet as the celebrity of his time. I suggest that it was self confidence and not religion that enabled the beauty of that time in Islam and that it is a sense of having being defeated and not religion that causes the excesses of fundamentalism today. Maybe the ugliness you think you see in Islam is only a reflection of your own new fear in the mirror.

    The Muslim man who wrote the book "The Islamist" had to run away from home to join an Islamist group. Put that in your pipe.

    • wake up.

      who are you trying to fool, the idea of islam is to take over, and make everyone muslim, if they chose not to, kill them, kill the the none belevers remeber, you know what i hate, is people who pretend islam is a peacefull religion and they are just trying to live in the west like everyone else, the truth is they try to take over in every way. they need to be stopt NOW.

    • Rob H

      Jews have always been ghettoized in the Islamic world (along with other religions), forced to pay non believer taxes, not allowed to own property and if a muslim killed a jew he would normally not be prosecuted. That's when they just weren't killed outright as Mohammed did according to the Hadiths. Which Caliphate are you talking about?

      • http://intensedebate.com/people/canucklehead canucklehead

        I haven't found the book (it's an Islamic history that counters the Islamist version of what it means and has meant to be Muslim) I was thinking of. I haven't really looked yet, so maybe I will. I think it was the period from 1300 back to the beginning of Islam. And I'm not saying things were ever all that good, but the book makes the case that it was definately better than conditions in the Christian world. Come to think of it, maybe all I'd need to say is that the holocaust did not happen on Muslim soil – but then again… not for a lack of trying since the creation of modern Israel.

        Btw, I'm a Rob H too ^_^

  • mel

    canucklehead:
    are you kidding? the ugliness we think we see? the fear in the mirror? i don't "think" i see anything. i know what i see. i see people being murdered for speaking out against islam. i see planes slamming into buildings full of peole, i see suicide bombers blowing themselves up in crowded clubs and markets, i see foreign aid workers being decapitated while still alive, i see bodies of american soldiers being dragged through the streets, i see girls being murdered for becoming too "westernized" , i see classrooms full of kindergarten children being sprayed with automatic weapons, i see trains being blown up in london and india. there may have been a time when islam was beautiful, but that time has long since passed, and the only reason there is fear, is because that's what they want us to feel. there is no excuse, defeat or religion, that justifies the sort of fundamentalism we see today.
    why don't you put that in your pipe.

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/canucklehead canucklehead

      Again I refer to the book "The Islamist". The man who had to run away from his home to join an Islamist group also found that Muslim countries like Egypt have harsher laws against such organizations than western countries, and most shocking to him was that in countries such as Jordan and Syria very few people wear the burka – instead he found various colourful scarves. Here's the thing: you are making the same mistake that he had made by taking the Bin Ladens of the world at their word when they say they represent Islam. They do not. They know very little but that they want power. It is not Islam that is the problem, it is the people who think they own Islam.

      It is undeniable to say – as Ann Coulter once remarked – that the Amish have been quiet lately. There are differences between religions and there are problems with Islam itself that it must deal with. But again, to say it is about the people and the religion is to take the Islamists at their word and advance their goal of separating all Muslims from the rest of the world. You would give them more victims and more power by doing that.

      • mel

        PART ONE OF RESPONSE
        no people like you are the problem. sitting there telling the world that it has nothing to worry about. you are what islam calls a dhimmi. a "useful idiot". someone who can't see past their own self rightiousness to the danger in front of you, activley trying to blind others to that danger. you think that colorful scarves are a sign of free thinking in a muslim country? they are not. women are still forced to wear those scarves, or be beaten or killed. honor killings are rampant in the muslim world. not by the bin ladens, but by ordinary people. i'm not saying that there are not some muslims in the world who are good people, but i am saying that islam, the religion itself, is not one of peace if you are not a muslim.

      • mel

        PART TWO OF RESPONSE
        there is no denying that the koran tells muslims to kill infidels, although i'm sure you'll try. i also don't know what you're getting at with regard to the amish. they're always pretty quiet aren't they? who cares. they aren't the ones blowing people up, and cutting peoples heads off. there are obviously differences between religions, my religion tells me to love others, and respect them. it tells me i am supposed to convert people who don't believe as i do, but that people have free will and that is to be respected. islam says no such thing. convert or die, that's the choice, and that is a problem that can't be dealt with, because that would undermine the book it's based on. it is about the people. and why should we not take them at their word exactly?

      • mel

        PART THREE OF RESPONSE
        because of their long history of not doing what they say they will do? i'm pretty sure they are fairly good at following through on their threats of violence. and by the way, their goal is not to separate themselves from the rest of the world, if it were, they'd stay in their home countries instead of spreading out all over the world. their goal is to dominate, to exterminate, and to replace. you give them more victims, every time you manage to convince someone that a threat does not exist. you give them more power, every time you make excuses for what is wrong with their religion.

  • mel

    try this, think of all the examples of islamic terrorism over the last ten years, and replace all the muslims with white christians. would you still be defending them then? i bet there are a lot of christians who feel defeated in their religion. would they be justified in your mind too? i doubt it. but then again, you'll never have to, because any real christian values the life of every other human being as they do their own.

    • The Truth

      AMEN! Just keep in mind there are Christians of many colour…I know you know that and were just trying to make a point.

    • Guest

      Just like they did in Iraq right? Or Bosnia? or Chechnya? or Goa? or South America?
      When it comes to violence, Christendom takes a back seat to nobody.
      Do you not see, the Holy Land was desecrated by whom? Jews? No. Muslims? No.
      "Christians", well let history speak for itself.

  • eddie

    finally someone is talking some sense!! we should follow his example and start taking action against this creeping, passive invasion the mullahs are conducting over very noses!! the gross naivety and gullibility of the people of this country is astounding, to say the least! these guys are walking into our country and taking FIRM root with our permission and we are letting them. this whole 'equality' BS is going to lead to them taking away our freedoms. Heed the warning now while there is still time.

  • spaceman

    take a deep breath right wingers. you have no one to blame but yourselves.
    my heart does not bleed for right wing fanatics or religious fanatics. you've colonized and marginalized these people and now
    they are here to kick you asses.

    • mel

      too bad bombs don't make distinctions like "right" and "left"

    • Guest

      Karma brother. They shudder just by thinking of us. HAHAHA
      They don't enjoy peace. That is enuough for me.
      Bless

  • Harm

    If only atheists ran the world. If you want to achieve peace of mind and happiness, have faith. If you want to be a disciple of truth, then search.
    We as citizens need to question the impact our judeo christian teaching and values on society. Simply banning the burka and sharia law will not rid us from the evil religon has inflicted on the world.

    • mel

      how ironic that you promote atheism, and then tell us to "have faith". doesn't jive does it.

  • http://canadianpoliticsandissues.yuku.com/directory Largs

    Spaceman wrote: "take a deep breath right wingers. you have no one to blame but yourselves.
    my heart does not bleed for right wing fanatics or religious fanatics. you've colonized and marginalized these people and now
    they are here to kick you asses."

    And you think you or your family will be safe. You left wingers make me laugh.
    Of course you won't have to worry any longer about how we in the west oppress women and homosexuals. Under Sharia law women will not be allowed to leave the home unless they are completely covered and without a male relative. No more worries about that dam glass ceiling eh. Homosexuals will be publicly hanged of course so I guess Gay Pride parades are out of the question.
    Socialism and Political Correctness are mental disorders. Unfortunately they may doom us all.

  • Bill Desmond

    This sixth century religion of illiterate tribesmen is the worlds most dangerous anachronism. It brooks no interpretation, no apostasy, no tolerance as we know it and no secularism. This is a religion and a culture that lives by the old testament lunacy- misogyny, stoning for adultery, an eye for an eye, the murder of children for so called honour crimes. Though not a tenant of the Koran, female genitle mutilation is practiced only in Muslim countries, by Muslims. Stoning to death is practiced only in Muslim countries. These despicable practices have no place in a modern, liberal, secular society, or anywhere else in the 21st century. The religion that condones them is an abomination. People that commit these acts are savages.

    The sooner we wake up to that fact, stop being so politically correct and start saying what needs to be said, the better for us all., and that includes what the Israelis are doing to the Palestinians. We’re not being tolerant, nor accomodating. We’re being blind and stupid. Europe is slowly realizing what the danger is- and we better realize it as well.

    Fanaticism, superstition, tribal warfare and slaughter may have been fun and games in the sixth century. Now, with nuclear weapons, they threaten our very survival. The lunatics that fly planes into buildings, or drop bombs on wedding parties after first having morning prayers, and the born again hordes that look forward with glee to the nuclear annilation of millions so their so called saviour can return, are all to blame.

    As some wit once said, the world won’t be free till the last king is strangled with the entrails of the last priest..

    • spezza4life

      Really loving the dialogue on this comments board. Don't understand how Africans can practice a religion handed down to them through slavery and bondage.

  • Rob H

    Moderate Islam? Where is moderate in the Islamic countries of the world where most of the world's Muslims live? Iran, Iraq, Indonesia, Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, Somalia, Sudan, Egypt? Everyone of these countries restricts the rights of women, tolerates honour killings of women, doesn't allow other religions to preach freely, build places of worship, does not give equal treatment under Sharia to non muslims and on an on. Where is this moderate Islam?

  • The Truth

    Please disregard the spell/grammar. Was typing fast.

  • kia

    do any of you have any morals or ethics to ban a holy book is fuleing the fire between the division of islam and the media. i am muslim living in canada and i have never seen such excuse my for my language such assholes. The islam that is shown in the media is not what islam is and will never be and when your speaking about banning a holy book who dont we go ahead and ban the bible and the torrah .We allow this we are allowing a fundamental freedom that many countries strive towards. Does anybody want to go back into a secular time where the only relgion and true force was the church that atheist, muslim or jews were allowed. NO one does and the ISLAM the word is arabic for peace so before you utter such disgusting ideas like banning a religion you should do some research !!!!

  • BARRY GREENWAY

    WHEN IS AUSTRALIA GOING TO UNCOVER A POLITICAL SAVIOUR SUCH AS GEERT WILDERS..WE HAVE NO POLITICAL PARTY OR LEADERS WITH THE COURAGE OR BACKBONE SUCH AS THIS MAN…

  • REALITY IN OUR TIME

    THE MUSLIMS ARE ON THE MARCH TO DESTROY WESTERN VALUES AND RELIGION,IF YOU DONT BELIEVE OR ACCEPT THAT FACT,THEN ITS ABOUT TIME YOU CHECKED OUT WHATS HAPPENING IN THE WORLD..WAKE UP YOU SLEEPERS…WHILE YOU HAVE PRECIOUS TIME LEFT…

    • Guest

      Actually the Masons, illuminati are out to detroy everything.
      Read you dumb son-of-a-criminal Aussie. HAHA

  • Guest

    Holland is low-land right?
    Sodom was buried underneath the the Dead Sea.
    This modern day Sodom, quite literally, will also face the same fate.
    Burn Theo burn. Shame on you Ms.Ali, for bowing to the white man who will use and abuse you, then shall you be discarded.
    Try as you will, the banner of Islam will be raised in Europe, but by
    the right minded white people, not as much through immigration, as you suggest. We don't need to fight you at all, our way is superior…watch all the conversions worldwide on "YouTube".
    Mr. Wilders', fear God, you blaspheme Him, then how can anyone help you?

  • Guest

    Oh angry white people. Yes, your men are impotent. Yes your women
    infertile. Yes, Christians, LOL, you are killing your own babies, hence your own future. If you're feeling less-than, work on yourselves, don't
    try to tear others down.
    You are enraged, and feeling very inferior. This is why you resort to such low-minded tactics.
    You see us, people of colour, and you see us excelling in school, buying nicer homes than you, having stronger family structures, and you can't stand it. I love it. You conquered and robbed with violence, acts for which those perpatrators are now burning in the lake of fire.
    Guess what? You invited us all here. We used our minds, and have gone further than you can stomach.
    Karma, no?

From Macleans