John Geddes

John Geddes

John Geddes writes on politics and policy, with occasional reporting and comment on arts and culture.

Here's hoping Danny Williams got Canadian-style heart surgery

by John Geddes on Monday, February 22, 2010 8:28pm - 80 Comments

Newfoundland Premier Danny Williams has finally done an interview discussing his decision to go to the U.S. for heart surgery. You’ll recall that critics of public health insurance on both sides of the border pounced on this high-profile case of medical tourism as evidence that the Canadian system is hopelessly second-rate.

But wait a minute. I see that Williams says his problem was with his mitral valve. Now, I’m no expert, but I seem to remember reading something recently about that particular part of the old ticker.

Oh, yes, here it is: a news release from Dec. 3, 2009, announcing that the prestigious New England Journal of Medicine had just published a feature article on the latest techniques for reconstructing the valve, which separates the heart’s two chambers so blood flows during a normal beat.

Maybe you’re guessing now that the premier decided to travel to the famous hospital where one of the physicians who authored the article fixes hearts. That would make sense. But here’s the funny thing: the authors are Dr. Thierry Mesana of the University of Ottawa Heart Institute and Dr. Subodh Verma of St. Michael’s Hospital at University of Toronto.

Apparently Ottawa and Toronto have somehow managed to emerge as leading centres for both the theory and practice of heart surgery—in particular, it seems, the operation Williams needed—despite the horrors of socialized medicine.

In case this leaves you fearing that the the premier might have received substandard care in the U.S., please don’t worry. I understand  they have excellent physicians there. And that New England Journal of Medicine article is specifically meant to spread the word of the latest surgical techniques everywhere.

Bookmark and Share
  • Ann

    Folks, the bottom line is that one's ability to access timely and quality health care is directly proportional to one's wealth. Thus, one's wealth in our society is the measure of a man. Pretty gauling, as we have plenty of unmonied types who contribute much to the quality of those who live among them, but because they lack deep pockets, they must languish whilst waiting for procedures they desperately need. Let THEM eat cake! What makes Danny's case more gauling is that as premier, he reigns over healthcare in his province. Thus, what he's saying is that he thinks his province's healthcare system works well enough for his subjects; it just doesn't measure up for himself. Now THAT's sick!

  • http://www.legalclassaction.org/ oasamax lawsuit

    wow interesting post. I had no idea that those doctors went to school in canada.
    plastic surgery in Texas

  • http://www.mybodybuildingcoupons.com/ body supplements

    It is a very interesting debate health care that is. Well unless everyone starts bickering over it like at my family gatherings boo. I know that in Canada it is available to all citizens but not all services are offered in every providence. Canadians often come down here to the us for specialized services. Its a win/lose in both situations.

  • http://www.mybodybuildingcoupons.com/ body supplements

    can you say hypocrite? lol splendid post funny too keep it up :-)

  • http://www.samui-villas.biz Koh Samui Villas

    I agree it is hypocritical and funny at the same. Time i'd say more ironic that someone of that stature from Canada has to come down to the US for surgery.

  • http://www.couponfan.com/coupons/ebags.com Ebags Coupon
  • http://www.couponfan.com/coupons/ebags.com Ebags Coupon
  • http://www.couponfan.com/coupons/ebags.com Ebags Coupon
  • http://www.geniemove.com/ Chicago movers

    Tim i really agree with you. "if Obamacare was ever passed here in the states, it would be the same: Only the rich would be able to go to the front of the line."

  • http://www.everlastwelders.ca/ Plasma Cutters

    a news release from Dec. 3, 2009, announcing that the prestigious New England Journal of Medicine had just published a feature article on the latest techniques for reconstructing the valve, which separates the heart’s two chambers so blood flows during a normal beat.

    Very pleased to see the below info.

  • Josha Tanyard

    The thing with heart surgeries these days is that the recovery is so intense. You often need a myriad of vitamins and supplements to help you get on track. Not only are you losing money since you aren't working while recovering, you often spend an arm and a leg on supplements, vitamins, and minerals. I always recommend to shop online for these types of purchases. I like to go to Bodybuilding.com, and I always use these Bodybuilding.com coupons to help save on my purchase. Supplements for my heart and blood pressure are all purchased online using coupon codes and I couldn't be happier and healthier because of it! Gotta love online shopping ;)

  • http://www.coupongravy.com Tom

    Wow that's pretty insane. Way to represent Canada Mr. Premier!

  • http://www.coupongravy.com/site/bodybuilding.com Bodybuilding.com

    Pretty interesting. That's all I will say.

  • OnTheJob

    The existence of one (1) surgical procedure, out of tens of thousands of procedures, developed in Canada does not automagically constitute a robust defense of Canada's "health" "care" system, but rather seriously indicts the reason, or lack thereof, of the individual attempting to make such a claim. It's mathematically incorrect, and grotesquely so.

  • Joel

    expecting a statement to be automaticaly accepted as fact is… how do you say, but rather seriously indicts the reason, or lack thereof, of the individual attempting to make such a claim. It's mathematically incorrect, and grotesquely so.

From Macleans