Closing Ceremonies: The Live Blog

ANDREW COYNE with the minute-by-minute commentary, some of it respectful

by Andrew Coyne on Sunday, February 28, 2010 7:08pm - 144 Comments

As we wait for the closing ceremonies to start, CTV, for one, is anxious to show you that they are very mindful of the bilingual character of Canada, via a two-handed rendition of I Believe….

And we’re off.

Cool: don’t hide the opening ceremonies malfunction: celebrate it. Takes moxy to make fun of yourself. And Catriona gets to light the flame already.

And Catriona descends into the gates of hell…

It’s the march of the dancing white people! With, a band that looks a lot like Coldplay.

And now they’re moving into formation as .. a lot of people with snowboards. No, it’s Olympic Rings. No, it’s … well now they’ve broken it up again. As we go to commercial.

The Official Party! I was waiting for that to begin. Oh, they mean dignitaries. I see the native chiefs’ bus didn’t break down this time.

The Prime Minister in an Olympic team jacket. Some debate here whether it suits him. I say it’s slimming.

The anthem. Is there any country on earth, by the way, that breaks into the national anthem as spontaneously as Canadians? My theory? It’s easy to sing. It has a particularly beery quality to it, if you’ve noticed: that last chorus of O Canada seems almost made for slurring.

Joannie Rochette! The right choice, on balance, for Canada’s flagbearer. Yes, Charles Hamelin won two gold, but Joannie was … incomparable.

And the athletes parade in, en masse, all the nations of the earth mixed together.  So why is it all Americans? Oh here dcome the Germans, in their licorice Goodies outfits.

I have to say, all cynicism aside, when you see the athletes all together, the pressure of competition passed, you do start to believe in the whole Olympic ideal thing. They look so happy and relaxed, and you can imagine the friendships that have been formed. Right,, now back to the cynicism.

… Okay, I’ve just missed the last 10 minutes thanks to WordPress. But it was fine, wasn’t it? Lots of Canadians.  Melissa Hollingsworth looks quite nice when she’s not crying. And Jon Montgomery, looking decently sober.

Canadian musicians I’v e never heard of! It’s like a 1970s Juno Awards!

Is it just me, or is this the tune to Since You’ve Been Gone?

A salute to the volunteers. Seriously well-deserved. Everyone I know who had anything to do with them has universally positive experiences to report.

The Greek national anthem, on the other hand, you couldn’t really belt out in a bar. Unless you’re Greek, I suppose.

Ben Heppner rocks the Olympic anthem. Another moment of Canadian pride: if he were an alpine skier, he’d have nailed the downhill, oh, .34 seconds off the Austrian.

Mayor of Vancouver hands off the Olympic flag to Mayor of Sochi. Okay, you can let go of the flag now, Greg. Let go of the flag. Let – Greg! Ah, at last. International incident averted.

Russian anthem next. Turns out it’s still the Soviet anthem. As in: Greatest. Anthem. Ever.

You don’t belt this anthem out in a bar. You rent a concert hall.

I’m guessing the Latvians and Estoninans aren’t singing along, however.

Russian supermodels! Followed by wraithlike figures in glowing giant gel-like snowballs. Yes, the opening ceremonies in Sochi promise some advanced Russian weirdness.

Where ARE we? First we’re in Red Square, with a Russian orchestra, then we’re back in Vancouver, with the Russian ballet, nw we’re  in Sochi, figure-skating by the sea (which is a mega-cool idea.) Now we’re back in Vancouver again with a floating opera diva dressed like a butterfly. Which is actually an Italian idea, but who’s counting?

Which leads naturally to … Alexandr Ovechkin. And several small children. Question: Would you let your children near Ovechkin? I don’t mean he’d do anything improper or untoward. Just eat them.

Oh GOD NO: John Furlong speaking French!!! That’s Diefenbaker French. Worse. National unity set back 30 years.

Question: what’s worse? No French, or Furlong French? Moliere dying several more deaths.

Patriotism broke out across the country. Give ‘er!!!

“You are the wind beneath our wings.” Did he really say that? A Bette Midler song?

Score: Blue Jackets 1, Cypress weather 0. Mad cheers in the Whistler village for the volunteers.

Tribute to the deceased Georgian luger. Furlong’s Georgian is better than his French.

A big shout out to the concept of the “right to play.” But not, strangely, to Right to Play, the Canadian-based organization dedicated to promoting sporting opportunities for disadvantaged youth. They were shut out of the games, on account of an unfortunate choice of sponsors: Mitsubishi, rather than Games sponsor GM.

IOC chief Rogge speaking now. The Best Games Ever? “These were excellent, and very friendly games.” I think we’ve been dissed.

Neil Young. Looking remarkably like Jimmy Fallon, doing Neil Young. You know what would be cool? If he started doing an imitation of Fallon…

And Neil Young disappears into the bowels of the earth, where Catriona Lemay Doan had gone before.

Now its’s Canada Geese flying through a blizzard.  And from their midst comes… William Shatner! Okay, so this is the self-deprecating part of the ceremony. Waiting for him to do Lucy in the Sky With Diamonds.

“Canadians, with four beers inside them, can successfuly proounce Straits of Juan de Fuca, without being censored.” Seriously: is there ANY other country that could pull that off?

Catherine O’Hara. “Hurry hard.” Fuckin’ A! Oh lord, I’m about to be overtaken by an attack of Canadian pride. “Guests, like fish, start to stink after three days. When you pee your name in the snow, we know who you are. Canadians say sorry 10, 20 times a day and we’re sorry it’s not more. We’re sorry you thought Canada was one big frozen tundra.” I don’t know if the rest of the world is getting this, but my God she’s killing here.

Michael J. Fox with another oddly Canadian moment. “I know I’ve been living in L.A. for 30 years, but…”

Michael Bublé as a Mountie, singing the Maple Leaf Forever. It’s a great, great song — but isn’t it banned? “Wolfe the dauntless hero came?” Bloc MPs, to your microphones!

Leading into masses of dancing Mounties. This is getting seriously campy. Followed by hordes of hockey players who can’t skate. But no: it’s a giant game of table hockey! This whole ceremony is a giant in-joke. Outstanding.

Dancing maple leaves, followed by giant inflatable beavers, Disnelyand lumberjacks, bears, etc. I don’t think I’ve ever been so proud.

I’m serious: no other country could pull this off. No other country would even think to do it. You think the French have this kind of sense of humour about themselves? The British? The Germans?

OH GOD: Just when things are going so well, they bring out Nickelback. Cancel last half hour’s posts.

A colleague has a theory: Nickelback is still part of the whole self-deprecating thing. “The joke’s on them.” Uh, no: way too meta.

Avril: Is she meta, or meta-meta? Is she making fun of the whole concept of making fun of yourself?

Alanis!?!? Of course, the thing you have to realize is, half these athletes are 19-year-olds from Eastern Europe. They’re probably only getting Alanis records now.

All these cool Canadian bands – Arcade Fire, High Dials, Hot Hot Heat — that we’re never going to hear.

Simple Plan, doing Nickelback? Am I right? There’s self-depreating, and then there’s just lame… squared. Oh God, make it end. Next we’ll have Paul Anka doing Simple Plan doing Shania doing Avril doing Trooper doing…

Now, from Toronto: K-OS! Nothing says street cred like fame American rap! Not to mention Canadiana…

That’s it? That’s the end? Bad rap, acid-wash jeans, and giant purple spheres? This is a joke, right?

Bookmark and Share
  • mark

    Martha Av was signing live, the rest were not. I can not understand why we have to listen to pre recorded tunes and artists that lip to the music. Poor.

  • doug

    can't believe how negative the comments are. while it's unfortunate that they picked a lineup of such relentless mediocrity for the concert part, the first half is still going down as the stuff of legend.

  • Mark

    Whoops i mean singing…….

  • buddy alec d

    No men's hockey players at the closing ceremony – pathetic. R they too good for it?

    • Katherine

      I'm going with "exhausted and busy celebrating". And after a game like that, I can't blame them. I'm sure there's a lot of things they'd prefer to a mediocre concert.

      • http://intensedebate.com/people/OntarioTown OntarioTown

        I thought some had to leave town soon to get back to their day jobs – they have money paying commitments.

      • Jan

        They had a private dinner.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Gaunilon Gaunilon

    Things started to go wonky when Furlong sallied into French. Honestly when he came out with "Merci bien" I thought he said "messy BM"…yes, yes, I nodded thoughtfully, BM is messy, wait … what?

    But it definitely got better when the sexy Mounties came out. That was nearly the highlight, topped only by the airborne moose on ecstasy. Those were truly sublime.

    Got lamer after that, but the happy memories of sexy female mounties prancing under floating euphoric moose-balloons carried me through the rest of the show.

  • Tackytacky

    OMG Andrew you describe my feelings exactly as I watched this big joke go flat. The closing ceremonies felt like watching an accident about to happen that you can't stop. I wished they had quit at Neil Young instead of erasing all those good feelings that surprised everyone over the last 17 days.

    • Doobsey

      Again, the stick in your butt, get it out or go away.

  • Peter

    "NBC"? What is NBC?

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/madeyoulook madeyoulook

    I am now listening to Mr Furlong butcher one of Canada's official languages for a second time, the replay is on in the background.

    I think you're right. This had to have been an up-yours message to those who complained about the lack of French in the opening ceremony. He HAD to know it was awful during rehearsal. And he went ahead with it anyways? Yeesh.

    But I will not let that diminish the success of these Games, and the well-deserved pride Furlong can feel. Now can we all scurry off to the john before the bill comes to the table? Oh, right, that's what we've been doing for most of the last couple of generations…

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/madeyoulook madeyoulook

      Oh, and the clown handyman for the cauldron at the start? That was bang-on perfect, and I agree it takes a special group to laugh at its own slip-ups, and invite us all to convert any harrumphs into laughing along with them.

      It reminded me of Stephane Dion. No, really. Remember when his pre-vote (for the Liberal leadership) long-winded speech got cut off for time? Dude wins the leadership and opens his acceptance with "Looks like you wanted to hear the end of my speech after all." That endeared me to him.

    • matt

      The dude shouldn't have to apologize for the language he speaks. That's what being a bilingual country should mean: you don't have to apologize for the language you were raised in, rather than having to apologize for not being raised in both.

  • Anon001

    No Governor General. Harper has her locked up somewhere?

    • W.B.

      I was wondering as well. Why did she take almost no part in Olympics?

  • ronin

    What an awful closing ceremonies. It turned into a Juno show. CTV and Canadian Record labels pumping there artists at you. How disappointing. The opportunity was there to make it something deeper. It started out as a salute to the athletism that was on display, but in the end, the show became a sales pitch. Bye this shit music. I mean, they already beat me to death with the "Believe" them. I believe I believe! But I knew the shit hit the fan when Michael Buble popped up. Then Nickelback. That's like leaving dirty underwear out and you have company over. Most of the performances lip-synched too. Who was the demographic for this live rock show? 15 year olds? One or two "cool" bands would be great. How about some cirque du soleil? What else do we do in Canada, besides make some bad rock music, that we can entertain people with? And blow up dolls? I mean the beavers were kinda cool, but what the…? Who produced this schlock?

  • ronin

    What an awful closing ceremonies. It turned into a Juno show. CTV and Canadian Record labels pumping there artists at you. How disappointing. The opportunity was there to make it something deeper. It started out as a salute to the athletism that was on display, but in the end, the show became a sales pitch. Bye this horrible music. I mean, they already beat me to death with the "Believe" them. I believe I believe! But I knew the s**t hit the fan when Michael Buble popped up. Then Nickelback. That's like leaving dirty underwear out and you have company over. Most of the performances lip-synched too. Who was the demographic for this live rock show? 15 year olds? One or two "cool" bands would be great. How about some cirque du soleil? What else do we do in Canada, besides make some bad rock music, that we can entertain people with? And blow up dolls? I mean the beavers were kinda cool, but what the…? Who produced this schlock?

    • Doobsey

      Wahhh to both of you. You sound like nothing but whiners. The door is always open for you to leave.

      • ronin

        Not whining. Show was bad dude. Make that Doob.

    • anony

      The demographics was not just for 15 year olds, but obviously 15 year old boys. I did not appreciate the sexy mounties. That's not our stereotype of women.

  • vancouver

    I thought the "maple leaf forever" bit was a deliberate 'in your face' to those who complained about a lack of french. Could they have picked a tune that would have set a worse tone for french-Canadians than that? Ha!

  • anony

    Can the women put some clothes on?

  • Jan

    Stephen Colbert will have a lot of new material. I'm afraid to watch him tomorrow night.

  • MJJ

    Does anyone know what the Grade 9 Students dressed in white with red snowboards made as a symbol?

    • AT1

      Nope, CTV cut away from that too fast

      • Dot

        Red maple leaf on white circular background – I think it reversed colours when they flipped their boards over.

    • Bonkers

      It was a countdown to the beginning of the ceremony …. 10, 9, 8, 7 etc … each little area of kids formed the number as it was counted.

      It was hard to spot. My kid caught it, but by the time I saw what he was talking about they got to "1" and cut away.

  • MMY

    I was SO proud to be
    Canadian during the Olympics and then that god-awful closing ceremony made me embarassed all over again. Those feelings usually come out when we try to showcase our beautiful country and aleays fall flat. I knew that the ceremony would do the same once they opened with those snowboarders dancing to that horrible tune that hardly any Canadians know, let alone anyone in the World. Then John Furlong’s french… When it’s THAT bad, just don’t bother or get someone else to do the french parts. Insert more embarassing/shameful vibes here. Oh wait, more to come with those kids, CDN idol chick and the ‘I Believe’ chick who bops here head around so much I got whiplash. Were any of the Canadian comedians really that funny? Ya, okay, sure we can poke fun at ourselves but after the Juno-like horrible performances to follow, we sure as hell better be able to. I can’t believe my children’s children will still be paying the bill for all of that!!

    • Doobsey

      You're embarassing! If you think that bad of where you come from go somewhere else. Furlong's french just fine for someone who is forced to speak a language that he doesn't really need to speak except to appease a very vocal minority. He spoke just fine.

      • Canadian all the way

        Really nice contribution to this blog Doobsey! Gentle, subtle and tactful. Indeed, Canada needs more of your kind in order to be able to keep this country so smart and so well ahead of the rest of the world!

        By the way, I will provide you with the few words of advice already given to Tiredofthewhining:

        My suggestion is that you move further west and thus, have the opportunity to enjoy the unique experience consisting in visiting the bottom of the Pacific Ocean and its friendly inhabitants (not whining indeed, but sometimes biting, you'd better be careful), sunk by the huge weight of your crap…

        See, bilingualism did help us understanding each other!

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/OntarioTown OntarioTown

    It reminded me of a high school production in the school auditorium.

    Too bad Rick Mercer wasn't in the show – oh, perhaps because he works for CBC and CTV wouldn't like it.

    CTV coverage was so bad.

  • knick

    Sometimes a spoof is just a spoof, from start to finish.

  • Bill

    It appears, that based on this article and many of the people who write comments here, our country has way too many bitchers and whiners who don't have a constructive comment or thought. If you think the closing program was less than you would have liked, just think what those reading your comments think of you.

  • kcm

    "Russian anthem next. Turns out it’s still the Soviet anthem. As in: Greatest. Anthem. Ever"

    Yes, it is wonderful. Still, i'm glad i don't know what the lyrics mean, i have a feeling i'd be much disappointed.

  • sbt

    "our country has way too many bitchers and whiners"

    Too true. It's the end of the games and everyone is relaxed and in a good mood. The light-hearted nature of the ceremonies and the self-deprecating humour (which, admittedly, did go overboard at times) was the right way to finish these games off. No need for serious displays on the greatness of Canada. The world's been watching us for two weeks and we won 14 gold medals. My only regret was there were no igloos.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Gaunilon Gaunilon

    The Sov anthem is the best ever, but it sounds way better sung by the Red Army Choir. It just works a lot better sung by dudes than by mixed voices.

    • guest

      I like it better with the mixed voices.

  • Rachel

    Disappointed with the closing ceremony. As it was very nice to see Michael J Fox representing Canada, where was Mike Myers, Jim Carey and Keifer Sutherland? It was great to hear from Allison Morrisette and the World knows her, what's up with the song she sang. Whey didn't she sing something the World has heard before? Where was Rush, and Celine Dion, instead we heard from bands that some of the World has never heard of. Our Canadian Athletes deserve more than that! You know that if this was held in the USA, there would be only the Top celebrities representing their Country. Why does Canada always do thing half assed? Our Athletes worked os hard and came through for Canada, why didn't the organizers of the event come through for Canada…shame on you!

  • Flip

    Wow… I didn’t think it would be possible, but in one hour, they managed to virtually erase all of the positives of the last 2 weeks.

    That was truly awful. Actually found myself cringing.

    While we might think everyone out there gets OUR kind of self-deprecating humour, they DONT!!. Not even the US understands us after living next to us for centuries.

    So after everything gets “Lost in Translation”, the world in which “CANADIAN” ENGLISH is not their first language believes….

    1) We breed in canoes because Cptn. Kirk said so…
    2) Catharine O’Hara told them they smell bad and its now time to leave.
    3) We cant get enough of Nickelback beer drinking/fighting anthems.
    4) We worship giant buck toothed rodent deities.
    5) We like our female law enforcements officers to put on whore makep and dress up in barely coochy covering mini’s and knee high go-gos

    Bet those last two were a huge hit in the entire islamic world.

    For God Sakes…. Ovechkin was posing with little children while a symphony was playing and we had flying moose!!

    I found myself praying that Celine Dion was going to ride out on an elephant and salage everything, but sadly…no.

    Kill me now.

    • Jan

      I'm surprised they didn't have her sing 'the song' from the bow of an ice breaker.

      • Joe

        Get a life Flip. Your comments are over the top and ridiculous

  • dan

    Is it me or was the Old Russian Anthem militant and overwhelmingly out of place for such a human, down to earth, green and friendly olympics. Here comes Red Square, Stalinism and a country with 10's of thousands of nukes…come visit us! We have sterile circles :)

    • Duke

      Out of place eh? What would you have suggested in place of the next host's national anthem? I guess the British national anthem was a bit too imperialisitc in a people's republic at Beijing – overwhemingly!

      And Stalin? I don't know that I watched the same broadcast as you…I don't know how you get Stalin from that short segment – maybe too many Cold War movies for you – consider that not all Russian heritage = Communist Stalin heritage, lot of the presentation items (images, music etc.) predate the Bolsheviks.

      Hopefully it was just you – it thought the Russian Sochi segment was the highlight of the ceremonies

      As for the comment about it being a Soviet anthem – not exactly true.

      Tune is the same lyrics are different….

From Macleans