Beyond The Commons

Beyond The Commons

Aaron Wherry covers all the goings-on in and around Parliament Hill. Follow Aaron on Twitter: @aaronwherry

The Commons: The minister walks away

by Aaron Wherry on Thursday, November 4, 2010 9:48pm - 0 Comments

A few minutes after three he appeared from behind the gold curtains and strode down to his seat in the front row of the government side, a blue folder in one hand. Unfortunately, Peter MacKay was already in that seat, the Defence Minister having taken advantage of Jim Prentice’s absence from Question Period to sidle over for a chat with the Prime Minister.

Mr. MacKay moved over one spot to the right and Mr. Prentice claimed the seat that would be his for at least a few more minutes. He exchanged a few pleasant words with the Prime Minister. Mr. MacKay extended his right hand and Mr. Prentice shook it. As the final moments of QP played out, Mr. Prentice opened his blue folder and reviewed the text, typed out neatly on a few pages of white paper, that was contained therein.

The Speaker drew the attention of members to the presence in the gallery of Mr. Phillip Bradbourn, chairman of the Delegation for Relations with Canada of the European Parliament. Members applauded. This being a Thursday, the Speaker called on the opposition House leader to stand and ask the government House leader to inform the House as to how the government intends to proceed with its legislative agenda when business resumes after next week’s break.

Then finally, after John Baird had finished wishing everyone a productive constituency week, Mr. Prentice, took a sip of water, nodded at the Speaker and rose on a point of order.

“Mr. Speaker, after meeting with the Ethics Commissioner today, I have informed the Prime Minister that I am resigning from cabinet effective immediately,” Mr. Prentice explained. “Furthermore, I will be resigning as the member of Parliament for Calgary Centre-North by the end of 2010.”

Well then.

This had already seemed a particularly odd week, what with the capital being positively gripped by something called Potash, Tony Clement thus charged with rendering, apparently single-handedly, a profoundly meaningful decision about this Potash and the reasoning for that decision then deemed top secret for the next month. And now this—a quite unexpected twist reported just moments before Mr. Prentice appeared in the House.

“When I entered federal politics in 2001, I made a commitment that my time in politics would last 8 to 10 years,” Mr. Prentice continued. “It has now, remarkably, been nine years, and it is time for me to pursue new opportunities outside of public life.”

The minister was as sharply styled as always, in this case in a dark suit and white shirt with french cuffs. He has always looked and sounded the part of a man who approaches the part with a certain seriousness. And now he had apparently found a new part with a new kind of seriousness.

“I have, therefore, today,” he said, “accepted a position with the Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce as the vice-chairman of the bank and as the senior executive vice-president of the bank effective January 1, 2011.”

He rubbed his hands together as he spoke, perhaps a touch nervous. He has generally seemed a talented combatant in the House, self-assured without being insufferable, aggressive without being vicious. He could finely dismiss an opposition query, but I recall most of all his rising on a point of order some two years ago to other a rather eloquent apology for his use of the letters “B” and “S” and in too close proximity.

So he was talented, well-spoken and well-dressed. And as such he was considered a potential successor to Mr. Harper. And now, for whatever reason, he was taking his leave, honouring his party, his government, his constituents and his Prime Minister as he concluded his farewell. By 3:09pm, he was done—leaving everyone plenty of time to speculate as to why.

After a standing ovation from all sides and a long procession of well-wishers, the Prime Minister rose and offered his warm thanks. Representatives from the opposition parties followed suit—graciously withholding their questions about the ethical concerns raised by his departure and future place of work until they were out in the foyer.

“Like many other colleagues in this place, we share a great respect for our friend. While we have sometimes disagreed on particular issues, he has always held himself to a high standard of dignity when representing his government’s views on whatever issues,” New Democrat Nathan Cullen said on behalf of his side. “I congratulate him on an important decision he had to make just recently that I think was positive for all of us. It is often a place where we do not get to address the personal here. The House of Commons can be a difficult place for that, but at this moment I think it is an expression on behalf of all New Democrats that we wish our colleague the very best of luck in his future endeavours and that his family warmly welcomes him back from something a little bit more of a regular life.”

Bookmark and Share
  • Emily

    Smoooooth move.

    And he may well be back.

    • lenny

      Back? His predecessor at CIBC pulled in 2.7 million last year.
      He just collected his reward for years of faithful service to his corporate masters.
      He ain't coming back.

      • Emily

        The chance to be PM is a strong lure.

  • Chris B

    I wonder if it doesn't reveal question period to be even more of a game that when someone retires or gets ill or whatever, there is this kind of outpouring. Are they being insincere the rest of the time or now? Or is it just politeness? But then they don't care about politeness the rest of the time.

    Nevertheless, I am glad that they can maintain decorum in the house occasionally, even if it is insincere.

    • Emily

      Well it's a unique job, and there are only 308 of them so there's a certain camraderie there that crosses party lines. They do their jobs and all, but they also attend each other's weddings and bar mitzvahs….and all the social parties and so on.

    • MarionKl

      I think we mistakenly assume that there is no separation between political views and personal relationships. MPs are co-workers even if they belong to opposing parties, and while nobody likes all their co-workers, I'm sure they can respect/like other MPs for a variety of reasons, even if they don't see eye to eye politically.

      • Orson Bean

        I'm dating myself here I know, but it kind of reminds me of that classic old Warner Bros/Bugs Bunny cartoon, in which the coyote and sheep dog fight, claw and rip the sh*t out of each other all day long, and then punch their time cards at the end of the day and walk home from work like they're best buddies.

        • MarionKl

          I haven't seen that cartoon since I was a kid, but yeah, that is a good analogy.

        • danby

          One thing about dating yourself: It's always your turn to pick up the tab – but it costs less ;)

        • Dot

          Don't forget to mention the sheep.

    • pivnick

      Jim Prentice might just represent a special case, worthy of more then the usual sending off. He was one of the last strong PC members of the COnservative party, and is probably the strongest MP of the government. He departure is lamentable for Canadian politics.

      Good Luck Mr. Prentice!

      See you in a few years as a Conservative Leader Candidate…?

  • Dot

    Walk gently with a big schtick.

    • Emily

      A reference to the Battle of the Yiddish no doubt.

      • Dot

        Oy!

        • Emily

          Heh heh

  • TwoYen

    Prentice was one of the strongest ministers in Cabinet. He will be sorely missed. I wish him well.

  • Taxslave

    So why couldn't he have resigned before he screwed B.C. out of a new copper mine? One that already had provincial approval.

  • Dot

    As Environment Minister, he won certain victories – expanding Canada’s national parks – but was regularly shelled for the government’s inaction on international climate-change treaties and loose standards on oil sands development. Roger Gibbins, head of Calgary’s Canada West Foundation, called Mr. Prentice the “best energy minister that western Canada has ever had,” referring to his hands-off approach to the oil sands.
    http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/politics/pren…

  • Holly Stick

    "…Sure, he continued as Stephen Harper's mouthpiece, inevitably having to take responsibility for the actions of a governing party that thinks climate change is a good thing (it gets makes it easier to get to Arctic gas and oil). But at least Prentice had the decency to look like he was embarrassed by the role…"
    http://www.desmogblog.com/environment-minister-pr…

  • pivnick

    Put in a position where he is the mouth piece for bad policy. Wasn't going anywhere fast with that portfolio…

From Macleans