Death raises questions about luge track, Canadian competitiveness

Athletes feel like ‘lemmings’ thrown down ‘exceedingly dangerous’ course

by Nancy Macdonald on Friday, February 12, 2010 4:21pm - 72 Comments

A collective cry went out at the Main Media Centre this morning when video featuring the horrific crash of Georgian luger, Nodar Kumaritashvili was broadcast into the main hall. The 21-year-old racer died at the Whistler Sliding Centre — following his second crash in just two days. His death cast an immediate pall over Vancouver, where the opening ceremonies are set to begin in just two hours.

Both International Olympic Committee president Jacques Rogge and John Furlong, chief executive of the Vancouver Organizing Committee addressed reporters this afternoon. Both donned black suits and black ties and appeared visibly shaken by the day’s event.

“This is a very sad day,” said Rogge. “The IOC is in deep mourning. Here you have a young athlete who lost his life pursuing his passion.”

“We are heartbroken beyond words,” said Furlong. “The accident is tragic. It will be investigated and when we know the results you will be informed.”

Even before the accident, questions about the “exceedingly dangerous,” 1,450-m-long course — the fastest on earth — were being raised. The top speed reached at the track at Fitzsimmon’s Creek, on Blackcomb Mountain is 153.93 kph. Kumaritashvili was believed to have been travelling at 143.3 kph.

In training runs Thursday, both Guntis Rekis of Latvia and Stefan Hoehner of Germany had high-speed crashes. “My goals are to stay alive, not break bones,” Rekis told reporters. “I was scared a bit.”

“I think they are pushing it a little too much,” Australia’s Hannah Campbell-Pegg said Thursday night after she nearly lost control in training. “To what extent are we just little lemmings that they just throw down a track and we’re crash-test dummies? I mean, this is our lives.”

“I’ve never slid that fast,” Maya Pedersen, a Swiss gold-medallist told Maclean’s last February.

Although both the international luge and bobsleigh federations declared the track safe and Games-ready a year ago, the International Luge Federation (FIL) president Josef Fendt of Germany told reporters that the sporting body wanted less-experienced, and less-talented lugers to have more training time at the WSC prior to the Vancouver Games. Fendt also said the protective devices near the track’s curb were too short, and needed to be lengthened so athletes were protected from flying from the track.

Questions will likely also be raised about Canada’s aggressive pursuit of the home ice advantage in Vancouver and Whistler.

Earlier this week, Andy Schmid, the performance director of British Skeleton called the Canadian decision to limit practice time for overseas competitors (compared to the more than 300 runs set aside for Canadian athletes) as irresponsible. “Please, let there be no accidents there because that could kill the sport,” he told Britain’s Telegraph.

“People have the argument that it’s just home advantage and that’s normal for an Olympic host country, but it’s different for sports involving high speed. Can you imagine in Formula One nobody being allowed on a track because somebody has home advantage?”

No one yet knows how the crash will affect tonight’s Opening Ceremonies at BC Place, or the luge event itself, set to begin Saturday, with the men’s singles. Luge training at Whistler has been suspended.

Bookmark and Share
  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Scott_Tribe Scott_Tribe

    I'm reading in some reports that this is the 1st death at a Winter Olympics event (ok, so it was pre-Olympics training, if you want to get technical).

    Not exactly a great way to start off the Games.

    • Warren

      YIKES!!!! look at the pictures…there is no screen to protect the competitors from hitting the columns…NASCAR learned this lesson back in the 60's……… even the wood trim boards on either side of the track are blunt enough to split a head open at 100mph…….common sense…not so common.

    • Falconcr

      This is not the first death in a Winter Olympics, just the first since 1992.

  • VanGirl

    "This isn’t the first time a competitor has died at the Games. At Lake Placid, Sergio Zardini, who was competing for Canada, died in a training run. At the 64 Innsbruck Games, Australian alpine skier Ross Milne and British luge slider Kazimierz Kay-Skrzypeski both died during training prior to the Games."

    Did you read the whole story?

    • janet s

      Actually the story is wrong. Zardini did not die at the Lake Placid Olympics. He died in 1966 at a competition held at Lake Placid but not the Olympics which were held that year.

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/Scott_Tribe Scott_Tribe

      Seems we're both not reading:

      Olympic historian David Wallechinsky told the New York Times on Wednesday that there have been no deaths during official Winter Olympics competitions

      http://www2.macleans.ca/2010/02/12/georgian-luger…

      I'm technically wrong in that this was a pre-training event where it happened… and that report you're quoting me is erroneous as well, since those deaths mentioned were also pre-training Olympics.

      Regardless.. it's still horrible.. and it's still irresponsible if we limited track access to this course.

  • Jen

    Seriously people…Canada is not out to get anyone hurt or stop them from practicing there given sport. I think printing that is just a stab and an attempt to put a nasty spin on an already terrible accident and death that occured today!

    • John D

      We clearly are stopping people from practicing their chosen sport.

    • Andrew

      Welcome to the media. Anything for a headline.

  • Tim

    So sad and such a young man. All thoughts and prayers are with the family, friends and Country.

    This is not the first athlete to die during an Olympic competition or training session. In 1912, Portuguese marathon runner Francisco Lazaro, 21, collapsed from sunstroke and heart trouble and died the next day.

    In 1960, Danish cyclist Knut Jensen died during the Olympic road race as a result of ingesting amphetamines and nicotinyl tartrate which were alleged to be performance enhancers.

    The 1983 Summer Universiade in Edmonton was marred by tragedy when Soviet diver Sergei Chalibashvili died eight days after hitting his head on the platform while attempting a reverse 3 1/2 in competition.

    In the 1964 Innsbruck Winter Games, Australian alpine skier Ross Milne and British luger Kazimierz Kay-Skrzypeski both died as a resulting of training crashes

  • Charlie In the US

    The lack of training opportunities for athletes from other countries due to the in-your-face-sounding 'Own The Podium' program made me mad when I first heard of it. It DOES NOT sound like something done in the Olympic spirit!

    I am now livid. What a dangerous, selfish decision. Boo Canada.

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/rp_ rp_

      I agree. How is this welcoming the world? Come to our Olympics but we'll restrict your practice sessions to 10% of ours, so we can maybe beat you and boast? When did this country get so pathetically insecure?

  • Maureen

    I guess the writer would have Canadians go back to the good old days when we were thrilled to get 4th place or be in the top 10. What nonsense – if you are in it, you are in it to win or go home!

  • janet s.

    sorry, 'which were not held that year'.

  • Kelly in CANADA

    Why are you taking this tragedy and turning it into an opportunity to bash Canadian patriotism. Charlie in the US I think your country has long been the number one in-your-face patriotic country on earth. Your countless wars prove this.

    • Olympic crash

      And now that the shoe is on the other foot patriotism is ok? They knew the track was dangerous and they deliberately limited everyone else's practice time to 10% of the "patriotic" canadians. People like you spend your lives criticizing everyone else but can't take it when you receive well-deserved criticism. Well, you won some medals tonight on your track – I hope it was worth it for you. Enjoy it because I can't believe the IOC or any other serious international sporting federation would allow you guys to organize a bake sale after this abortion of an olympics.

  • Canadian Citizen

    Boo Canada??? It was an awful accident and many many Canadians are in shock and feel terrible about the death of such a young and talented young athlete. Don't bash a country or its citizens for the decision of a few. Our sincerest sympathies to the athlete's family, teammates and fellow competitors.

  • ballylama

    Training restrictions started January 1 of this year whereby only Canada and Developing Nations had access. Otherwise training was accessible up until Dec. 31. This type of training restriction occurs for host countries frequently. regardless, this is a brutal crash and peoples concern about the track should have been considered along the way.

    • Guest

      AND the Luge World Cup was at that track last year.

      But hey, I guess no one was allowed on the track except Canadians right? So we must have gotten Gold, SIlver, and Bronze in that event.
      I feel terrible for the family of the young man. And my heart goes out to them. But the knee jerk reaction to blame Canada is beyond pale and completely tasteless.

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/rp_ rp_

      Canada shouldn't have extra time! We live here! The track has been open for more than a year!

  • Jen

    Let's also find out how many times this luge track has been tested by all athletes before making a decision…do you think he was the first to go out on the track….use your head before blaming all Canadians for something that is an ACCIDENT…look up the meaning of the word! This is a tragedy and people are taking away from that with there antics!

  • John D

    Who are all these idiots coming out of the woodwork to yell OMG GO CANADA, YAY PATRIOTISM! A man has died and it is quite possibly our fault. Who cares how many golds we get if we are indeed complicit in this?

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/rp_ rp_

      I don't know, but I'll give it 48 hours before the local media starts blaming the guy who died. CTV apparently ran the video of the crash over and over while filling the air with their inane comments. Way to go guys! Any idiot could have deduced that hitting a metal pole at 140km/h is fatal. I think they're so stupid they don't even realize how horrible they are.

    • NVan girl

      This has nothing to do with patriotism, or psycho nationalism. A young man had died in a horrific crash. Investigations need to be made, adjustments made and responsibility taken. What we should be focusing on is how to prevent this from here on out. Stop blaming Canadian rules about practice times, poor Canadian sportsmanship and other nonsense. Canadians and citizens of the world are mourning the loss. This should not be a time to villainize or valourize Canadians. It's a time for reflection and action.

      • Golden girl

        Finally…someone who has made a valid point…..with a clear decision on what needs to happen immediatly. We can do all the finger pointing after. Fix the problem so no one else dies. My heart goes out to the familly and teammates of this beautiful young athlete.

        • Dr Glynn Wright

          When my children were young we specifically travelled from Britain to the West Coast of Canada because, above all other skiing and snowboarding venues, Canadians were concerned with the safety of young people. We admired, and stil admire you, for your values and realisation of what is important in life.

          This is a shocking tragedy that could have easily been avoided.The design of the track is defective, I have no doubt that Canadians will act quickly to protect the lives of the other young people in the coming days, this is far more important than who eventually wins a medal.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/rp_ rp_

    Also, a lot of people seemed to think this course was a death trap. The sporting officials signed off on it, but it's our responsibility too. There's no need to make a course that's so unforgiving. Simple slip ups should not send people flying to their deaths. Why wasn't there plexiglass or something covering those beams?! Serious injuries were plausible in any case at those speeds – the sport is dangerous – but it's hard to look at that setup and not think that much more could have been done. Why weren't the concerns raised by the experienced people addressed?

  • Ceeger

    The thing about lemmings, is that they willingly go over cliffs themselves. No one throws them. Hannah Campbell-Pegg is guilty of a very mixed metaphor.

    In regards to the Macleans headline, ''Death raises questions about luge track, Canadian competitiveness', my response would be:

    Um, then don't hurtle down the track!

    That should answer those 'questions' raised about luge.

  • Gman

    Terrible accident
    Athlete was ranked last of all 2008-09 world cup participants
    Limiting practice time for other than host countries common practice.
    Track is too fast, but approved by both body's
    Part of the draw for this "crazy sport"
    Bless him and his family
    The games go on.

  • warset

    tbh, i've seen luge courses in the past and crashes before
    but this course just seems too over the top
    its too hard and too fast and with too little protection
    i really think it needs modifcation for safty
    who cares about "setting new world record" for faster speed on an over the top difficult course like this when players are all dead…

  • Mike Stokes

    Blame Harper and the dirty COC.. You know it's coming from Iggy any moment know.

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/frenchie101 frenchie101

      I dont like Iggy, but I dont think he's that crass.

    • Surrey guy

      You partisan hack, we're talking about someone loosing their life and all you can do is take pot-shots at the Conservatives. Let me remind you that they had absolutely nothing to do with the design, or implementation of the luge track in question… hence your red herring.

      Off Topic and Poor Taste – take it somewhere else.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/TorontoGuy2010 TorontoGuy2010

    I don't think it's unpatriotic to question bad policy.

    If organizers limited training runs for international competitors in a dangerous sport to try to give Canadians an upper hand, and that leads to dangerous conditions for international competitors, we should review it and not be blindly patriotic.

    People have been crashing on this track all week. Other people were airlifted to hospital. This wasn't taken as a clue that maybe they needed to slow the course down for safety reasons?

    duh.

    • hosertohoosier

      As I see it the bad policy was the unsafe track not the limited practice time, which is standard for host teams in the Olympics. Indeed if that track is unsafe, as seems to be the case, nobody was at higher risk than our own athletes. Building an unsafe track is something nobody can defend.

  • DukeLaw

    As an American, it's moronic for the US to worry about the medal count and it's sad that the Canadians have adopted the same philosophy. I usually want my countrymen to reflect Canadian values instead of vice versa.

    Limiting practice runs when the governing body of your sport has explicitly asked permission for the less talented sliders to get more time is a HUGE factor in this accident. Don't be disingenuous to suggest it isn't. Sad day for the sport.

  • Paul

    I think it is easy to point fingers now and quote athletes who recently declared the track fast and scary. But I recall the same types of quotes from athletes in past Olympics. And I recall some pretty spectacular crashes too. These add to the excitement of the sport. As do claims that "this is the fastest track yet". They always are. This sport is designed to be extremely dangerous such that the best trained athletes in the world manage to hang on only by the skin of their teeth. I agree that this is a tragic accident, and I feel for this young athlete's friends and family. But I do not agree with statements above which lay blame like those made by "Blue Collar". Please keep the accusative fingers firmly tucked away. They do no good. Nodar is not the first luger to lose his life to his sport, and he will probably not be the last. I am sure that Nodar would want not just the games, but specifically the luge event to proceed as planned.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/hardmouth hardmouth

    Wow, I can't believe they limited practice runs for such a dangerous sport!? That's totally irresponsible…. I can't believe believe my country would risk people's lives just to get some stupid medals. This is so un-Canadian and not sportsmanlike at all. Maybe once we win a gold everyone will relax a bit and we can ditch this terrible attitude.

    Good luck team Canada. Win or lose you guys are national heros!

  • Shaun

    he should have been proud of himself: he died at 143 k mph. But it is so sad RIP.

  • Stunned Onlooker

    Canadians need to stop this event until it gets cleared for safety to the highest degree. This track and especially that video evidence of Nodar Kumaritashvili's crash, may he rest in peace, looks like it was an accident waiting to happen. The responsible thing by the IOCommittee is to make sure another accident does not happen.

  • Dad

    the fastest track ever. Maybe a bit too fast?

    It's obvious from the comments in the article that the luge federation had some concerns about the track. What a sad waste. And if it comes to light that this is in any way caused by foreign competitors not getting sufficient training time Canada will have yet one more international shame to add to the growing list.

  • http://theplaceofbiff.blogspot.com biff

    Sadly,

    those on this blog who took every opportunity to pour cold water on the Olympics (for mainly partisan reasons) over the last few weeks,

    have/will jump all over this tragedy for partisan gamesmanship.

    What did Rahm Emannual the consumate reactionary leftist say 'never let a good crisis go to waste'.

    Despicable.

From Macleans