Jesse Brown

Jesse Brown

Jesse Brown offers critical thoughts on technology and what it means. Follow Jesse on Twitter:  @JesseBrown

Help me unsuck Canada's Internet

by Jesse Brown on Friday, May 20, 2011 1:39pm - 104 Comments

Any way you slice it, the Internet sucks in Canada.

I know, I know—it’s the same Internet everywhere, the Internet knows no boundaries, etc. But work with me here! And consider the evidence:

  • Many (most?) of the best commercial sites and services online are blocked to Canadians.
  • We haven’t had a single major web startup in Canada, despite the incredible amount of engineering talent that emerges from this country every year (and from the University of Waterloo alone).
  • The OECD ranks Canada #28 out of 33 countries when it comes to broadband speeds, and #32 out of 40 when it comes to the price we pay for our pokey access.
  • They also note that Canada is one of the only countries where ISPs impose explicit bit caps.
  • Canadians don’t have much privacy on the Internet, and we’re about to have less; once the Conservatives pass Lawful Access legislation, as they’ve promised to do, police will have unfettered access to all kinds of our personal information online.

Even the U.S. government thinks Canada’s Internet sucks—they’ve again put us on their Special 301 watchlist, placing us with China and Pakistan as the world’s worst online pirates. Recent evidence shows that piracy is actually at an all time low in Canada, but why quibble? Opinions and positions differ wildly on these issues, but the one thing everyone can agree on is that our Internet stinks.

So let’s fix it.

On Tuesday May 25th, I’ll be hosting a workshop at the Mesh Technology Conference in Toronto. It’ll be an open forum exploring a range of solutions to the problem of Canada’s sucky Internet.

I could use your help.

In the comments, tell me what practical steps we could take to fix our Internet. What I’m looking for is a sentence or two on one smart fix that would have a big impact. Your answers will be shared on stage and discussed by some of the world’s smartest technologists.

So have at it!

Tags: , ,
Bookmark and Share
  • Laurence Cooke

    We believe that the solution to our internet is to make it more competitive by having more players, but our country’s unique geography (large area and small population) presents an economic challenge for any telco to deploy FTTH.

    An alternative is to have a common shared fibre local loop, that would allow all ISPs and IISPs to offer services over. The Australian government is building a national broadband network at great expense, but most medium sized cities in the US and Europe have opted for data utilities. This makes sense since we already own the water pipe, the sewerage pipe, the gas line and electrical cable on our property. And the city owns the local distribution. So why not the same for fibre?

    But if cities create data utilities, this has its own set of problems: no economies of scale, steep learning curve and limited experience in agreements with telcos. In addition most city business cases rely upon a triple play service including TV to make the economics work, but TV is a complicated business. It does not make sense for a city to compete with the telcos and cablecos, who have already invested billions of dollars in national networks.

    Our solution is to work with local communities to build fibre local loops that are then connected to the telcos and cablecos. We call it FFTH (Fibre From The Home), which has the benefits of being community centric, future proof and creating a model where telcos and cablecos can all compete for your business the old fashioned way – price and service.

    Our model creates thousands of local entrepreneurs who want to deploy fibre in their neighbourhoods. If you think this is interesting, we are just about to launch some trials, so check out trial our web site. http://www.fibreloop.ca/

  • Dylan Leite

    Make Macleans available in e format to those who already subscribe to the paper format on Window and Linux operating systems. I would love to read it on the go on my Windows tablet.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=547625004 Hayden Ventresca

    Lose the Bandwidth Caps entirely, you can’t cap an intangible product like this reasonably, so can it.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=547625004 Hayden Ventresca

    Lose the Bandwidth Caps entirely, you can’t cap an intangible product like this reasonably, so can it.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=547625004 Hayden Ventresca

    Lose the Bandwidth Caps entirely, you can’t cap an intangible product like this reasonably, so can it.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=547625004 Hayden Ventresca

    Lose the Bandwidth Caps entirely, you can’t cap an intangible product like this reasonably, so can it.

  • http://twitter.com/akenjeev Alex Kenjeev

    Just one comment – not true that we haven’t had a single web startup – I can think of two, both very hot, well-funded and rapidly growing: Dayforce and Rypple.

From Macleans