Inkless Wells

Inkless Wells

Paul Wells on all the latest out of Ottawa—along with the occasional post about jazz. Follow Paul on Twitter: @InklessPW
He also offers his thoughtful perspective of Stephen Harper’s last 10 years in his recent eBook, The Harper Decade.

Reinforcements

by Paul Wells on Monday, December 20, 2010 4:38pm - 14 Comments

I finally got around to reading Patrick Deane’s installation address as President of McMaster University, which came highly recommended for its defense of the campus as a bastion of values more universal and durable than we usually read about in the morning papers. The whole speech is worth reading. Deane doesn’t just offer ringing endorsements of grand principles, but acknowledges that worthy goals can conflict. But I stopped short after the first sentence — “In 1975 I was an undergraduate at the University of the Witwatersrand in Johannesburg” — because it suggests a trend.

Deane is in fact South African. He came to Canada in 1978 as a grad student, the kind we are sometimes told will take “our” fancy education, paid with our tax dollars, and go home. He stayed. So have a growing number of Canadian university presidents who were born far abroad.

I’m most familiar with Amit Chakma from Bangladesh, who is already making an impression as Western’s new president. A few weeks ago Léo Charbonneau wrote about a bunch of others, including Alaa S. Abd-El-Aziz at UPEI, Feridun Hamdullahpur at Waterloo, Mamdouh Shoukri at York and a relative veteran, Indira Samarasekera at the University of Alberta. Lesley Lovett-Doust, at Nipissing, is Scottish. Neil Turok, not quite a university president, is Canada’s most prominent advocate for higher education in his native Africa. One could go on and on.

I mention this for its own inherent interest and because we’ve got some fights coming up in Canada about whether our universities (and, yes, our tax dollars) are supposed to help us function in the world or reinforce our parochialism.

 

Bookmark and Share
  • Cats

    This is like reading that Sun media piece on why David Johnson was a good Prime Minister …

    but in reverse.

    Opposite Cats.

    • Amateur Hour

      You mean Governor General …

      Now go play in traffic.

  • MikeB

    Dr. Shoukri was my Dean of Engineering at McMaster. Great guy, I didn't know he had moved on to be President of York U.

    Thanks for highlighting this very interesting trend!

  • Stewart_Smith

    I find it interesting that many of those that most admire the US educational system are opposed to the scholarship program. The dominance of the US system is based on its ongoing ability to attract the best talent, worldwide at all levels.

    • Inkless

      With (along with other and sometimes more high-minded incentives) cash money.

    • bergkamp

      "I find it interesting that many of those that most admire the US educational system are opposed to the scholarship program."

      I am one of those against scholarships for foreigners when we have lots of clever people already in Canada. I see no need for governments to spend $$$ so we can ensure next generation of first generation immigrant university presidents.

      I don't know what scholarship program you have in mind but the Ivy League schools offer scholarships off the backs of the rich people who pay enormous fees to attend Harvard, Yale …… etc.

      In Canada, where the average salary is 38 grand a year, our government wants to offer scholarships to foreigners off the backs of taxpayers who don't earn all that much and would prefer their children receive the scholarships instead of people who don't live here and haven't contributed to civic society.

      • Thwim

        Fun facts:

        1. The most significant predictor of whether an individual will undertake post-secondary education is whether their parents did. This is a more significant factor than anything, including family income.

        2. The higher the education level, the fewer kids a family is likely to have.

        The conclusion is that if we only support our own, we're simply going to run out of people. That's not good for the taxpayer either, as an increasing burden of elderly people will be resting on a smaller and smaller base.

        Besides, it's not as if this is the only scholarship out there. The vast majority of them are only for Canadian students. Hell, they're even more specialized than that, the vast majority of scholarships are only for *young* Canadian students who are taking full-time course loads.

  • Leo

    This is going to be a hard sell with Ontario $18 billion in the hole.

    Chakma, I believe, refers to the success of the Feds. Science & Technology, R&D Programs that have been getting billions in funding. Maybe he needs to borrow from their experience to justify his position to the parochials.

  • Criacow

    I just hope we get to have that fight/conversation instead of it coming pre-decided like so many issues.

    Hi, I'm an immigrant. I've been here a while. I'll be a citizen in another year or two. In my mind, this is the greatest country on the planet, and I'm honoured that it has welcomed me as it has so many other new immigrants over the years..

    On the flipside, there are several conversations we, as a country, need to have about the future. An aging population, unfunded liabilities, a shrinking workforce to fund the first two, etc. Young immigrants (like me!) with another 35, 40 years of work ahead of us help there. One citizen, one taxpayer at a time, it helps balance out the generation line.

    It's my belief that a program like the one Paul Wells is talking about will pay great dividends beyond the small amount of money Ontario and Canada invest in it. If we attract top talent from around the world, we raise the bar for the whole country. And if we make it a welcoming place for them to stay afterwards, they more than pay back the value of the scholarship in future taxes and contributions to society. (And some of them will invent things or start businesses that employ other Canadians (and bring in other quality skilled-worker immigrants), multiplying the effect downwards.)

    So, please, when this fight comes–and it is coming–remember these things. It's not always just about lowering taxes and cutting spending. Sometimes, we have to invest for the future.

  • Matlock

    I had the privilege of hearing this speech in person (I received my Masters degree at this year's convocation). Thank you for posting this, it was great to revisit it. This passage in particular stood out for me when I heard it:

    "It remains astonishing to me—and an odd sort of consolation—that the apartheid regime in those difficult days in South Africa could never quite bring itself entirely to eliminate academic freedom. Even though you had to do so under supervision of a stern and disapproving librarian, you could read Marx’s Kapital or the Communist Manifesto; and the Vice-Chancellor could put on his robe of office and tell the student body why detention without trial was indefensible in a civilized society, and why the doctrine of habeas corpus had to be defended. Barbarism, evidently, is only rarely absolute."

    This speech made me appreciate what we have in our universities in Canada. In today's political scene, where it is almost impossible to debate ideas (instead people's motivations are debated and debased), we still have institutions where ideas can be vigorously debated in an environment of mutual respect.

    Let's hope that Canada's leaders of tomorrow don't forget these ideals they picked up in school and carry them into our political institutions.

    • Claudia Lemire

      Congratulations!!

  • Guest

    "We’ve got some fights coming up in Canada about whether our universities are supposed to help us function in the world or reinforce our parochialism." Forget about that fight, Ottawa Citizen editorialists want to do away with all public education (from kindergarden to university) in favour of something even smaller than parochialism. Children should be home-schooled, to keep them in the bosom of their family and away from the leftist indoctrination of long division. Meanwhile, the same columnist thought residential schools were just peachy for native kids. But, as he says, "equality is a dark and monstrous ambition".

  • http://www.linkedin.com/companies/merger-law-associates-ltd. Julius C.

    We need to keep the talent in Canada…

  • Emily

    I had hoped we'd reached the tipping point in population…big enough to get past our parochial prison…but apparently not.

    So, as always we'll be behind the times and lose huge benefits instead of doing the leading we could.

From Macleans