Letter to Maclean's from another rogue Helena Guergis staffer

Doesn’t ID herself as minister’s spokesperson, sees no conflict, and is not apologizing

by Cathy Gulli on Tuesday, March 30, 2010 8:23pm - 127 Comments

helena guergis letterA long-time spokesperson of Minister Helena Guergis insists there was no conflict of interest when she wrote a glowing letter to Maclean’s about her boss—but failed to identify herself as the MP’s employee.

Valerie Knight, who has worked for Guergis for three and a half years in her Alliston constituency office, says it never crossed her mind to disclose their affiliation when she sent a letter to the editor on Mar. 14. The letter was written in response to the Maclean’s article “Power couple, unplugged,” about Guergis and her husband, former MP Rahim Jaffer, who have been scandal-plagued lately. Knight listed awards that Guergis has received, and concluded, “Power couple—I don’t know. Smart, hard working, accomplished—you bet.” The letter is signed with Knight’s name and personal contact information only.

Knight’s stunt coincides with a similar incident: earlier Tuesday, another Guergis staffer, Jessica Craven, was caught sending flattering letters about the minister to Ontario newspapers using her married name, Morgan. She has apologized, and insists Guergis had no idea. The minister has since spoken out, calling these letters “inappropriate.”

Guergis wasn’t aware of her letter either, says Knight, which she penned out of frustration one Sunday morning after reading the magazine article. She doesn’t regret not identifying herself in the letter, and says she was exercising free speech. “People are dying for that friggin’ right.” Nor is Knight concerned about what her boss will think. “I don’t care what [Guergis] thinks of my letter, quite frankly. I mean, it’s a letter. She knows how I feel,” Knight told Maclean’s. “She knows that if I want to say something, you can’t stop me.” Just what everybody wants in a spokesperson, no doubt.

When furthered questioned about whether this was a coordinated effort from the Guergis camp to lift the minister’s tarnished image, Knight maintains she didn’t know about Craven’s letter, and no one knew about hers: “I just sit here, have my coffee, get pissed off, write a letter, end of story.” For now.

Bookmark and Share
  • Eric Vehkalahti

    Harper should fire her for her indescretions and she should fire her staffer for exercising her right of free speech. What happened with Ruby gate nanny affair? The Liberal adscam only hit supporters and everyone knows there were elected politicians involved. Does anyone think that people who comment negatively to articles about the govt are frustrated conservatives. The Liberals have no policies so they fling dirt. They have fallen a long way from the days when they were a prty of principals,and ideas

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Stewart_Smith Stewart_Smith

    I thought staffers were supposed to spend their time working on the wikipedia article! What are they doing wasting time on some slimmy, Liberal-subsidized rag?

    • Brian

      Another LOL shot from S.S. Made my morning.

      Bravo

    • Dick Richards

      Macleans never came across that way to me

      • http://intensedebate.com/people/frenchie101 frenchie101

        LOL!

  • Malcolm Barry

    Minister Guergis,staff and most of the Ministers in Govt. are totally lost and could care less. Mr. Harper has abdicated leadership and his arrogance is spreading and he is becoming a Lame Duck.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Open_Democracy Open_Democracy

    Several weeks back I wrote a comment stating that the next time we read about Rahim and Helena, it would be regarding their divorce proceedings. I was mistaken. I apologize.

    Apparently they really ARE more compatible and have much more in common than I first thought. "Radio Show Rahim" must have coached his wife in how best to dupe the sweaty masses, so they are obviously communicating at a deep and meaningful level.

    http://viableopposition.blogspot.com/

  • PO'DConservative

    The PM's not being seen to sort this person out immediately after the airport fracas is bad for the party and I speak as a conservative supporter. It looks bad on the members of parliament and cabinet who are not self absorbed prima donnas or "prima donalds" as the case may be. As the English say; Send them both to Coventry.

  • Harvey Mushman

    Guergis is to Conservative as Dhalla is to Liberal.

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/frenchie101 frenchie101

      Excpet Rubys story was buried, where is she now? who knows.

  • AUGGIE

    AH THE RIGHT TO FREE SPEECH ITS TO BAD WE AS CITIZENS CAN`T HAVE A RECALL VOTE FOR THESE ELECTED BAFOONS, UP TO AND INCLUDING THE APPOINTED SENATE. THAT WOULD BE THE ULTIMATE RIGHT OF FREE SPEECH IN CANADA.

  • Peter b

    We would have something to worry about if a staffer wrote that her superior was incompetent and a thief etc. Fact that she expressed her opinion can't be a cardinal sin and holds as much water if not more than many of the comments being made by members of the media and opposition ( which may include some members of the opposition staff) who have an agenda and can be accused of exaggeration and embellishment of facts and innuendo.
    This is just becoming a character assassination and a personal attack of little substance . What can we expect next in this personal attack – an accusation that her dog raped the neighbors dog?

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/YYZ YYZ

      Dude – the writers should've disclosed their positions.

      There's nothing wrong with the opinion, I'm glad her staff thinks highly of her.

      • Brian

        Dude – you and I pay taxes to pay for these staffers. If they're sending out letters from work, they're doing it in our name as much as they are doing it in hers.

        • http://intensedebate.com/people/YYZ YYZ

          A nuance, one that doesn't bother me but I take your point.

          However, even if she did it from her home computer after hours….she still should disclose. Being a government employee doesn't remove one's ability to have an opinion.

  • Peter

    As Rahim Jaffer’s lawyer and a member of the senate, I don’t believe she did anything wrong.

  • Mike

    They know nobody can prove collusion. One assumes they also know people don't actually have to see it, to be convinced that the cat crapped behind the couch; the overpowering odor is sufficient.

    • Brian

      Or maybe not. I wonder if an FOI request would produce blackberry messages back and forth from HG to staffers talking about the coverage, the letters, or whatever. So far, these guys seem inept enough that this might just be possible.

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/WesternInterest WesternInterest

      Seems to me the PMO wrote the book on how to disrupt parliamentary committees, who's to say they didn't pen a manifesto on how to boost their image in newspapers and magazines? I wouldn't put it past them, it would probably be considered very witty and another great way to ensure their majority next time around.

  • alsandor

    Obviously, the words "conflict of interest" are not part of the "transparent" conservative government du jour.

  • Capitalist

    Policitians lie or mislead the public and lawyers lie in court (Senator Ann Cools Bill 2-12) . What you have here is an epidemic of "entitlement" liars and no one does a thing about it including parliament or federal justice.

    How does the Banana Republic of Canada sound?.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/frenchie101 frenchie101

    This is almost as bad as the Liberals planting senior Ignatieff strategist and former CBC lawyer Mark Sakamoto in a H1N1 vaccine line-up to complain about the Conservatives handling of the roll out.

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/YYZ YYZ

      I thought it "didn't phase you at all"

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/FranIrwin FranIrwin

      Mark and his wife were in line to get their 12 month old little boy vacinnated – it was NOT a plant, when the reporter asked he and his wife the question he responded honestly. To even suggest he dragged his wife and baby into a LONG line up to score political points is CRAZY!

      • http://intensedebate.com/people/frenchie101 frenchie101

        It was absolutely a plant , and the CBC aided them as per

  • Mike

    Sarah Nolan also works for her and is known to lye about everything!

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Stewart_Smith Stewart_Smith

    Thanks Brian, NOW GET BACK TO WORK! I am not paying you for your typing skills.

    • Margaret

      "Slimmy"? What's that mean – a weight-watching publication?

      Oh – you mean slimy.

  • gar

    Harper has to let this woman go back to the back benches until she is either re elected by her constituency or turfed.As a Conservative she is becoming an embarrassment to us.this is either straight favoritism or stupidity on the P,Ms part

  • heather

    This staffer absolutely had the right to pen a letter, praising her boss, if those are her opinions. As another commenter pointed out, it means that we get to hear about an MP from someone who personally knows them.

    At the same time, the public has a right to know that it is a staffer who wrote the letter. These women should know better.

  • John

    [youtube zcpafN9yv4U http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zcpafN9yv4U youtube]

  • Bill D. Cat

    I wonder how long our esteemed MSM can keep this vitally important news on the front burner ? I'll put the over / under at two weeks to start .

  • Peter b

    Ms. Taber didn't bother to comment or find fault with the Liberals when they were found guilty of planting senior Ignatieff strategist and former CBC lawyer Mark Sakamoto in a H1N1 vaccine line-up to complain about the Conservatives handling of the roll out of the vaccine.
    Does she have a double standard? Did she ask for any resignation , a slap on the wrist or did she just ignore the story – after all it is a Liberal and they can do no wrong.
    However we were exposed to Wayne(doorknob)Easter and his histrionics in the House about Guergis.

    In the Sakamoto controversy Harper and Conservatives did not ask for resignations and try to blow the incident up into a big scandal – in fact the opposite was true and as you can see they deliberately downplayed it.
    What is more can't you all be impressed by the way Harper handled this controversy – he said the party will not be commenting – how different from Ignatieff and Wayne (dooknob Easter) who try to blow this minor incident into a scandal with help from a subservient media .
    At the time of the Sakamoto incident Taber's column was
    "1. The politics of H1N1. Did the Ignatieff Liberals really plant one of their own to complain on national television about the shortage of vaccine? Indeed, the accusations are flying today with the Harper PMO sending out an alert to all of its MPs, Senators and staffers urging them not to respond or comment about a news story on CBC's The National last night “in which an employee of Michael Ignatieff’s office appears in a ‘street interview’ as an ordinary citizen concerned about the supply of H1N1 vaccine.”

    The notice, sent via email, goes on to “urge MPs not to respond to the transparent attempt to pass off an Ignatieff staffer as a non-partisan Canadian. We will not be commenting on the incident. It is very sad and unfortunate that the Ignatieff Liberals are desperately attempting to politicize the H1N1 preparedness efforts of the federal and provincial governments.”

    http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/politics/otta…

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/CTM Claudia Lemire

      Well, Jane Taber…she is not even worth commenting about….

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/FranIrwin FranIrwin

      Mark and his wife were in line to get their 12 month old little boy vacinnated – it was NOT a plant, when the reporter asked he and his wife the question he responded honestly. To even suggest he dragged his wife and baby into a LONG line up to score political points is CRAZY!

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/FranIrwin FranIrwin

      Mark and his wife were in line to get their 12 month old little boy vacinnated – it was NOT a plant, when the reporter asked he and his wife the question he responded honestly. To even suggest he dragged his wife and baby into a LONG line up to score political points is CRAZY! And IN FACT Mark was let go and returned to his Toronto Law Firm shortly after this incident – it was a stupid thing to not introduce yourelf, your wife and your 12 month old little boy when standing in line for hours and asked a question by some reporter in line. Pretty sure he was happy to return to Toronto full time, those babies grow like weeds!

  • Peter b

    So Fife is on CTV saying that Helena has a fan club, her staff….then says Helena has not been able to hang onto staffers because no one likes her.

    Which of the above is true Fife?

    You can't have it both ways. What's wrong with Fife's picture.
    Do you believe there are any Conservatives that would share party inside information with Robert Fife?

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/frenchie101 frenchie101

      No. Fife makes it up as he goes along.

    • Brian

      The staffers that sent the letters to the newspapers are her political staff from two of her constituency offices in the riding. These people were hand picked by Guergis (often friends and political supporters) and their jobs depend on Guergis getting elected. The "revolving door" that Fife is referring to is the non-political staff that are employed in Ottawa as part of her ministry. These people are traditional government employees whose jobs do will remain even if Guergis does not.

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/WesternInterest WesternInterest

      Her "fan club" consists of employees desperate to stay employed and will say anything to appease her.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/YYZ YYZ

    Hey I live in Toronto, and that makes most people assume that I'm a Layton-loving communist hippie. We all have our crosses to bear, I suppose.

  • Oliver

    I just hope the Liberals don't try and ride this to the ends of the earth.
    Ask for her resignation, make sure everyone how unfit she is for the job and let it go.

  • WalterF

    So CBC staffers freely exchange info with the Liberals, but it's not okay to write an unsolicited letter to the paper in support of your boss. I do have questions about the latter, but why not do something about the former as well?

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/frenchie101 frenchie101

      Yup!

  • Margaret

    WOW. Is she ever dumb. And NEVER going to win a beauty contest outside the neighbourhood!!
    I don't know what she sounds like in Parliament, but that is one manufactured, fake princess-voice.

    What an act. I've got a teenager who just aced a Social Gr. 12 test, after just reading the book and missing 3 weeks of classes. She could do Guergis' job with her hands tied behind her back. I cannot believe we've got something like this in Parliament. Harper certainly likes them dumb.

From Macleans