Canada’s most dangerous cities

See where your city ranks in terms of homicide, sexual assault, and other crimes

by macleans.ca on Thursday, October 14, 2010 3:30pm - 0 Comments

The West claimed the worst top 10 slots, as it did 10 years ago, when seven B.C. cities and three in Saskatchewan came in worst. Ontario and Quebec dominate the good list.

Maclean's 2010 - National Crime Rankings

WORST CITIES PERCENTAGE ABOVE THE NATIONAL CRIME SCORE
Prince George, B.C. +90%
Victoria, B.C. 81
Regina, Sask. 73
Saskatoon, Sask. 69
Fort McMurray, Alta. 68
Kelowna, B.C. 65
Grande Prairie, Alta. 64
Surrey, B.C. 60
Chilliwack, B.C. 58
Winnipeg, Man. 57
BEST CITIES PERCENTAGE BELOW THE NATIONAL CRIME SCORE
Caledon, Ont. -70%
Wellington County, Ont. 58
Halton Region, Ont. 58
Lévis, Que. 51
Nottawasaga, Ont. 50
York Region, Ont. 49
Richelieu Saint-Laurent, Que. 48
South Simcoe, Ont. 44
Vaudreuil-Soulange MRC, Que. 44
Blainville, Que. 42

Sources: 2009 and 1999 Crime Severity Index data from the Canadian Centre for Justice Statistics, Maclean’s

See where your city ranks

METHODOLOGY: Maclean’s obtained annual crime data from Statistics Canada for municipal police services serving the nation’s 100 largest populations, each encompassing a city or town of at least 10,000 people. Using 2009 rates per 100,000 people for six crimes—homicide, sexual assault, aggravated assault, vehicle theft, robbery plus breaking and entering—in each area, Maclean’s calculated the percentage difference from the national rate. The overall crime score ranking for the 100 communities was created in consultation with StatsCan, using its Crime Severity Index (CSI) score and calculating the percentage difference from the national CSI score.

Bookmark and Share
  • Anonoymous

    Grande Prairie !? Really .. ?

  • Rita

    I grew up in the hood, and all i hear is how bad everything is. Really? you think? All i hear is the sentences the police need this and that. Did anyone stop and think hey lets nip the problem before it gets outa hand? Start anti racism, funded training, youth centers that encourage the youth not shun them. I didnt ever have a helping hand nor did my friends that are now killing each other over this messed up town. Do u actually think they could get a job? Theres no work and people drink like so many people do in P.G. How about the government tries to make P.G a more livable place and start with the people running the businesses and schools. I had teachers tell me I would never amount to anything because I stood up for myself and wouldn't let the authority tell me i was another statistic. Educate the people, listen to the youth were screaming for help but everyones to drunk pointing the finger at whos at fault.

  • nic

    Well after reading this, I'm not bothered at all, infact I'd much rather live back in Canada..and that is what I plan on doing…I've been over here in the Uk for the last 10 years and believe me, its garbage..I've lived in the lower mainland(PoCo) and Calgary and in eastern ontario..and not once did I have any problems in all the years spent living in Canada…

  • Riley

    WOOOOO! PRINCE GORGOE IS NUMBER ONE!!! I feel so Bad*** since I live in Prince. I am actually sick and tired of all the crime. Gosh people are dumb. Like…what does murder, rape, stealing, assault and all the other stuff show people? That your a messed up person who needs to be locked up…or beaten…or have done to him what he/she does to people. Thats what i think ahould happen. I think is someone rapes someone, I think the person that man/woman raped. should be aloud to rip the balls and penis off the man who raped that person. Than the rapist should be able to walk with no charge. He ain't rappin anyone again! Sorry, that was waaaay over the top. Anyways. I agree with Stacy, we can't be number one. I'm 16 and I live my life percetly fine in Prince.

  • Ivan Litvinov

    how about ranking actual "cities" (Toronto, Montreal, Ottawa, Vancouver, Calgary….)? The only city that I see on that list is Winnipeg….

  • Step5555

    See that huge "OVERALL BY RANK" list? Click it.

  • rotti

    So Victoria isn't a city? Kelowna isn't a city? But Winnipeg is? What's your definition of a "city" anything east of the Rockies? East of Saskatchewan?

  • mcm

    You're really retarded, I'm sorry but you are. I don't even live in Canada and I can tell the cities.

  • david

    no kidding…with Edmonton having 19 homicides already this year

  • Oleg

    I am happy to live close to Caledon.
    I believe lot or yours know who is Julian Fantino. I've red his biography "Duty, the life of the cop". Despite the book is written by very casual language he clearly indicated the problems of our society. He brought attention of readers for few problems : bugdet,of correctional institutions, gun control, court system and some apathy to the problem of somebody else.

  • Guest

    I don't understand… how come the map and the table don't exactly match? Apparently the NWT and Nunavut have terrible crime averages and yet no mention. Not even of Yellowknife. And then Manitoba only has one city on there despite having a higher percent than BC.
    And then Grande Prairie… i mean, Edmonton has had more murders this year and still, we are higher?
    Is it per capita? Because that would explain why the east does so well. There is so many people there that it throws the average off.

  • Giggle

    Gotta laugh over this one! I have 2 big brothers: The eldest has lived in Point Gray in Vancouver & now Bowen Island. The other one lives in Oak Bay in Victoria. Victoria Bro is constantly telling EVERYONE how great Victoria is. This is humble pie for you Patrick! And the family debate goes on…. :) LOL!

  • John D

    Translation: Julian Fantino wanted more money

  • Russell Barth

    the ways to reduce crime is to fund housing, education, social programs, sports/art/music for kids, and health care.

    Harper will deal with crime by hiring cops and building jails that a third of the country can live in.

    God – yes, GOD – bless Canada.

  • Joe

    C"MON, DO YOU THINK YOU GUYS IN THE EAST ARE ANGELS !!!!!!
    I AM NOT SAYING THAT IN THE WEST PEOPLE ARE, BUT A LOT OF CRIME HAPPENS OUT EAST !!! ONCE AGAIN MCLEANS FAVORS THE EAST !!!!! GOD, I CAN'T STAND YOUR BIASES !!!!

  • Albthe01

    To say that the east is safer than the west could probably be summed up as follows; all of their criminals had moved out west to take advantage of the economic boom, and then could not afford to move back home after the economy tanked.

  • DerekPearce

    Maybe crime is higher in the West because you're all SHOUTING at one another?

  • jimmy

    Anyone or anything that is going to tell us that kelowna and Victoria are more dangerous than Toronto is full of crap,the non-white population does not trust the police(and for good reason)and will not report or assist them into solving the street gangs,home invasions,mugging,pimping and sexual assaults crowd whom emanate in disproportionate amount out of there communities

  • true north

    LOL…Good one !

  • Joe

    I'M SHOUTING AT THE EAST, YOU ARROGANT SOBs THINKING THAT YOU ARE ALL ANGELS AND BETTER THAN ANY OTHER PROVINCES

  • Jason

    Um have you even been to Toronto? Typical BC ignoramous.

  • Tyler

    Again, what's with people calling them Indians? What is this, Texas? It's not even that the term offends me. Ok, it's not JUST that the term offends me. More that anything, it's just confusing. In Victoria, from what I can tell, actual Indians outnumber the natives. You could refer to people from India as "east Indian", but why must they get an extra word in their title just because Chris Columbus was a jackass? They were Indian first. It's about time they got that term back.

  • Jimbob

    this article seems setup, maybe Prince George City council is in on this to get Prince George more funding for police or some other not so obvious reason

    Prince George is also one of the last cities in BC to still have Fluoride in the water…we get medicated here only 3% of the province still does this…wonder if thats correlated

    There was a news article about how the Harper government employs people to monitor and respond like "real people" on forums/youtube/ so I'd expect they are on here to speaking Propaganda

    Google search: harper government monitoring online chats

  • Bonbon

    The Good the Bad and the Ugly , I believed It never seen change over 1000 years. It'd happened more or less crime in the world. HA HA HA WHAT "S A BEAUTIFUL = Balance?

  • Guest

    So you labled Toronto safer that some of the other Canadian cities?
    What the? I've lived in the GTA my entire life and every day there's crime going on here. Get your facts right! Oh so I guess now I can feel safer because Toronto made #57 on the list? What a bunch of #@%!

  • diviaknorth

    Hello readers, moderator,

    Our youth fully exploits without a second thought as to rest of us the liberal system including social safety nets and this circle widens with our own inaction and without our notice and we point at RCMP, the kind judicial system, our extreme individual and liberal rights, easy go peezy-happy go lucky attitude, our food banks (wherein we shamelessly send our already fatigued and hard worked elders and retired making them feel ashamed having worked so long just to wait in food bank line-ups-in fact our youth should roll up their sleeves and get their due share at their door steps) and fall prey for immediate and get rich quick schemes, street drugs and the list is endless.

    I am also ashamed that the present government had a about turn face when it came to recent voting on long-gun registry. This pondered me for a long time as to how a responsible individual can tell people and the law system two opposing things at the same time.

    The police system we take for granted is always on the line and if you had closely observed "put their lives and families at risk and mind you they do not have the same safety back-ups as the firemen do". If we want our fathers, mothers, children, sisters and brothers protected we better obey the laws.

    Drugs might get you high momentarily but it takes away all your hard work you earned hitherto and we will fall in the same food bank line-up.

    These days it is a very rare sight that a grandpa walking with a grand daughter hand-in-hand or that a grand son flying a kite and the grand father watching sitting on a park bench nearby.

    Retirement means we all become aged and expect fruits to ripen and accessible to pluck and enjoy.

    In my mind it is more peaceful and respectful to accept challenges in earning our bread and butter which is over thousand times easy in Canada !

    Which one do we need and want ?

  • Rapha

    The GTA has over 8 million people. For 8 million people, the GTA is pretty damn safe for the few stories you hear on a daily basis. That is the point of this report. To show that smaller cities/towns in Canada are getting more dangerous because the criminals are dispersing to these rural areas.

  • jimmyinstthomas

    I live in St Thomas Ontario, not listed, but about 35,000 people. We have a lot of out of work people here, (and Chatham down the road which is listed) and we don't seem to have any of the problems listed in PG and other cities. One, we have a great police presence. The seem fair, and they are very visible. I'm definitely not an angel and I have no beefs with them. There are no gang issues that I have ever heard of. No drug zone (of course there are drugs here, there are drugs everywhere) and no dangerous area in town. Perhaps there IS a real problem with BC/Alberta/Northern Canada crime and police policies…..

  • hpcmpr

    Grew up in Victoria then moved abroad in 1994. We moved back in 2008 and definitely didn't feel safe in the downtown core, particularly at night it had a somewhat ominous feel. We moved to Montreal in 2009 and can't believe how much "safer" it feels. We can walk around downtown and in our neighbourhood any time day or night and feel very safe. It's great not having to worry when we go out – we definitely feel our quality of life is better here, largely because of this.

  • YYZ

    Umm hello? Guest says there is crime EVERYDAY in the GTA. Why are you bringing facts into the argument?

  • Joe

    GTA IS A BUNCH OF RUDE PARASITES LIKE YOU !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • wunderbank

    Flouride in the water connected to crime!!??!! Are you kidding right now? Why not just say the pulp mill smell causes the crime, or perhaps falling snow makes people want to commit crimes?!!?! Keep your stupid musings and conspiracy websites to yourself next time.

  • wunderbank

    Maybe you can ask your god to help you with that haircut—

    —Why do you god lovers always have to put a religious spin on everything? If your god was real, why not give all homeless people and the poor a leg up? Because your god is a manelovant prick that sees fit for people to suffer. Yep-he's a good one. This comment enrages me more than the "Indian" comments below

  • bag a Gangbanger

    you said it Jeff ! THEY sure stand out more than any others in PG…so those are the real facts its the truth and people pull your heads outta your ass and admit the the facts…man we need some real stats on what ethnic groups are causing this crap in PG…

  • Sco-Town

    haha fort McMurray thats all the scotians and newfies,

    but this all depends on the crime reported theres there is a very large amount of unreported crime in NS I think thats cuz of the blacks and the greasy whites follow. People dont realize it but nova scotia has the largest black (ex-slaves not immigrints) population in canada and it has ghettos very similar to the american ones rural and urban

    PS Scotians I'm not hating but I'm telling it like it is im not gunna lie

From Macleans