Beyond The Commons

Beyond The Commons

Aaron Wherry covers all the goings-on in and around Parliament Hill. Follow Aaron on Twitter: @aaronwherry

Promises, guarantees and projections

by Aaron Wherry on Tuesday, October 12, 2010 1:51pm - 0 Comments

Stephen Harper, October 14, 2008Our election platform is not full of grandiose, costly promises. It’s a prudent approach. We can afford it. We’ll never go back into deficit.

Jim Flaherty, November 27, 2008No government at any level can guarantee the future. In fact, given so much uncertainty, no one could unconditionally guarantee the fiscal projections contained in today’s statement … Today’s statement lays out a plan that keeps our budget balanced for now. However, in the weeks ahead we will determine the extent to which we will inject additional stimulus to our economy, joining the efforts of our international partners.

Jim Flaherty, January 27, 2009. Our government projects a budget deficit of $34 billion for the next fiscal year; and $30 billion the year after that … By 2011 we project the deficit will fall to $13 billion; by 2012 it will fall to $7.3 billion. By 2013 we project a return to surplus, and for that year, a surplus of $700 million.

Jim Flaherty, todayBy winding down the Action Plan as the economy recovers and implementing the savings measures announced in Budget 2010, the deficit is projected to decline from $55.6 billion in 2009–10 to $29.8 billion in 2011–12, and to a small deficit of $1.7 billion in 2014–15. By 2015–16, the federal budget is projected to record a small surplus of $2.6 billion.

Bookmark and Share
  • http://www.TennisVagabond.com Big Dave S

    What do you expect when the Opposition leader openly criticizes our economic policies? Ignatieff should wear that 55 Billion emblazoned in red on his forehead for all eternity, or whatever time he has left in his visit.

    • Silly_Walks

      Brilliant satire or utter rubbish…

      • http://intensedebate.com/people/Ottawa_Centrist Ottawa_Centrist

        Don't question, just applaud.

      • http://www.TennisVagabond.com Big Dave S

        How do you get 10 thumbs up and I get zero?
        Did Iggy say something about me?

        • Silly_Walks

          No, but criticizing the OPPOSITION leader for opposing the Government policies is sort of like criticizing a garbage man for picking up the trash. Further suggesting that said opposition has somehow raised the deficit, or created it in the first place is absurd.

          • http://www.TennisVagabond.com Big Dave S

            Ah, you decided on "Utter rubbish" then!

          • Silly_Walks

            If I've run afoul of Poe's law, I apologize.

  • Emily

    The clueless amateurs march on.

  • Richard_S_Argent

    I absolutely hate how cynical these Conservatives have made me – there is literally nothing that comes out of their mouths that I believe…espeically anything involving fiscal policy.

    • Joh

      "literally nothing"? Well, may I suggest you cease with the drama and exaggerations and join the rest of us in the land of the reasonable, and then perhaps you will see things a bit more clearly.

  • bergkamp

    "The Five-Year Plans for the National Economy of the Soviet Union were a series of nation-wide centralised exercises in rapid economic development in the Soviet Union." Wiki

    Here's hint for Cons – you are on wrong track if we can't tell difference between Cons and Commies.

    I also think Flaherty is learning from global warming believers – keep on kicking can down the road and your numbers never have to be correct. Sure our numbers don't look good now or next year but we are going to be most productive place on earth in just a few short years and no one can claim otherwise.

  • Anon 001

    And yet, the Liberals keep voting confidence. Over and over and freaking over again!

    • Emily

      With the polls always at 50/50 pretty much, they don't have much choice.

      • Orson Bean

        Actually, they do. It's called "growing a pair".

        • Emily

          Ahhh the old faith in 'manhood' comes up again.

          Sorry, this isn't a bar brawl.

          • Dave

            It might be a locker room though.

          • tedbetts

            Or kindergarden playground at recess.

          • Emily

            LOL well I can't see how anyone can criticize Iggy for this….the last time he mentioned an election his poll numbers nosedived, and as he said he got the message that Canadians didn't want an election 'loud and clear'

  • LynnTO

    At what point did the Conservatives stop believing that things have to be plausible to be taken to heart, and instead take up the line that things just have to be said by them in order to be possible?

    Good lord. Based on what will our economy increase in size and productivity such that the government will be able to project a surplus of more than triple what it did a year ago?

    • Emily

      He's waiting for oil to make a come-back.

  • TJCook

    For his entire political career, Jim Flaherty has a plan to return to fiscal balance in five years.

  • peter

    The entire western world is in the clutches of crooked bankers who have formulated tax and spend policies for decades peddaled with glee to moron socialists , because it makes them money. Now a government that is "the fiscal envy of the world" that hates these policies is sucked into them with a gun literally to the head of our economy and we are criticized by pack of fools who backed Iggy and jack when they said "borrow more, spend more" and now you have the gall to criticize the deficits which are billions less than they would have been under either of the other two? Now you hate the government because it is doing what you advocated? Your ignorance and hypocrisy are matched only by your self-righteousness.

    • Emily

      Oh DO be serious.

      • craigola

        Seconded.

    • http://www.TennisVagabond.com Big Dave S

      Actually, literally, our economy doesn't have a head or a gun. So I think you meant "metaphorically" but you could have just left the disclaimer out altogether, since most people understand that there is no head or gun, literally.

  • brooster

    I pine for the good ol' days when the federal government repeatedly missed its forecasts by underestimating their surpluses.

  • Tceh

    Flaherty is not particularly good at this "economics" thing.

    More fodder: http://caiti-online.blogspot.com/2010/10/harpers-…

From Macleans