Beyond The Commons

Beyond The Commons

Aaron Wherry covers all the goings-on in and around Parliament Hill. Follow Aaron on Twitter: @aaronwherry

In memoriam

by Aaron Wherry on Tuesday, November 9, 2010 2:27pm - 24 Comments

The concept of ministerial accountability was born on the morning of May 25, 2010, invoked so as to protect ministerial staff from having to testify before parliamentary committees. It lived a short, but fitful life.

The concept was injured slightly in October when a member of Christian Paradis’ staff resigned after meddling in access to information requests, but Minister Paradis himself went unpunished. It was wounded again days later when Mr. Paradis did not answer questions on the matter in the House. The concept was emboldened somewhat when the official opposition declined a confrontation on the matter, but, sadly, it sustained serious injuries weeks later when Rona Ambrose, rising to answer about events involving Mr. Paradis, explicitly directed questions to the public service.

Undaunted, but now doomed, ministerial accountability clung to some semblance of hypothetical existence until last night when a member of the Prime Minister’s Office, an individual who had steadfastly avoided a summons to appear before a parliamentary committee, turned up on the evening chat shows to explain the government’s thoughts on the future of this nation’s military mission in Afghanistan.

Though only briefly in existence, the concept of ministerial accountability will be remembered for the accountability it theoretically conceptualized and for the heightened discourse it so fleetingly visited upon Parliament Hill.

Bookmark and Share
  • bergkamp

    " … turned up on the evening chat shows to explain the government’s thoughts on the future of this nation’s military mission in Afghanistan."

    This is disgraceful but not unexpected from these numpties that call themselves a Government.

    I didn't watch the talk shows yesterday but did the hosts happen to ask Soudas why he was making this announcement on tv and why wasn't the PM telling us about the policy change in Parliament?

    Harper/Cons are pathetic, they are afraid of their own shadow.

  • Geiseric

    The men can only see him when he's not in.

  • bennji1977

    It is not that easy to understand – it is always the fault of
    a) A political staffer
    b) A unionized public servant
    c) The previous Liberal government(s) of Trudeau, Chretien or Martin
    d) The unelected, unaccountable senate
    e) The biased MSM
    f) The Toronto Elites
    g) The Russians

    Never, I repeat NEVER is the fault of any member of the current government or a member of the crown (unless of course your name is Bernier or Guergis)

    • brooster2

      How could you forget h) the coalition?

    • Pat

      (d) stopped applying once the unelected unaccountable senate became conservative dominated.

      Much like the way the phrase "unelected unaccountable senate" disappeared from all conservative talking points.

      • bennji1977

        Yes, but they still have to use it to explain why so many of their crimes bills have to be reintroduced in the HOC.

        Of course the real reason that they are back to the drawing board on some much of this is Harper's perogie # 2 – but, that would imply some degree of culpability on their end…..so, the only logical explanation is to blame the senate.

  • John W.

    The role of the Press Secretary as an official spokesperson for the Pres/PM/Gov't is another Americanization of our politics by the Harper group who see themselves as the Executive branch which from time to time has to deal with a distant unstable squabbling Congress.
    The Ottawa media has agreed to go along with this because it makes the news gathering process easier. It gets really amusing when Evan Solomon reads emails from, Dimitri Soudas right off his Blackberry and live on the air. No other news personality or organization that I know of with the exception of the late Mike Duffy has ever gone this low. But I suppose they are all headed there.
    Susan Delacourt has tried to expose some of this on her blog in the last few days.

  • LdKitchenersOwn

    Is it possible that this is all simply a misunderstanding? Perhaps the Prime Minister and the Minister of National Defence simply haven't been informed of the change in our Afghanistan policy yet.

    Soudas is a very busy man after all. Maybe he figured Harper and McKay would just find out about it on T.V. like everyone else.

    • tobyornotoby

      Yeah, like the prime minister can't afford cable!

      • danby

        He cannot only afford it, it's becoming his byword – provided you prefix it with despi

      • tedbetts

        He doesn't need to. Why do you think the PMO budget has gone up 30%?

        Rogers HDTV VIP packages and cable boxes in every room of 24 Sussex and every office at the PMO and the Conservative war room/government communications department.

    • Sigh

      I thought the PM didn't watch Canadian TV.

  • gottabesaid

    Quite frankly, I'm disgusted. Here you all are, led by Wherry, debating the fine points of ministerial accountability, when there are Russians violating our airspace, Tamil terrorists knocking at our doors, unreported criminals on the prowl, police officers plotting to take our long guns, thug-huggers looking to give Omar Khadr a free pass, and (I think I'm gonna puke in my mouth) census takers ready to violate our liberty. And, for the love of all that is decent and holy, the pandas are coming! And you people are talking about ministerial accountability? The Conservatives are the only ones standing between us and The Evil. Stop questioning them, and start supporting the troops!

    • PeterboroDave

      Cats away!

      Cats says we ne….

      oh, nevermind.

    • sourstud

      This is what you call "debating"? I've seen one serious comment here.

      • TJCook

        I think you just cancelled out the one "serious"comment.

  • http://www.TennisVagabond.com Big Dave S

    Nice post. Though you have to give Harper some credit for it.

  • Matt

    The same Conservatives who rail about the "MSM" should note the easy ride Dimitri Soudas is given by the cable poltical shows. Why do you need Sun TV when you have Evan Solomon content to let Dimitri recite his talking points unchallenged?

    • John W.

      Susan Delacourt suggests the Ottawa media think they need the PMO in order to do their jobs.
      I guess this means means they need PMO to compete with each other, so PMO has them in a sort of endless loop. Nobody has the guts to say, ok stuff it PMO, we'll just get all these big scoops last! Instead they all crawl and beg for every scrap. Pitiful really.

  • MostlyCivil

    With apologies to William Hughes Mearns, a Dimitri poem:

    Antagonist:

    Yesterday upon the air
    I saw a man who wasn’t there
    He wasn’t there again today
    How will we know he's gone away?

    • tobyornotoby

      Awesome, but I still miss Jack.

    • Sigh

      I wish, I wish, he’d go away

  • Out There

    Unfortunately spinal fluid seems to be in short supply for Canadian media organizations. They send reporters to anonymous briefings, allow themselves to be manipulated again and again, and now they are turning the main manipulator into some kind of celebrity famous for being hired by someone famous.

    I agree with your analysis, but I see two problems that Canadian media organizations face:

    - A media organization that calls the Tories on their BS will likely be shut out of press briefings and whatnot. And, for better or worse, what the government does is news, even if the government is just being manipulative. A media outlet that is frozen out by the Conservatives risks losing viewers or readers to more compliant outlets. Journalistic integrity is a wonderful thing (seriously), but sadly in this day and age it may lead to bankruptcy.

    - Media organizations are short-staffed. (This is possibly due to overemphasis on the bottom line, but that's a separate issue.) So they probably don't have enough person-hours available to do anything other than accept what they're given and try to get something done before deadline.

  • http://www.pogge.ca/ pogge

    Does this mean I can once again look forward to the arrest of Dimitri Soudas for dodging a subpoena? These days I take my joy where I can find it.

From Macleans