TV Guidance

TV Guidance

Jaime Weinman writes about all kinds of television and other kinds of popular culture. He does not write Gossip Girl episode reviews. Follow Jaime on Twitter: @weinmanj

What Happened To TV Insta-Knockoffs of Movies?

by Jaime Weinman on Friday, March 19, 2010 1:09pm - 4 Comments

Parenthood is a well-made, well-acted show that doesn’t fully grab me, at least not yet. One thing that interests me about NBC’s decision to do a second TV remake of the movie is that it reflects the changing relationship of TV to feature films: it seems like there are fewer new shows that remake, or rip off, recent Hollywood features.

For a long time, a lot of studios and networks would respond to the success of a feature film by putting a similar television show into production, hoping to cash in on the fad. Sometimes this was a remake: M*A*S*H was a hit in 1970, and the studio had a TV version ready to go two years later. Uncle Buck, Parenthood and other 1989 movies became flop TV shows in 1990.

And sometimes a studio would produce a show that, while not a remake, was obviously an attempt to ape the success of a recent film. So Paramount had a big hit with Saturday Night Fever in 1977, and in 1979, the same studio unveiled Makin’ It, a TV show from their top producing team (the four-headed hydra of Garry Marshall, Tom Miller, Eddie Milkis and Bob Boyett) that had absolutely nothing in common with Saturday Night Fever except that it’s about young blue-collar guys who live out their dreams by going to a disco at night. Oh, and there’s a Travolta in it. The show starred and had a theme song sung by David Naughton, who later moved to London and became a werewolf.

But now, TV remakes of recent movies are rarer than they used to be, which is why the biggest new film-to-TV transition is an adaptation of a movie that’s over 20 years old. And there are some shows that are trying to cash in on the success of recent films — like the lame Apatow-influenced hijinks of Accidentally On Purpose — but not that many. Looking at the top-grossing movies of 2007, I don’t think a lot of them had obvious TV equivalents by 2009. Of course, a lot of this is because the big movies are mostly interchangeable blockbusters, or based on already-familiar properties that wouldn’t lend themselves to TV adaptation (or were imitated by all of popular culture, including TV, before they even became movies). But I certainly think there seems to be a trend away from networks looking at the latest big movie and saying “get me something like that.”

There are some exceptions, of course, particularly on basic cable, which operates in a more old-fashioned way than the broadcast networks. ABC Family was obviously thinking of Juno when they greenlit The Secret Life of the American Teenager — and it worked. Just like it worked for the parent network, ABC, when they responded to American Graffiti by dusting off a two year-old unsold pilot about the ’50s (Happy Days) and rushing it into production.

Bookmark and Share
  • Loren

    The last immediate TV remake that springs to mind was CBS's "My Big Fat Greek Life." Huge box office, but bombed on the TV. I think every more recent remake has adapted an older film: Tremors, Parenthood, Terminator…

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/akurjata Andrew

    What about the whole vampire thing? Is that movies cashing in on books cashing in on TV or TV cashing in on movies cashing in on books? Or just a giant coincidence?

  • http://manvsclown.wordpress.com Peter Lynn

    And, of course, there was Parker Lewis Can't Lose, an off-brand knock-off of Ferris Bueller that was actually better and longer lasting than the official Ferris Bueller TV spin-off.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Babbler Babbler

    What's the trend in the other direction, that is, movies out of television series? I have a vague feeling that's increased over time, but I'm not sure.

From Macleans