How the Conservatives plan to turn a minority into a majority

Doug Finley on Harper’s election playbook

by John Geddes on Tuesday, February 8, 2011 8:37am - 92 Comments
Harper’s playbook

Sean Kilpatrick/CP

From his second-floor office in Parliament’s East Block—once John A. Macdonald’s lair and still appointed with some of his furniture—Sen. Doug Finley has a direct sightline across Wellington Street to Stephen Harper’s office in the Langevin Block. He points out the Prime Minister’s window for a visitor. Asked if they ever wave to one another, Finley deadpans, “Not much.” Neither man is known for his playful gestures.

What they are known for is partnering to reshape the federal political landscape. But that relationship is now changing. Finley, 64, is undergoing chemotherapy for colorectal cancer, and is stepping down as Harper’s campaign director. He’ll remain, though, a key adviser to the Tory machine, which he largely assembled and kept oiled for eight years. He recently summed up his role this way: “I’m not the world’s greatest strategist, or the world’s greatest pollster, or the world’s greatest advertising man, but somebody has to pull these bits together.”

That’s a deceptively chipper job description for a notoriously hard-driving party boss. Finley’s few moments in the public spotlight solidified his reputation as a tough customer. He was once ushered out of a House committee room by security, after he showed up at hearings demanding to testify according to his own timetable, refusing to wait to be called. He banished would-be Tory candidates who didn’t meet with his approval. He lashed out at the CBC in a fundraising letter to Conservative supporters.

But in a rare interview with Maclean’s last week, Finley sounded like the methodical backroom organizer Tory insiders talk of in awestruck tones, rather than the intimidating figure who occasionally emerged to brief bursts of media attention. He sketched a road map to majority that the party will surely try to follow in the next election.

His starting point is elementary election arithmetic. Of the 308 seats in the House, each of the Conservative, Liberal, NDP and Bloc Québécois parties, he reckons, can reasonably be allocated about 40 seats at the outset of a campaign. That leaves just 148 up for grabs. So to claim a majority, the winner would need to grab 115 of those ridings. “To win 115 of 148 seats is a huge, huge undertaking,” Finley says. There’s no clear sign of either party cresting toward the roughly 40 per cent of the popular vote needed to accomplish that feat. Conservative and Liberal polling numbers have remained stubbornly consistent since the 2008 election, the Tories in the mid-thirties, the Liberals in the high twenties.

Still, that puts Harper several precious percentage points closer than Liberal Leader Michael Ignatieff to majority territory. To get the rest of the way, Finley says, means converting voters who can’t be easily corralled under either of the two parties’ banners. “There’s a sizable group of people, perhaps enough to sway an election, who could be Blue Liberals or Red Tories,” he says. How to switch Liberal voters in that centrist group to his side? With a gruff laugh, Finley says they must be “transmogrified”—the trick Calvin, of the defunct Calvin and Hobbes comic strip, while playing a spaceman, accomplished using a hair drier as a ray gun.

In the political playground, the tools used to transform voters aren’t so harmless. Attack ads have been a hallmark of Finley’s style. The most recent batch of Tory TV ads again take aim at Ignatieff’s character. They accuse him of returning to Canada, after about three decades in Britain and the U.S., not to serve his country, but to satisfy his ambition. The acerbic tag line: “He didn’t come back for you.”

Bookmark and Share
  • MostlyCivil

    "How the Conservatives plan to turn a minority into a majority"

    More like

    How the Conservatives WANT to turn a minority into a majority, using the same tactics they've used before.

    I don't see anything new here. That's the playbook?

  • Jim Rocket

    The reason a majority is eluding the Conservative Party is Stephen Harper himself. If they ran Brad Wall or Danny Williams they would get a majority. That's not going to happen, though, because it really is the Stephen Harper Party of Canada. He controls it completely and won't allow any other contenders.

    As for the attack ads on Iggy, I have to laugh at them because a big part of Harper's problem is that he never had the gumption to leave Canada and see the world. His narrow-mindedness is holding him back. He's a very shrewd man who is very short on wisdom.

  • maudie

    This is all wishful thinking. Canadians deserve better than Harper and his trained seals. Time for Big Ig to take over.

  • Peggy

    Excellent article and shows how manipulative this govt (sic) has been. No moral fibre, as far as I'm concerned.

    Up to us voters to vote them out though, and start thinking outside the box for parties like the NDP and the Green Party.

  • http://www.google.com mars

    The only intelligence on the hill–is in power right now—-who would U rather have——-the 3 stooges???

  • Rosie

    Doug threw a temper tantrum deserving of Tweens' Bullying Schoolyard tactics when he DEMANDED to speak on his own terms at Committee!

    Herr Harper Robotson will never get a Majority—in Canada, at least!

    Perhaps Zimbabwe …they need him there….God save us from these Unprincipled Bullies who've shamed Canada on the world stage (kicked out of the Security Council after 60 years) who are selling off dismantling Canada and will have us become the 51st State—kick them out with our Vote!

  • ThinkingMan

    I just cannot bring myself to support a political party that runs a campaign based on fear and intolerance. It's not the Canadian way.

  • illbethejudge

    I wish Doug Finley the best of success in his fight against cancer. I do hope he uses this time to re-evaluate the disdain with which he has treated Canadian voters. Negative, ruthless and dishonest politics may be effective, but it's not noble.
    Be noble Senator Finley and above all else, be well.

  • Briansz

    If the Conservatives ever do in fact get their so called majority, there will probably be a lot more shameless liers walking around in Canada pretending that they didn't vote for Harper and the pseudo-GOP party selling Canada to the USA. In fact one will think that the Conservative GOP party got their majority by MAGIC.

  • jim babwi

    The americanization of canada continues and that is the harparian dream. next we will have the lords prayer, backroom abortions, more kids in jail and 1950s hairstyles.

  • Blake53

    I agree and I will never vote for a party that uses smear campaigns. Every time I see a smear ad, I give $1 to another party. It is hard to be a teacher and try to educate our youth not to be bullies when the federal government exhibits the bully mentality every day.

  • Carson

    Yes!

    Send Harper to Zimbabwe. Our Great Leader is fit to rule there!

    Glenn Beck, Sarah Palin, Limbaugh…these are NOT reprsentative of the CANADIAN way. The neoCons have made this proud land the playground of the Village Idiots

From Macleans