Beyond The Commons

Beyond The Commons

Aaron Wherry covers all the goings-on in and around Parliament Hill. Follow Aaron on Twitter: @aaronwherry

Toward a total ban on analogy in political rhetoric (II)

by Aaron Wherry on Monday, August 30, 2010 1:33pm - 0 Comments

The policy director of the British Columbia Civil Liberties Association explains why aggregating government data to replace the census would be unfortunate for the basic principle of individual privacy.

The government has said that in addition to the new voluntary National Household Survey, it will rely on existing databases to paint a picture of the Canadian population, but Vonn said that approach is far more worrying than the long-form census.

Citizens’ privacy relies on data in government and private databases existing in silos, she said, but linking them will “create de-facto citizen dossiers that are a privacy Chornobyl waiting to happen.”

On the one hand, the measure outlined here could conceivably lead to a disastrous breakdown—a meltdown, if you will—of citizen privacy whereby a large amount of information is inadvertently released or abused.

On the other hand, in the case of the actual Chernobyl, several dozen people were killed and several thousand were poisoned, while a large area in Ukraine was rendered uninhabitable.

Bookmark and Share
  • Olaf

    I thought you were going to make the point that Chernobyl meltdown can in no way compare to the unmitigated disaster that is the National Household Survey, as the effects of the former will eventually dissipate but the problems associated with the 2011 census can’t ever be fixed.

  • Crit_Reasoning

    The policy director of the British Civil Liberties Association

    British Columbia Civil Liberties Association. For a moment there I thought people in the UK were actually taking an interest in what goes on here.

  • wascally wabbit

    And this Harper government knows that.
    Back in around 2000-2001 the Mike Harris government, of which Jim Flaherty, John Baird and Tony Clement were prominent members spent around $500 million on a project called Smart Card – where they intended to link – guess what – hunting and fishing licence holders with Personal Health Information and drivers information and have it carried on the holder's card with a computer chip in it.
    I can't remember whether Jim Wilson or Elizabeth Witmer was Health minister taking the lead on it – but that initiative fell on its face because the Privacy Commissioner cut them off at the knees!

    • brooster

      "that initiative fell on its face because the Privacy Commissioner cut them off at the knees!"

      Those damned analogies…I swear it's like whack-a-mole around here!

  • LynnTO

    Hey, Wherry – if we can't use analogy in political rhetoric anymore, what are we supposed to rely on?

    Onomatopoeia?

    Facts?

    • McC_

      if it quacks like a duck, it must be…. tax policy!

  • John D

    This will make my life so much easier. I am going to threaten that everything will turn into a <prefix> Chernobyl. If you'll excuse me I have to eat lunch, less there be a hunger Chernobyl.

    • TJCook

      Isn't that funny, I had a bean burrito for lunch and I expect a different kind of Chernobyl later this afternoon :)

  • Standing By

    Banning analogies would be tantamount to, ahh, …

  • Richard_S_Argent

    man, that's some forced rhetoric. It doesn't even really make sense.

    "Disaster" would've worked just fine.

    p.s. Is "Chornobyl" a typo or an alternate spelling?

    • Charles H.

      Alternate spelling, depending on whether you're transliterating from the Russian or the Ukrainian, according to Wiki.

      (I would have guessed "transliterating from non-Latin to Latin alphabets often results in varying spellings," but there you go.)

  • McC_

    The BCCLA? But wait, I'm confused, I thought Aaron Wherry only posted on gotchas of the Conservatives and praise of Michael Ignatieff? Please stop complicating my life!

  • wellwell

    On the strength of this analogy, I think we should appoint Homer Simpson as our new Privacy Commissioner.

    • DBM

      Thus turning a potential privacy Chernobyl into a mere privacy Three Mile Island.

      • Phil

        Which would then actually be several orders of magnitude better.

  • MostlyCivil

    More realistic analogies:

    "de-facto citizen dossiers that are a privacy Jerry Lewis Movie waiting to happen.”

    "de-facto citizen dossiers that are a privacy Sarah Palin Self-Help Book waiting to happen.”

    "de-facto citizen dossiers that are a privacy Joey Bishop Monologue waiting to happen."

From Macleans