Beyond The Commons

Beyond The Commons

Aaron Wherry covers all the goings-on in and around Parliament Hill. Follow Aaron on Twitter: @aaronwherry

'All kinds of things are going on'

by Aaron Wherry on Wednesday, December 2, 2009 6:39pm - 28 Comments

The Canadian Press gets a look at several uncensored documents.

The International Red Cross met twice with senior Canadian officials in Kandahar to deliver veiled but insistent warnings about torture in Afghan jails a year before Canada acted to protect detainees.

Details of the face-to-face meetings in 2006, outlined in uncensored memos examined by The Canadian Press, undermine the federal government’s claims that diplomat Richard Colvin was a lone voice raising vague concerns about torture.

The Red Cross is prevented by international rules from using the term “torture” and from commenting on one country’s behaviour to another. But the risks were so dire that detainees might be tortured in Afghan jails that the agency felt compelled to alert senior Canadian diplomats and officers in person, say memos made available on a confidential basis to The Canadian Press.

Some of this would seem to be referenced in KANDH-0032, which is found in its redacted form in today’s release at page 126.

Bookmark and Share
  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Style Style

    It's not news that there was torture in Afghan jails in 2006 and that governments knew about it – that fact was well-known all along. The Government has said that it had no evidence that specific Canadian detainees were tortured.

    Journalists can keep reading Colvin's memos, but I would like to see the issue put in its proper context – Canada and our allies chose, in 2005, to transfer detainees to Afghan prisons, knowing that torture was prevalent. What were the alternatives and why was this choice made? Maybe that will damn the Liberals too, maybe it's just a vital part of the discussion about our role in Afghanistan.

From Macleans