Fake lake wake

by Andrew Coyne on Friday, June 25, 2010 6:43pm - 101 Comments

Let’s get this out of the way off the top, while we’re waiting for some real news. I’ve now had the opportunity to see the infamous “fake lake,” tucked away in a corner of the cavernous Interantional Press Centre. As one of the first to fly off the handle over this without first checking my facts, let me be one of the first to confess this is a total non-story.

It’s not an “indoor lake,” as the first story I read suggested. It is a reflector pool, about the size of a backyard swimming pool, only no more than two inches deep. There can’t be more than 10 gallons of water in it, tops. It is bordered by a small wooden platform simulating a dock, with Muskoka chairs casually strewn about. There’s a bank of canoes on either side, and a large screen showing some quite breathtaking high-def footage of Canadian lakeland scenes. And that’s it.

It’s not extravagant in the slightest. Modest would be closer to the mark. The government puts the cost at about $57,000, which sounds about right: about what it would cost to finish your basement. Or to be precise, it represents just over two 100,000ths of one per cent of federal spending. All in all it’s rather a pleasant spot, a small oasis of calm and comfort away from the conference churn, and shows every sign of being a hit with the foreign press. A few minutes of that footage is bound to persuade more than a few of them to want to return, or to tell the folks back home.

It is, in short, a perfectly acceptable, if hardly vital, use of public funds, and should never have become a subject of controversy. The media got rolled on this one, the opposition ran away with it, and we all ought to be ashamed of ourselves.

Tags:

Bookmark and Share
  • Anonymous

    Well said! Let's just all remember to take a few days to confirm some facts the next time the Lieral Party of Canada tries to tell Canadians, through their media agents, that something which cost $57k should anger us for costing $1.9M. Facts aren't always what the Liberals spin.

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/danby danby

      The Liberals are certainly not the sole operators of the spinning facts machine – the Conservatives do one helluva lot of spinning too.

      • Gary

        Like the prorogation issue in reverse?? They did it too!
        Funny, you Libs were all over us for that comparison and now you play the same game?
        How do you spell hypocrite??

    • Kat

      "…to take a few days to confirm…"

      Not possible in this information age – it's still important to be the first to break the story so who has the time? We the readers want to know yesterday what happened today so getting your facts straight is not necessarily the first order of business.

      How does that saying go "Sometimes it's better to ask for forgiveness than to ask for permission"

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/VinceClortho VinceClortho

    Having put together a number of trade show booths, which this is kind of the equivalent of. This cost isnt out of whack, especially for a unique one off.

    Bigger question is what happens to all of the materials afterwards. If the government wants to prevent yet another PR disaster they'll donate the canoes to kids camp somewhere.

  • SpenBC

    I am so tired of the whiney Liberals in this country. Suck it up! You lost the election! I hope Harper gets a majority next election, if for no other reason then to shut these whiney Liberals up for a while.

  • cooper

    A billion dollars for a summit, the G20, that was not necessary. The real work of the G-20 takes place next year in Korea and this extravaganza is just a meet and greet.. This was just a phot-op and an impulsive one at that at a big price to Canadian taxpayers. Next year may, hopefully, bring a whole new set of performers to the show. This is one costly tea party.

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/danby danby

      According to the website , the next meeting is Nov 11-12, this year

    • matt

      Except that the accord reached at the conclusion of this summit wasn't expected until the Korea summit. Read Ibbitson in the Globe. Given that result, is it worth it now? Or, on a relative basis, would it have been better for Canada to have avoided hosting because it's too cheap (going the bathroom with the cheque arrives, per John Manley)? I would agree with you if you said that Kananaskis or Whistler ought to host, but I'm told those conference facilities might not have sufficed.

  • Anonymous Ontarian

    Remember in the old movie 12 Angry Men when, faced with strong rebuttals of all the evidence in the case, the juror played by Lee J. Cobb just repeats that evidence verbatim as if nothing was ever said against it?

    That's how I feel every time I look at the user comments on a newspaper or magazine's website. Partisan bigots — whatever their political orientation — don't care much for facts. Faced with a good article about how the "fake lake" wasn't much to be upset over after all, people make irreverent replies or move on to a separate topic like they never cared about the fake lake in the first place.

  • Dee

    And after the damage wrought in the summits in Seattle, Quebec City and Genoa, what did Chretien do? He held the G8 summit in Kananaskis. No security problems and smallers costs than holding it in a big city. Too bad Harper and the Conservatives didn't have the smarts to do the obvious. And now Canadian taxpayers are stuck with a bill of over $1 billion.

  • Curt

    Andrew,
    Thanks for the clarification. I always enjoy reading your articles. I might not agree with some but I usually understand the message you are attempting to put forth.
    It could be you London School of Economics training.

  • jeremyrupke

    You think the fake lake was a waste of money….Security was the real money sucker! I was here in Huntsville and there was a police officer every 10 feet, they could have solved every crime in Northern Ontario in one day! They say it was good marketing, but I guess I will have to see. Maybe it will help my friend sell some of his Muskoka chairs :D

From Macleans