The lesson of a Jewish cemetery

MARK STEYN: The ‘sanctity’ of this burial ground in Tangiers speaks volumes

by Mark Steyn on Thursday, June 17, 2010 8:00am - 402 Comments

A Jewish cemetery in Cracow, Poland (Tobias Gerber/Laif/Redux)

Thanks to the wonders of globalization, I’m writing this in a fairly decrepit salon de thé off the rue de la Liberté in Tangiers, enjoying a coffee and a stale croissant grilled and flattened into a panini. What could be more authentically Moroccan? For some reason, the napkins are emblazoned with “Gracias por su visita.”

Through a blizzard of flies, I can just about make out the plasma TV up in the corner on which Jimmy Carter, dubbed into Arabic, is denouncing Israel. Al Jazeera doesn’t so much cover the Zionist Entity as feast on it, hour after hour, without end. So here, at the western frontier of the Muslim world (if you don’t include Yorkshire), the only news that matters is from a tiny strip of land barely wider at its narrowest point than a rural Canadian township way down the other end of the Mediterranean.

Notwithstanding saturation coverage of the “Massacre In The Med” (as the front page headline in Britain’s Daily Mirror put it), there are other Jewish stories in the news. This one caught my eye in Canada’s Shalom Life: “No danger to the Jewish cemeteries in Tangiers.” Apparently, the old Jewish hospital in this ancient port city was torn down a couple of months back, and the Moroccan Jewish diaspora back in Toronto worried that their graveyards might be next on the list. Not to worry, Abraham Azancot assured Shalom Life readers. The Jewish cemetery on the rue du Portugal is perfectly safe. “Its sanctity has consistently been respected by the local government that is actually providing the community with resources to assist in its current grooming.”

Sounds great. Being in the neighbourhood, I thought I’d swing by and check out the “current grooming.” It’s kind of hard to spot unless you’re consciously looking for it: two solid black metal gates off a steep, narrow street where the rue du Portugal crosses the rue Salah Dine, and only the smallest of signs to indicate what lies behind. On pushing open the gate and squeezing through, I was greeted by a pair of long underwear, flapping in the breeze. In Haiti, this would be some voodoo ritual, alerting one to go no further. But in Tangiers it was merely wash day, and laundry lines dangled over the nearest graves. If you happen to be Ysaac Benzaquen (died 1921) or Samuel Maman (died 1925), it is your lot to spend eternity with the groundskeeper’s long johns. Pace Mr. Azancot, there is no sense of “sanctity” or “community”: as the underwear advertises, this is no longer a public place, merely a backyard that happens to have a ton of gravestones in it. I use the term “groundskeeper” but keeping the grounds doesn’t seem to be a priority: another row of graves was propping up piles of logs he was busy chopping out of hefty tree trunks. Beyond that, chickens roamed amidst burial plots strewn with garbage bags, dozens of old shoes, and hundreds of broken bottles.

It’s prime real estate, with a magnificent view of the Mediterranean, if you don’t mind the trash and the stench and the chickenshit, and you tiptoe cautiously around the broken glass. I wandered past the graves: Jacob Cohen, Samuel J. Cohen, Samuel M. Cohen . . . Lot of Cohens here over the years. Not anymore. In one isolated corner, six young men—des musulmans, naturellement—watched a seventh lightly scrub a tombstone, as part of a make-work project “providing the community with resources to assist in its current grooming.”

What “community”? By 2005, there were fewer than 150 Jews in Tangiers, almost all of them very old. By 2015, it is estimated that there will be precisely none. Whenever I mention such statistics to people, the reaction is a shrug: why would Jews live in Morocco anyway? But in 1945 there were some 300,000 in this country. Today some 3,000 Jews remain—i.e., about one per cent of what was once a large and significant population. That would be an unusual demographic reconfiguration in most countries: imagine if Canada’s francophone population or Inuit population were today one per cent of what it was in 1945. But it’s not unusual for Jews. There are cemeteries like that on the rue du Portugal all over the world, places where once were Jews and now are none. I mentioned only last week that in the twenties, Baghdad was 40 per cent Jewish. But you could just as easily cite Czernowitz in the Bukovina, now part of Ukraine. “There is not a shop that has not a Jewish name painted above its windows,” wrote Sir Sacheverell Sitwell, visiting the city in 1937. Not today. As in Tangiers, the “community” resides in the cemetery.

You can sense the same process already under way in, say, London, the 13th-biggest Jewish city in the world, but one with an aging population; and in Malmö, Sweden, where a surge in anti-Semitism from, ahem, certain quarters has led Jewish residents to abandon the city for Stockholm and beyond; and in Odense, Denmark, where last year superintendent Olav Nielsen announced he would no longer admit Jewish children to the local school. The Jewish presence almost anywhere on the map is as precarious as, to coin a phrase, a fiddler on the roof. And Israel’s enemies are determined that the biggest Jewish community of all should be just as precarious and prove just as impermanent.

In 1936, during the Cable Street riots, the British Union of Fascists jeered at London Jews, “Go back to Palestine!”, “Palestine” being in those days the designation for the Jewish homeland. Last week, Helen Thomas, the doyenne of the White House press corps, jeered at today’s Jews, “Get the hell out of Palestine,” “Palestine” being now the designation for the land illegally occupied by the Jewish apartheid state. “Go home,” advised Miss Thomas, “to Poland and Germany.” Wherever a Jew is, whatever a Jew is, he should be something else somewhere else. And then he can be hated for that, too.

Bookmark and Share
  • Other Guest

    It's sad, ironic, and instructive to look at the photo of a cemetery in another, concurrent Maclean's article, and to compare the stories, and the (mostly ugly) comments on this thread:
    http://www2.macleans.ca/2010/05/24/turning-the-ot…

  • Occam's Tool

    18 million Jews in 1939, 13 million today. get the numbers right. North Korea is more of an economic basket case than Iran—it has the bomb.

  • Melesti33

    Hashalom

     

     

    Regretfully, very little can be done through diplomatic
    channels, to resolve the 
    Palestinian/Israeli impasse.

    Both the Palestinians and the Israelis are victims of the
    Middle East Despots’ Agenda aimed at perpetuating their regimes through the
    elimination of encroaching Democracy.

    Another Democratic Palestinian State is not-at-all a
    priority on their agenda.

    They, with the inception of Israel
    as a fledgling Democracy, readily, exploited and harnessed the Palestinians to
    achieve their end.

    They, initially, through the years, financed Middle East
    Terrorism and then proceeded with teaching of hatred, of the infidel, in the
    Mosques and the Madrasah to embrace, with their Fundamentalist cohorts, the
    campaign for instituting Sharia Law throughout the world.

    They will go on sacrificing the last indoctrinated
    “Freedom Fighter” and spending their last dollar to ensure their
    autocratic regimes.

    Sixty years of victimization and frustration have not
    thought the Palestinians anything. It is doubtful that the Palestinians will
    have the fortitude to awaken to the need of ridding themselves of their true
    “enslavers”. Hope that true freedom will “spring” into the hearts of
    Progressive Palestinians is receding as the months go by.

  • jon

    My father, who was Jewish and mildly liberal was fixated on "rich Texans" as the model of anti-semitism. He was out of date. He suported Israel, but he couldnt grasp that the biggest anti-semites in the West are liberals, leftwingers, and skinheads – who all have much more in common than one might think… Opposing the legitimacy of Israel is a code for "I don't like Jews…"

  • Faustino

    Welcome to the fight Mr. Jon. Spread this information to your friends. Canadian and American Jews are still obsessed about being excluded from country clubs while ignoring much deeper malice.

  • albert

    Nice try…no…poor try…but conservative to the core so, good for the feeble minded.

  • minaka

    Well, there's one group that undermines the legitimacy of Israel and can't be accused of hating Jews, and that's diaspora Jews who support left wing parties that have long shown their animus for Israel. What to call them?

  • Vikram D.

    I never really thought about Jews much, or Israel. Would shrug off the prejudices whether from the left or the right as common biggotry. But after living in a condominium for 7 years and being the only gentile, all I can say is if it's been hell of me I can't imagine what it's like for Palestinians in Israel.

  • Dave

    Mr. Steyn is a Nation Treasure.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/minaka minaka

    The "Palestinians" lucky enough to be IN Israel have more rights than they have in any ARAB/MUSLIM country.

    The Palestinians left to twist in the wind by their Arab/Muslim brethren in the West Bank and Gaza are diverging in their fates. Those in the West Bank co-operating with and learning from Israel how to make the desert bloom are doing pretty well with a growing economy. Those in Gaza who keep voting for Hamas which denies Israel's right to exist and spends the greatest per capita foreign aid on bombs are not doing so well.

  • Assassin1

    Well sir your racism shining through. Why is it that white people who
    have everything, are so enraged by Muslims? Inferiority Complex.
    We hold our values, you have lost them all so you must resort to
    childish tactics. Keep watching, "Pakism" will show you. You can do nothing about it. Failed state? Pak army defeated Taliban in 3-4 months. The whole of NATO still cannot accomplish this. Shame.
    Muslims, nor anyone need bother the Zionists, they are sowing the seeds of their own destruction. Hate all you want, and die in your rage.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Faustino Faustino

    I'm not sure they can't be accused of hating Jews. Self-loathing seems to be a common phenomenon in the West. See Prince Charles.

  • minaka

    You hold your values indeed and the disgusting handle you've chosen and sentiments expressed give a clear picture of what those values are, totally inimical to the West.

    In the hate and rage department, Muslims are in a class of their own. It has to do with following a barbaric warlord as a role model.

  • Hughy

    Pakistan – failed state. Sub-human animals grunting out their daily lives with utmost piggish opinions. Incessant murderers of each other.

    Pakistan – hell

  • Darden Cavalcade

    At its very best, the Government of Pakistan is corrupt and incompetent. Pakistan has defeated anyone or anything…ever.

    Hate, rage, and scapegoating are the hallmarks of the national psyche.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/minaka minaka

    I have a problem with the "self-hating" concept because such people believe they are very fine fellows indeed, on a higher intellectual and moral plane than the rabble.

    However, functionally they may as well be self-haters because if the betrayal of their own culture and society came to fruition, they would lose their own prominence and probably their lives as well.

    They are proof that the end stages of liberalism and socialism are brain rot.

  • Faustino

    This may sound odd and off the subject but read about the life of Oscar Wilde. I highly recommend 'The Unmasking of Oscar Wilde' by Joseph Pearce. His life is very interesting. He was brilliant yet led a very debauched life. He loved being a wit and a dandy and was very good at it. Yet, in his plays – I'm thinking ' An Ideal Husband', or 'The Picture of Dorian Gray' he is obviously struggling with the consequences of that life. In his plays – especially the later ones – he had a very Solomon-like wisdom about him. I don't know if he ever reconciled the split in how he led his personal life and his beliefs in his literary life but he was well aware of the tension.

    Unlike Wilde, liberals (and secular Jews) seem so tin-eared, unreflective and self-destrucive about the consequences of their worldview. It is very troubling especially in a people as accomplished and bright as the Jews.

  • sabashimon

    Hey Johnson, are you sure you don't spell your first name Aryan?
    We've outlasted the Pharaohs, the Romans, and the Nazi's, to name just a few……..we'll be around long after the likes of your filth has been eradicated.

From Macleans