Our Afghan M*A*S*H unit

In Kandahar, our docs are saving lives and making friends

by Jinder Oujla-Chalmers on Tuesday, January 19, 2010 4:00pm - 4 Comments

D uring my stay on the base in Kandahar, I spend time with the Afghan cultural adviser for our troops, an Afghan-born intellectual whom I shall call Hamid for the sake of his security. He says there is a misconception in the West that all the suicide bombers and Taliban members are Afghans. But, he explains, “two years ago, the Pashtuns didn’t even have a word in their vocabulary for suicide bombers. The bad guys are from everywhere, from Saudi Arabia, Iran, India, Pakistan and other Arab countries. The Taliban recruit not just Afghans, but young boys and men who have no education and no hope for a future.”

The following week, Hamid introduces me to local women. They express admiration and respect for our military personnel. Among them is Saghna, a slim, brave girl who just turned 20. She had been running an underground radio station in Kandahar city for two years in the hopes of educating Afghan women on basic health issues. As a result, she has been shot twice, and abducted. She quietly tells me about the day not that long ago when her neighbour turned her in to local Taliban insurgents, who threatened to kill her for her efforts to educate other women. Miraculously, she escaped.

Saghna is the breadwinner of her family. She knows little English and never had the opportunity to go to college or high school. She and her family are under the protection of our armed forces in Kandahar, after having to flee their homes five times. “The happiest day of my life was when the Canadian Forces stepped in last year and offered me and my family protection,” Saghna says, smiling. “They helped by moving us closer to the base so that my brothers and sisters could go to school safely.”

Before I leave Saghna, she says, “If the coalition forces leave our country, my people would have no hope.” She hugs me and offers me the gift of a shawl. I try to pay for our interview so that she could feed her family, but she refuses to accept the money. Instead, she says, “Just by talking to me you have done more than enough.”

When you consider all the nationalities taking part in the Afghan mission, it speaks volumes that Canadian Forces personnel and civilians are, to my mind, the most liked by the locals. But helping our troops comes at a price.

I spend a great deal of time with the Afghan interpreters who work at the hospital. They are initially surprised to see a brown-skinned, Indo-Canadian woman in their presence, and stare at me, unsure of my place there. When I smile at them, the three young men blush and turn their heads away. Then one of them looks back at me and smiles as well.

After they lose their inhibition they talk to me. They say they face extraordinary personal risks in supporting our troops and aid workers. They also say they feel betrayed by the Canadian government, which promised that they would be allowed to immigrate to Canada and is now reneging. (As of early December, none of the interpreters had been allowed into Canada, eight months after Immigration Minister Jason Kenney announced the policy.) They feel that somehow because I am “brown” I can help them, and insist that I personally speak to Prime Minister Stephen Harper and tell him how their families’ lives are threatened daily by the insurgents because they work at the hospital.

In spite of such complaints, during the course of my stay I become converted from someone opposed to the Afghan war to one who supports our troops being there. But our federal government has reiterated its position that Canadian Forces, who have assumed even more dangerous duties in the vital district of Arghandab, north of Kandahar city, will end the combat mission by 2011. I believe we should stay longer. While Afghanistan remains a country beset by bloodshed and corruption, after three decades of chaos the Afghan people deserve to have peace, the basic human rights that we take for granted in the West, and a functioning, honest government. As the furor over fraud during the August presidential election has shown, achieving those aims will be a tough battle, but one that must be fought. It is nowhere near time for Canada to abandon Afghanistan.

Bookmark and Share
  • J. Maclean

    “I have just arrived to spend three weeks doing research for a TV drama series, as the guest of the Canadian Forces.”

    Is the military now getting involved in TV drama production? How much Canadian taxpayer money did the military spend to host this TV show producer for three weeks?

    If she spent all her time on the base as a guest of the military, and talked only to Afghans on or near the base, people that associate closely with or work for the military, then she spoke specifically with people that have a very strong vested interest in the Western military presence continuing.

    According to a news article in September, her next step in pushing her show, entitled “Combat Hospital”, was to obtain financing for what she estimated at $1.2 million to $1.5 million per episode. So does she possibly have a significant vested financial interest in Canada remaining in the war in Afghanistan? Is this TV show her ticket to the big times?

    She wrote that “many” Canadians oppose the war, instead of saying “most”, downplaying the fact that the majority of Canadians oppose the war, not just in the one most recent poll, but repeatedly in poll after poll for the past few years.

    • Guest

      James Cameron has managed to generate over $1 billion in worldwide revenue with a film, Avatar, that condemns the military and presents a viewpoint similar to your own; a task which Mr. Cameron could not have accomplished without the deep pockets of a capitalist somewhere; a capitalist being one who puts up capital with the expectation of a favorable return on that investment.

      Surely, in the interests of debate and free speech, you would not presume to hinder an individual from presenting a different view of the world, nor would you presume to hinder a capitalist from putting up capital with the expectation of a favorable return on that investment.

      Furthermore, in the interests of debate and free speech, do you not think that, even as the majority of Canadians favor withdrawal from Afghanistan, it might be in the public's interest to see the viewpoint of the soldiers themselves, rather than assume that the perspective of the majority of Canadians is all that is of interest.

      Finally, in presenting the soldier's perspective of the morals and ethics behind their roles, it may come to light that there is in fact no conspiracy behind their motives, nor in the motives of the writer of this article, nor in the motives of the capitalist that would fund such a venture, which would unfortunately put a deep gash in the hosiery of conspiracy that you seem to have no problem tarting yourself up with, and provide people like myself with a dollop of amusement; a dollop to uncover a trollop as it were.

  • http://www.newsgates.com Lisa

    That sure is a mind blowing news.

  • http://www.matthewbproman.com/ John Proman

    Great Article. I like the fact that they help keep Taliban members live too. It just shows that they are both human.

From Macleans