Beyond The Commons

Beyond The Commons

Aaron Wherry covers all the goings-on in and around Parliament Hill. Follow Aaron on Twitter: @aaronwherry

A metaphorical cry for help

by Aaron Wherry on Wednesday, September 22, 2010 12:28pm - 0 Comments

One flourish from the Finance Minister’s speech yesterday has since been the cause of particular consternation in the English-speaking world. To wit.

In the global recession, the ship of state has had a difficult voyage. But we can see the harbour lights. And that’s just when a would-be captain and his ragtag crew are trying to storm the bridge. If they seize the wheel, ladies and gentlemen, they’ll have us on the rocks. And that’s not how this voyage should end.

This has been interpreted as a reference to piracy; a suggestion that the opposition parties are like marauding outlaws on the high sea, preparing to board the S.S. Harper and steal all the gold doubloons. These metaphorical pirates would then, either intentionally or drunkenly, crash the ship into the nearest metaphorically rocky shore.

Alternatively, this could be read as a warning of potential mutiny.

In this case, the ship is Parliament and Captain Stephen and his crew are outnumbered by ill-intentioned usurpers who intend to seize control of the wheel (which is to say, the executive branch of government). These metaphorical mutineers will then, either intentionally or drunkenly, crash the ship (which is to say, Canada) into the nearest metaphorically rocky shore (which is to say, socialism).

The latter would seem a metaphorical suggestion of metaphorical treason, which, while serious, is essentially what was said, somewhat less metaphorically, the last time the Conservative ship appeared doomed. The former, while also somewhat criminal, is at least funny in that it involves imagining Michael Ignatieff with an eye patch and a parrot. Either way, one hopes the Finance Minister would at least metaphorically inform the Attorney General of this metaphorical threat.

Bookmark and Share
  • tedbetts

    You aren't the only one to see the piracy metaphor and how ludicrous it is.

  • Emily

    It could also be read as the mutineers in the Con caucus threatening the 'bridge'. LOL

    • CAPS

      We can only wish (or fear – depending on whom).

      • Emily

        Well a caucus revolt was said to be brewing over this arena thing, and they're meeting this week….so anything is possible. Of course it's also possible that Flaherty is just a lousy speaker.

  • Amateur Hour

    The man and his government are an embarrassment to all Canadians.

  • LynnTO

    I think it was just a call to action to support an expanded naval presence on our great lakes. After all, the Canadian Navy is celebrating its centennial this year.

    • Jan

      So they will be restoring that old boat in Clement's riding.

    • CAPS

      Stephen Harper is going to increasing the naval presence on our Great Lakes. Canadian lakes. Boats with guns. On our lakes.

      In Canada (and shared with the States).

      We might be making this up.

  • danby

    rag tag crew

    I "see" your ragtag crew and raise you one Tony Clement

    • tedbetts

      I would not call that a "raise".

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Ottawa_Centrist Ottawa_Centrist

    Mutiny is probably the most rampant unreported crime in this country.

  • TJCook

    Flaherty has a pretty low opinion of Canada's democracy.

    • tedbetts

      And Canadians.

  • brooster

    If there is a mutiny, I hope they swab the poop deck. It's 'way overdue.

  • Leigh

    It might have been more entertaining for the audience forced to listen to such drivel if he'd thrown in a few 'ahoy me mateys, avasts, arrrhhhs, and shiver me timbers.

    • Dave

      And a couple of yo-ho-ho's.

      Of course, he's already got a good start, with a caucus full of talking-points spouting parrots behind him.

    • Sigh

      Or at least wore a parrot on his shoulder.

  • John W.

    These Harris/ Harper tough guys like Flaherty relish striking fear in the hearts of opponents and even innocent bystanders in the federal civil service, but being laughed at and mocked may not have been part of Giorno's plan. When people start thinking you're a joke it's not good.

  • Mike T.

    To further torture the metaphor, it was the "mutineers" who set the course, above the objections of the current captain, who claimed that if there were rocks on the voyage they would have been made apparent earlier.

  • tedbetts

    It was also the current Captain who left port in the middle of a gale and claimed that it would be clear sailing and, later, that no one saw the change in the weather coming.

  • BCer in Mtl

    The captain says: "If there were rocks we would have hit them by now"

  • Richard_S_Argent

    At least Ig-beard the Pirate wouldn't even need an eye patch – he could just pull down one eyebrow! :)

  • lgarvin

    Not to forget that the current Captain has also scuttled his own ship – twice already – seemingly on nothing more than a whim and a wish to "recalibrate."

    I think that I'll follow the example of that pretty Keira Knightley and throw in with the pirates.

  • Andrew (not PorC)

    We have a winner!

  • Holly Stick

    Like the Titanic, they turned right when they should have turned left.

From Macleans