John Geddes

John Geddes

John Geddes writes on politics and policy, with occasional reporting and comment on arts and culture.

Stacy Bonds on police abuse: listen and marvel

by John Geddes on Sunday, November 28, 2010 12:04pm - 129 Comments

Would anybody blame Stacy Bonds—the Ottawa theatrical makeup artist who was arrested for no good reason by the city’s police, then abused in custody in the most outrageous manner—if she suspected the fact that she’s black influenced her mistreatment? Would anybody think Bonds, 27, was out of line if she roundly denounced the cops?

Yet in her first interview since this episode came to light, she does neither. “I don’t want to make it into a big black-white issue,” she tells the Ottawa Citizen’s Gary Dimmock. “I think it’s more an issue of questioning authority and I’d like to tell people don’t be afraid to ask police questions.”

To those angry at police in general on her behalf, Bonds offers this more balanced thought: “People do need to know that police do abuse their power, and people need to speak out. But there are a lot of great cops out there, too, and people need to know that.”

For anyone who isn’t up on the story, these measured words come from a woman who was questioned by police as she was walking home from a party a couple of years ago, and when she asked why she had been stopped, was arrested. Down at the station, they pulled her hair, kneed her in the back, cut off her clothes, and left her half naked in a cell for hours.

A judge who saw security videotape of the ordeal called what he saw an “indignity,” noted that Bonds showed no sign of violence or aggression, and tossed out the absurd charges against her. Ottawa Police Chief Vern White has called the sordid incident appalling. The officers involved are being investigated by a provincial government agency.

Bonds seems reticent about the spotlight, which is, of course, fine. She didn’t choose to be a public figure. But if she keeps talking in the dignified, admirable way she does in today’s Citizen story, we might have no choice but to make her a bit of hero.

Bookmark and Share
  • Lee_JD

    Oh yes, the police are so brave, the five of them taking on a woman who weighs all of 100 lb. By your comment, it would seem that you are also a cowardly police officer who hides behind his badge. Or did you mean something else by your comment?

    • John D

      I think he was being sarcastic

      • Lee_JD

        I hope so. If he was it was a little too subtle for me.

  • Canadian

    The Ottawa Police Chief should resign or be fired. Too much wrongdoing has recently come to light and it all happened under his watch.

  • dan,Vancouver

    I'm sure the Taliban are eager and waiting to infiltrate the Harper/Rae/Ignatieff training-camps in Afghanistan and pick up on all the best, latest, and most enlightened police methods.

    Tasering people in airports, beating Vancouver immigrants' faces to a half-blinded pulp…

    Makes you proud to be a Canadian.

    • Jim T

      Almost as proud as it made me as I watched masked protestors smash windows, burn cars, assault people, and destroy hard working businesses in the name of “social justice”, “climate change” or whatever other nonsense they were using as an excuse for their crimes.

      • Holly Stick

        Funy, the cops were watching that too; they sure did not try to stop it; it made such a good photo op as an excuse for them the next day to arrest, threaten and beat peaceful protestors and innocent bystanders who were not protestors.

  • John D

    The question I would like answered is: What does it take for a cop to get fired in this country? I bet most if not all of the cops involved in this episode will keep their jobs.

  • thenonconformer

    Just the tip of a big iceberg too

    If you read my blog, or my cartoons the last few years you would clearly have noted that I had rightfully for ages now said and clearly detailed even too as to why that wrongfully too many of Canada’s police, RCMP, politicians, justice ministers, civil and public servants, doctors and nurses, so called professionals and their regulating bodies as well are bad, pretentious, unacceptable and they and their supervisors should be immediately fired, terminated now too http://thenonconformer.wordpress.com/

  • amandaburnett

    I admire Ms. Bonds for her choice of words in this article because if they did to me what they did to her, i might have difficulty being so polite. It also crossed my mind whether this was a race issue, and if the same thing would have occured if she was blonde haired and blue-eyed. However, the fact of the matter is, we don't know if it would. And instead of this being a race issue, its more than that, its a human rights issue. As human beings no matter what race or culture or socio-economic class, we all deserve to be treated with dignity and respect. Especially by people who are being paid by tax payers to keep us safe. Some of you will accuse Ms. Bonds of being intoxicated and probably mouthing off. So what? Regardless of what Ms. Bonds could have done to upset the officers, they are in positions of authority and a certain moral standard is expected while on duty as well as the ability to make good decisions and follow procedures. These officers seriously undermined the legitimacy of our police force with their stupid and uncalculated actions.

    • John D

      I actualy do not believe she mouthed off. The cops questioned her, then let her go. Only when she then asked why she was stopped did they arrest her. If she was rude/rowdy they would have arrested her in the first place, not let her go.

    • briguyhfx

      It certainly wouldn't have happened if she were 6'5", male, and 220+ lbs. Bullies choose their victims carefully.

  • PeteTong

    At least they didn't taser her! I had one friend question the police and they peppered sprayed him. Another questioned the police and was tasered. The police love to rough up drunks.

  • John D

    Way to miss the point

    • Humble observer

      Geddes: "But if she keeps talking in the dignified, admirable way she does in today’s Citizen story, we might have no choice but to make her a bit of hero."

      That's a disgusting statement, coming from a journalist. First, because Stacy Bonds is a hero already. Second, and more importantly, while she can talk in however dignified a way she likes, a journalist has a responsibility to get angry once in a while and not back instinctively away from anything — like calling for wholesale reform of the SIU — that might rock the boat even a tiny little bit.

      Too bad, I thought Geddes had courage. Guess I should have looked more closely.

  • pdpd

    Yes, exactly. I'd happily grant that White says all the right things, and that he's probably a very well meaning, hard working, terrific individual and cop. I imagine that you would agree.

    But the proof of the pudding is in the eating. He might be a good chief who is doing good work, but we sure aren't seeing it in tangible results. The implication seems to be that the OPS deserves the benefit of the doubt because a)White is an impressive chief, and b)most cops are good people. But despite these things we've still got a pattern of abuse and subsequent cover-ups at OPS, so perhaps, just perhaps, we should ask if Vern White's outrage is a sufficient response to a seemingly systemic problem.

  • NorthernPoV

    @tryon "In Canada no one is obligated to talk to the police when stopped <snip> Avail yourselves of it! "
    Yes, stand up for your rights! And end up beaten and charged – just like Stacy.
    A new (and one of the only) tools we have against cop thuggery is the personal surveillance technology – digital cameras, esp. cell phones that we tend to carry everywhere.
    Much of the G20 police effort went into controller the citizens' video footage – hey its my theory, that this was one of the motivations for the mass arrests.
    Control of video footage (whether official video like the Bonds beating or personal video like the Van-Airport tasing) will somehow be declared a matter of national security…..
    So, next time you have an encounter with the cops, hope that someone is nearby with a camera – but not so nearby that they get arrested for disturbing the police. And hope that youtube survives state control.

  • LaxAtlDfwYow

    Updates:
    - OttCit reports another case of claimed abuse of a woman while detained by the OPS on Chief White's watch: http://www.ottawacitizen.com/news/Woman+alleges+a…

    - Mayor Watson to be sworn-in Tuesday.evening. Announces plans to spend his first day in office visiting city employees in the the offices and the work yards. Wants to bond with the staff. Apparently, meeting with the Chief of the force that has been repeatedly charged with abusing Ottawa citizens is not on our Mayor-elect's agenda.

  • magaphone

    Clearly she was being molested. That was the intyent of the officers when they spotted her walking down the street!!!!!

  • ron

    cops are criminals beware of harper and fantino

  • Rob

    I say get rid of the police altogether and let the citizens protect themselves. We could have citizen patrols for dealing with murderers thefts and even traffic violations. I can't imagine that this kind of system would produce any abusive behavour because it appears from all the comments here we could do a much better job.

  • Dale

    We have a problem Canada!
    The police used uncalled for force.
    School authorities don't bother reporting the gang rape of a child during a school trip.
    Teachers who report the systematice faliure of our school to protect children from repeat sex offenders is forced out of teaching, professionally terminated, reprimanded by the Ontario College of Teachers and then suspended from teaching becuase he dare question a policy that allows repeat sex offenders to teach in our schools.
    If our school system can get away with this garbage, one thing we can bet on is simple. Not one police officer will ever come forward to stop beatings………….. NOT ONE!
    Watch these filthy pictures and watch the body langauge. If a teacher, a former judge turned Ontario Teacher can be destroyed by the Ontario College of Teachers, you think one single cop will run the risk of losing the support of his fellow officers….you got another thing coming.
    Citizens, we let this situation happen, it is our fault. Want to do something about it. Ask your MPP to vote to let the Ontario Ombudsman into our schools, our hospitals, and our police forces.

  • ganesh_loch

    I'm puzzled by statements from Vicki Bair, a senior Crown Prosecutor in the Ottawa area, as
    reported today in the Montreal Gazette by journalist Andrew Seymour, apparently of the Ottawa
    Citizen. Seymour wrote in part:
    "Bair also accused the media, including the Citizen, of "cherry-picking" portions of Lajoie's decision and advancing its own version of the events."

    I believe I have found the whole decision here: http://www.canlii.org/en/on/oncj/doc/2010/2010onc…
    as R. v. Bonds, 2010 ONCJ 561, Docket 998-09-13642 .

    My question: suppose we don't cherry-pick and read the entire decision. Shall anybody
    stand up and publicy explain why the case was brought to court? It appears that
    this has not be done in detail so far.

    The Vancouver Sun reports as follows:
    << A spokesman for Attorney General Chris Bentley says the Bonds case has been reviewed by the province's chief prosecutor, who has determined that it was reasonable to take it to court. >>

    Has Ontario Attorney General Chris Bentley pernonally reviewed the decision to prosecute
    Stacy Bonds, in the light of all information available to him?

    Under parliamentary custom, a minister is reponsible to the parliament for
    his or her ministry. Therefore, the Ontario Attorney General ought to be responsible
    before the Ontario Legislature for the Ministry of the Attorney General.

  • SGC

    The physical abetting of the kneeing of Bonds proves the matter against the 4 cops. It is logical to presume that 4 trained officers (within their holding facility) ought to be able to restrain a 100 pound woman without using swinging knee kicks. The matter following of them having Bonds lay in her own urine proves that there was a failure to care for the dignity of bonds. Those two matters each confirm malice and confirm that it was a false arrest. There was not any attempt to ask Bonds to undress her bra and nor was there a reason to presume a risk of suicide. Where there was the assault undressing thru force gave Bonds reason to fear that the assault was sexual.

  • SH CU

    They are not to presume the unspoken vulnerabilty of people that they do not know (according to their strength). Any may be suffereing a tragedy or report of an illness. Any may be a victim of domestic violence or intimidation. An accused has the right to not become the victim of crimes where there is an allegation of a false arrest nor a victim of the same sort of crimes or greater crimes on the journey to a ruling on an allegation, and has the right to not have their unknown life revictimized in neither of those two ways..

  • SH CU

    The physical abetting of the kneeing of Bonds proves the matter against the 4 cops. It is logical to presume that 4 trained officers (within their holding facility) ought to be able to restrain a 100 pound woman without using swinging knee kicks. The matter following of them having Bonds lay in her own urine proves that there was a failure to care for the dignity of bonds. Those two matters each confirm malice and confirm that it was a false arrest. There was not any attempt to ask Bonds to undress her bra and nor was there a reason to presume a risk of suicide. Where there was the assault undressing thru force gave Bonds reason to fear that the assault was sexual.

  • SH CU

    The judge stayed the charge that Bonds assaulted a police officer and saw presumption freeing right of evidence confirming that her Sept. 6, 2008 arrest on a charge (of public intoxication) was illegal . He also called the officers behaviour toward her appalling. There are 9 lawsuit claims of brutality & false arrest against Ottawa police. When there is an allegation of a false arrest thru a breach of the Charter what is proven after the arrest may serve as critical evidence confirming that the allegation of the false arrest is true. Remember this is not on the number of officers, this is on the physical abetting of the kneeing of Bonds.

  • upset mom

    On January 12, 2005 my son suffered similar police mistreatment, in his bedroom, for no apparent reason, because four Saanich Constables wanted him to go to a hospital for toxicology testing. They didn't identify themselves as police, were not wearing hats, and assumed that he could not understand them, while he waited for an explanation, unarmed, lying on his bed, as he had completely undressed himself, and was also not wearing his prescription glasses – so wondered if they were mislead or mistaken paramedics. To his horror, and mine when I learned of is about a half-hour later from a friend who arrived outside my son's house while the police were inside, the officers then yanked him off his bed, hog-tied him on the hardwood floor, and as one of them pressed his knee down on my son's head, Tasered him five times. He was then handcuffed and forced to lie on his cuffed hands while being taken by ambulance to a hospital. In the hospital, he was found to have zero toxicology, yet was given a sedative injection and a variety of non-required medications over a period of 16 days, until I was able to advocate for him to be discharged. We then sought a second medical opinion from a doctor at the University Clinic my son had gone to the day before this Taser incident. That doctor ordered my son to be given full academic concession as a student so that he could withdraw and move back to Alberta. It was as though the doctor thought no student who had suffered such unjust treatment, could remain safe living in the vicinity patrolled by the Saanich Police. The BC Police Commissioner did a white-wash on my son's complaint of Torture, and refused to allow a public hearing. I read the Criminal Code – then wrote up 11 counts of criminal charges, including Torture, contrary to Section 269.1 and my husband drove back to Victoria and swore them as a private information application to a Judge on Dec. 22, 2008. Christine Lowe (so-called Crown Prosecutor) quashed that application, refusing to accept my son's and our prima-facie evidence. She admitted she had already read a police report – I wonder, is that because she's married to Stan Lowe (BC Police Commissioner)?

  • upset mom

    Part II – In Alberta, my son and I also tried to obtain assistance from the RCMP in our community, to report the unlawful arrest and assault he suffered at the hands of Saanich Police. We were ordered out of their detachment office, and contrary to medical orders, told we had to go back to Saanich to deal with that department ourselves – obviously – an impossibility. We called hundreds of lawyers in BC and Alberta for help – receiving assistance only from Cameron Ward, who was only willing to file a civil writ, and act on a 40% contingency fee basis. Then when he withdrew for personal reasons, we received no referral to another lawyer, only a demand to provide "trust funds" to enable a Pivot Legal lawyer to review the evidence we had already collected – from witnesses, the BC Police Commissioner, and the paramedics who were called – not by police, but by a bystander. Costs of discovery of evidence were thus born by us, totalling thousands of dollars and at least 3 years of my work, plus the fact that injuries sustained by my son, left him unable to work full-time, and similarly me, while assisting him and providing care-giver aide. He suffered about 18 months total duration of neurological trauma – Post Taser Attack PTSD and so did I – even longer as I also sprained my back while helping him get moved and resettled in my home in Alberta. The discovery of the Saanich Police Department's representative was eventually done by an Edmonton Lawyer – one who had himself also been Tasered in an incident in Edmonton. That discovery demanded the "use of force" report – that still has not been provided or entered into my son's medical records. I also made a submission to the Braidwood Commission – but was told that investigation was limited to that one incident (costing tax-payers $3.7 million). Then as I learned that the Saanich Police were terrorizing other citizens, still acting on erroneous "tips" to enter private residences with or without a warrant, I went back to asking the RCMP to assist us. They still refused.

  • upset mom

    Part III Later, as my son's lawyer in Alberta (who previously had an office in BC also) was on vacation, awaiting response from the lawyer acting for the Saanich Police in the civil claim to produce the "use of force report" and a long list of other undertakings, that Defence lawyer for the Saanich Police, began harrassing my son and his wife and myself by telephoning and sending e-mail and letters slandering and threatening to libel us. The risks of waiting for his lawyer to provide another referral were such that my son wrote back to one of the letters and said he would withdraw the civil claim without costs – because the lawyer was threatening that my son would have to pay $10,000 in court costs. With that letter, that lawyer then applied for a dismissal with costs – attempting to aggravate the damages with more extortion! I attended to Justice Parrett's hearing of that chambers application, as my son's legal representative. He said "I know it's not just", and ordered the case dismissed without costs. He also gave right t us as co-plaintiffs to continue as plaintiffs in the BC Court of Appeal. We filed the notice – but can not afford the costs and trauma of providing all the evidence again, in triplicate, to a tribunal of judges.

  • upset mom

    Part V So as it is now New Years Eve of 2010 – exactly six years since the date my son and I talked about New Years resolutions together in the same room I am sitting in now, just 12 days before he was assaulted with a Taser, I hope I have had some beneficial effect for my son and the Saanich Police and the RCMP. I know I and my son have lost at least $400,000 value from our homes, because our homes are the only places other than our university tuition, where we had invested any savings, while we were both full-time students, though still doing temporary summer jobs or part-time contracts. It is, similar I think, to what Percy Schmeiser and his wife suffered in being obliged to defend themselves against prosecution for no real reason by Monsanto, except that they were able to continue retaining a lawyer, and enabled to settle out of court for costs, so they could keep their farm. My son and I only have a few tropical indoor plants – the only things we raised over the past six years were a few garden vegetables and some tropical fish. We gave some away, but never sold any – and all our employer's deducted tax from our pay-cheques. I see little point in worrying about retirement pensions – I think we are all going to have to keep working till we die – because of the legacy of Tasers and human rights offences in our own country. We were born here in Canada – but working until you die, is not a much different reality than what most people born in Cuba have to face.

  • darwin2

    These officers should be fired, period. They acted with a gang mentality, and obviously do not have what it takes to be 'officers of the law'. Given their jobs back, they will again abuse their uniform. The bigger question remains: how did the Ontario Solicitors office dismiss this case, deeming the actions of the officers justifiable?

  • Jenn_

    Exactly. And taking Halo Override's point, without worrying about being in a dangerous situation with people you've pissed off, the prosecution has absolutely no excuse not to have stood up to this and launched a criminal investigation of these police officers, instead of covering up their crime by going after the victim. Where's the investigation into them?

  • mevets

    Fired? How about arrested. If a group of people kidnapped, stripped and videotaped a young woman in the middle of the night, that would be their fait. They would be put onto a sex offenders registry for the rest of their lives. There is no conceivable way that these thugs thought they were doing police work. There should be an extra charge for hiding behind the badge.

  • PeteTong

    They acted like it's something they do all the time.

  • ASH999

    What if she said she was going to kill herself? Wouldn't they have had to cut her bra off? What would have happened if she did hang herself with that bra? Imagine what all of these comments would be like? The front page of every paper and magazine would be blaming the police for not protecting her. There would be a public inquiry of course! What if she was resisting so they had to physically force her to do what they were requesting? What if? Does anyone even consider that she might not be the innocent victim???? My god, let the investigation conclude before we judge. This is disgusting.

  • Holly Stick

    They had no right to strip search her and in fact they had no right to arrest her in the first place. Stop blaming the victims; those cops are scum.

From Macleans