Inkless Wells

Inkless Wells

Paul Wells on all the latest out of Ottawa—along with the occasional post about jazz. Follow Paul on Twitter: @InklessPW
He also offers his thoughtful perspective of Stephen Harper’s last 10 years in his recent eBook, The Harper Decade.

A land too acquainted with grief

by Paul Wells on Saturday, April 10, 2010 9:39am - 14 Comments

The Gazeta Wyborcza “turns the rules” in mourning, publishing its website only in black to chronicle the astonishing death of the country’s president Lech Kaczynski and dozens of others in a plane crash in Russia. The great newspaper’s founder Adam Michnik, who came from the Catholic reform left and disagreed with most of everything Kaczynski was in politics to accomplish, prints a short and dignified appreciation (I’m linking to Google translations; Polish doesn’t robo-translate well to English, but you can get the gist).

Kaczynski was a controversial figure who put a broadly-brushed xenophobia at the centre of his politics. In a country with a long history of violent dismemberment at the hands of its neighbours, most recently by the parties to the Molotov-Ribbentropp pact, xenophobia can at times be forgiven and often politically profitable. But most recent accounts suggest Poland was tiring of Kaczynski’s  assorted resentments and that he’d have trouble winning re-election this autumn. Still, Michnik gets it right: Kaczynski was courtly and warm in his personal relations with friend and foe, and his constant motive was patriotism. A cornerstone of his personal legacy is the Warsaw Rising Museum, to which Kaczynski gave the green light and his strong support while he was the city’s mayor. (In a city full of museums, if you get into a cab and say “take me to the museum,” this is where they take you.)

On the accident itself, it’s worth pointing out that for any politician, a decision about whether to land an airplane in inclement weather is an inherently political call and I’m a little surprised something like today’s tragedy doesn’t happen more often. To pick a relatively trivial example, during the stormy autumn of 1998, I rode in Quebec Liberal leader Jean Charest’s campaign plane as it made more than one reckless descent through freezing rain and high winds to get to campaign events.

Prime Minister Donald Tusk will surely cancel an Ottawa visit that was to happen this week. He and Kaczynski barely got along and had used airplanes as instruments to express stark disagreements over foreign policy before (I’m trying to track down an account of an airborne dispute between them that played out during the 2008 Georgia-Russia unpleasantness.) With a passenger list that included the country’s entire military command, its Olympic chairman, relatives of the Katyn murder victims and many politicians, the destruction of Kaczynski’s plane is tragedy on a scale Canadians can barely imagine. What makes this such a Polish catastrophe is that to many of the country’s older residents, it will all feel so familiar.

Bookmark and Share
  • http://intensedebate.com/people/sea_n_mountains sea_n_mountains

    it does not take long in reading stories from the Gazeta and elsewhere today to realize how right Paul is in pointing out that "the destruction of Kaczynski’s plane is tragedy on a scale Canadians can barely imagine", or at least not this Canadian. Several list of passengers are being updated with the roles of the dead and it is breathtaking to say the least. I think former president Aleksander Kwaśniewski captured the very essence of how devastating and, as Paul also calls our attention to, how familiar this is:

    <block>It is a cursed place. It sends shivers down my spine. First the flower of the Second Polish Republic is murdered in the forests around Smolensk, now the intellectual elite of the Third Polish Republic die in this tragic plane crash when approaching Smolensk airport.</block>

    • YoungAngry

      I don't really see that many prominent Poles in the list of the passengers. I mean, even Kaczynski in Canadian system amounts to a Foreign Affairs minister, and the only other people of really major significance on the plane were the head of National Bank and the top military guy. It's not like the entire government has been devastated, as some reports suggested.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Crit_Reasoning Crit_Reasoning

    My heart goes out to the people of Poland.

  • MediaBuff

    I was uncharacteristically overcome with grief when I heard about this accident, knowing today's import. The horrors of WWII flood back, accompanied by fears that Poland cannot remain free. Those who lit the fuse of Solidarity are extinguished at the very hour of their most sublime achievement.

    This is a tragedy so monumental, it is as if the world is in the grasp of a truly wicked God.

    • McC

      wasn't 1989 "the very hour of their most sublime achievement"?

      • MediaBuff

        I would say that 1989 was the most glorious achievement, but only the middle of the story. Today, Russia writes the final chapter, and comes to terms with free Poland. When you live beside the bear, it doesn't get any better than that. Such a thing was unimaginable in the Gdansk of 1980.

  • Mulletaur

    There but for the grace of God go many of us. My heart and sincere condolences go out to the Polish nation. What terrible irony.

  • Canadian Immigrant

    "My heart and sincere condolences go out to the Polish nation."
    I second this.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/CTM Claudia Lemire

    My thoughts and prayers to Poland.

  • Ron

    President Lech Katczynski was a great President, that few coutries have. The list of other passengers who were lost in Smolensk is full of other key personalities of the Polish Government. They were all an important part of Poland's recent successes, and they all will be missed. What a terrible tragedy. P.S. "GW's" opinions are not as widely shared, as this article seems to suggest.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/OntarioTown OntarioTown

    There are things that make you feel empty. This is one of them.

    How sad.

    Makes me think of a neighbour of my father-in-law (Polish woman) who was in a concentration camp during WWII. She never complained or talked about it. But there was that nagging number on her arm.

    She was so kind and had quite a personality. When my father-in-law was dying she'd go "every day" to sit with him, pray (stauch Catholic) and cry.

    He couldn't eat, but she'd bring him some homecooked food every day.

    He didn't even know her that well.

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/novagardener novagardener

      Our neighbours were Polish immigrants. They moved into a Seniors Home a couple of yrs ago. He was with the British Military during the war and emigrated to Canada after the war and worked as a logger! Obtained his Dr.'s degree in chemistry and worked in the paper industry in NB. He met his Polish wife, a nurse, after they both emigrated to Canada.. He was a stubborn 'bastard' but kind hearted. She was a lovely woman. Both were extremely religious, as most Poles are. (My French hubby got to know a few young refugee couples from Poland taking English as a 2nd language who were also extremely religious – we befriended them). Our neighbours had 3 children – all medical Drs. of the higest calibre. We and other neighbours shared many wonderful evenings at their place. We held a 50th wedding anniversary for them at our home. They sent a lot of money to family in Poland over the years and brought family to Canada for vacations. They lived simply but generoursly. I learned a lot from them about gardening. I miss them. Thankfully, their home was purchased by someone who loves to garden.

      • http://intensedebate.com/people/novagardener novagardener

        PS to my previous post. Neither my hubby or I are religious tho his Mother is. It was a taboo subject with our neighbours. They watched 'Mass for Shutins' every day and, after he lost his driver's license, would take a taxi every couple of days to go to church.

From Macleans