Deux Maudits Anglais

Deux Maudits Anglais

Deux Maudits Anglais

Martin Patriquin and Philippe Gohier dissect the latest out of Quebec. Follow Philippe on Twitter: @pgohier

"One of the most incompetent and harmful governments this country has ever known"

by Philippe Gohier on Friday, July 23, 2010 4:43pm - 0 Comments

André Pratte has an absolutely devastating editorial in today’s La Presse, in which he essentially calls for an anti-Harper mutiny by cabinet ministers he otherwise lambastes “for having such a poor handle on their files, they unjustly make the federal government look profoundly incompetent.” You really should go read the thing for yourself, but here are some translated bits:

The controversy surrounding the terms of the census is typical of the pillaging the conservatives have engaged in since coming to power. Not only is their behaviour dictated by simplistic ideology, the Conservatives impose their politics while displaying a exceptional degree of incompetence.

A competent right-wing government would have asked Statistics Canada to do an in-depth comparison of the advantages and disadvantages of mandatory and optional census forms. It would have then submitted the proposed solution to consultation, as is done with all modifications to the census. Instead, the government decided to change its approach in spite of the reservations of Statistics Canada on the sole basis of phone calls to MPs’ constituency offices. School boards are run more seriously than that.

[...]

Before this government does even more harm to the institution that is the government of Canada, the intelligent people within the federal cabinet have a duty to rise up and stop the pillaging. Otherwise, the Harper government may be remembered as one of the most incompetent and harmful governments this country has ever known.

I think it’s probably safe to say Pratte would like to politely withdraw his paper’s 2006 endorsement of the Conservatives.

Bookmark and Share
  • Blacktop

    Pray tell, what does CATEGORE: DEUX MAUDIT ANGLAIS mean?

    Somehow I've heard thelast two wortds.

  • sven

    yeah – getting rid of an intrusive mandatory census is the end of the world as we know it.

    faux outrage gets very tiresome.

    anyway, how about we keep the census and add some questions, like:
    "do you agree that we should kick Quebec out so they can pay their own bills for once?"
    " do you agree that state should bugger off and leave you alone?"

  • Philanthropist

    Hilarious! this bozo would ask Statscan to study Statscan, why not just create another government department to study the first government department, and a multiparty political committee, and hire consultants, and contract a Liberal polling firm, and pass a few envelopes stuffed with cash…….

    Get the government out of the way of Canadians.

    • Orson Bean

      Yes, there is some irony in a Quebecker trying to tell us how to run government efficiently.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/PolJunkie PolJunkie

    "I think it’s probably safe to say Pratte would like to politely withdraw his paper’s 2006 endorsement of the Conservatives."

    Yes indeed.

  • JamesHalifax

    Another Frenchman whining?

    Say it ain't so…..

  • Phil King

    You know, the Conservatives could've eliminated the jail time and kept the fines. If they'd done that I'd bet you they would've come off looking way better than they have on this issue, and may have even gained votes.

    All things being equal, if a fine for simply parking in the wrong spot is acceptable, then surely a fine for not filling out the long form should be equally acceptable right?

    • tedbetts

      According to the Conservatives words, it is not acceptable.

      But according to the Conservatives actions, like on the mandatory short form census and the mandatory agricultural census (both of which carried the threat of jail until the opposition started saying "why not just remove jail time as a threat"), it is not only completely acceptable but good.

  • bluemlein

    leave it to the quebecois, as usual, to speak up unequivocally. the rest of us, one supposes, are too busy being polite.

  • anon

    Harper and the RCMP and local cops make US cops in the past and Bush look like Saints.

  • Tammy

    I am appalled at what Harper is doing to this country. Shameful. WHy was the G20 in toronto? Why were the police behaving like bullies? Why is the country punishing Toronto for arts rather than celebrating what is good? Why did harper take money away from Canadian Women's Centres and then promise money for womens groups in other countries? We all know the G20 promises always break so why did we spend ludicrous amounts of money on this one?

  • MICHAEL HAMPSON

    SCHOOL YARD BULLIES THESE

From Macleans