John Geddes

John Geddes

John Geddes writes on politics and policy, with occasional reporting and comment on arts and culture.

Whipsawed by WikiLeaks: Canadian self-doubt and smugness

by John Geddes on Wednesday, December 1, 2010 8:07pm - 107 Comments

Can we settle on the putdown of preference when it comes to right-wingers expressing their disdain for Canada?

They often resort to either of two seemingly contradictory, but equally condescending, lines about Canadians: we are insufferable in our sense of moral superiority, or we exhibit an equally tiresome inferiority complex.

Now, I’m willing to take my lumps, but do they have to come from both directions at once? Can’t you decide if my national ego is obnoxiously over-developed or pathetically under-developed?

I come to this question after being whipsawed by WikiLeaks.

First, we read of former CSIS Director Jim Judd telling his American friends about the likelihood of Canadians indulging their “speciality” for “moral outrage” over seeing video of a weeping Omar Khadr at Guantanamo.

Next, we learn that the U.S. embassy in Ottawa judged our Canadians psyche so enfeebled by “an almost inherent inferiority complex” that the mere mention of the U.S. during the 2008 election was too much for us.

Can both be true? Come to think of it, seen a certain way, maybe so.

Maybe it is possible to both experience moral outrage over a teenager being cruelly treated during a lengthy imprisonment with no recourse to anything the resembles due process and harbour feelings of unease about the practical implications of living beside a military, economic and political power ten times as populous as your own country.

So I withdraw my initial objection. For those who care to, please feel free to continue sneering at Canada from both angles. I think we can live with it.

Bookmark and Share
  • haha – haha

    Canada has an inferiority complex and a superiority simplex

  • johane

    i am glad to be canadian because canada is my home, yes i live in the province of quebec, our country has improve on lots of things but we still have some work to do on our healt care, police, military and politics, i got nothing bad to say about the usa, i got lots of familly and friends who are american, i know they are trying to make their country better too. i thing as human beings, we should all help each other to make life easy for all, i know it aint easy, but i would like to start with my own country first , if that is wrong of me, that is ok, everyone has a right to their opinion

  • Thedoo

    @judge Roy bean – I’d say Sweden.

  • Mike T.

    Superiority "complex"?

    The United States can get back to us when it has equal rights for gays, decent gun contro, respectable health care and hasn't started an insanely stupid war for at least two presidents.

  • Emily

    Thank you for providing the perfect example Mike!

  • Guest

    Based on your descriptions, I hope we can never get back to you.

  • Lobien

    Oh boy, more of the "My country is better than yours" drama. Some Americans such as myself admire many things about other countries such as Canada. However, I do not think any country is better than any other country in the world. We are all people, and it is egotistical for anyone to think they are the best. I love America, but I would never say "Oh I am the best." Seems a bit weird you know. I really do not get into the wacky noodle doctrines of the Jehovah's Witnesses, but I like how they put aside all the nationalistic propaganda to consider all humans as god's creatures.

  • guest

    actually…and this is to you JW comment….they only see us as God's creatures if we are also practicing JW's. Aside from that, we are all evil.

From Macleans