Why do Canadians still vacation in Mexico?

A staggering 35,000 people have been murdered in Mexico since December 2006

by Michael Petrou with Erica Alini and Julia Belluz on Sunday, March 6, 2011 11:02pm - 42 Comments
Beaches. Buffets. Bullets.

Mexican police keep a close watch on one of the beaches in Acapulco Pedro Pardo

The Plaza Sendero shopping mall on the outskirts of Acapulco has a fabric store, a shoe shop, and a movie complex, screening Tron: Legacy, The Tourist, and Gulliver’s Travels. A red-eyed dog lies asleep in the shade of the mall entrance, and nearby a man sits on his haunches, awake but equally motionless. The parking lot is scattered with bright orange shopping carts. Across the adjacent highway, shanties cling to an eroding hill, where the scorching sun has singed off almost all greenery. Smoke drifts upward from a cooking fire or burning rubbish.

A pedestrian bridge spans the highway. On it someone has pasted a flyer for a local church that promises salvation for those who suffer from vice, broken families, curses, or sicknesses with no known cause. Fifteen bodies were dumped here in January, most with their heads cut off and bodies mutilated. Six more were found stuffed into a nearby taxi. Their hands and feet had been bound. Two police were shot and killed the same day.

Handwritten posters at the crime scene link the murders to one of the drug cartels in the midst of a war for territory and export routes in Mexico. The victims almost certainly belonged to rival gangs. They are among more than 1,000 murdered over the past year in Acapulco, a popular vacation spot for Canadians.

The violence in Mexico began to soar four years ago, when President Felipe Calderón intensified a crackdown on drug cartels. The cartels fought back, but also turned against each other, where previously a sort of fragile truce had persisted in the interest of mutual profit. The growth of domestic narcotics consumption drives the escalating competition. “The size of the pie has increased,” says Jorge Chabat, a specialist in Mexico’s drug cartels at CIDE, a Mexico City think tank. “There are more reasons to fight.” A staggering 35,000 people have been murdered since Calderón took office in December 2006.

Terror and cruelty have exploded along with the death toll. Decapitations are now commonplace. A policeman or soldier involved in taking down a drug lord, if identified, risks losing his family. Dying first won’t save them. Mexican marine Melquisedet Angulo died during a 2009 raid against a cartel. He was celebrated as a hero. Hours after his funeral, gunmen burst into his home and murdered his mother, aunt, brother and sister.

Now, members of elite anti-drug units wear masks and die anonymously. Even street-level police patrol without ID. “The most dangerous thing is not knowing who might attack us, who we should worry about,” says one local officer, standing on an Acapulco sidewalk with a submachine gun. “If the criminals wore uniforms like us it would be too easy.” He declined to give his name. “I’m afraid of reprisals.” It’s more difficult for senior officers to hide. Gunmen in Acapulco attacked the home of a local commander last month. He, along with his son, survived. Politicians are likewise threatened. At least 14 Mexican mayors were murdered last year.

Many in authority are also corrupt. Faced with choosing between promised death and an offer of cash, some politicians, bureaucrats and security officials choose the latter. Calderón’s government has purged thousands of compromised police and law enforcement officials, including from top levels of the country’s security apparatus. But no one believes the problem has been eradicated.

Bookmark and Share
  • JustWondering

    Why do Canadians still vacation in the U.S?
    How many people have been murdered or killed by gunfire in the U.S. since December 2006??
    I'm betting you won't post this comment.

    • Stewart_Smith

      Murders and accidents using guns run at about 10,000 per year in the US, so you are correct that since Jan 1 2006, there has likely been about 45,000. people killed in the US. (If you count guns used in suicides the number would be much higher. ) I guess you could say this makes the US about 1/3 as dangerous as Mexico when their respective populations are considered.

      I am not sure why you thought Macleans would be unwilling to post your comment, it is hardly offensive, but just to be safe you should stay clear of casinos.

    • citizen_CA

      You can't really compare the two, because the authority structure in the states can still be trusted. When I travel the states, I don't have to be concerned about being pulled over by a police officer for nor reason, just so that he can stuff his pockets with my money.

      • Funny Guy

        The point is :

        How many people do you know had a bad time in Mexico ? None. So people still vacation there. It's a nice place, nice people, and it sure beats Cuba and Dominican Republic if you talk about "corruption".

        The article title is completely unwarranted.

        • Stormcrow

          Cuba has more corruption than Mexico? That would be news to virtually everyone I know who vacations there…year after year after year. Meanwhile, I know lots of people who love Mexico and Jamaica, provided you don't stray too far from the resort.

          Oh, and how many Cuban resorts have exploded recently?

        • citizen_CA

          I actually know of several that have been "held" up by the Mexican cops. They were stopped for no reason, but after paying the asked bribe, they were let go.

      • harebell

        The authority structure in the states can still be trusted.
        Really? While you might not worry about the average copper, the non-accountable guys in suits at the airports and the penchant of those in power to cover their mistakes up is scary.
        Also I guess you can ask those renditioned about adherence to the law and its equitable application.

        • http://www.opensourceg.com FreeSCV

          you get MY upvote! :)

          I don't think the US cops are trustworthy let alone their leaders. lol

      • jstudent

        You must be caucasian.

    • John D

      Wow, writing "I'm betting you won't post this comment" simultaneously makes you look like an arse AND someone who doesn't understand how the internet works!

      • jstudent

        YOU must not know how the internet works. MacLean's filters comments that may count as offensive, defamatory, or pointless, or any of that sort.

    • beagleman

      This is an article on Mexico yet half the comments I see here are critcal of the USA. Well now I am going to talk about Canada. I have travelled to many countries around the world over the years and time after time, I can say without any doubt or hesitation that Canada is the most unfriendly country in the world to American tourists. People I know from other countries tell me that Canadians are cold people. And people of color who live in Canada tell me the Canadians are very predudiced. What gets me are these Canadians who move to the USA to get out of paying Canadian taxes to support the paradise Canadian social welfare system and then say great Canada and how bad the USA is. My most telling experience regarding Canadians was when i was in a hotel elevator in Edomonton and someone standing next to me noticed the American address on my suitcase and then called me a “dirty American — and go back home!” Don’t recite how bad America is, we are talking about You, Canadians.

  • Judge Roy Bean

    How many people in the States vs. Mexico , brainwave. How many, besides the Mexican mafia victim in Arizona have been beheaded anywhere in North America. How many towns have had whole police forces resign and countless numbers of police chiefs murdered? Realaity just ain't a bit 'thang' to you, is it?

    • Stewart_Smith

      At least one near Portage la Prairie, Manitoba. Perhaps a moment using your considerable brainwaves to reflect on your own bizarre choice of statistics would be a better idea than throwing insults first thing in the morning.

      • citizen_CA

        The beheading near Portage la Prairie, Manitoba, was done by a mentally ill man, so you can't really use that as an example.

        • RayK

          An example of what?

          Regardless of the reasons, beheadings are a very rare event in Canada, the United States and Mexico. For that matter, a beheading in Arizona is still a murder in the US even if it was committed by Mexicans.

          You're writing as the question at hand is whether Mexico is somehow "bad". If there are people who don't want to go to Mexico because of police corruption, fine. But the question being asked above is whether the high number of murders in Mexico shouldn't be discouraging travel there. If that's one's concern. the obvious answer is that while the murder rate is high in Mexico, it's not an unsafe place to which to travel. The murder rate is higher in Jamaica. The murder rate is FOUR TIMES higher in New Orleans!

          • Charles B

            I lived in New Orleans for a bout 3 years. The murder rate in New Orleans is no where hear that in Mexico. I have no idea where this person is getting his figures. I have also lived in Mexico for a number of years. I would live there again even thought it is a dangerous place to live, because I accept the risk. Millions of people drive on our U.S. highway drunk each year, but I still drive even though I could be killed at any time by a drunk driver. Driving drunk is dangerous and so is living in Mexico, but you accept the risk.

  • RayK

    12,900 people a year are killed in the US.

    8,800 people a year are killed in Mexico.

    Mexico has about half the population of the United States.

    Unilke the United States the vast majority of the increase in violence in Mexico has occured in particular areas and between specific people (cartels and government).

    So where's the story about why are people still traveling to the United States?

    • TheWholeTruth

      Hey RayK, if your intent is to draw an accurate comparison, then why not make sure you actually do so? You say "the vast majority of the increase in violence in Mexico has occured in particular areas and between specific people (cartels and government)." That is probably true. But, you fail to mention that crime statistics for the U.S. show that the vast majority of murders are black-on-black, drug-related crimes. One of the next largest categories is murder by a known person (i.e. family member, friend). If you're not black, not involved in the drug trade, and don't have a spouse or boy/girl friend out to get you, you are statistically very safe in the U.S. as well.

      • Vatro

        I love it when spokespeople say "It's a war." Mostly because it's absolutely accurate, but then no one but the Cartels behave as though it's a war. Is it really any surprise that they come out on top? Should the Mexican government actually start to behave as though they are dealing with a rebel domestic force they might make some head way.

        Also for those that believe legalizing drugs in Mexico would solve the problem, I find that idea hard to credit. While their illegality certainly contributes to the problem, the problem itself is independent of drug legality. In other words, were drugs suddenly to become legal the Cartels would still be there trying to maintain power. Not to mention that it is actually the US that would have to legalize drugs in order to actually have a precipitable effect.

        As for why Canadians still travel their to vacation? They don't perceive it as dangerous obviously. I think they are factually wrong, but that has no effect on whatever their perception happens to be.

  • Tony, SFO-YUL

    Make drugs legal and leave the cartels to do their business.

    • Harvey Mushman

      Why go only half way?

      Make murder legal in Mexico and ka-pow…you've got a damn near crime-free country to vacation in!

    • kitanda

      I agree. If drugs were legal and taxable, it would be business as alcohol and cigarettes. Druglords will change to CEO of a company and the illegal market would finish. It is still illegal because lots of people are making too much money. I will say, legalize, put in the open market and shareholders will make lots of money. At least, drugs could be more controlled and they would have more awareness like alcohol and cigarette. people will still use it, doesn't matter what but at least less people would fight over it.

  • TheRealKuri

    I think Canadians visit Mexico because it's cheap and warm.

    • harebell

      That's why I went and it was a grand time

  • Leo

    Looks like the cruise ships have Mazatlan on their list of Mexican cities not considered safe as well. The local police are getting worse. My neighbour was stopped driving on the highway just outside Cancun in December and he demanded $1,000 U.S!!

    "We are working closely with the Mexican government and local officials to review their plans to improve security in all of the main tourist areas," Carnival said in a statement sent to The Associated Press on Monday. "Once we are comfortable with their plans and implementation, we expect to return to Mazatlan."

    • Claude

      i have lived in playa del carmen for the last 5 years and i have been stopped once by a cop because i was speeding. it cost me $10.00 . yes it is corruption but at the end of the day i was in the wrong and i prefered paying right away than getting a ticket and having to go and wait somewhere to pay it and so on. No demerit point. I look at the good side of living in Mexico and let me tell you there is a lot more plus than minus. I feel very safe to walk at night here. I have noticed that this kind of article always comes out in the US and Canada during spring break … Coincidence ?

  • Harvey Mushman

    "Why do Canadians still vacation in Mexico?"

    To check out the same kind of chicks the police are in the photo.

  • Pat Silver

    Mexico is a wonderful and safe place to visit if you are smart. I wouldn't walk at night in a shaky area of any American or Canadian city, and I choose my vacation spots just as carefully. The people in Mexico are welcoming. The AARP (American Association of Retired Persons) has deemed Puerto Vallarta the best place in the world to retire because it is the safest, most foreigner-friendly, and most affordable. Vallarta is a little piece of paradise with almost no crime, great beaches, spectacular sunsets, and delicious restaurants. Why go anywhere else?

  • Marilyn Dodd

    We are just nearing the end of our 4th six month winter residency in old Mazatlan. The people here are gracious, welcoming, and much more distressed about the violence than the Canadian or American visitors. It is destroying the economy and hurting everyone. Having said that, we certainly do NOT feel unsafe here. Yes, we are a little more careful about walking around some areas at night, and we don't flaunt money or jewelery, but we do the same in Canada or the States. In Mazatlan, we shop, go to entertainments, restaurants, visit friends, go to the beach, etc. without worrying. We sincerely feel that any danger to tourists has been grossly overstated by the media and are very concerned about the effects of this on our many Mexican friends. Yes, there is violence but if you are not involved in the narco trade in some way, chances are you will never see it. Will we come back next year??? A resounding YES!

    • truenorth

      Close friends of ours ( both widows ) spent 3 seasons ( Nov.- March. ) in San Filepe and fell in love with it so much that they sold their properties up here in B.C. and have decided to spend out their years in San Filepe. The local community have embraced them, and made them feel very comfortable and secure in their new surroundings.One of the ladies told me she feels more secure going for a walk down there in the evenings than she did up here in B.C….for me, the thoughts of a ''huge'' plate of fresh Seafood and a beer for around $ 4.00 makes me think about joining them……

  • http://twitter.com/besafe84 @besafe84

    Mexico is a dangerous country to travel to period! Many tourist deaths happen inside of the resorts and are a direct result of poor or nonexistent safety standards. To read tragic Mexico vacation death stories, as well as stories written by victims that “survived” their Mexico vacation, go to: http://www.mexicovacationawareness.com

    • Claude

      Have you ever vacationed in florida ? I went to buy something around 11 pm at a convenience store near West Palm Beach a few years back and there was 3 young man waiting at the door and looking at me in a way that made me actualy scared and for the first time in my life i really felt threatened (i was 45 at the time) . I never felt that way having lived here in Playa del Carmen (Mexico) for the past 5 years. I wonder how many killings, muggings etc… there is in Florida. It is spring break time which means it is …. let's scare people about Mexico time so they can spend their money in Florida…. PS: is there a site about victims that "survided" their Florida vacation ?

  • adiós México

    To me the issue is something like the issue of smoking. People know it can be dangerous yet they continue to do it with the "that won't happen to me" attitude. I will never go back to Mexico because I consider to be a high risk area now plus it's way too commercialized now. I've found a few other spots that are safer, cheaper and less crowded than Mexico and until the rest of the world discovers them, I'll continue to go there. In the meantime, if you want to Mexico, none of my business.

  • Joel

    This is a silly article. Unless you walk about Tijuana, your 5 stars hotel is pretty safe in Cancun or Acapulco!

  • Paco

    I think the Macleans writers are watching too much cable news. This is all about an attack on the Mexican Tourist Industry to bolster the economy. Sure the US offers the same "sun,surf and sand" but stay away from shopping malls and high schools or you could be shot. And while walking the beaches you better be armed

  • MJM

    Most of this artical doesn't even seem to address tourists at all, it would have been better to name it Mexico's War on Drugs, or Mexico's Cartel violence. It seems that the actual tourism aspect was only a side note, and at that doesn't tell the whole storey on tourism at all. While there have been a few deaths, when you compaire it to the number of people going, it is very minor. I am pretty certain that more then 20 people have died in violence in Toronto, Vancouver, Halifax, etc since 2006. I just returned from the Mayan Riviera and felt very safe the whole time I was there.

  • Funny Guy

    The point is :

    How many people do you know had a bad time in Mexico ? None. So people still vacation there. It's a nice place, nice people, and it sure beats Cuba and Dominican Republic if you talk about "corruption".

    The article title is completely unwarranted.

  • Vania Doige

    I love Mexico, I spent 4 months in Mazatlan and I will increase to 6 months in the near future. It is a lovely place and crime is here like is in Vancouver, Toronto etc. People are friendly, food is good and cheaper, sunshine all the time. Corruption? yes. Any different than Canada? Well, depend how you see it. Do we really know what the politicians are doing with our money? They use taxpayer money like it belongs to them. At least in Mexico we know the corruption is there, in Canada, it is under the carpet and people believes that it is not happening there. How many contracts are giving to friends of politicians? It is corruption, just using other name. Mexico needs lots of work and the people here is trying hard to overcome their problems. At least they are trying hard and they really don't need bad publicity. This author has being in many cities in Mexico? Did he lives between the mexican people, every day and see the beauty of the cities and the people in Mexico? Or he write what he sees in the media and statistics. I can be in Surrey, BC and get shot during the day,so what is the difference? I feel safe in Mazatlan and other cities in Mexico. I can't say the same thing about some neighbourhoods in Detroit.

  • Stewart_Smith

    If not completely unwarranted, at least disconnected from the article content. There have been some high profile issues with Canadians in Mexico. Certainly it has also happened for other nationalities. An intelligent article linking the degree to which violence in Mexican society spills over into vacationers would have been an interesting read. It simply was not there in this article.

  • John D

    Because people don't put much thought into their vacations. Oh, the girls at the office had a blast in Mexico/Cuba/The Dominican, that's where I'll go.

  • claude

    I totally agree with you Vania, I live in Playa del Carmen and i love it .

From Macleans