Inkless Wells

Inkless Wells

Paul Wells on all the latest out of Ottawa—along with the occasional post about jazz. Follow Paul on Twitter: @InklessPW

Voice of Geddes

by Paul Wells on Thursday, January 21, 2010 10:05am - 17 Comments

Our Ottawa bureau chief is a renaissance man, is what he is. One day he came into the office and showed us the publisher’s cover design for his novel. What, Geddes was writing a novel? News to us. And then it turned out to be a really good novel, which is not the way most novels turn out.

Most days he comes in and talks to me about Angela Hewitt or Bill Charlap, or to Wherry about Cooperstown, or to Petrou about military doctrine. Each of us thinks we’re pretty smart, but usually we wind up listening to Geddes talk circles around us on our own chosen topics. Partly that’s because he’s quite a talker. But it’s also because he knows about a lot of things, he’s always curious, and he’s always thinking about how one thing connects to something else.

He brings all these qualities to his journalism, which is usually about federal politics. But sometimes he gets to indulge his other interests. He’s the visual-arts man in our bureau, for instance, and here’s a lovely piece from last week’s issue about the Voice of Fire controversy, which was 20 years ago, my how time flies. You remember Voice of Fire. It’s the Barnett Newman painting that looked like this and cost a lot of money and provoked a nation-wide debate about the nature of art. John’s piece reminds us what the fuss was about, and revisits some of the protagonists.  I enjoyed reading it and I’ve been waiting for it to pop up on the website so I could pass it along, in case you missed it in the print edition.

Half the fun of working at this magazine is finding out every week which one of my colleagues is going to be swinging for the fences. Most weeks it’s someone different from the week before. Anyway, go read John’s piece.

Bookmark and Share
  • http://intensedebate.com/people/jolyon jolyon

    I don't often agree with Geddes but I find he always makes a good argument, at least.

    I occasionally see Geddes on CPAC program on Friday nights, forget what it's called, and I wonder why he does not appear on more mainstream programs because he's one of the more thoughtful journos.

  • Kevin

    Thanks for the link, PW. Excellent article.

  • Anon001

    But will the Voice of Fire survive the Axe of Day?

  • Dot

    It's nice to see that the controversy from 20 years ago is over, and that the gallery is no longer hanging it upside down as a sign of protest.

    • Loraine Lamontagne

      Very funny!

      I recall siding with the purchase of the piece. I have seen it, don't like it much, but that's OK as I am happy to read that other people love it.

      I just wish we could get the collection of the National Portrait Gallery out of some basement and in the open for all Canadians to appreciate – or not.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/jandrewpotter andrew potter

    First time I was at the Geddes residence, I was sat in a chair next to a short little bookshelf. It was full of lots of Canlit, the kind of writing I mostly hate. So I started playing mock the stock, until John walked over, all earnest and polite, and said "Have you ever read the polish poet Wislawa Szymborska? She won the nobel prize in 1996." He pulled out a book, and read me this:

    BODYBUILDER'S CONTEST

    From scalp to sole, all muscles in slow motion.
    The ocean of his torso drips with lotion.
    The king of all is he who preens and wrestles
    with sinews twisted into monstrous pretzels.

    Onstage, he grapples with a grizzly bear
    the deadlier for not really being there.
    Three unseen panthers are in turn laid low,
    each with one smoothly choreographed blow.

    He grunts while showing his poses and paces.
    His back alone has twenty different faces.
    The mammouth fist he raises as he wins
    is tribute to the force of vitamins

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/novagardener novagardener

      I love Piet Hein's Grooks. I have them in my bathroom.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/novagardener novagardener

    Wasn't there another piece that the art gallery purchased – almost a blank canvass – that caused protests as well. My memory is poor, so maybe this is the one. The current art gallery is so much better than the old one. A friend who used to work at the new gallery gave us a tour years ago., A niece is doing her Masters at Carleton (SHIRK grant) and spends part of her week the NAG. Her area of interest is a particular Aboriginal Artist who died a year or 2 ago. Damn, can't recall his name. Thoughts anyone.

    • Non-partisan

      Small correction – you mean SSHRC (Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council). Unless you were making a subtle joke about the granting institution.

      And the artists in question is likely Morrisseau, as novagardener indicates.

      • http://intensedebate.com/people/novagardener novagardener

        LOL. I can never remember the name and just think of it as SHIRK. No, it wasn't meant as a joke! I rec'd a quiz – sort of a joke from a friend the other day – which I actually passed – confirming that I didn't have alzheimers :-) Just an f'n lousy memory. And yes, it's Morrisseau.

    • CAPS
      • http://intensedebate.com/people/novagardener novagardener

        Thanks. That's the artist.

  • Non-partisan

    "…he’s always thinking about how one thing connects to something else."

    That is the essence of intelligence.

  • Lynda

    My favourite Voice of Fire anecdote was the prairie farmer who painted his barn like the piece and offered to sell it to the National Gallery for $1.8 million. Such a brilliant post-modern gesture!

    • MikeB

      That anecdote is in the article!
      I read it on the subway the other day, and really enjoyed it. I didn't realize John Geddes wrote it. Good stuff!

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Tridus Tridus

    This was a great article. I still sit there thinking "they paid HOW much for that?"

  • Nullan

    http://www.morrisseau.com – about that artist.

From Macleans